Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Theeighthelephant · 08/05/2020 18:55

The percentage of blacks killing other blacks which was posted

From a white supremacist website, @hollybon2

Bristolbitsandbobs · 08/05/2020 18:53

Xenia, you obviously don’t understand lawGrin
That’ll land well Grin

Swooningmonkey · 08/05/2020 18:53

Also I dont believe the bullshit of you have to be black to understand the prejudice, that's a poor excuse. You dont have to be gay to believe in LGBT rights, you dont have to be Jewish to stand against anti-semitism and you certainly dont have to be BME to see the ingrained racism and know when to call out white privilege.

This!

HelloToMyKitty · 08/05/2020 18:51

Oh dear Kitty. Look into the FBI hate crime reporting process. Their statistics only reflect the data from the 30 States that have hate crime laws AND require the filing of reports of hate crimes to the FBI at the federal level. 20 states and all the territories either don’t have hate crime laws or have them, but don’t report them to the FBI. If you look at the map, it’s very obvious that the Deep South states where hate crimes against black people are most prevalent are states that don’t report hate crimes to the FBI

Oh my Plan. You can’t hide behind incomplete statistics when hate crime can be prosecuted at a federal level. Especially with something as serious as murder.

Your stats wouldn’t even support your assertion: as 234 black people are murdered by whites in 2018, it still wouldn’t come close to the literal thousands you asserted in a previous post.

Swooningmonkey · 08/05/2020 18:50

Laughing at some of the responses here Hmm

Disproportionate force against black people happens here too.

twitter.com/essmurph/status/1258556377364140032?s=21

apple.news/AFf8f5F8dTOCHNUGK5wKjCQ

TwelveMonkeys · 08/05/2020 18:50

"not really sure how", that should have said.

TwelveMonkeys · 08/05/2020 18:50

Genuine my arse, wtf is wrong with you? Black lives matter isn't about white crime. It's not about you. You are not the victim because you feel targeted by wording indicating that black people are the victims when they get killed for being black

I think you misunderstood my post (although I'm not sure really, how since it was really a very short and simple one). Go back and read my other posts on this thread if you're unsure.

EastMidsMumOf1 · 08/05/2020 18:49

NRTFT but heck some of the responses are awful.
Fuck all lives matter.. this isnt about ALL lives - it's about a young black man who was murdered for being black, just like others before him.

Also I dont believe the bullshit of you have to be black to understand the prejudice, that's a poor excuse. You dont have to be gay to believe in LGBT rights, you dont have to be Jewish to stand against anti-semitism and you certainly dont have to be BME to see the ingrained racism and know when to call out white privilege.

Yanbu OP but sadly, no I dont think they ever will - some of the responses on here already show that.

memememoi · 08/05/2020 18:46

@hollybon2 you're embarrassing yourself Blush

HavartitoMeetYou · 08/05/2020 18:45

Xenia, you obviously don’t understand law.

Presumption of innocence is a legal principle that only applies within an actual court of law; it was created to enshrine in law one’s legal right to a fair trial. Presumption of innocence does not legally apply in many areas outside of courts, and there are specific exceptions where courts can overrule it within the legal system.

For example, police cannot act according to presumption of innocence; if they have a suspect then the entire process of evidence-gathering is predicated on the theory that person is guilty. When CPS decide to bring charges, it’s certainly with the presumption that those charges will result in a conviction, ie presumption of guilt.

If you work in a safeguarding role and have an employee who has been arrested or charges for child sexual offences, you would be in breach not to act - certainly you would not invoke presumption of innocence there!

Law courts can ignore presumption of innocence in certain terrorism cases.

One thing presumption of innocence absolutely does not and was never intended to cover is public opinion. And it certainly doesn’t mean that a person actually IS innocent — it’s not like suspects/arrestees/people on charges awaiting trial exist in some kind of Schrodingers Jail Cell where they are both simultaneously innocent and guilty but you can’t find out which until verdict. If someone committed the crime they are 100% guilty, period - conviction or lack of doesn’t change that.

GoddessOfGettingThereInTheEnd · 08/05/2020 18:44

I can't believe the way this thread started off either. I'm white but fgs, do some people just want to ARGUE FOR THE SAKE OF IT

FlaskMaster · 08/05/2020 18:43

Does the "Black Lives Matter" movement only seek to address white on black crime? Genuine question
Genuine my arse, wtf is wrong with you? Black lives matter isn't about white crime. It's not about you. You are not the victim because you feel targeted by wording indicating that black people are the victims when they get killed for being black. It seeks to address the complete disregard for the value of human life that is so disproportionately experienced by black people. Black people are getting killed for being black. That's what it's addressing, is that ok with you?

mbosnz · 08/05/2020 18:42

Sorry, that was in response to hollybon2.

mbosnz · 08/05/2020 18:41

This thread is about two white men, taking it upon themselves to create a situation in which they (the evidence is incontrovertible) shot a black man. So how many black people killing how many black people is not exactly pertinent. Unless you're arguing 'well, they kill each other all the time, so if a white person takes one out every so often, that's not so bad'. I'm sure you're not saying that. Right?

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 08/05/2020 18:39

The man who filmed it has been identified and being investigated

FlaskMaster · 08/05/2020 18:39

I'm really shocked at the racism and willful ignorance on here. I can't believe all the "all lives matter", "white people get killed too", "I won't have an opinion on this until I see evidence the black guy was guilty of something", "black people kill black people too". What the fuck is wrong with you all?
It's VE day today. We defeated Nazism 75 years ago. We saw what racism did, and how far it could go if ordinary people didn't challenge it, made excuses for it or pretended they couldn't see how bad it was. This was the wake up call we all needed to get our heads out of the sand about it, end it and to cherish every human life. But some people are still willingly in complete denial and happy to try to justify it, or refuse to see that it's even happening.

Xenia · 08/05/2020 18:38

Ogo, I am sorry you feel like that. In England websites don't even allow comments on active court cases which are sub judice as how things are shown in court when the full evidence if available is so important. We don't have mob rule in the US or UK and waiting to see what the jury decides is often very wise. I hope that is not a controversial comment.

hollybon2 · 08/05/2020 18:38

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Tunnocks34 · 08/05/2020 18:35

Would have been*

Tunnocks34 · 08/05/2020 18:35

Sorry people are delusion if they think this would have happened if the man was white. It wouldn’t.

Also, can you imagine the outrage if it had been two black men shooting a white jogger? It wouldn’t have been prosecuted as murder IMMEDIATELY.

Britain has serious problems with racism too - I speak from experience of being called a paki, terrorist blah blah. But I thank GOD I don’t live in America where racism is practically part of the fucking way of life. Must be absolutely terrifying to be black there

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 08/05/2020 18:32

It's not just the crime that the problem it's the police response after. It seems likely if this video wasnt aired it wouldve gone no further.. and hopefully the outcome of the trial be the right one!

TwelveMonkeys · 08/05/2020 18:32

pointing out that white people get murdered too begins to sound a bit like the 'when is International Men's Day?' posts we occasionally get on International Women's Day

Don't forget "When is white history month??"

mbosnz · 08/05/2020 18:31

The sooner however that the US ensures fewer people carry guns the better. They just lead to far too much violence.

Yeah, not gonna happen. Guns plus unchecked racism. both institutional and otherwise, not a good combo.

OgoPogo8 · 08/05/2020 18:28

I am sure 100% of people on this thread will of course agree that everyone is innocent until proven guilty in court under English and US law of course however.
Depressing to see posts like this pop up when someone is shot to death on camera.

HebeMumsnet · 08/05/2020 18:28

Us again, we're afraid.

We're still getting a lot of reports on this thread and to be honest, we can see why.

Of course all lives matter, but in the context of the horrible news story this thread was about, we do think that pointing out that white people get murdered too begins to sound a bit like the 'when is International Men's Day?' posts we occasionally get on International Women's Day, so we can see why that's caused offence.

At the centre of the thread is a young victim and some serious and understandable concerns about the way the black community is treated, in the US, but also globally. Could we ask that perhaps everyone tries to stick to answering the original post of this thread? We're keen to get it back on track and if we have to make lots more deletions we'll end up having to zap the whole thing, which feels pretty unfair on the OP.

Thanks.