Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to suggest that many newcomers to this site are put off by the cliqueness on this site?

142 replies

Somewhatdismayed · 11/09/2007 14:30

I think lots of people (including myself) have started to change their names and have hesitated to post recently, because they are genuinely put off by the cliques on this site. If someone, usually a newbie, dares to disagree with one of the "annointed few" even in quite a mild way, their cohorts jump on the bandwagon and a virtual strain of bullying commences.

Many of the participants in recent arguments can be divided in to two camps: the old set and those that dare to disagree with them.

Everyone welcomes and enjoys lively debate but I guess this is a plea to old timers to try and reflect on how you come across. If you had been flamed or criticised very strongly the very first time you posted, how would you feel?

I've also noticed that if someone new or fairly anonymous makes a point earlier in a thread it's ignored, but then if one of the 'elite group' makes the same point later on - everyone notices and praises them for it.

Someone actually said on a thread yesterday that conversing on Mumsnet used to be like going to a dinner party and now it's like eating at McDonalds

How snobbish and elitist is that? Please can you try and be a bit more welcoming and conciliatory to newcomers?

Stands back and waits to be flamed ...

OP posts:
quadrophenia · 11/09/2007 17:45

MN has always been like this, if you like the way it functions, you stay, if you don't then there are plenty of other sites. This isn't meant to be unwlecoming or rude, its just how it is, it's what sets Mn apart from other sites.

Saturn74 · 11/09/2007 17:43

Only read the OP.

When newcomers join with the express intention of posting unpleasant and ghoulish ideas on thread after thread after thread after thread after thread on the same subject, they deserve all they get.

I haven't seen any "snobbish and elitist" behaviour.

Any sensible newcomers know to test the ground first if they want to avoid clashing with established posters.

Like in RL.

Dropdeadfred · 11/09/2007 17:42

law3 you can have one ffor aged 11-16 and another for 16-18 yr olds. Pick the forms up from th PO and it costs £5

Dropdeadfred · 11/09/2007 17:41

PG whereabouts in the country are you? take a really outspoken friend with you just incase you need someone to speak up for you too..

berolina · 11/09/2007 17:40

I am not a particularly prolific or particularly contentious poster. I've been here 3 years, but sometimes MN (the sheer size for one, and the prolificness of the truly prolific posters for another) is capable of making me feel on the edge of things. That is Entirely My Problem, though. And, despite not being right in the thick of things, I have still made some lovely virtual friends on here. And when I have had difficulties or shit in my life, MN has been a real rock to me.

And, tbperfectlyh, MN is different. I dip into other forums but nowhere have I found the level of intelligence, reflection ahd humanity that I have here. I think here, as in RL, people gravitate towards one another for entirely natural reasons.

law3 · 11/09/2007 17:38

sorry totally off the subject, does anyone know anything about oyster cards and how old you have to be to carry one, cant find the info i need on internet?????? Could someone please come to my rescue and redeem yourself!!!!!!

PondusLector · 11/09/2007 17:27

I thought it was a comment about quality - crap food v haute cuisine!

But crumpet, you have explained and I now understand and think it is a fair point. See, we do listen

crumpet · 11/09/2007 17:20

Won't make any difference what I say, people will take it how they want.

pyjamagirl · 11/09/2007 17:18

I know I've heard so many stories about bridal store staff it's put me off a bit

pagwatch · 11/09/2007 17:18

um class? - isn't it more about a substantial number of people who don't know each other 'passing through' rather than six or eight friends engaging. Not my comment but thats how I interpreted it...

Pobblestoes · 11/09/2007 17:15

So it wasn't a comment about class then Crumpet?

SueBaroo · 11/09/2007 17:14

It's fairly easy to feel piled on wherever you might be posting online, surely? Depends on what the topic is mostly. And how aggressive you start off, of course.

If you've got the balls to start off arsey and carry on that way, then good luck to you. I reckon LoveAngel is a bit like that and she always makes me laugh (in a good way).

Dropdeadfred · 11/09/2007 17:13

why PG? I am just not sure I'm going to be someone who knows 'the dress' when she finds it..I can't even be satisfied with a pushchair for long so how can I pick a gown I'll still be proud of for years?

pyjamagirl · 11/09/2007 17:10

Thats about as much as we have dome too got some bargain tiaras from ebay the other day aswell though
I am dreading dress shopping

crumpet · 11/09/2007 17:07

Saw a reference to the dinner/McDonalds on another thread too...must be the most controversial thing I've said!

Take it how you want, but it's true. The site has moved from a place where you could keep up to speed with all the convos around you, and now its difficult to "hear" what's going on with so many people and so much shouting. There used to be spats in the past but none of the continuous haranguing there is now.

So yes, exactly like the difference between a dinner party and McDonalds.

Not even an original pov - first came up ages ago and I can't claim to have been original enough to have thought of it...
happy to stand by it though.

Dropdeadfred · 11/09/2007 17:06

not at all PG..we have booked the venue and the registrar and thats it!!! and only 10 months to go!

pyjamagirl · 11/09/2007 17:05

Ohh thanks drop dead fred I found a really friendly forum about weddings I love it in there

Youandyourwedding.co.uk

You get a counddown to your wedding and everything lol

can you tell i'm a bit wedding obsessed at the moment ??

Are you a scary organised B2B I'm not lol

smugmumofboys · 11/09/2007 17:05

I'm newish too and think that the perceived cliqueyness brings out my inner 14 year-old! But hey ho, I'm 38 and have lots of RL friends so I get over it. I have found the site really useful in terms of parenting tips and just the reassurance that my children and their behaviours are no worse than anyone else's. I'm too slow and crap a typist to keep up with fast-moving chat threads.

Dropdeadfred · 11/09/2007 17:01

OOOhh I get married next July...I'll let you talk weddings without being bitchy..

pyjamagirl · 11/09/2007 17:00

I get married next september

OrmIrian · 11/09/2007 16:58

You do need to shout sometimes. And repeat the same thing several times. And sometimes what you thought was an innocuous comment can cause ructions and great offence. And sometimes you can get so cross that you post something that seems quite huffy and offensive and it gets ignored. Weird place. But that's how it is and I would respectfully suggest that if it isn't for you I'd try somewhere else. But if you think you can put up with the inconsistency and the little irritations it's worthwhile for all the good stuff.

TwitmonstEr · 11/09/2007 16:56

lol mellow. I would like to say that as a newish member I have made a few friends on here. I joined up because
a] I had a specific question and having lurked for quite some time, felt mn was the best place for me.
and
b] Being pregnant with my 4th child, and with a dp who works away all week meant that I was spending every evening alone and starting to get a bit down.
I started mning and now have some adult 'company' when the lo's are in bed, as well as the support of various experts and the support of an ante-natal group as well.

So thank you mumsnet and thank you to everyone who has made me feel welcome.

pagwatch · 11/09/2007 16:51

Agree totally Madamez. Special needs and parenting are great. Not sure what I would have to do to get flamed on SN! I have occasionally dipped a toe into the other sections but I mostly just read around. I actually comment less than when I first joined because I got sucked in on some of the 'difficult'threads and then realised that no one was interested in anyone elses opinion and if I just want to hear people shouting at each other there are other places to go.
Some of the posts are laugh out loud funny and it is often sharp witty and thought provoking. So I love an hour here when I can

LoveAngel · 11/09/2007 16:48

It's not being 'in', it's getting used to the site. There is an acronym list, too.

lizzih1974 · 11/09/2007 16:47

what puts me off is all of the abbreviations, obviously the 'in crowd' know what they are talking about, I have no idea