Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
radiantrose · 08/05/2020 17:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 08/05/2020 17:23

Many of the slogans like 'Black lives matter' are in themselves racist, all lives matter.

With the greatest respect, ODFOD.

CherryPavlova · 08/05/2020 17:19

I don’t know about the perpetrators of violence sufficient to comment. I do know there is a shocking level of inequality in healthcare in the U.K. and BAME people are likely to have worse healthcare access and outcomes.

mbosnz · 08/05/2020 17:18

But I don’t believe there are large numbers of white people who get kicks out of murdering blacks. The stats just don’t support that.

The existence of the KKK sure as hell does.

mrsBtheparker · 08/05/2020 17:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

OgoPogo8 · 08/05/2020 17:16

Relying on statistics produced by US law enforcement, when trying to argue against the idea that law enforcement in the US is institutionally racist, seems a bit dubious to me.

mbosnz · 08/05/2020 17:14

Unfortunately nothing will ever change. As a non white person I have accepted this. Many white people will not/cannot acknowledge racism. They cannot see that this wilful ignorance is fuelling racism even further. It’s exhausting to even have this discussion anymore.

@Mamathebest a lot of us are listening, a lot of us are hearing and accepting what you are saying. It must be so exhausting, but thank you for persisting, and please believe, your words and your arguments do make a difference.

HelloToMyKitty · 08/05/2020 17:13

Imagine pulling out irrelevant stats to discuss whether black lives matter after a innocent black man was gunned down by racist white men

The point is that this is not a widespread trend in the US. Stats back it up.

Individual cases do matter, of course. And I hope justice will be done.

I do think racism exists in America and I do think it leads to poorer life outcomes. We need to do better on that.

But I don’t believe there are large numbers of white people who get kicks out of murdering blacks. The stats just don’t support that.

bananafish · 08/05/2020 17:13

Hmmm - African-Americans accounted for about 15% of murders of Whites, according to FBI data if you want to talk about violent crime..

It is something you see so often on here @Mamathebest. It's fascinating how defensive some posters become when racism is pointed out. It makes them very uncomfortable to have their viewpoints challenged.

Most white people have a very limited understanding of racism but, as you can see in this thread alone, have no problem with assuming that their perspective is 'correct'. They will readily dismiss the arguments and experiences of those with greater knowledge i.e. people of colour, without a shred of humility. It's annoying.

CorianderLord · 08/05/2020 17:10

I hope so. They went after a jogger believing he was a burglar likely because he was black. I found it shocking - imagine feeling scared to exercise because someone might hunt you down

HelloToMyKitty · 08/05/2020 17:08

are you saying black people are killing white people because they are white....??*

Of hate crimes in general, you have a point. This is the FBI breakdown:

Among single-bias hate crime incidents in 2018, there were 5,155 victims of race/ethnicity/ancestry motivated hate crime.

47.1 percent were victims of crimes motivated by offenders’ anti-Black or African American bias.
20.1 percent were victims of anti-White bias.
13.0 percent were victims of anti-Hispanic or Latino bias.
4.1 percent were victims of anti-American Indian or Alaska Native bias.
3.4 percent were victims of anti-Asian bias.
3.4 percent were victims of bias against a group of individuals in which more than one race was represented (anti-multiple races, group).
1.9 percent were victims of anti-Arab bias.
0.5 percent (26 individuals) were victims of anti-Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander bias.
6.5 percent were victims of anti-Other Race/Ethnicity/Ancestry bias.

That said, hate crimes which lead to murder are very rare according to FBI statistics. I didn’t get a breakdown by ethnicity but the total number regardless of race/ethnicity is vanishingly small:

Law enforcement reported 5,566 hate crime offenses as crimes against persons. By offense type:

46.0 percent were intimidation.
34.0 percent were simple assault.
18.4 percent were aggravated assault.
0.8 percent consisted of 24 murders and 22 rapes. (See Methodology for more details about changes in the definition of rape in the UCR Program.)
0.7 percent involved the offense category other, which is collected only in NIBRS

24 murders in 2018 in the US is still too many but is really a small number when compared to overall murder rates. The largest category of hate crimes (for those interested) was apparently damage to property.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 08/05/2020 17:05

wonder how many people would be pulling out stats and trying to find arguments that all lives matter and we shouldn’t be focusing on violence against women.

Too many. I speak from experience and hanging around the FWR board. People will also fall over themselves to deny DV, male violence etc while throwing whatabouteries about.

LaLaLanded · 08/05/2020 16:55

@Mamathebest we have to believe things will change.

The pace of change is frustratingly slow - so frustratingly slow. But we have to keep up the good fight. I have high hopes for the next generation.

PlanDeRaccordement · 08/05/2020 16:54

SimonJT,
they weren’t arrested because the authorities saw the video, they were arrested because we saw the video.

In the reports I’ve read, the authorities got the video at the same time as the public because it was anonymously released. The arrests came within a week of the video being released.

I completely agree police corruption caused the police department to take the killers word for the situation and that they almost got away with it. Its terrifying to contemplate that if the video had only been released to the authorities that they would have buried that evidence too.

www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/may/07/ahmaud-arbery-former-police-officer-and-son-charged-in-shooting-of-black-man

Jellycatspyjamas · 08/05/2020 16:52

I wonder how many people would be pulling out stats and trying to find arguments that all lives matter and we shouldn’t be focusing on violence against women....

Have you ever tried to discuss gender based violence in the context of domestic abuse - in my experience folk fall over themselves to deny violence against women is an issue.

Almost as much as they do in denying racism is an issue...

Mamathebest · 08/05/2020 16:48

Could you imagine if this was a video of a white woman being chased and gunned down by two men (regardless of race). I wonder how many people would be pulling out stats and trying to find arguments that all lives matter and we shouldn’t be focusing on violence against women.......or bringing up random cases of violence from women towards men to make sure we see that men are actually the victims.

Unfortunately nothing will ever change. As a non white person I have accepted this. Many white people will not/cannot acknowledge racism. They cannot see that this wilful ignorance is fuelling racism even further. It’s exhausting to even have this discussion anymore.

NurseButtercup · 08/05/2020 16:47

Op YANBU I gave up attempting to discuss racism on Mumsnet, when a poster told me that my lived experiences of racism, as a British born black woman are a figment of my imagination and attributed to the "chip" on my shoulder that I'm walking around with.

OgoPogo8 · 08/05/2020 16:47

You have to remember, they weren’t arrested because the authorities saw the video, they were arrested because we saw the video.
Well put.

OgoPogo8 · 08/05/2020 16:46

Unarmed black men are 3.5 times more likely to be shot by the police than unarmed white men in the US.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4634878/

RainbowGlittersandSparkles · 08/05/2020 16:45

Of course they matter! But sadly America has a huge racism and gun problem. Just look at the mug shots of the ignorant pigs.

hopeforlucky3 · 08/05/2020 16:44

YANBU. 2 yrs ago me and my partner went to a Beyonce &Jay-Z concert. I admit had a bit too much wine...I went into a full on rant to police who were telling us we weren't aloud to walk on a side of the road (after the concert) and were telling everyone to queue, about how this was not the law and they couldn't force us to!

I also flung something in about corruption and was loudly voicing to the crowd about the press coverings of a royal wedding or baby at the time, whilst black kids where being murdered at an alarming rate down in London, which didn't receive a spot of the amount of media coverage.

My point was we had just been to see Bey&Jay and they are advocates for the Black Lives Matter Movement. Sadly unless you come from an "ethnic minority" community people will always find excuses to get round their muddy view of these issues.

memememoi · 08/05/2020 16:43

@Jellycatspyjamas agree 100%

Jellycatspyjamas · 08/05/2020 16:42

And yet white people need to be part of the discussion- to challenge themselves about the million micro-aggressions and assumptions that create a world where this is even a matter for debate.

SimonJT · 08/05/2020 16:41

You have to remember, they weren’t arrested because the authorities saw the video, they were arrested because we saw the video.

Just as in the UK non-whites are more likely to not be believed by the authorities.

memememoi · 08/05/2020 16:39

Imagine pulling out irrelevant stats to discuss whether black lives matter after a innocent black man was gunned down by racist white men, these racist white men were then protected by the law which is meant to serve and protect ALL lives.

Little wonder people do not want white people anywhere near discussions about race

Swipe left for the next trending thread