Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Jellycatspyjamas · 09/05/2020 14:28

I swear some people sound like they're almost afraid to admit/acknowledge that black lives do matter, that racism is alive and well and that innocent people are being abused and murdered purely because of the colour of their skin

I think some people are indeed scared to acknowledge that racism is alive and well in U.K. society/US society because that would mean looking at all the systems and process that we buy into that deny the humanity of others.

It much easier to convince yourself that there’s a legitimate reason this man was killed than to recognise the horror of not being able to go for a run knowing with certainty you’ll come home safe.

It’s much easier to point to black on black crimes than to acknowledge the justice systems on both sides of the pond fail to protect all its citizens.

It’s much easier to think that black people are paranoid or feckless than to recognise the very real barriers to education and employment faced by people of colour.

It’s much easier to place slavery and discriminatory law in historical context than to accept that history impacts on values and perceptions society hold today.

Because to fully acknowledge those things means life would need to change, that inequalities would need to be addressed and those organisational systems would need to be dismantled, perhaps resulting in less favourable conditions for those who enjoy privilege by dint of skin colour, birth, sex, wealth or the intersection of all those things. God forbid the playing field might be levelled in a way that life gets a bit harder for white, heterosexual, middle class men (and women). Or that I might need to acknowledge that the benefits I enjoy come at a cost to others, or that as a white, middle class women I don’t experience anything like the levels of prejudice and adversity that my black friends do.

People are scared that better for you means worse for me - or that if it does mean worse for me, maybe it’s because I inadvertently benefit from the racism I claim doesn’t exist.

It wasn’t that long ago African Americans weren’t even recognised as human in US law, sadly it seems we’ve not travelled far from that place.

Glowcat · 09/05/2020 14:25

It’s a horrifying case. The father was a police officer and then an investigator for the district attorney’s office (a job commonly taken by former police officers.) For the office that refused to file charges on him for months. The US has a huge problem with racism.

The UK has a racism problem too. It’s a remembered stat I cannot find the details for but in the 90s there was a ‘ring of steel’ around London to help prevent IRA attacks (Irish terrorists.) Over 20% of those stopped were BAME at a time when they made up under 5% of the population as a whole and 0% of the IRA.

The Grey’s Anatomy link should be shown to anyone who questions the existence of white privilege. It’s something that you don’t even have to think about if you’re white.

TwelveMonkeys · 09/05/2020 14:14

I don't know. I get that saying "oh it's not the same in the UK" appears to diminish the problem in the UK, BUT in my experience... it's not the same in the UK, lol. By which I'm not trying to say it's not a major issue in the UK (I've experienced a lot of "institutional" racism AND my fair share outright racism in the UK), but that it's a much, much bigger problem in the US. The hangover from slavery and segregation is far more noticeable there. And the much bigger wealth inequality gap disproportionately leaves so, so many black people in poverty there just makes it all worse.

I'm really glad I don't live in the US, put it that way.

VerticalHorizon · 09/05/2020 14:05

I don't think we are all that different leckford. Racism in the UK is still around, just a little more covert.
I really do not have to look far, even amongst friends who I know to be 'good' people, to find casual racism.
In truth, I am not immune either.

Would I look longer at an Asian man carrying a backpack longer than I would a white man?
Would I feel more vulnerable if I entered a predominantly black area?
Would I make certain assumptions about a white man wearing a suit vs a black man wearing a hoodie - about threat, about intelligence, about many things...

If we are honest, I think we all hold some prejudice. Recognising in ourselves is important. That's a far cry from having hatred, but we each have little preconceptions about others (not just race based).

But there's not a pub in the UK, or a decent size office that that doesn't have someone prepared to say 'I'm not at all racist but...' when they think they are our of earshot of getting into trouble.

MarieQueenofScots · 09/05/2020 14:02

This was in America not the U.K., attitudes are different

In what way? I don’t think there can be any question that institutional racism is a serious problem in the UK.

leckford · 09/05/2020 13:39

This was in America not the U.K., attitudes are different and don’t forget the ready access to guns

CuppaZa · 09/05/2020 13:37

👏👏👏👏👏 @VerticalHorizon

mbosnz · 09/05/2020 13:30

Beautifully put, VerticalHorizon.

HavartitoMeetYou · 09/05/2020 13:29

Well said, Vertical.

VerticalHorizon · 09/05/2020 13:27

This is always an issue with racism...

it is true that every case has to be viewed on its own merits, and yes, sometimes someone idiots kill regardless of colour, so a black death isn't always the result of racism...

However, that is a joker card that is constantly pulled out of the hat in face of any racist incident. But we aren't talking about a street fight between drunken idiots and one of them happens to be black. We aren't talking about a self-defence situation which results in a death of a black man...

We are talking about two men who armed themselves (as you do) and actively sought out what they claim to believe was a suspect...

a) They armed themselves
Already they prepared themselves for confrontation. Even claiming a weapon is for self-defence still presupposes you envisage an encounter.

b) They had ample time to spot the suspect and call police, but failed to do so.

c) They had ample time to approach the suspect in a civil manner, but failed to do so.

d) When approached by two men in a vehicle bearing weapons, it is difficult to believe they feared for their lives more than Mr Arbery did.
If they feared so much, they needn't have approached him at all.

Whether they intended to kill, injure, apprehend, or merely intimidate Mr Arbery, the entire onus was on them. If take a weapon, seek confrontation and it results in injury or death, you could reasonably have foreseen that danger and it's manslaughter at the very least.

I can't 'prove' it's racism. Do I believe it was? Absolutely I do.
Actually, I believe it's a mix of factors, of which racism was one.
When you combine vigilantism, a propensity for violence as a 'resolution' and racism - you end up with dead black deaths.

Racism combined with other stupid beliefs is still racism.

TooTrueToBeGood · 09/05/2020 13:22

What is especially shocking is that one of the murderers was a LEO for 30 years. I wonder would the authorities might uncover if they were to go through his service record with a fine-tooth comb. Not that they will of course.

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 09/05/2020 12:51

Course all lives matter. But it's pretty clear and obvious as many cases have unfortunately shown that had it been the other way around either

A. Wouldn't have happened which is obvious in this case.

B. Not taken 3 months for charges to be made! If there wasnt the video put out then it still wouldn't have been the case.

DreamChaser23 · 09/05/2020 12:50

If you are not black

DreamChaser23 · 09/05/2020 12:50

We have people on here who would argue for "women's rights" but when it comes to "black rights" the tone changes: no it's all lives matter, we aren't all racist, the black guy must be threatening etc.... I would urge everyone to watch 13th on Netflix. Just goes to show how poorly black people are treated. And why do people defend the UK so much? Many newspapers are racist that is a fact! Look what they do and how they perceive certain groups in societies. If you aren't a women you don't know how it feels like to be a women. If you aren't a Muslim you do not know understand the hate they face. Likewise, if you are black you will never understand their struggle.

HavartitoMeetYou · 09/05/2020 12:46

Some posters just enjoy the opportunity to taunt and upset POC folk.

And yes the assumption that a black man must be up to no good shows how strong racist beliefs are. Look at the poster acting like it was a given that there was a recent local burglary which the killers might reasonably suspect Ahmaud for. Then it turned out there had been no burglaries in that area recently at all! People invent excuses out of thin air, but as soon as someone brings something up even as a hypothetical, it becomes a “what it” and very quickly “what ifs” get taken as fact.

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 09/05/2020 12:46

I swear some people sound like they're almost afraid to admit/acknowledge that black lives do matter, that racism is alive and well and that innocent people are being abused and murdered purely because of the colour of their skin.

NowSissyThatWalk · 09/05/2020 12:44

If the pair were black and the victim white, would it have taken 3 months and leaked video evidence before they were arrested?

Would it fuck.*

Exactly. Of course they wouldn't.

NowSissyThatWalk · 09/05/2020 12:43

Just to add @anewdispensation I'm sorry that's your experience and thank you for sharing.

Have you watched Becoming on Netflix? New Michelle Obama documentary and she really shines a light on a lot of what you said, it was a real eye opener for me.

Bristolbitsandbobs · 09/05/2020 12:42

the shooters may have been acting in good faith

WTF? What good faith that vigilante actions would become legal?

How about THEY let the justice system work and they call the police?

@peoplewhoannoyyou I’m not sure if you are just trying make counter arguments for sport here, or using this as some misplaced intellectual exercise, but it comes over that you are a racist apologist.

TwelveMonkeys · 09/05/2020 12:41

It's telling that none of the apologisers have answered:

If the description was a young white male, would the pair given chase so aggressively? Would they have picked on a random white guy jogging in a park? Would they have cut him off in their truck and jumped out of the vehicle with a shotgun?

If the pair were black and the victim white, would it have taken 3 months and leaked video evidence before they were arrested?

Would it fuck.

memememoi · 09/05/2020 12:40

@peoplewhoannoyyou you are actually a sicko. So you mean to tell me there is not an drop of empathy on your part after viewing footage of a person being gunned down????. I am under no doubt that your "matter of fact" post is based solely on the fact he is black.

ALovelyBitOfSquirrel · 09/05/2020 12:40

The amount of thick as pigshit racist cunts on this thread is extraordinary.

NowSissyThatWalk · 09/05/2020 12:39

All lives matter
Fucking hell, first post. That's the problem right there.
YANBU OP. I've just finished reading The Hate U Give, have you read it? Devastating book.
I'm a police officer but I can tell you now I would never ever be one in the USA and most of my colleagues agree.

MockersxxxxxxxSocialDistancing · 09/05/2020 12:39

To get the death penalty, the jury has to unanimously vote for it. If even one jury member objects it’s a hung jury and the judge can’t do a death sentence.

But juries are gerrymandered to prevent this, even to the extent in some states of excluding anyone who expresses opposition to the death penalty.

MouthBreathingRage · 09/05/2020 12:34

Sorry, bad tag in my last post @peoplewhoannoyyou