Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to suggest that many newcomers to this site are put off by the cliqueness on this site?

142 replies

Somewhatdismayed · 11/09/2007 14:30

I think lots of people (including myself) have started to change their names and have hesitated to post recently, because they are genuinely put off by the cliques on this site. If someone, usually a newbie, dares to disagree with one of the "annointed few" even in quite a mild way, their cohorts jump on the bandwagon and a virtual strain of bullying commences.

Many of the participants in recent arguments can be divided in to two camps: the old set and those that dare to disagree with them.

Everyone welcomes and enjoys lively debate but I guess this is a plea to old timers to try and reflect on how you come across. If you had been flamed or criticised very strongly the very first time you posted, how would you feel?

I've also noticed that if someone new or fairly anonymous makes a point earlier in a thread it's ignored, but then if one of the 'elite group' makes the same point later on - everyone notices and praises them for it.

Someone actually said on a thread yesterday that conversing on Mumsnet used to be like going to a dinner party and now it's like eating at McDonalds

How snobbish and elitist is that? Please can you try and be a bit more welcoming and conciliatory to newcomers?

Stands back and waits to be flamed ...

OP posts:
LoveAngel · 11/09/2007 16:45

Ah, AIBU. I love it. The reason is always fucking YES, let's face facts. but that's why I love it. If I could be arsed I would go off now and start a thread called 'AIBU to love AIBU quite so much?'

MellowMa · 11/09/2007 16:44

Message withdrawn

nanninurse · 11/09/2007 16:43

YANBU. I have found this site bitchy at times, but, as someone has already pointed out its a bit like real life.

Some sheep , some individuals, some lovely folk & some self opinionated twats..

Very addictive too!!

madamez · 11/09/2007 16:40

It also depends where you post. If you are using MN for support in the TTC or antenatal or new mum sections, or you've joined up because you have SN kids and want to chat to people in a similar situation, you'll probably get the advice and support you need offered you in fairly sensible civil language (unless you're unlucky enough to need advice on something that;s either screamingly contentious or was done to death (in the opinion of the oldies) the month before you joined).

The worst kicking, screaming, dummy-spitting and hair-pulling goes on in the chat/news/AIBU sections, but that's kind of what they are for.

Now I like a good online ruck. Fair sets me up for the day. But I've also found MN informative on all sorts of subjects, like childhood illnesses and what'#s eating my pot plants etc. It's a mix of stuff like any site, so ignore the bits you don't want and make use of the bits that are useful.

CatIsSleepy · 11/09/2007 16:40

erm because you posted on it at about 3 o'clock mello

Divvy · 11/09/2007 16:39

I think all forums get pmt from time to time

MellowMa · 11/09/2007 16:38

Message withdrawn

Dropdeadfred · 11/09/2007 16:37

Pyjama girl are you getting married then? or have you recently?

LoveAngel · 11/09/2007 16:31

Try Babycentre - a real eye opener. I am a self confessed feisty bitch and I was practically lynched on the 'Attachment Parenting' boards by a bunch of humourless lentil weaving shotputter types. I flounced the fuck out of there before they could tear any more flesh from my bone over my 'Gina Ford-esque' opinions (Oh Fuck off! Carrying a 3 yr old around in a sling all day and sleeping with it all night is weird).
Anyway, my point is - intelligent, opinionated, funny women are one of my favourite things in the whole world and thus, MN really isn't too bad a place.

kittylouise · 11/09/2007 16:30

I am pretty new, and have not been put off at all. Of course there are going to be posters who have been here a long time, and who know others, but that's pretty obvious; I think it's a bit paranoid to call it cliquey.

I like MN, it makes me laugh.

Neverenoughhandbags · 11/09/2007 16:27

I'm perfect pyjamagirl!

pyjamagirl · 11/09/2007 16:23

that was meant to say argue ffs bad sausage fingers

pyjamagirl · 11/09/2007 16:18

I'm new I love it here did find it a bit scary to post at first but then again if soemeone doesen't like what I post they wont jump out of the Pc and hit me (i hope)

If you think people areruide here try the confetti website they are a real bunch of nasty bitches who scream obscenities at you if you dare to disagre with them or butt into one of their threads

This forum is the only one that that often makes me LOL plus makes me realise that all the other mummys are not perfect and have all the same worries as me .

Neverenoughhandbags · 11/09/2007 16:15

This forum merely reflects real life, surely-some personalities are larger than life, some make a lot of noise but say very little of value, others are quietly confident.Some play devil's advocate for the sake of it.
We all have our own reasons for coming on-I think the original "mission statement"-to support those members that need it-is still alive and well-I have seen some very kind and helpful responses in my reading.

law3 · 11/09/2007 16:13

Somewhat - agree with you, people do jump to each others defence, not quite sure if thats because they are just agreeing with the other person or because they already know each other.

But hey who cares, your entitled to your views, dont let anyone put you off and welcome from another newbie

DarrellRivers · 11/09/2007 16:09

I'm in a clique with Dior all by ourselves actually

hanaflower · 11/09/2007 16:04

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Dior · 11/09/2007 16:02

Message withdrawn

Cappuccino · 11/09/2007 15:33

oh phew I am glad there is a clique thread

there hasn't been one for a while

I had assumed that everyone I knew must have left

BIWI · 11/09/2007 15:28

It can feel sometimes like hanging around in the playground, waiting to be noticed and invited to play. But, like real life, that doesn't work and you just have to join in without waiting to be asked.

Cliques are inevitable, and it's when people post here to ask others to go on MSN with them that I find vaguely irritating - but probably only because I don't use MSN so can't join in!

And I have never liked the assertion, which has been put forward a lot, that it's the newbies who lower the tone/intellectual capacity of MN.

So welcome - look forward to talking with you!

Dropdeadfred · 11/09/2007 15:25

I am a relative newbie..never had a problem...

bubblagirl · 11/09/2007 15:22

lol maybe i'll give all hese things a try lol thanks

Aitch · 11/09/2007 15:22

LOLOL DaDaDa. Bang on.

DaDaDa · 11/09/2007 15:21

Since it's only t'internet and not real, why not pretend to be a bloke like me (I'm actually an 18 year old trainee beautician from Ormskirk)

Then you can be in the elite clique of Dads who are ignored by female posters 99% of the time, and who all ignore each other unless they're discussing who they fancy.

littlelapin · 11/09/2007 15:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.