Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to suggest that many newcomers to this site are put off by the cliqueness on this site?

142 replies

Somewhatdismayed · 11/09/2007 14:30

I think lots of people (including myself) have started to change their names and have hesitated to post recently, because they are genuinely put off by the cliques on this site. If someone, usually a newbie, dares to disagree with one of the "annointed few" even in quite a mild way, their cohorts jump on the bandwagon and a virtual strain of bullying commences.

Many of the participants in recent arguments can be divided in to two camps: the old set and those that dare to disagree with them.

Everyone welcomes and enjoys lively debate but I guess this is a plea to old timers to try and reflect on how you come across. If you had been flamed or criticised very strongly the very first time you posted, how would you feel?

I've also noticed that if someone new or fairly anonymous makes a point earlier in a thread it's ignored, but then if one of the 'elite group' makes the same point later on - everyone notices and praises them for it.

Someone actually said on a thread yesterday that conversing on Mumsnet used to be like going to a dinner party and now it's like eating at McDonalds

How snobbish and elitist is that? Please can you try and be a bit more welcoming and conciliatory to newcomers?

Stands back and waits to be flamed ...

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SimplerTimes00s · 09/11/2022 19:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ as it's a PBP

cocolepew · 12/09/2007 18:03

What I worry about is offending someone by turning off the computer and then 5 minutes later someone asks a question that could be aimed at me. So if it ever happens, sorry in advance.

Don't know Aitch, I used to call my dd2 it when she was a baby

Dior · 11/09/2007 20:05

Message withdrawn

kindersurprise · 11/09/2007 20:03

Only read the OP and a few responses.

I am reasonably new to MN and have only once had a rude(ish) response, but nothing to make me upset. I am an adult and I can cope with honest opinions of others, even when I don't agree with them.

Obviously, there are MNetters who have been here for years and they know each other well, have met up in RL and they respond to each others posts. They also support each other, which is completely normal for friends.

I like the honesty on MN, the humour and the help and support available for those who need it.

If you don't like it, go and form your own clique on another website.

Aitch · 11/09/2007 19:32

was coco the girl skunk?

littlelapin · 11/09/2007 19:30

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

morningpaper · 11/09/2007 19:28

cocolepew
"I've only been on MN for a few weeks. How can you tell who is in a clique? Even when I remember to read the posters name, I've forgotten it 2 seconds later."

I am pretty much the same - I rarely look at names. I think that some people get the vibe from the get-go and fit in well - there are lots of newbies who just slot in and you think they've been around forever because they obviously 'get it'

Somewhatdismayed · 11/09/2007 19:10

F&Z

OP posts:
FrannyandZooey · 11/09/2007 18:50

Oh come out

at least we will remember you now

Somewhatdismayed · 11/09/2007 18:44

I take the point about the difference between some people knowing others for a long time v cliques.

In my experience though in RL most people ARE willing to give you a fair go if you are new to a situation.

I'm not a habitual complainer or whinger. I'm human. Like others, I come on Mumsnet because life with dc can sometimes be boring, lonely and a bit crap. Then life on Mumsnet gets a bit crap too!

I was making a protest about the tone of some of the threads and some of the unecessary nastiness, especially to newbies.

Having seen the other threads in AIBU which mimic this one, I'm glad I made the decision to "hide" behind a name change. Yes, I'm a coward.

Thanks for the reasoned responses though.

OP posts:
Snogsuck · 11/09/2007 18:41

I'm a newbie and although I've changed my name a couple of times, I feel welcome. In fact I'd completely addicted already. Used to post on a birth board on a certain other website and got bullied off it for being honest and perhaps slightly feisty... that's why I like it here!

cocolepew · 11/09/2007 18:35

I've only been on MN for a few weeks. How can you tell who is in a clique? Even when I remember to read the posters name, I've forgotten it 2 seconds later.

Clique isn't the right word. Surely if people have been on it for x number of years, they're going to have shared experiences, therefore get to know each other better. I've only posted a few times,and have no problems. Everyone is lovely.

What an arselicker

law3 · 11/09/2007 18:32

cod - you obviously missed the irony in that!!!

quadrophenia · 11/09/2007 18:23
Pobblestoes · 11/09/2007 18:20

you cared enough to post though Cod

FluffyMummy123 · 11/09/2007 18:08

Message withdrawn

law3 · 11/09/2007 18:08

cheers dropdeadfred, you are hereby my favourite mumnetter

curiouscat · 11/09/2007 18:05

Hi somewhat, sorry you feel like that. I've been a member for 6 months and though I recognise regular posters sometimes I've never found it cliquey. I've killed a few threads but it happens to everyone .

I steer clear of threads which will obviously wind me up (style/news/politics) or upset me (bereavement/miscarriage/depression). NOT suggesting you should avoid anything of course, merely that there's probably room for everyone here.

VagusPabo · 11/09/2007 18:00

Just read the OP and last few posts.

It's all about perception - you really need a thick skin for internet forums. People will tell you exactly what they think without the social niceties or non verbal nuances. It's easy to misconstrue a reply, or lack of one.

Everyone gets ignored from time to time. HAve a look through 'unanswered threads' - plenty of oldies and prolific posters on there.

And I have to say, I don't buy into the whole clique thing. But I am v glad you didn't call it a cleak, click or quiche

Shame you felt you had to name change - you won't get to know people well by hiding behind your non-regular name.

hifi · 11/09/2007 17:58

didnt mean one off toS, see, no sense of humour sometimes also.

nurseyemma · 11/09/2007 17:53

Stuff not stiff sorry for crap typing/spelling

nurseyemma · 11/09/2007 17:51

I have found MN very supportive on a couple of occasions and with some v helpful info but the reason I sound riled in my last post is because I read a HORRIBLE thread yesterday about mums you hate in the school playground.

Strated off quite dry and funny quickly deteriorated into nastiness.

Expect I might be one of those "boho" types that seem to be universally hated when my dd starts school. OR I might turn up in full make-up and a ponytail cos I've got important stiff on at work (another hated playground Mum). Hope none of these Mum haters lives round my way

hifi · 11/09/2007 17:50

i do agree with the clique thing but i use mn mainly for advice, and have been given some very good advice indeed. some holy cows are annoying and downright snobbish and am sure if they were newis wouldnt be tolerated.
some posters imagine alsorts of racism going on etc. when half the time none intended.the bad spellers throw me.

nurseyemma · 11/09/2007 17:47

haven't read all this thread can't be bothered but it's totally fucking ridiculous!

Didn't realise you needed to be accepted, or ingratiated into a "crowd" on an internet chat site.

I don't post that often cos I'm busy having a busy life, howver I thought the point of it was about having a supportive forum to listen and share advice, not about bitching and excluding each other.

this is typical of a bunch of women, I used to worry about not being in the clique at school, too old for it now and the reason why most of my mates are blokes.

Don't get the elitist cliqey thing. Form groups of similarly minded people but no need to be exclusive about it.

Saturn74 · 11/09/2007 17:46

Hello Quad!
How're ya doin'?