Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think not on for teacher to ask us to take in deodrant for after pe?

61 replies

Blossomhill · 11/09/2007 21:41

Sorry not sure if I spelt deodrant right. Anyway I digress....
Just been to ds's meet the teacher and one of the requests was to make sure we take in deodrant for after pe and swimming. This was because some of them were developing and obviously ponging. I just found this a strange request. Only because although my ds does have slight bo. Now we use deodrant soap and he baths every night so actually as long as he does that he is ok. I don't want to start spraying chemicals under his arms at 9 and feel annoyed that I have almost been told to iykwim!

OP posts:
LadyMacbeth · 12/09/2007 10:25

Agree RE use a natural one - Bionsen do a refillable crystal tube with pump spray. Dh and I use it nd if it works on dh it'll work on your ds! I advocate aluminium-free deodrants for adults too - there's all kinds of shite in anti perspirant.

twentypence · 12/09/2007 10:24

Do they get to shower after PE?

Deodrant on top of sweat is pointless really. Maybe the crystal in the morning before he goes to school would be best.

3andnomore · 12/09/2007 10:18

I have been trying to think how it was done when I went to school...lol...obviously the early developement wasn't as much of an issue back then, in general, and for me personally, lol...

We have a different system in germany, but in primary school, don't think there was a issue with pong after pe...obviously there was sometimes pong issue with teh Kids that weren't as well looked after, I suppose...
between age 10/11 I changed into a different school...it's and inbetween stage from primary to secondary school, I suppose...and after pe or swimming we would all be able to shower...so, I suppose deodorant wasn't as necessary if you can have a shower after sweating in pe...and then well, deodorant...we just started using as and when necessary...

No idea if there are showers in brittish schools, tbh...

brimfull · 12/09/2007 10:12

if they pong after pe then good on the teacher for bringing it up.Just get a natural one of you're worried about chemicals.

I wouldn't want my son to be the smelly boy.
I remember dd talking about smelly bo on other children at this age.

3andnomore · 12/09/2007 10:08

handlemecarefully...there have been links to certain types of cancers and the use of deodorents, especially those that use aluminium...I don't know much about it msyelf, tbh...

3andnomore · 12/09/2007 10:05

not sure how old your son is...

mine is 11, and even though he gets sweaty, it's not yet to bad smell wise,, iykwim...

maybe getting one of thsoe crystal things for him, to use instead...and there are otehr deodorent products around without all the nasties...

elasticbandstand · 12/09/2007 09:57

i cried when i had to use it, and had to i did cos my friends said i was whiffy! at primary school.
i cried cos it meant i had to wash!

Snogsuck · 12/09/2007 07:54

As a former teacher who had to have all her windows open in January, I fully understand the teacher's request!

LoveAngel · 12/09/2007 07:33

As soon as you start to pong, you need to use deodorant - it's not an age thing. There are natural products on the market if you're worried about the chemicals. I don't think the teacher was being unreasonable.

serenity · 12/09/2007 00:20

I agree it's probably a blanket request - DS1(9) uses deodorant on days when he does PE at school because his pits do get quite rank if he does a lot of exercise. We get him the Simple roll on as it seems the most gentle. I do think he's young, but then again I can't remember when I started using it myself.

hana · 12/09/2007 00:09

nothign worse that a smelly classroom of prepubescent children

imo

GessGalloway · 11/09/2007 23:31

Get the Lush powder one (MrT or something?). It looks like talc.

CitizenColditz · 11/09/2007 23:12

It's not too young for one kid to be smelly, the other kids to notice, and cue 5 years of bullying that may have been prevented.

4mum · 11/09/2007 22:50

same message at our school,surely primary school is too young.

EscapeFrom · 11/09/2007 22:33

But BH, some parents are braibnless, and wouldn't think to give a pongy child deodorant. The school aren't allowed to only send letters to those parents, so you get the "Don't forget to open your eyes when you wake up in the morning"

I got a letter advising me to 'cross the road with the crossing lady to avoid the road works'.

And I thought "Fuck off! I am twenty seven years old, I decide where to cross the damn road!"

but in hindsight, they have to allow for idiots.

handlemecarefully · 11/09/2007 22:32

[Ignorant emoticon] - what is wrong with deoderant? Are there harmful ingredients in it?

cece · 11/09/2007 22:30

Have you ever smelt a classroom of whiffy junior kids? Lovely

pointydog · 11/09/2007 22:24

It is your decision, yes.

The school could notify everyone of a headlice outbreak and that's what's happening with the deodorant. Informing everyone that b.o. may be an issue. There are obviously some children in teh class who would benefit from deodorant at some stage and I think it's right that parents are made aware of that.

Blossomhill · 11/09/2007 22:17

It is I agree. On the other hand teachers cannot point out if a child has headlice so for me say thing? Infact headlice far worse.
I just think that it would be like saying remember shampoo for greasy hair.
My ds baths every day and is very clean. Whether he uses deo or not is surely my decision.

OP posts:
pointydog · 11/09/2007 22:01

My 8 year old dd is whiffy and I've been encouraging her to use deodorant for the past few months.

The teacher will notice smells and will see other children noticing and making comments. I think it's good for her to be so up front. It's those sorts of little things that can save a little misery.

NKF · 11/09/2007 21:53

No, not nice. Lynx best avoided.

EscapeFrom · 11/09/2007 21:52

Quite a lot of 9yos have to use deodorant to avoid sinking to high heaven, especially the girls, IMO, and they can't line them up for pit checks. 9 is the onset of puberty for many kids.

Hulababy · 11/09/2007 21:52

If you do decide to get one why not try a crystal type one, more natural.

JackieNo · 11/09/2007 21:51

half those 30...

JackieNo · 11/09/2007 21:51

Imagine half that 30 sweaty 11 year olds with Lynx on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread