Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
MouthBreathingRage · 09/05/2020 12:33

Oh boy, I've just reread your username @@peoplewhoannoyyou. I hope it's origins is just a coincide....

insideoutsider · 09/05/2020 12:32

@peoplewhoannoyyou said: We do not know the full events leading up to the killing... it's hard to tell whether it was justified or not... the shooters may have been acting in good faith

A human being was killed. Not a spider.

This thread is really eye opening. Racism is obviously more mainstream than I had imagined.

memememoi · 09/05/2020 12:31

I've reported @peoplewhoannoyyou

JourneyToThePlacentaOfTheEarth · 09/05/2020 12:30

peoplewhoannoyyou your ignorance astounds me. You believe zimmerman was innocent because the justice system said so? A justice system that has never been fair to black Americans? That was set up to keep them down? That statistics have shown to be racist in its outcomes?

And this case which didn't even get av arrest until now 3 months later, due to public outrage?

You think there is more to this than the video shows? That someone unarmed and jogging should be chased, blocked and threatened with guns?

You are a fucking disgrace to humanity

memememoi · 09/05/2020 12:30

Funny how it mostly shows up when discussing the murder,abuse and discrimination of black people, don't you think?

Exactly

memememoi · 09/05/2020 12:26

Everyday it's "be kind he kind" until it's Black bodies on the line... then you are tripping over each other to make it "not about race" even though there is video evidence. Give me strength.

Black lives never have and never will mean shit to a lot of you and while I'm personally not shocked/surprised by it, I am sure frightened by it.

ProudMarys · 09/05/2020 12:23

I hate racism so much. How anyone can have a hatred enough to murder because the colour of your skin or where you are from is beyond me. So sad the he racists are scum of the earth no matter what you look like we are all equal.

Theeighthelephant · 09/05/2020 12:21

The fact that someone is "unarmed" doesn't necessarily mean that they are not perceived to be a threat.

He was perceived to be a threat because he was black. Th at does not justify cold blooded murder.

MouthBreathingRage · 09/05/2020 12:21

The fact that someone is "unarmed" doesn't necessarily mean that they are not perceived to be a threat.

As opposed to the armed men who confronted him, without any proof her was a 'threat'? More victim blaming, well done.

YinMnBlue · 09/05/2020 12:15

I am utterly gobsmacked that anyone can use the death of Trayvon Martin to claim the possibility that due process could show a justifiable ‘good faith’.

If you believe that it is perfectly reasonable for lethally armed civilians to kill people because they think they might pose a threat (and part of that belief is because they are black and wear a hoodie... or are running down a road, for example) then you have a very different understanding of a civilised society to me.

HavartitoMeetYou · 09/05/2020 12:03

Words exist within contexts. You cannot ignore those contexts.

Yes, of course everyone’s life is or should be equally important. As a belief, separated from any societal context, that’s a fine idea. The specific phrase “All Lives Matter” has been adopted by white supremacist groups and is a known racist dog whistle. You cannot ignore that context.

It’s like those American protestors using signs from Auschwitz. You could argue that “work sets us free” is a perfectly normal, harmless thing to say which is relevant to the situation. But writing it in German is a very intentional act to invoke Nazism and has a set of meanings and contexts that go beyond the dictionary definition of those few words.

Of course there’s space for a nuanced conversation about how different forms of racism apply and interact. I’m right in the middle of organising a co-existence event aimed at examining anti-black and anti-Asian racism and how they differ and intersect, for example looking at how umbrella terms like BAME cause harm, and how white supremacy pits different minority groups against each other. There are many nuances, of course there are.

But let’s get real. When people use a specific catchphrase invented by/heavily associated by white supremacists, it’s not because they are concerned that Sinophibia is being overlooked by the binary nature of contemporary racism discourse! That phrase is a racist dog whistle, pure and simple.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 09/05/2020 11:40

We do not know the full events leading up to the killing, we don't know for what purpose the video was being recorded - nor why they held onto it for so long

By the accused own admission, they saw a black man running, they THOUGHT he was guilty of something so armed themselves and went to confront him as civilians. They went after him. What else do you need to know?

peoplewhoannoyyou · 09/05/2020 11:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

VerticalHorizon · 09/05/2020 11:24

I dont know the motives of other posters.
I do know that when I read about something like this, it acts as a wider reminder about racism in general. The same lines of thinking in two American white men who see a black man as a threat and killing as a justified reaction is the same line of thinking as two blokes in a British pub moaning about the number of Asians in the area, or think it's funny to mock the waiters in an Indian restaurant.
I cannot be alone in that thought process.
'All lives matter' doesn't have to be dismissive. It may well be used by some that way, but not all.

To be frank, if hearing about this case doesnt make folks consider the casual and overt racism and prejudice in their own communities against a number of minority groups, then what would?

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 09/05/2020 11:09

I dont think every utterance of 'all lives matter' comes from a bad place or dismissive view.

Funny how it mostly shows up when discussing the murder,abuse and discrimination of black people, don't you think?

That's because it's used to shut down discussions, not as a nod to other discriminated races.

OP wrote a post about a black man being killed in cold blood. Do you honestly believe the replies she got were a nod to other discriminated against races?

Lockheart · 09/05/2020 11:04

It's true that all lives matter - of course it is, and I don't think anyone is arguing differently. But to use it as a counterpoint to try and shut down those highlighting the awful prejudice faced by many in our society is to totally miss the point.

It's like going to a women's protest against rape and the trafficking of prostituted women and saying "but men matter too".

How can you be so tone deaf and privileged as to not understand what problems other people face, and that if you are living in the US or UK and if you are white and they are not then they will almost certainly be far greater than your own. I'm not a huge fan of this sentence, but sometimes people need to sit down and listen.

It's "when is straight pride day / white history month / international men's day" all over again.

If I may paraphrase Friends, EVERY DAY IS INTERNATIONAL MENS DAY / STRAIGHT PRIDE.

Truthpact · 09/05/2020 10:54

I like to think things will change, but honestly I don't think they will unless we took extreme and probably controversial measures. I'd be happy to carry them out though on the racist scum bags. Grin

Annamaria14 · 09/05/2020 10:52

@RockLock I know it was bad, but it is one case. There are so many millions of other problems going on in the world.

I am not going to be able to fix the deep rooted racism in the southern states in the USA. They need to instigate change there, themselves.

VerticalHorizon · 09/05/2020 10:51

I am not so sure 'all lives matter' is said to dismiss black lives. I think it might often be said because it is also a nod to other races and cultures that suffer a similar fate and for the same reasons. Muslim communities will almost certainly echo those of black ones, as will Indian... the list is long!
They all share the same root cause. Racism. I know Islam is a religion, but race and religion become one in the minds of many racists.

I dont think every utterance of 'all lives matter' comes from a bad place or dismissive view.

TooTrueToBeGood · 09/05/2020 10:23

I hate the phrase All Lives Matter. It's used mostly as a response to Black Lives Matter to minimise the plight of the black and wider BAME population. If a group starts a campaign to highlight a grievance they have, or persecution/discrimination they believe they are being subjected to, surely the human and morally right thing to do is to listen to them and try to understand? Not just dismiss them out of hand with a put down implying that they are nothing special.

RockLock · 09/05/2020 10:20

Anamaria14, I started this thread about a heinous lynching of a black man by 2 white men and still had people try to defend the indefensible. They refuse to acknowledge that race played any part in it. Imagine trying to get them to admit that racism in the UK is also a massive problem.

They are part of the problem.

OP posts:
MarieQueenofScots · 09/05/2020 09:08

YANBU OP, but then MN has always had a blind spot when it comes to racism. Anyone arguing the US and UK doesn’t have significant and deep-rooted problems with racism is either ignorant or wilfully blind.

It’s interesting the crossover in posters who post “all lives matter” and “NAMALT”.

CherryPavlova · 09/05/2020 09:00

The phrase All lives matter is technically correct but missing two words. All lives SHOULD matter EQUALLY.
Slavery in any form is abhorrent. One person should never be able to own another, whether that be a husband owning a wife or a white woman having an enslaved maid.
Personally, I think fortunes built on slavery should be returned as aid to the countries most affected. Companies like HSBC, Barings, Imperial tobacco, Lloyds of London all grew from slavery. Perhaps they should be funding anti-malarial and AIDS management programmes in sub Saharan Africa? Our recession will be nothing compared to the poverty of others.
Until inequality is addressed, there will be continued violence among the most disaffected. Emily Wilding Davison died in a violent death because she knew life treated her and other women unfairly; the way to reduce violence is by building a more just Global and national society.

Annamaria14 · 09/05/2020 08:40

The thing is - I think that it is bad.

But there are also a million other awful things going on in the world

Why don't people in the UK stop racism here. There is white supremacy every where that I look in the UK.

So why do we condemn the USA, when we let so much racism go on in the UK.

This is the generation where white people really need to look at themselves

SonEtLumiere · 09/05/2020 08:25

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.