Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Will black lives ever matter?

860 replies

RockLock · 08/05/2020 12:36

So another killing of a black man Ahmaud Arbery by 2 white men (Father and son) in US. They nearly got away with it calling it a citizen arrest and self defence. Father was a retired policeman.

They followed him, armed with guns and shot him.

Prosecutors tried to cover it up until the video emerged.
Ahmaud’s crime? He was going for a jog.

Will black lives ever matter?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
TorkTorkBam · 10/05/2020 12:46

America was settled by religious fanatics.

VerticalHorizon · 10/05/2020 12:27

in the UK, if you take a gun out like they did, it's deemed horrific (rightly so in my view), but in the USA, this is so commonplace and accepted, it is difficult to fathom.

Going out with a gun in the USA simply isn't always seen as a clear indication of premeditation to murder. We might not like it, or agree with it, but that's the truth. Many Americans see no problem with it.

What then transpires is an unholy mess. 3 shots fired, none of which look to 'aimed' and fired deliberately but 3 accidentals is also hard to believe.

Annamaria14 · 10/05/2020 12:22

America is a shocking country. I don't know how it developed into the way it is.

I was thinking: settlers from Europe went to both Canada and the USA, around the time,

Yet,

Canada is a peaceful, humanitarian country.

The USA is materialistic, incredibly corrupt, rife with racism, terrible justice system, terrible health care, gun crazy and has the largest amount of people in prison.

How did it get so bad?

Namechangervaver · 10/05/2020 12:10

The legal/judicial system in America beggars belief. It's like a tin pot dictatorship, not a so called first world country. Anybody seen Making A Murderer on Netflix, or the documentary about those young men falsely convicted of rape in Central Park? They get away with this shit all the time and people just turn a blind eye/ justify it. Sickening.

VerticalHorizon · 10/05/2020 12:04

What utter bollocks. You cannot just base your opinion of the incident by considering the struggle in isolation. They set out with guns to hunt him down before there even was a struggle. That context is vital to any sane determination of what happened.

Clearly not read previous posts then have you?

UmmH · 10/05/2020 11:49

@HelloToMyKitty I do think racism exists in America...

Oh you think so, do you? Well done.

You do realise that 'stats' are not irrefutable evidence? That stats have to be questioned and interpreted like any other evidence?

TooTrueToBeGood · 10/05/2020 11:36

it seems more like a genuine struggle than a premeditated murder.

What utter bollocks. You cannot just base your opinion of the incident by considering the struggle in isolation. They set out with guns to hunt him down before there even was a struggle. That context is vital to any sane determination of what happened.

NearlyGranny · 10/05/2020 09:44

Imagine the young man's terror, empty-handed and hotly pursued by three hostile men, at least two of them armed, in two vehicles. If he runs for help to any of the houses he passes, he's likely to meet just such another armed person ready to shoot him on sight.

It seems black people, especially young black me, spend their lives in hostile territory in a way women can probably understand better than men.

Ineedaduvetday · 10/05/2020 07:34

The hangover from slavery and segregation is far more noticeable there. And the much bigger wealth inequality gap

But this case is also about power. The DA refused to agree to the suspects arrest as he / she knew the elder suspect for 20 years.

ttim985y · 10/05/2020 01:15

What is astounding is that an attorney apparently uninvolved in this (but who clearly sympathises with the father and son) leaked the video online to prove the innocence of the father and son

'I really thought releasing the video would put the truth out to the public,' Tucker stated.

Oh it certainly did put the truth out ...... just not how he thought

RockLock · 10/05/2020 00:59

I do not understand the american obsession with guns but I know racism when I see it. 2 DA’s covered this up and tried to blame the victim. They had the video and they did not see anything in this video that would warrant the arrest of the father and son. They are only upset because we have seen the video.

What is astounding is that an attorney apparently uninvolved in this (but who clearly sympathises with the father and son) leaked the video online to prove the innocence of the father and son, claiming that Ahmaud shouldn’t have resisted when he had a gun pointed at him!! It beggars belief!

To all you voters who think IABU, you are ignorant, racist and part of the problem.

OP posts:
VerticalHorizon · 10/05/2020 00:28

Murder might be hard.
Gun culture in the USA is different. We might not like it here, but it is what it is in the USA.

Defence will claim it would be utter madness to set out to shoot someone in broad daylight and video it... with potential witnesses everywhere.
Prosecution will argue that they actively sought out trouble in a vigilante fashion, and made no obvious attempt to carry out a peaceful arrest.

The shooting doesn't look particularly controlled, but 3 accidental shots won't wash.

My hand on heart instinct says it's redneck vigilantes setting out to kick someone's ass on video, and it's gone horribly wrong very quickly. Which is what can happen when you mix aggression, guns, racism and vigilantism.

Creation · 10/05/2020 00:17

In my opinion, the very fact that they brandished the guns and approached him like they did, they took the risk of something like this happening and so should be charged with murder. Apparently they tried to block him in with the vehicles twice unsuccessfully before this final encounter. He must have been scared for his life and felt his only option was to try to defend himself.

I really believe their actions warrant a murder conviction.

Namechangervaver · 10/05/2020 00:16

I suppose we’ll have to wait for the court case for all the facts to be confirmed

This is America, so don't hold your breath

BackseatCookers · 10/05/2020 00:13

Do you know how best to not "accidentally" shoot someone?

Don't accost them, unprompted and unnecessarily, as a civilian, holding a gun.

Why are people so desperate for this to not have been a case of clear racism resulting in death?

What's the motive for wanting that not to be the case when all the evidence points at it being the case? I don't get it.

I've never been in that situation, and hope I never am, but my gut feeling is that they intended to beat him, but it turned into a struggle immediately.

This was so troubling to read.

Your gut feeling is that they were going to kick the shit out of him but because he struggled aka defended himself and tried to get away, they "accidentally" shot him three times?

You've wrapped up by saying you think it's awful and they're guilty. But why all the qualifications and mitigating factors?

Someone defending themselves and trying to get away is I suppose a "struggle" of sorts but that description is unnecessary and implies an equal footing.

He defended himself, attempted to get away and was shot to death. In the middle of a street in February. And they were not charged until now. Fuck me, how much more clear cut can a case be.

VerticalHorizon · 10/05/2020 00:01

If you see the full video - there are three shots about 2 seconds between each in a struggle. From the video alone, it seems more like a genuine struggle than a premeditated murder... but after the final shot (the first two appear to have missed him), the white guy does not appear to have an 'oh shit' moment.
I've never been in that situation, and hope I never am, but my gut feeling is that they intended to beat him, but it turned into a struggle immediately. If the gun went off by accident the first time, you'd think they'd be shocked back to reality, but no... there is a second shot, and then the fatal one. It DOES look unintentional (to me) but three accidental shots is almost impossible to believe.

The seeming lack of remorse right after looks terrible too. Maybe it's shock. I really don't know, but when you combine all the factors together, it just looks so bad.

Creation · 09/05/2020 23:59

The hammer “rumour” I suspect is because people are trying to give more weight to the theory that he was out to burgle. There are so many people trying to justify his death which makes me sick to my stomach. I suppose we’ll have to wait for the court case for all the facts to be confirmed however, regardless of the ins and outs, those 2 men lynched him and deserve to serve lengthy prison sentences. I just know the American justice system doesn’t always seem fair so I’m praying that it’s proven he was simply out running unarmed so that the defence don’t get off with their “citizens arrest” argument. Those men deserve life for what they have done regardless!

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 09/05/2020 23:44

Why would he be jogging with a hammer?!
Have not read that anywhere and its worrying it's been said.

BackseatCookers · 09/05/2020 23:42

I’ve seen a lot of conflicting information on this story. Some are saying he was armed with a hammer whilst others are saying he was unarmed.

He was unarmed and I believe this is undisputed.

No reputable news sources whatsoever have reported (let alone confirmed) that he was armed with a hammer.

So sharing that ‘some are saying’ is problematic in itself because it’s spreading erroneous information that clearly hasn’t been fact checked.

None of this obviously justifies the brutal attack he suffered.

So why does it take up about a third of your post along with his footwear?

I don't mean that in an aggressive way to you but it's something to think about.

If he was armed with a hammer then do you not think this would have been widely reported and verified?

This thread makes me feel so sad.

LetsGoFlyAKiteee · 09/05/2020 23:34

@NearlyGranny its disgusting the whole thing. I hope it doesnt clear them really do and hope they also is consequence for him too. He didnt step in and try and help in anyway instead watched it.

And the victim blaming ahhh. If hadnt chased him then wouldn't have needed to stop cause wouldn't been there

Bristolbitsandbobs · 09/05/2020 23:29

We really @Creation you can watch it you realise, right?

PrincessConsueIaBananaHammock · 09/05/2020 23:17

@Creation have you watched the video?

BackseatCookers · 09/05/2020 23:15

Can't get over the first three comments on this thread. 2020 really is disappointing us on every level isn't it. Fucking hell.

USirName · 09/05/2020 23:06

Oh FFS, now it's 'he may have had a gun back in 2013', and 'he may have shoplifted in 2018'. I have fucking had it with the American legal system, and all who support this kind of mentality. I remember watching the Rodney King video in the 90s, nothing has changed.

Note: The man who filmed is distressed because he has been receiving threats and has lost his job. How tragic Hmm. Apparently it hasn't occured to him that an innocent young man lost his LIFE.

Creation · 09/05/2020 22:54

This story is absolutely heartbreaking. I feel awful for Ahmaud and all his family and friends who have to come to terms with his tragic loss.

I’ve seen a lot of conflicting information on this story. Some are saying he was armed with a hammer whilst others are saying he was unarmed. There are also people questioning why he would be running in boots?

None of this obviously justifies the brutal attack he suffered. I just hope justice is done.

Swipe left for the next trending thread