Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour told my kid off.

265 replies

Shootingstar2918 · 26/03/2020 17:23

I’m not precious and nor do I think my kids are angels! But hear me out. Most of the houses around me have kids living in them. Due to the current situation a lot of them are out playing understandably.

My children were playing outside whilst I cleaned up. All of a sudden DS started screaming that he’d been told off and told me the man who lives behind us told him off. I couldn’t see what DS was doing. There’s a Tallish fence between our gardens so I cannot imagine a lot could be done.

Just to add DS has autism and wants to talk to everyone. I think he was at the back of the fence shouting hello. I’m not really sure. My garden is secure and safe enough to let them out without me being outside. I was in the kitchen with my patio doors open but missed what actually happened. Sometimes DS can be a bit loud but I don’t let him out for hours on end or anything. Far from it.

So a man told him off. If he did wrong then that’s fine but the man told him off with no explanation. When I came out he hurried in his house and slammed the door. Aibu to think he should talk to me. With distance of course!

Like I say DS has autism. My neighbours wouldn’t know this I guess but it’s ended up with DS having an hour long meltdown on the grass outside. They must be able to hear him.

I’m not the type to go matching round and of course we can’t right now anyway but aibu to think the guy should man up and come and speak to us (again distance) and give me an explanation at least! So I know what the hell just happened. DS is that upset he can’t explain to me!

OP posts:
cakewench · 26/03/2020 19:56

"bit weird why a man would be standing alone in his garden"

FGS it's his garden, people are getting told off for walking in the streets, leave the man in peace in his own bloody garden.

I'm not weighing in on the interaction with your child because as you say, you've no idea what actually happened. However, this isn't the time to be nitpicking people wrt how they choose to spend their time on lockdown.

Puffalicious · 26/03/2020 19:54

choli so the OP needs to be stuck like glue to both her DC as they have ASN/ SEN, just in case they might possibly irritate the one neighbour who doesn't know them? If you had ASN/ SEN children you'd know how depressing that sentence sounds.

Jellycatspyjamas · 26/03/2020 19:52

Yelling at a child for shouting hello, or whatever it is "DS" did, which was verbal, probably non confrontational, and not physically damaging. I just really can't imagine any neighbour here reprimanding a child for repeatedly speaking, or even shouting, for that matter.

But no one knows that’s what happened, the OP is assuming her son was trying to say hello, and assuming the neighbour shouted at her child but she wasn’t there and neither of her children can tell her what happened. It’s equally possible the neighbour didn’t reply, asked him not to call over the fence etc etc we don’t actually know.

Bugaboob · 26/03/2020 19:51

I would Never tell another child Off. I would
Speak To their parents

And there you have it. You wouldn’t but lots would. This is not a serious thing OP get a grip

choli · 26/03/2020 19:51

the OPs son doesn't chose to be annoying, does he?
No, but the OP chooses to leave him unsupervised to annoy the neighbors.

Sabine123 · 26/03/2020 19:51

Sounds a very unfortunate incident but people are quite worried and stressed at the moment. I would let it go and let you son carry on as normal in the garden tomorrow. Keep an eye out and if anything further happens maybe pop a note through door explaining your son's condition. I do agree with you - I would never shout at someone else's child - always speak to the parent but maybe your neighbour is a bit "old school" ! Not an excuse but possibly a reason. Good luck and let it go.

Puffalicious · 26/03/2020 19:50

More serious things on their mind? I've lost my father very recently, have a child with a debilitating, serious illness and there's a world pandemic: I'd still find 2 seconds to say a simple hello. Hell, even if George Clooney had decided to call me and offer me a night of unbridled passion I'd have had a sec to say hello!

Chinks123 · 26/03/2020 19:49

I honestly didn’t know how many people hate children
I don’t think anyone’s said they hate children? It’s ok to admit that children are irritating, they are, just like adults are irritating.

In the supermarket today, a grown adult, not distancing and getting right up my backside with her basket= irritating.

Neighbours child, leaning over my fence and shouting constantly= irritating.

I like children, but when I’m in my garden to be honest it does really annoy me when they keep jabbering on. I smile politely and say hello because...what can you do. I always watch my dd and have more than once said “come away now leave them alone.” And the person either smiles in appreciation Grin or says its fine and carries on chatting to her.

DartmoorChef · 26/03/2020 19:48

think a few people have missed that the guy in question was invading our own privacy earlier by being stood
Up at the back
Or his garden over our fence talking to our neighbour over the way whilst my kids played! That was an invasion
Of our privacy !

Confused you are starting to sound like the nightmare neighbours

FrippEnos · 26/03/2020 19:47

Shootingstar2918
I honestly didn’t know how many people hate children 🤣

Most people hate being annoyed by someone whatever the age.

my wasn’t lingering by his fence. He just went up to speak.

By your "thoughts" he repeatedly shouted "hello" at him.

blue25 · 26/03/2020 19:47

You need to supervise your children better. Be considerate towards your neighbours.

Winterlife · 26/03/2020 19:45

Doing what?

Yelling at a child for shouting hello, or whatever it is "DS" did, which was verbal, probably non confrontational, and not physically damaging. I just really can't imagine any neighbour here reprimanding a child for repeatedly speaking, or even shouting, for that matter.

Puffalicious · 26/03/2020 19:45

Fripp but the point is if the person just said a quick hello back there would be no repetition! It's not difficult to understand. This whole situation right now shows us that we don't live in isolation and we need common courtesy and community relationships.

BritishHorrorStory · 26/03/2020 19:45

I think a few people have missed that the guy in question was invading our own privacy earlier by being stood Up at the back Or his garden over our fence talking to our neighbour over the way whilst my kids played! That was an invasion Of our privacy !

No it wasn’t. He was standing in his own garden.

Duchessofblandings · 26/03/2020 19:45

I understand that your priority is your son but you have no idea what your neighbour is going through. In these uncertain times, he could have been standing at the end of his garden trying to find some equilibrium. He could, providence forbid, have lost a loved one, there are any number of scenarios.

Likewise, he doesn’t know that your son won’t stop until someone replies. Some people are asking what sort of person doesn’t reply to a child? Maybe someone who has far more serious things on his mind.

You need to directly supervise all outside play at this difficult time for everyone. If you can’t, your boy needs to play inside when you’re busy.

Biancadelrioisback · 26/03/2020 19:43

I love children but I still think YABU

Jellycatspyjamas · 26/03/2020 19:42

I've just assumed it's a "British" thing, as I live in Canada, and can't imagine a neighbour doing this.
Doing what? The OP has no idea what happened - there’s no evidence to suggest the neighbour said anything at all much less that he told her child off, shouted at him or anything else. The OP saw the neighbour go inside and her child upset but doesn’t know what happened between them, if anything.

Puffalicious · 26/03/2020 19:42

Winterlife thank God for another voice of reason and kindness. The USSR set-up sounds just lovely and exactly like it was where I grew up ( West coast of Scotland). It may be a ' British' thing is some places but certainly not where I'm from or some of my family ( Ireland/ N Ireland).

Sceptre86 · 26/03/2020 19:42

Nothing wrong with your kids being in the garden and you were in the kitchen not upstairs so not irresponsible. However, you are being super defensive, knock on his door and stand 2m away and ask if there is an issue if you are annoyed. Otherwise attempt to spend as much time with the kids when they are outdoors. Whether your son understands or not kids noise is unsettling for a lot of people. I can't say I enjoy hearing kids shrieking and that includes my own!

Shootingstar2918 · 26/03/2020 19:41

I honestly didn’t know how many people hate children 🤣 my wasn’t lingering by his fence. He just went up to speak.

I think a few people have missed that the guy in question was invading our own privacy earlier by being stood
Up at the back
Or his garden over our fence talking to our neighbour over the way whilst my kids played! That was an invasion
Of our privacy !

OP posts:
FrippEnos · 26/03/2020 19:40

Puffalicious

If a child is saying "hello" repeatedly, then they are "pestering" and "irritating".

Puffalicious · 26/03/2020 19:39

British yes it's annoying but the OPs son doesn't chose to be annoying, does he? It's nothing out of an NT adult's day to say a quick word back.

JeanJackeys · 26/03/2020 19:38

I wouldn't respond to a child who kept shouting at me in my garden in case they thought it was the green light to annoy me every time. Especially if they had been doing it for a while and there was no sign of a parent around.

I have young children. It's up to me to ensure they don't annoy people. Not make nasty little comments implying he's dodgy because he's at the end of his own garden.

Winterlife · 26/03/2020 19:38

There is something very, very wrong with our world when we have no patience for a child.

This. I am quite flabbergasted at many of the responses here. I've just assumed it's a "British" thing, as I live in Canada, and can't imagine a neighbour doing this. I also lived in the USSR, in a neighbourhood of apartments which all opened to large common spaces with benches, where babushkas went to sit, men sat playing dominoes after work, and children ran around noisily. No one ever said a thing to the children, it was considered perfectly normal for children to be running around, playing noisily and occasionally talking to anyone outside. It was not uncommon for any unrelated person to stop and take a child's hanky and wipe his/her nose, or tie a two year old's shoe.

Puffalicious · 26/03/2020 19:37

Pestered? Irritating children? The language on here completely confirms that people see children as irritants. It's so sad.