Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Snubbed at private school? AIBU?

185 replies

nonamesleftatall · 28/04/2020 08:18

So in September I moved my children to a private school about 30 mins from my house. DC in Y4 and DC in reception. Previous school was also private but small, very intimate and friendly, children were happy with good friendship groups (youngest was at nursery there), but had to leave due to work commitments/ personal stuff.

At new school reception DC is settled and the Mums seem to be very friendly. Y4 DC is having a rough time (and so am I). Parents very unfriendly, I think only 5 have actually spoken to me at all. I have sent notes/ WhatsApp inviting kids for play dates at my DCs request and one note was totally ignored.. despite child running out and handing it to Mum. My son kept asking if she’d replied through October HT and she never sent a text to say busy still haven’t heard. Other requests for play dates via text have been met with we are busy for the rest of the year?!?! This was 2019. One child even lives in our village and this has been declined. There is a parents group and people just seem unfriendly, the total opposite of reception and the previous school. Our house used to be filled with kids for sleepovers, dinner, play dates, bbqs. My DC keeps asking in lockdown as we are doing our garden and we are talking about once restrictions are lifted having people round etc... and he keeps asking about friends from school. He seems very out of sorts and like a former glint or is prior happy self. I would elated if someone offered to have my children for a day!!

I am a youngish Mum - under 30. We are also not super wealthy. I drive a very low grade car which is pretty out of place amongst the range rovers and volvos. Also I know year 4 is an odd age to join. So my question is will it get better with time? Or should I pull them out and send them somewhere else? My husband thinks I am projecting my anxiety about it on to our son and the friendships we had at the previous school were rare. But then it is odd that reception are so friendly. As an example another new boy this year whose mother I knew prior the school move invited whole year (2 classes of 16) to a birthday party and only 3 kids said yes and one was my son. I asked 1 parent at rugby whether their child was going and she said no we said we are going away. I think this I strange. This lady had also posted on the group about a play she was in locally with a photo and not one person out of 32 acknowledged the message. I sent a message about a drama worship in Feb and again not one person replied. Will it just take time or are they just mean???

I feel quite insecure dropping off due to car/ and everyone doesn’t speak to me. Granted some are probably 20 years older (although I made many lovely friend at previous school who were older) and it’s the Range Rover brigade with country boots etc... but we are all just mothers who want the best for their children.

So my question is AIBU. Click yes if you think it is early days and by year 4 people are past the play date phase and I may just have an unsociable year group. Or no if you think it sounds like a nightmare and I should get my child out!!! The only trouble with that is he struggled with the move and what if I move him again and it’s no better? Plus we live in a 3 bed semi and it’s a huge push for us to send him to that school... to buy uniform, registration again would be so hard to pay for.

Also can I ask if your child goes to private school... honestly would you judge someone if they didn’t fit the stereotypical profile. Would driving a Yaris, being younger, not looking apparently monied bother you? We are all paying and want what’s best for our kids. I have friends from all walks of life. For background son is sporty, friendly, never had any issues with friendships ever always been friends with everyone.

OP posts:
Itsabitmessy · 28/04/2020 09:09

DD was worried about the reaction of other parents when her first started at a small private school as she is the opposite of the stereotypical private school parent. Pierced, tattooed, grungy and definitely grotty of car. We had a talk about whether she should adapt her style to ‘fit in’ for her DCs sakes. As it turned out she has met some really lovely parents and made some great friends as have the DC. I truly think it’s the luck of the draw sometimes.

I have gone to a lot of evening classes and other groups over the years. With most classes the people were ok but no one kept in touch away from the class. With one special interest group though, everyone just clicked and we are still going 15 years later - different backgrounds, some well off , some struggling.

Are there any out of school groups your DC used to go to before lockdown? I think it’s important not to let on to your DC that you/they feel excluded and to focus on the 5 parents who have spoken to you a bit. Everyone is up against it right now so I would concentrate on doing nice things as a family as far as lockdown allows and when life gets more normal to try arranging low key get togethers and see how it goes. Don’t assume the problem is you though. I really do think it’s just a random mix of people and that this time round they’re not very forthcoming .

Bridecilla · 28/04/2020 09:08

Have you moved house or just school? Surely he still maintains his old friendship groups from his old school?

KingscoteStaff · 28/04/2020 09:08

It can also be due to birth order - if many of the Year 4 children are second or third children, then their families may well be extremely socially busy already, whereas if the Reception cohort are firstborns, then the mums will be super keen to build a network.

I would make sure that DS is playing all the sports he can - in school and at the weekend - there’s nothing like bonding on a wet touch line to cement friendships!

5zeds · 28/04/2020 09:08

I don’t think it’s your car/cash situation, I think it’s the parents I. That year group. I have a large family and find some year groups fun and some dire. They change though so don’t pull out. It also takes time to settle and you have had a jumbled year now like the rest of us.

VanCleefArpels · 28/04/2020 09:06

Any school group - state or private - is just a random group of kids (with parents) who happen to be the same age and live in the same area. Given that fact it’s actually a miracle if you as a parent find a group of fellow parents that you gel with. It’s not a given, neither is it compulsory to be friendly with other parents.

It’s difficult when the kids are at an age where they need parental input to organise play dates etc. Try not to worry- as they get older they will organise themselves and parents really have little to do with each other after year 6 (if you/they don’t want to).

And try not to judge people based on their car or type of boots they wear. We really know nothing about the lives of others and in a way you are judging them in the course of wondering if they are judging you

missyB1 · 28/04/2020 09:05

I suspect it’s the year group and those particular parents. My ds is year 6 at a private school, some parents are very cliquey, and ds has been at that school since the nursery class! Like you Dh and I don’t exactly fit the mold. I’ve learnt not to give a toss. Ds has a few friends and I’ve made friends with parents like yourself who have moved into the school at a later stage.

Base your decision on how your ds is doing and perhaps check with the school as to how happy and settled he is. Try to avoid moving schools again if you can it’s very unsettling for them.

FakeFraudSquad · 28/04/2020 09:05

Coming at it from a child’s perspective, I joined a new private school in Year 4 and was very badly bullied from the get go. It was made worse due to the fact it was a small year group, an odd number and single sex. They were settled in their friendship groups and didn’t want a new girl. Even someone I’d known since I was 3 didn’t invite me over to play. It was a horrible year group, which does happen unfortunately but also, by that age play dates were mostly over. I seemed to be the only one who invited anyone and even birthday parties were few and far between. A lot of parents had nannies or saw very little of their own children (surgeons, pilots etc) so had no time for either hosting or dropping and picking up at play dates. Friendships seemed to have been firmly established in Reception or even Nursery and were often based on who the parents got on with.

I stuck it out there as long as I could before eventually being so depressed that I had to transfer to another private school partway through Year 8 where, once again, I was initially bullied due to girls at the first school having sports friends at the new school and telling them to give me a hard time. Luckily, after a difficult few months, I’d made a great new friendship group and we’d started socialising outside of school.

What I will say I noticed as both a student and teacher at private schools is that the most popular groups of pupils tend to be the ones who started in Nursery or Reception and went the whole way through the school. Newcomers seemed to be viewed with suspicion. At Senior School it was easier to start with other newcomers in Year 7 than to come in part way. Early on, in primary or early years education, parents seemed to micromanage their children’s social lives and carefully choose who they wanted their children to mix with. Sometimes that would be based on parents themselves being alumni of the school.

Even now former students I know with toddlers and babies are ensuring they go to the “right” hobbies with the “right” children so they get the best start; ie Rugby Tots in the most affluent village (even if they don’t live there and there is a more local session), KODALY or Suzuki Baby Music Sessions, the Alumni Playgroup, Baby Ballet at a certain school etc. It’s all very carefully managed!

To answer other questions, yes children bullied me because we didn’t have the newest Lexus or BMW. My parents collected vintage BMW and Mercedes and I was called “poor” and a “wannabe” because of that. There was a girl who “didn’t fit in” because her mother had been a teenage mother and they still lived with her grandparents who paid the school fees. Parents were generally much more interested in what your parents did for a living etc. Certain professions seemed more “acceptable” than others. Holiday destinations seemed to be another way that you’d be judged...I remember at our school it seemed almost vital to spend a month in the States in the summer (Naples, Sarasota or the Keys in Florida where many of us had holiday homes), then a cruise or European trip in the October half term, Dubai or the Far East in February etc. One holiday a year or UK breaks didn’t seem to count Confused.

Arriving there from a primary school where I’d been popular and no one much bothered about my parent’s careers, what car they drove or where we’d been on holiday was a real culture shock!

Private schools can be tricky places to navigate socially. I’d back off on the play dates for now and just see what friendships naturally evolve. Encourage older DC to join clubs at the school (sporty kids were always popular) but also focus on outside of school friends because they won’t be there forever!

WhyCantIThinkOfAGoodOne · 28/04/2020 09:04

That's tricky OP. When schools go back I'd arrange a chat with the Y4 class teacher and find out how she/he thinks your child is settling - who do they play with etc. If they haven't yet infiltrated any of the established friendship groups (and by y4 there'll be some solid dynamics) then the reluctance may be coming from the kids. In this case perhaps the teacher could encourage some likely friendships by giving them a job to do together just before playtime or similar.

If the teacher is able to name kids your child is friends with but the parents are still stand offish it's more tricky. By Y4 age you'd expect the kids to be beginning to discuss playdates amongst themselves so if your DS is able to suggest a fun outing to a friend hopefully they'll nag their mum to let them go.

My kids go to a prep school and while there is some cliqueness amongst the parents it's definitely not associated with nice cars and spending money.

Soontobe60 · 28/04/2020 09:03

It sounds like you're trying too hard. Friendships have to be cultivated, they don't happen overnight. For your younger child, it will be more friendly as you've all started at the same point but for your older child, they've been together for 5 years, so will have well established friendship groups. That's hard to overcome. If you move schools the same is most likely to happen again but this time your youngest will also be in the same position.
In September, things may well be different because of the whole lockdown thing. Stick with the school, smile and say hi to parents at pick up time and let things happen naturally.

GrumpyHoonMain · 28/04/2020 09:02

I drive a banger and send my kids to private school. Never had any issues with friendships with my DN (who lives with me).

Firstly I would ask whether you are really meeting parents at the schoolgate or childcare workers/grandparents. Also do they know you are the mum? Most of the women under 30 who pick kids up at my DN’s school are nannies, and so play date invitations directly from them can sometimes be viewed with suspicion as parents can and do cancel at very short notice. Make it clear you are Y4 child’s mum in the invites (put your mobile number on them somewhere saying you are the mum etc)

Secondly your son being new to Y4 means he probably hasn’t made close friends yet and so you need to rely on making friends with the mums / childcare workers/ grandparents directly. Are you volunteering with the PTA? If not that’s usually a good opportunity.

Thirdly you need to consider the possibility you may be right about the snobbery about you being a younger mum / your car etc. If that’s the case do you really want to send your child to such a school?

HugeAckmansWife · 28/04/2020 09:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

HugeAckmansWife · 28/04/2020 09:00

My dd is in y4 at a prep (y3 is the first year of prep rather than pre prep). Playdates aren't that common because, whilst not wishing to stereotype, kids at private school often do have a lot else going on, lots of hobbies, music lessons, riding lessons. The parents too might have hobbies that takes one of them out of the house for most of one weekend day, or a 2nd home they go to most weekends. Also, my dds school doesn't finish til 4.15 so after school playdates don't really happen as there's no time. People also come from a wider area. There no doubt are factors about pre existing friendship groups etc but at y4 I'd say it is a lot less common to have playdates and whole class parties than lower down. I wouldn't over think the snobby thing.. There may be some but it won't be all. I'm very much at the poorest end of the parents, and a single mum and don't encounter that issue (to my face anyway!)

LaMarschallin · 28/04/2020 08:59

It actually doesn't matter whether the school is private or not.

State schools aren't full of the cast of Oliver! dancing round the playground, singing "Consider yourself one of us!" with parents saying, "Cor blimey, luvaduck, let's have a knees-up, mother of new child".

All sorts of schools will have these sorts of problems. There was certainly a group of mothers of children in my elder daughter's primary state school class who'd all grown up together; had actually gone to that school so thought they owned it and had obviously been the Mean Girls of their day.

I do wonder if the other parents are actually as conscious of the class and/or age thing as you are. Or maybe they pick up how you feel - bad news if they've picked up on the age thing Wink

I suspect it's just normal human nature which you find everywhere so another move may not necessarily help.

FinallyHere · 28/04/2020 08:58

we are all just mothers who want the best for their children.

You can't rule out the possibility that their view of what is best for their DC may not include you / your DC.

I'm not suggesting it's right, or fair, but it is potentially consistent with a mindset that chooses to pay to provide 'the best' for their DC. Especially joining when other friendship groups are already formed, new friends may just not be on anyone's radar.

It might get better over time, especially if you don't 'make a fuss' and your child can find activities, usually sport, at which to shine.

What other options can you explore ? Some children find an interest outside school very helpful.

opticaldelusion · 28/04/2020 08:58

It's all part of teaching your kid to look down on other people. I'm staggered that you're surprised to find fee-paying schools stuffed full of snooty parents.

This will literally be your own child one day.

GreyishDays · 28/04/2020 08:58

Not sure what you mean by ‘past play dates’, children go to play at friends’ houses at all ages.

Do you have any semi friendly contacts? Anyone who has answered a WhatsApp? If so I’d ask if their child is on House Party (once you find one child you’ll find their friends) or ask if they play Roblox and ask if your child can sometime house party/FaceTime while they are doing it. Or ask if their child can do iMessage or something (less good, this, but better than nothing).
Focus on what you can do now.

Quartz2208 · 28/04/2020 08:56

I am torn here because it sounds like you just have an unsocialable year and to ignore and to say that it of course doesnt matter you are all paying and want the best for your children

But I remember going to private school from a 3 bed semi and seeing all the others and I hated it. Its the reason mine go to the local state school not private because I dont want them to feel like that

Beautiful3 · 28/04/2020 08:54

Sounds like it's the set if mums for year 4 im afraid. My eldest daughters year, the parents are friendly. My youngest daughters year, the parents are anti social and disinterested in arranging play dates. I feel sorry for the youngest really. How about putting them into an after school club and getting friends that way?

fascinated · 28/04/2020 08:54

I’ve heard similar stories about a local private school

VanillaSugarr · 28/04/2020 08:54

I had this. DS joined in yr 3 and didn’t make any proper friends until a new cohort arrived in yr 5. He now has friends for life as the boys are in Yr 8 and still the Band of Brothers.

DM me if you would like to chat with a bit more privacy. FlowersBrew

Hoppinggreen · 28/04/2020 08:53

It might not be the fact it’s a Private school, it just might be the dynamic of that particular cohort. DD is at Private school and we’ve never had any issues.
Also in DDs year at (state)Primary there was a really good mum related social life, I made loads of good friends but not in DS year - it often depends on if people work or have younger siblings or any number of things. Don’t just assume it’s because you aren’t super rich, September to March isn’t that long to make strong friendships, especially if the kids are already established

Dyrne · 28/04/2020 08:52

puffinandkoala The key word there is some.

Surely it’s just as shitty to judge someone and assume they’ll be a snooty stuck up twat because they drive a Range Rover?

(And I say this as someone who drives a beat up 12 year old fiesta, before someone says I’m projecting!)

Ironmanrocks · 28/04/2020 08:52

My son joined a school in Year 4 also. It was a tough year as he struggled to settle anyway. I was working so wasn't always there at pick up. I also felt inferior . still do But it has got better. My child has settled/has friends - he is so busy with after school activities there is no time for social stuff in the week and it is sports on the weekend. He is beginning to thrive - and now really appreciates his school and what it has to offer. I am getting to know the parents, slowly - most wave at drop off now. My anxiety certainly didn't help my child, I probably seemed quite uptight. Going to watch the sports matches has helped me bond with other parents. Be yourself and don't force it. Hope this helps.x

JE17 · 28/04/2020 08:51

Not private school, but I've had a similar experience with my DC. DD's class had a mostly engaged set of parents and there was lots of activity within the group and plenty of meet ups. I was surprised when DS's class was almost the opposite - no meeting up, very little interaction in the WhatsApp group.

Queenunikitty · 28/04/2020 08:45

Do you work? Do the other mums? I think a lot of working mums are just too busy to arrange social things for their kids and also want to spend time as a family after school and weekends as that is the only time they (and dad) gets to see the kids. Which is how it is at our house. Both work full time. My DC is at a private school, he has Autism and it’s the best option for him. In terms of wealth, status etc, many people do care about that sort of thing but at our school there are plenty of people who drive normal cars and have loads of money, and some don’t and also plenty driving G wagens and Bentleys that may not be back in the new school year if their businesses don’t survive lock down. Just don’t be too full on and pushy as I think it puts people off. There are all sorts of people who go private for different reasons, I think you just need to calm down and stop overthinking it all.