Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think these toddler tantrums can’t be normal?

85 replies

Nosleeptoddler · 13/04/2020 08:40

DS is 3.4. He has terrible tantrums. Every day, at least 3 - often up to 10+ on a bad day. At least 1 or 2 of them will go on for 45mins+ and involve screaming and rolling around in the floor. He is lucid enough to know he is tantrumming (he’ll often scream “I’M NOT SCREAMING”) but cannot seem to stop. He never hits or breaks anything it’s just screaming and throwing himself about.

This has been going on every single day since he turned 2. He (normally) goes to nursery 3 hours a day and is perfectly behaved there - it’s only at home that he tantrums.

I know that toddlers have tantrums, but this just seems so extreme and is ruining our family life (we have younger DD, 14mo). I have scoured lists of adhd/Asd signs and nothing seems to fit but I feel like something has to be going on, I read articles about when to be concerned and it says things like “if this is happening more than twice a week”. Twice a week! I’d be lucky if it happened less than twice a day!

AIBU to think there must be something going on?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Nosleeptoddler · 15/06/2023 09:12

@poppet131 he’s 6 now and he still has the occasional spectacular meltdown but they are much much less frequent - although still really difficult to deal with. I don’t think there is any ASD or neurodiversity - I think he is just an incredibly stubborn child and also quite emotionally attuned to others and the combination of the two sometimes means his feelings explode and he can’t control them.

I don’t have any magic tips for handling the tantrums - things that worked for him seemed to be to just sort of benignly ignore him and give him a pillow to hit if he was feeling physically overwhelmed. But am sending you sympathy as it’s exhausting and really made me feel like I was going through the emotional wringer too

OP posts:
poppet131 · 14/06/2023 14:31

@Nosleeptoddler We’re going through this atm with our nearly 4yo - did your DS eventually grow out of this and any tips you could share for handling the constant tantrums and meltdowns? X

Dee1975 · 14/04/2020 23:07

Sounds like my DD. From 18 months plus - terriable meltdowns. Multiple times a day. Yet perfect at nursery / school. I researched and she didn’t / didn’t have any classic signs of ASD. We were at our witts end. Finally got a referral at the age of 6 after she had a violent period and finally diagnosed with ASD when she was 7 - in particular with inflexible thinking.
Unfortunately it may take some time for you to get the diagnosis if your child isn’t ‘classic’ ASD. Only with age her behaviours and triggers became more obvious.
My advice would be to write a diary. Showing patterns of behaviour and with a history can really help.
Also explore all types of ASD. Particularly the control and inflexible thinking.
Hope that helps

Nosleeptoddler · 14/04/2020 08:06

Oh yes he can verbally count to 100 and recognise written numbers to 20. He loves money and change and buying things and will always pay using my contactless card when we go to the shops (back when we did such things!). He has a little cash register at home and loves playing shopkeeper, so reward shop would definitely work. @BertieBotts your chart idea is basically what we’ve been doing (but with small paw patrol toys as reward) and he loves it. I don’t care if it’s extrinsic motivation, it works!!

I think Bertie is right (and thank you, your posts are so enormously helpful). As always, listening to your instincts is usually right when it comes to your kids.

OP posts:
CherryPavlova · 13/04/2020 23:48

Three and a half year olds understand concept of buying, if they are given opportunities. They can often recognise numbers and count buttons. Especially the bright ones - and the description is of a bright child.

BertieBotts · 13/04/2020 22:36

Reward shop is lovely but I suspect a bit advanced for a 3.5 year old. We did a token economy with DS1 at around 5 or 6 with great success! At 3 in terms of rewards what worked was keeping it absolutely simple - he could earn "stars" for good behaviour, and when he had five, he could get a magazine. It stopped him pestering me for magazines every time we went to a shop, the stars weren't for any one specific behaviour but I'd sort of rig it so that he would end up with five about once every 1-2 weeks. I'd award one when I noticed him do something I was trying to encourage or that I knew he struggled with, sometimes I'd use them as motivation (e.g. help me carry the shopping home and you can have a star), sometimes he'd ask me if he could have a star for something he thought he'd done well and I'd usually say yes if he wasn't taking the P :)

And yes I am aware of extrinsic vs intrinsic motivation, but if you have a child who is often getting negative feedback for whatever reason, it is SO important to remind yourself to keep up the positive. If that ends up being extrinsic, so be it. I don't think it is an issue unless you are using it constantly for every little thing (which most people aren't).

I don't think there is much sense in worrying about diagnostics or neurodiversity type issues. At his age it's extremely unlikely anything would be diagnosed anyway, because there is so much overlap between ordinary, age-appropriate toddler behaviour which is the result in a not-yet-developed skill, and a slower than usual development of a skill which is related to some kind of disorder. You can really only separate it out when they are older, and really it doesn't make a difference right now anyway, because it wouldn't change any way that you should approach this. So I would not spend a long time focusing on lists of ASD or ADHD or this or that symptoms, especially of children who are younger than diagnostic age. When he's five or six, if you and he are still struggling, particularly once he's had about 6-12 months (or more) to get used to school, bring it up with the class teacher and potentially speak to SENCO, but right now the most important thing is to look at the child you have, the skills you feel he is lacking and work with that. If you feel that he does not behave because he can't, then go with that instinct, don't do something you instinctively feel is wrong just because "everyone" says well you must not be firm enough or you are letting him run rings around you.

I am not so sure about the idea to try "mainstream parenting ideas" for a month and see how you go. OK, it's a fair suggestion, if you don't feel you've implemented something consistently and you want to give it a go. Mainstream is mainstream because it works for the majority, after all. And absolutely if that's the case, crack out the 123 Magic or Supernanny and give it a proper go. But my guess/intuition from your post is that you've tried the mainstream things and they don't seem to be working, so you are now looking to well - could it be something else? It is natural to wonder, but if you could have a crystal ball and look at him in 10 years' time and be able to know whether he has this or that, would it actually be of any use to you now? Not really, because there is no such advice as ASD parenting for toddlers, because toddlers are generally not diagnosed with ASD. I suppose it allows you to have that understanding and cameraderie with other ASD parents - BTW, if you do want this, you would not be unwelcome on the SN Parenting boards here on MN, they are just out of active because it's easier that way, but you can opt-in if you go into Preferences, or navigate to them directly from the topic list. But what is useful to know is that the skills-based parenting and the non-coercive types of parenting like RIE and many (but not all) aspects of things like Attachment Parenting are all "friendly" towards neurodiverse children as well as neurotypical children. That is why it is a useful approach to look at.

LittleBearPad · 13/04/2020 22:06

Is he still going to nursery at the moment? If not, he’s probably very confused and trying to control what he can. I wouldn’t ignore him unless you do figure out it’s attention seeking.

He may just be completely confused. He’s only three and being three can be tough. It’s also the answer to a lot of crappy behaviour.

TudorRoses · 13/04/2020 21:53

Having read what the OP says, and that her ds doesn't seem to fit any of the behaviours mentioned by other pp's (and since I have two friends who have sons with ASD so I have seen some cracking meltdowns before), I still think that it is more likely that this is attention-seeking behaviour. Especially as he seems to be able to control these tantrums in other settings, and only does it at home.

I'm sure that for many, ignoring such behaviour would not be suitable (I agree that there is no 'one-size-fits-all' method) but there is no harm in the OP trying.

Toombumber · 13/04/2020 19:23

My daughter was like this (and worse). I really recommend a book called The Explosive Child. Try to be a rock of calm and love throughout. I know it's really hard.

TheSoapyFrog · 13/04/2020 17:53

He sounds exactly like my son. He's 5 and a half now and has outgrown his dreadful tantrums thankfully. He was assessed for potential behavioral problems when he was about 3, but they said it was just his personality! He is a little delayed in some areas and he didn't speak until he was 3. But they started easing up when he started school.

Nosleeptoddler · 13/04/2020 17:09

Thank you all

(I love the sound of the “reward shop” to the PP who suggested it!)

Again, I look at bogroll’s list and none of it applies to DS except for the not tantrumming at nursery and the getting dressed - but don’t think either of those are unusual. Hmmm.

Anyway lots of things to try so thank you all, I will see how we go!

OP posts:
BogRollBOGOF · 13/04/2020 16:36

I had the "tantrummy" type of toddler from 10 months when he realised that "no" meant that he wasn't going to get his own way and we're still going at 9. He got his high functioning ASD diagnosis at 8 following refferal at 7 after a particularly torrid summer of meltdowns in the aftermath of SATs.

Thinking back to when he was 3, our signs with the benefit of hindsight were:
Speech delay. He said enough words to make his point. He did not waste words on sentences and grammar. SALT intervention was required at 3.5.
Masking through nursery. There was one day that the nursery workers were incredulous that he'd had a tantrum as it was so unusual. He barely stopped at home.
Unusually long attention span for anything of interest. At 4 he could sit and build a Lego vehicle from a kit.
Perfectionist. Boy did I know it if there were the wrong numbers or angle of cars on the car-transporter-steam-train which I had to draw on the back of the Morrisons cafe reciept.
Sensory preferences for particular types of clothes/ fabrics
Transitions. Getting out of the house was an epic missiòn. It still had its moments. Frequently. Getting dressed, toothbrushing. Sigh.
Not fussed about other children. Accepted other children joining with what he likes, but does not gravitate towards others. Was about 6 when clear friendships developed. Reported more about annoying children than ones he liked!
Sensory stimulation, headbutting the floor, running into walls, biting.

Hunger/ tiredness/ thirst does not help and he's not great at self regulation for that.

I'm not saying what is/ isn't normal development. DS was just very intense and got stuck into phases more than normal rather than being obviously neuro diverse. We'd get better phases where his ability to cope with the world caught up (age 4) then tougher phases where expectations increased (age 5, being at school), oh and 2, with the toll of my pregnancy and a new baby was nuclear. It's taken many years for DS to stand out from what is developmentally normal (and even then he can mask and we pay later)
What ever is at play, it is worth changing tack and trying ASD friendly methods.

mumonthenet2 · 13/04/2020 15:29

I would remove the child for a set time, out of sight and a naughty seat
Our childcare suggested this as a way to discourage bad behaviour
He may fight you but stick with it.
Bedtime I have no answer it is a ongoing battle
I stopped turning into some of the nonsense and see how that goes, does he interrupt any phone calls and conversations? I stop him and say I am talking you need to stop,be firm.

3 years olds are lovely Interesting and fun
How we deal with the tantrums is yet to be solved!

Distractions, stickers, reward chart, praise for the good stuff.
I would enforce if you scream you are on a time out which means in a open door room close but out of sight until you calm down.
Bedtime before 9pm I am looking forward too!

tempnamechange98765 · 13/04/2020 15:19

Hi OP, that sounds very tough. My DS is 4.3 and very similar to how visionquest describes her DS. He's the first/only grandchild until DS2 came along a year ago and is used to being the apple of everyone's eye and lots of 1-2-1 time.

He is much better now at this age, although he's not been great the last few days, but we all have a lot to deal with at the moment!

Things that work/worked for us and some have been mentioned:

  • how to talk so little kids listen. It feels like a lot of effort at the start as I completely changed how I parent, but it does start to come naturally
  • the ignore bad/praise good where possible. I do actually do the back turning, continue what I was doing whilst humming etc, and it's usually effective. More so if it's just me and the DCs in the house, if DH is also here DS often goes and tells on me to DH eg mummy is being unkind to me! Which proves a lot of his outbursts are for attention
  • reward charts, your DS clearly responds well so keep on using them. Eventually you won't have to for whichever behaviour, we used one for getting dressed in the mornings on and off for nearly a year, and i think it's finally clicked as although he's still sometimes reluctant, we never have tantrums over it. We still use charts for other behaviours we want to encourage.
  • time outs didn't work for my DS, so I stopped using them which I think has helped him. Control is often driven by anxiety, and time outs can make anxiety worse

Also agree with PP that 3 is a horrible age. 4 is much better! Don't jump to conclusions that there is something "wrong" with him as that's what I did, I was actually suffering with terrible post natal anxiety and started taking ADs end of last year which have helped so much. I still have my moments of thinking something might be "wrong", but if there is, it's so subtle at the moment. All you can do is monitor. Some children are just more challenging than others, I know I was as a child.

LizzieAnt · 13/04/2020 15:02

*resilience

Areyoufree · 13/04/2020 14:57

BertieBotts Your posts are brilliant. Thank you.

OP: my son is very similar - if it helps, the tantrums / meltdowns (I classed them as meltdowns, because he couldn't be distracted out of them) have subsided now (he is 6). He started having meltdowns at about 10 months old - always connected with food or sleep. Every meal time was a 45 minute meltdown, and if you accidentally woke him up, that would send him straight into one. It was exhausting. He still gets "stuck" sometimes - it's the only way I can describe it. He gets caught on an idea, and you can't get him out of it. So, he'll be screaming about something, and you are trying to explain why it isn't the way he thinks it is, but he is so emotional that he can't understand even simple explanations. Another one can be of the "I want a sandwich", "I'm sorry, we don't have any bread.", "I WANT A SANDWICH!" (repeat ad nauseum) variety. Which might be understandable at 3, but not at 6.

These days, I can help him through his "moments". Just help him slowly process those emotions, without "giving in" to his demands. But yes, 3 was hard. You know him best - you know whether he is "trying it on" or not. My son definitely wasn't, and is slowly getting better at managing his emotions. I think a tough love approach would have been damaging to him.

LizzieAnt · 13/04/2020 14:42

Sorry, @TudorRoses, I probably came accross a bit harshly. Letting my emotions get the better of me! I spent years being told that DC's behaviour was because I was spoiling him or didn't discipline him enough, or correctly etc. Lots of kind, well meaning advice from loving grandparents and friends. I wish I had ignored it all, and that I knew then what I know now. Of course, this is the OP's child we're talking about and I sincerely hope he doesn't have the problems my child faced and still faces. But yes, one solution doesn't fit all. I really wish sometimes that I could go back in time with the knowledge I now have. OP, there are some great resources mentioned upthread. Read them, investigate, and trust your instincts. That said, I do hope it's just a phase and he'll develop the resilance to cope better as he gets older.

TypicalMeBreakMyTypicalRules · 13/04/2020 14:38

Have you looked at extrinsic rewards vs instrinsic rewards? Reward charts etc are extrinsic rewards and don't work for don't children/people. Instrinsic rewards is the sense of accomplishment and pride in what you have achieved. My ds couldn't couldn't give a monkeys about a sticker chart but sure as hell likes being independent and doing things for himself whenever possible and safe. I think it's also about emphasising the trying rather than the result. Sarah ockwell Smith explains this well in her publications and I'm sure there are lots of others resources too.

Vix20678 · 13/04/2020 14:28

My DD was exactly like this and I was sure there was something very 'wrong' with her. She's 6 now and can still have huge.m outbursts but they're more predictable and much easier to nip in the bud.

She only has them with us, never at school or at friends houses.

When she was a toddler I was at my wits end but she's grown into the sweetest, happiest 6 year old and really I think it was just the passing of time that eases the problems. Hang in there.

WhyCantIThinkOfAGoodOne · 13/04/2020 14:22

@TudorRoses

But not all tantrums are attention seeking or manipulative, especially in younger kids. (It's usually easy to tell the difference - kids aren't great actors). If it's a genuine meltdown the kid needs help to calm down - ignoring doesn't help.

forrestgreen · 13/04/2020 14:22

If he manages well at nursery then it suggests its behaviour related.
I'd offer a forced choice where possible to give him control, would you like a spoon or fork. Would you you like a yoghurt or fruit.
But I'd balance that with a star chart for behaviour, only positive stuff. Two stars for doing what was asked, two stars for having a positive hour/morning etc.
And if he has a tantrum I'd get your dd and move rooms, his shouting is giving you a headache so he can come play when he's finished and wants a hug. If you stay you end up still giving attention.

LizzieAnt · 13/04/2020 14:10

@TudorRoses
"These are attention-seeking strops".
Yes, that's what I was told too by well-meaning people. Unfortunately, in the case of my particular DC, it was complete nonsense. There's isn't a one solution fits all, I'm afraid.

TudorRoses · 13/04/2020 13:54

These are attention-seeking strops.

Ignore all of it completely, other than to tell him to stop making that noise. Leave him to it. When he finds out that all his efforts are not working, it will stop.

Give him attention only when he is behaving nicely, and reward the good behaviour.

WhyCantIThinkOfAGoodOne · 13/04/2020 13:50

There's a huge difference between a tantrum which will stop if the desired thing is achieved and a sensory meltdown which means the child is overloaded and literally cannot cope.

This - but also lots of neurotypical children will not have great emotional regulation at 3 years old so even without any sensory issues the pressure pf a day at nursery or the normal disappointments and frustrations of every day life can overwhelm them. They need the help of a calm adult who can help them reengage their higher level functioning brain.

user1471592953 · 13/04/2020 13:47

My eldest DC is much more badly behaved/prone to crying for no reason if blood sugar is low. We always give breakfast by 730 if DC are up at 7. It makes a lot of difference. I’m the same so we knew what to look out for!