Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour told my kid off.

265 replies

Shootingstar2918 · 26/03/2020 17:23

I’m not precious and nor do I think my kids are angels! But hear me out. Most of the houses around me have kids living in them. Due to the current situation a lot of them are out playing understandably.

My children were playing outside whilst I cleaned up. All of a sudden DS started screaming that he’d been told off and told me the man who lives behind us told him off. I couldn’t see what DS was doing. There’s a Tallish fence between our gardens so I cannot imagine a lot could be done.

Just to add DS has autism and wants to talk to everyone. I think he was at the back of the fence shouting hello. I’m not really sure. My garden is secure and safe enough to let them out without me being outside. I was in the kitchen with my patio doors open but missed what actually happened. Sometimes DS can be a bit loud but I don’t let him out for hours on end or anything. Far from it.

So a man told him off. If he did wrong then that’s fine but the man told him off with no explanation. When I came out he hurried in his house and slammed the door. Aibu to think he should talk to me. With distance of course!

Like I say DS has autism. My neighbours wouldn’t know this I guess but it’s ended up with DS having an hour long meltdown on the grass outside. They must be able to hear him.

I’m not the type to go matching round and of course we can’t right now anyway but aibu to think the guy should man up and come and speak to us (again distance) and give me an explanation at least! So I know what the hell just happened. DS is that upset he can’t explain to me!

OP posts:
FlamingoAndJohn · 26/03/2020 21:08

The girl who lives next door but one to me is a perfectly sweet girl but never ever shuts up. If I even vaguely acknowledge her it’s just constant questions. Therefore I tend to pretend I don’t hear her. That doesn’t stop her narrating everything she is doing.
I don’t hate children but she does drive me to distraction. I’m hoping she grows out of it.

Cheesepleas3 · 26/03/2020 20:58

If the neighbour is so entitled to peace and quiet to the point of telling a kid off, then surely it's a bit hypocritical of them to be chatting across someone else's garden?
I agree that it's not necessarily a bad thing for someone else to tell you child off, if the child is visibly distressed and a parent becomes present then the parent is entitled to an explanation!

Wilmalovescake · 26/03/2020 20:57

“It's clearly the neighbours fault. He chose a house and talks to other neighbours and has a cat and stood at the end of his garden like an absolute bastard instead of staying on his decking when OPs husband is a KEYWORKER!”

Brilliant GrinGrin

OP you just sound more and more unreasonable every time you post. Supervise your kids properly and stop making shit up that you don’t even know happened.

Redrover87 · 26/03/2020 20:46

Ahhh another one of those threads where everyone tells OP they are wrong and we just get a long drip feed of BUT BUT BUT
Accept you’re wrong op

alloutoffucks · 26/03/2020 20:40

In the nicest possible way, children can often say they were told off when a stranger did no such thing. The man could have said simply, I don't want to talk, please go away.

Thisismytimetoshine · 26/03/2020 20:38

You’re still not getting it, are you? Nobody “hates children”, they just don’t want to be pestered by yours. It’s quite simple, really.
Baffled at what you’re finding so hard to understand?

Bulb1976 · 26/03/2020 20:36

Poor man, can you imagine living near OP and her friend.

Probably just wanted to get some fresh air

nothingcanhurtmewithmyeyesshut · 26/03/2020 20:36

Tbf children's account of what was said and how isnt exactly reliable. Apparently I told off next doors son once. I told him off for playing near the fence. What actually happened was that he was swinging off the fence and trying to walk up it with his feet while holding onto the top and I said to him Be careful mate, you'll get loads of splinters.

Children are prone to over exaggerating.

Leaannb · 26/03/2020 20:36

Lot of excuses for the child and refusing to take responsibility for your child. You know your child has this issue so you should be with him to redirect him from bad behavior. Yes repeatedly yelling hello at someone is horrible behavior. Having Autisim unless extremely severe is not an excuse for bad behavior and poor supervision. Your neighbor has the right to peaceful enjoyment of his garden and has the right to stand anywhere he wants in his own garden. I would have ignored you also because you wouldn't have liked what I would have had to say. In that situation its best to walk away before true problems surface

taybert · 26/03/2020 20:35

The thing is, if I said something to a child who wasn’t mine and they got really worked up and cried, even if I didn’t mean to do that, and even if I’d been entirely justified in my complaint, I would feel worried for the child. Because I’m an adult and they are not. If their parent then appeared, I would be at pains to describe the incident so that they didn’t think I had hurt the child or something, and I would also be keen to check on the welfare of the child. If he’d done that this thread wouldn’t exist. And yes, maybe the child was being annoying in some way and he was entirely justified in his actions and there’s no way he could have expected the outcome it had. But he could have just spoken to the OP and explained. Then everything probably would have been ok (and before anyone says it, it’s perfectly possible to have a conversation at 2 meters).

That said.....maybe he has ASD and finds persistent small people distressing and difficult to deal with. Two sides to every story and that.

TiddlestheCat · 26/03/2020 20:35

It is unreasonable to expect the OP to fully supervise her son every minute of the day whilst he's in their own garden. I would be tempted to slip a note through his door apologising for anything that happened, but explain that your son is autistic and gets easily upset. If he understands and realises that your son is autistic, as opposed to being a noisy kid, he might feel more understanding and find it less annoying/stressful. It's hard for everyone right now.

vhs95 · 26/03/2020 20:34

As nobody seems to know what actually happened (apart from the man next door) I'd let it go but be on the alert for any further trouble and then you'll know if you need to intervene. I would think your neighbour will steer well clear having heard the melt down tbh.

Bowerbird5 · 26/03/2020 20:34

Could he have been climbing over the fence? I ask because yesterday morning I went out in the garden with my mug of tea to find the boy from next door in our garden. I didn’t shout but then I work with kids. I just told him politely that he shouldn’t be in our garden then I said Do you remember why you aren’t at school ? That is why you should be in our garden. He hadn’t gone to retrieve a ball etc. I was giving him a gentle reminder but I doubt if my husband would have been quite as calm.
I don’t think you can do anything unless you leave a note to phone you and the number but do you want that. I would just explain the man was feeling cross.

Dzundza · 26/03/2020 20:31

What you find an endearing "hello" could come across as annoyingly disturbing someone. People tend to accept a lot more from their kids than other people find acceptable.

AlexaAmbidextra · 26/03/2020 20:30

Hang on a minute. Why do posters keep on saying that the neighbour shouted at the child? OP said he was ‘told off’, she doesn’t say he was shouted at. Still, I suppose it adds a bit of drama doesn’t it?

Shootingstar2918 · 26/03/2020 20:26

I’ve also heard from
Other sources (the woman who lives next door to him who is a friend of mine) that he hates her kids too. Makes me feel a bit better I suppose!

OP posts:
maneandfeathers · 26/03/2020 20:25

I wouldn’t want to speak to a child or adult who shouted hello through my fence either sorry OP. It would really annoy me too, I feel like my garden is an extension of my home and I wouldn’t want someone shouting hello through the windows either!

dontdisturbmenow · 26/03/2020 20:25

Stop trying to find reasons why he was unreasonable to tell you son off when you have no idea what really happened and therefore coming up with scenarios that suit your position. If you don't want to be in this situation, then don't leave your kids unsupervised for even 15 minutes.

Why should the guy come and talk to you when you were not there to see what happened?

Either accept that your kids will be told off if they do things that annoy others and your bit there to avoid it or be there at all time.

Of course instead of directing your energy trying to find blame on him, you could have tried to explain to your DS, in language he can grasp, why people might react negatively to some of his actions even if not meant to upset.

SewItGoes · 26/03/2020 20:20

I honestly can't blame the man for not wanting to talk to you about it, if your son was having a meltdown. He probably just wanted to get away from the noise and not have to deal with it. Maybe he even thought that it would only make things worse, since whatever he said the first time (?) had triggered such a massive reaction.

You're free to dislike him for it, of course. He's probably not your biggest fan, either, rightly or wrongly!

Shootingstar2918 · 26/03/2020 20:17

Standing up over our shared fence over our garden to talk to the person next to our house. With the way it’s layed here they were talking loudly over the corner of our garden. Felt very invasive when we were in the garden!

OP posts:
PurpleCrazyHorse · 26/03/2020 20:11

Currently, it's a pretty testing time for everyone with many people experiencing extreme financial hardship as well as worries over the health of family and friends. Not everyone is operating at their very best. Not an excuse, but possibly understandable.

Your neighbour also isn't a mind reader and wouldn't know that simply saying 'hi' back would stop your son repeatedly asking (if that is what he was doing), often a response can open the floodgates of conversation. As you didn't hear anything, he can't have shouted at your son, maybe he just asked him to go away?

Alloftheboys · 26/03/2020 20:08

OP: “Neighbour upset my son, even though I don’t know what he said or did.
He should be more understanding of my sons additional needs, even though he doesn’t know he has them.
Neighbour shouldn’t stand at the end of his own garden.
I can’t leave my son alone for a moment, even though I did.”
Have I missed anything?

Duchessofblandings · 26/03/2020 20:01

Everyone’s different, Puffalicious

Yes, there is a pandemic, that’s exactly the point. OP has no idea about her neighbour’s current circumstances.

Sirzy · 26/03/2020 20:00

puffalicious I have a child with autism. I know I can’t leave him unsupervised in the garden, I know I need to be at very best within ear shot of him at all times.

It’s not ideal but it’s life!

Wineislifex · 26/03/2020 19:56

It’s pointless even debating this as we have no idea of the facts. The man might not have said anything to the child, he may have simply become upset because the man didn’t acknowledge him. If the mother was supervising him then this incident would not have occurred and the child would not have had a meltdown and strangers on the internet would not be slagging off a man enjoying his own garden!