Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Snubbed at private school? AIBU?

185 replies

nonamesleftatall · 28/04/2020 08:18

So in September I moved my children to a private school about 30 mins from my house. DC in Y4 and DC in reception. Previous school was also private but small, very intimate and friendly, children were happy with good friendship groups (youngest was at nursery there), but had to leave due to work commitments/ personal stuff.

At new school reception DC is settled and the Mums seem to be very friendly. Y4 DC is having a rough time (and so am I). Parents very unfriendly, I think only 5 have actually spoken to me at all. I have sent notes/ WhatsApp inviting kids for play dates at my DCs request and one note was totally ignored.. despite child running out and handing it to Mum. My son kept asking if she’d replied through October HT and she never sent a text to say busy still haven’t heard. Other requests for play dates via text have been met with we are busy for the rest of the year?!?! This was 2019. One child even lives in our village and this has been declined. There is a parents group and people just seem unfriendly, the total opposite of reception and the previous school. Our house used to be filled with kids for sleepovers, dinner, play dates, bbqs. My DC keeps asking in lockdown as we are doing our garden and we are talking about once restrictions are lifted having people round etc... and he keeps asking about friends from school. He seems very out of sorts and like a former glint or is prior happy self. I would elated if someone offered to have my children for a day!!

I am a youngish Mum - under 30. We are also not super wealthy. I drive a very low grade car which is pretty out of place amongst the range rovers and volvos. Also I know year 4 is an odd age to join. So my question is will it get better with time? Or should I pull them out and send them somewhere else? My husband thinks I am projecting my anxiety about it on to our son and the friendships we had at the previous school were rare. But then it is odd that reception are so friendly. As an example another new boy this year whose mother I knew prior the school move invited whole year (2 classes of 16) to a birthday party and only 3 kids said yes and one was my son. I asked 1 parent at rugby whether their child was going and she said no we said we are going away. I think this I strange. This lady had also posted on the group about a play she was in locally with a photo and not one person out of 32 acknowledged the message. I sent a message about a drama worship in Feb and again not one person replied. Will it just take time or are they just mean???

I feel quite insecure dropping off due to car/ and everyone doesn’t speak to me. Granted some are probably 20 years older (although I made many lovely friend at previous school who were older) and it’s the Range Rover brigade with country boots etc... but we are all just mothers who want the best for their children.

So my question is AIBU. Click yes if you think it is early days and by year 4 people are past the play date phase and I may just have an unsociable year group. Or no if you think it sounds like a nightmare and I should get my child out!!! The only trouble with that is he struggled with the move and what if I move him again and it’s no better? Plus we live in a 3 bed semi and it’s a huge push for us to send him to that school... to buy uniform, registration again would be so hard to pay for.

Also can I ask if your child goes to private school... honestly would you judge someone if they didn’t fit the stereotypical profile. Would driving a Yaris, being younger, not looking apparently monied bother you? We are all paying and want what’s best for our kids. I have friends from all walks of life. For background son is sporty, friendly, never had any issues with friendships ever always been friends with everyone.

OP posts:
christmastreewithhairyfairy · 28/04/2020 10:31

Agh, my post should say moved DCs to private FROM state

christmastreewithhairyfairy · 28/04/2020 10:31

Hi OP. I moved both DCs to private and state school and recognise some of the things you are talking about, but also like PPs think you have been unlucky with one year group.

I look "unconventional", drive an old banger and often feel out of place in a sea of Teslas and BMW 4WDs.... but for what it's worth I get on with the other parents very well, and my DCs have made good friends too.

The thing about private/small schools is that compared to a class group of 30 (or year group of 90 say), it can be harder to find your people as there are fewer of them - both for you and DCs. It also means one or two strong characters can dominate the culture of the year group - again both for parents and DCs. That can mean some year groups less friendly than others. I have been lucky with mine but have heard bad things about other year groups.

On the flip side, the small class sizes often means that cross-year friendship are more possible/common, which might be something that helps your DC.

Also it is a very strange time, I feel for anyone being in their first year of a new school in this environment, so don't make any decisions until things are back to "normal", or whatever passes for normal eventually...

Freeasabirdy · 28/04/2020 10:30

I think it’s the year group or that school, I have had that experience with one year in a state school and I moved to a private school which was really friendly. I think you just get these odd cohorts with socially ignorant parents.

I always go out of my way to welcome new parents now as I remember what it’s like. I couldn’t care less about cars or money but I think I get judged for driving a big expensive one myself.

It’s a difficult one as it might not get better, is there another school you could move to if you haven’t been there long?

TuttiFrutti · 28/04/2020 10:24

I really don't think anyone is judging you for driving a Yaris! My dc have gone to both state and private schools, and in both environments it is the luck of the draw who you happen to end up with in your year group. Some groups of people get on well, others don't.

Probably joining in year 4 has something to do with it. By now, parents will have their groups of "school friends" well established, and won't necessarily feel like making the effort to include you.

onanothertrain · 28/04/2020 10:24

You are expecting too much and maybe coming across as trying to hard and quite pushy.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 28/04/2020 10:21

I don't think it's the year group per se, I think you've just got a horribly unfriendly group of parents there!

Other factors, such as after school activities etc. might come into play but that's no reason to be so rude and fail to respond to invitations, or ignore people entirely - manners cost nothing and these days cost v. little time either, as a text takes seconds to send.

I'm sorry you're having that experience but I would suggest that you stick it out - if your son has friends in his class, then let him stay, and maybe they will come to put pressure on their parents, or he can join after school clubs himself and find other friends who might be more open to playdates.

wonderwhatnext · 28/04/2020 10:19

This stereotype of mums in prep schools bring more prone to “looking down” on someone because of their car or perceived wealth is utter nonsense and flat out ignorance tbh. Yes, some mums /people are predisposed to “looking down” on others, but they come from all walks of life and even, shock horror, have children in state schools. Imagine!

OP, it sounds like you have just been very unlucky and hit a weird year-group with an odd dynamic. Sometimes it just takes a few parents to set the tone, or people just haven’t “gelled” for whatever reason. It does appear, from what you’ve said, that the unfriendliness is a wider issue than just pertaining to you, Do try and not take it personally (I’m sure it’s easier said than done though).

It could be that there was bullying or something going on earlier in the school and parents have become distanced as a result? Or, as a pp said, maybe they all work full-on and can’t be bothered with much else.

I very much doubt anyone had even registered what type of car you have. Whatever it is, I wouldn’t know one if it smacked me in the face.

My kids were all in London preps. Admittedly, it’s a very different set to the Barbour and wellies brigade (if this is indeed an actual thing in the country - no idea)? But nobody cared about cars one iota, I can tell you that for sure. In fact the people who live in the ten million pound Chelsea mansions would be the ones who show up in a old mini or something because it’s easier to park.

I think you may have to accept it’s a weird year. Is there anyone there you could chat to about this - you mention there is also another new mum?

EngagedAgain · 28/04/2020 10:16

Its been a long time since I done 'school', but thought I would chip in. It's possible that you have just hit it at the wrong time, either because of those particular parents, and/or because they have all already formed their cliques and probably most, if not all their children, started at the same time. Secondly, most people of that calibre would not even realise how you are feeling. Not necessarily because they are stuck up, or look down on you, but maybe because they have other things on their mind. Many I expect would have professional jobs and literally wouldn't have time and are focussed on other things. So, don't take it personally. I would just concentrate on the here and now at the moment. There won't be any playdates just yet anyway. He doesn't need to know too much about the ins and outs of it all, and yes you could be projecting your anxiety on to him. Lastly, when my children were young, they didn't actually play with their school friends out of school. They played with local friends. So, could that be an option?

Highfivemum · 28/04/2020 10:16

I don’t believe it has anything to do with you being at a private or state school or your car it’s just every class is different. I experienced the same with one of my DC and it was from nursery all the way to year 6 !! The parents were clicky. There was a group of around 8 who just didn’t let anyone in. Didn’t bother me at all as I hate that sort of thing but it was hard when my DC would play with one of their DC and then want them round for tea and I would be snubbed. Don’t try to hard I am sure as you go along friends will come and all will be fine. Good luck

FiddlefigOnTheRoof · 28/04/2020 10:16

I’ve been to private school and send my children private. This behaviour does not take place in our school - but certainly some years you’ll find more people open to friendship than others years. The key is to continue to be open, smiley and make friends as if it’s your first day - even if it’s two years on and no one has opened up to you. People are going through all sorts and may not have had the mental bandwidth for new buddies at that particular moment.

tara66 · 28/04/2020 10:08

This behaviour can be quite normal in public (private) schools. These people have their own more important friends, plans, businesses, money, life etc. They are not looking to ''waste themselves, their time'' etc. on others if to no particular advantage. It seems to be a status game. I experienced it too. Just one of those things. Hope your DC is not too unhappy. Remember the school is for DC not for you.

YouokHun · 28/04/2020 10:06

I’ve had four children go through both state and private school and from what I’ve observed some years don’t gel regardless of state or private. There is plenty of “car judgement” in state schools too. The younger years are often more sociable as they contain new parents and tend to include class wide parties, whereas later groups are more established. Also if the Year 4 children are not firstborns then those parents may have older children and be focussed further up the school or on secondary school or they may be working full time or just simply “drop and go”. The other thing to remember OP is that the cohort will change every year and the original group of children will be diluted.

Keep your assessment of the school confined to whether it’s suiting your child emotionally, socially and academically and find out from his teachers if he’s happy during the day. Work on friendships for him and you outside school as well which is a good thing to do anyway. If people are judging you for your car (and you don’t know that) then it says more about them than it says about you.

GreyGardens88 · 28/04/2020 10:04

I went to private school - the bullying is atrocious if you don't fit in. Plus the staff are so arrogant they don't do anything to help

Hagbeth · 28/04/2020 10:02

Don’t try and make friends on the schoolyard. Try to sign him up to after school clubs like the Beavers, football etc.Anything he fancies. Make enquires first to find an activity where the parents as well as the kids are active rather than just a drop off and leave group.

allflownthenest · 28/04/2020 10:00

Hi nonamesleftatall, my children went to a private prep school. One in fact that I went to myself, I was by this time divorced and working myself in a nursery school so I couldn't hang around at drop off. I also drove a cheap car when all the others at school were top of the range and mostly mothers who didn't work. I didn't fit in (only spoken to when there was no one else about) but my children have friends for life from this school so I wouldn't give up. My ex.H was included if he ever went to drop off or pick up (almost never) as he was a partner in a law firm.......

Onone · 28/04/2020 09:59

I’m not friends with any parents,I speak to one mum who’s daughter is best friends with mine but that’s as far as I want to go

Lynda07 · 28/04/2020 09:53

I would never judge anyone on what they own or their financial status, never have, most of the time I don't notice. I'm not very observant by nature and couldn't tell you what cars people drive though might remember the colour if I particularly like it.

I've no idea if I have ever been judged for those reasons - certainly had periods of being very hard up - but I wouldn't have thought so. How would I know anyway? Being friendly with other mothers at school didn't interest me much, I wasn't unfriendly and got to know a couple of them but I always went to work and had friends there.

It's early days yet, op, your children have only been at the school for one full term. Please don't worry about it, there are other things in life. Your year 4 child will settle down eventually and make friends but you can't push these things, if you show anxiety about it you'll make things worse. There's the world of difference between a small and a large school and that is what you are experiencing but you'll get used to it. Live your own life and be independent. I doubt anybody is looking down on you, why would they?

Astrabees · 28/04/2020 09:53

Both my sons went to prep school until they were 11, then on to a very good grammar school. Most of the other mothers thought this was really slumming it! We had, in comparison, modest means at this time and i also felt a bit awkward. Some of the other mothers were lovely but a lot were not.
I was working at the time, well paid professional career, but the ideal for them seemed to be a very wealthy much older husband, days at gym and lunching and away somewhere every weekend. For me it was agony but sons were very happy and did really well, the teachers in the main were lovely. My sons stayed late for prep and activities as it enabled me to work, there were always boarders around. I found it was better to leave the social side for them as games, late staying and playing in the huge grounds rather then invite them to our house.
I really don't regret it, they have both done very well and academically the move to grammar school was good too as they came out with better A levels than those who carried on in the private sector. After they had left the prep school DH and I found a lot to laugh about, but it was a bit of an ordeal at the time.

BillieEyeFish · 28/04/2020 09:52

They’re a bunch of miserable sods. One of mine has a class like that and I often wish I’d just moved her as soon as it was obvious that it wasn’t a cohesive class. The parents have never got any better.

Bakedbrie · 28/04/2020 09:48

Had both kids in private school in Surrey - very hoorah Henry kind of place. Drove various small second type cars - never a Range Rover! Never had an issue with snubism. Sure there are arseholes anywhere, but the nice people do tend to find one another in the end. Hang in there, please stop worrying so much. If many mums have older kids they do naturally detach and won’t be as motivated as you by making mum-friends this is normal

2kool4skool · 28/04/2020 09:45

Its easy to assume/presume all the other mums are friends and excluding just you. My DC are at a very small private school and some of the mums are very social with one another. I work FT and simply don't have time to be as social. Doesn't mean I'm being anti social or dislike the other mums. I probably made more effort with first DC but for second I made considerably less social effort. Again nothing against the mums. As to the car, you are being silly. If anything, the more wealthy people are the less flashy the car. Can't presume either way. If the mums at the school ARE bothered by that (rather than you being paranoid) then it's probably a snobby school and you may want to move. Be sure its not just your insecurities before you do so though as those insecurities will follow you!

Aweebawbee · 28/04/2020 09:44

I've experienced more discrimination from parents who thought that I was too posh than from the ones who thought that I was too rough. People will find any excuse to keep a new person out of their clique. It's just bad luck that you landed with these bitches, don't try to look further than that.

Reallymissthegym · 28/04/2020 09:42

Also all the people that I know who have a lot of money, keep their cars. It’s more people who have just made money who change their cars every 6 months.

Genevieva · 28/04/2020 09:42

If the effect of the parents' behaviour is that your son is unhappy, lonely, becoming social insecure and less confident, then I would move him. If that hasn't happened and he has friends while at school then I wouldn't worry so much.

TimeForDinnerDinnerDinner · 28/04/2020 09:41

FakeFraudSquad what an illuminating post.
Thank you for your honesty and frankness.