Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Neighbour told my kid off.

265 replies

Shootingstar2918 · 26/03/2020 17:23

I’m not precious and nor do I think my kids are angels! But hear me out. Most of the houses around me have kids living in them. Due to the current situation a lot of them are out playing understandably.

My children were playing outside whilst I cleaned up. All of a sudden DS started screaming that he’d been told off and told me the man who lives behind us told him off. I couldn’t see what DS was doing. There’s a Tallish fence between our gardens so I cannot imagine a lot could be done.

Just to add DS has autism and wants to talk to everyone. I think he was at the back of the fence shouting hello. I’m not really sure. My garden is secure and safe enough to let them out without me being outside. I was in the kitchen with my patio doors open but missed what actually happened. Sometimes DS can be a bit loud but I don’t let him out for hours on end or anything. Far from it.

So a man told him off. If he did wrong then that’s fine but the man told him off with no explanation. When I came out he hurried in his house and slammed the door. Aibu to think he should talk to me. With distance of course!

Like I say DS has autism. My neighbours wouldn’t know this I guess but it’s ended up with DS having an hour long meltdown on the grass outside. They must be able to hear him.

I’m not the type to go matching round and of course we can’t right now anyway but aibu to think the guy should man up and come and speak to us (again distance) and give me an explanation at least! So I know what the hell just happened. DS is that upset he can’t explain to me!

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 26/03/2020 18:32

I think a child’s definition of being told off is not the same as an adult’s. The guy could have just asked him to stop shouting which if he was is not unreasonable.

dontdisturbmenow · 26/03/2020 18:28

So tired of parents who send their kids in the garden to let them off steam whilst they enjoy some peace and quiet inside. I had to tell our neighbour kids to keep it down. I did so very gently and smiling, it's it their fault. But they were screaming, one having a massive tantrum, shrieking to the top of her lungs and I couldn't understand why the parent wasn't intervening. Sure enough, when I looked up, not one parent and door to the garden closed. The kids are all under 5.

Unless your garden is in the middle of nowhere, don't treat it like a playground. Supervise your kids and tell them off if they misbehave. I love the sound of kids playing, it's heart warming, but shouting screaming and crying out loud is horrible racket.

willowpatterns · 26/03/2020 18:26

To be totally honest, people don't just tell other people's children off for no reason at all. Therefore it is highly likely that your dc was doing something that warranted a telling-off. Perhaps if the neighbour knew your dc has autism then he may have been more understanding, but everyone is more stressed out than usual at the moment. I'd let it go. And try to explain to your dc (in a way that he can comprehend) that he needs to stop shouting at people who are the other side of the fence.

TerrorWig · 26/03/2020 18:25

This is like the opposite side to those threads about children shrieking all day.

Elieza · 26/03/2020 18:24

Parents get used to the unbelievable amount of noise and destruction their offspring cause. They stop noticing it.

Those who have been enjoying peace and quiet in the garden when they can’t go out much due to cv may get a bit stressed by the racket if they don’t have dc or if they have grown up years ago and they have forgotten the amount of noise kids cause.

He could have had more understanding and patience. But you could have been there to supervise. You don’t know what happened. I’d supervise dc in future.

TheMagiciansMewTwo · 26/03/2020 18:24

You don't know what your DS was doing or saying. But you think the neighbour should have spoken to you - when you weren't there and the entire country is in lockdown so the neighbour can't come to your door even if he wanted to Confused

sussexman · 26/03/2020 18:22

Hi @Shootingstar2918

So we have a (14 y.o) with ASD so I can empathise. I'd say if this has upset you this much then it's up to you to speak to your neighbour. He most likely just feels he told a noisy kid off and/or that they then had a tantrum! Most people when told about how an ASD child processes things can understand and future interactions are then more productive for both sides. Until they are told/encounter children with ASD they most likely have no clue how to interact with them (you can see this from some of the suggestions on this thread). I sometimes have no clue how to interact effectively with my own child for that matter! A neighbour that understands and makes some effort will be way more valuable than one that gets irritated by the awful children over the fence :)

And yes, sometimes people don't get it. That sucks. Sometimes, it feels like people with ASD have to make social allowances for thpse of us who are NT.

Friendsofmine · 26/03/2020 18:22

He doesn't need your permission to tell your kid to stop shouting surely.

Mummyoflittledragon · 26/03/2020 18:20

Your ds May have been a bit loud. But unless your ds is doing it constantly, it sounds like the man was being a bit ott. If otoh your ds was climbing and hanging over the fence and potentially breathing on your neighbours land (neighbour could be just there thus rendering isolation pointless), I could understand why he’d tell your ds off.

Thisismytimetoshine · 26/03/2020 18:18

Go out and supervise your child, if he repeatedly shouts over the fence at the neighbours Confused
Why haven’t you had the wit to ask one of your other children what the “telling off” consisted of?

WorraLiberty · 26/03/2020 18:18

I think if there was a real issue he should have spoken to you rather than scuttle off into his house as soon as you appeared. Someone who does that was probably just being unpleasant and didn't expect you to overhear or arrive on the scene.

He didn't 'scuttle' anywhere. He went back into his own home.

sonjadog · 26/03/2020 18:16

I think what you should take from this is that you need to supervise your kids when they are outside. As it is, you don´t actually know what happened. Did he tell him off? Was it justified? Was he too harsh or fair? You don´t know.

KatherineJaneway · 26/03/2020 18:16

Really? I'd just say "Hello, how are you?" back to the child.

No way, then they never leave you alone!

JRUIN · 26/03/2020 18:14

You weren't around to tell your DS off for annoying your neighbour so your neighbour had to do it. People are entitled to peace and privacy in their own gardens you know.

YgritteSnow · 26/03/2020 18:13

I think if there was a real issue he should have spoken to you rather than scuttle off into his house as soon as you appeared. Someone who does that was probably just being unpleasant and didn't expect you to overhear or arrive on the scene.

SarahInAccounts · 26/03/2020 18:10

You have no idea what happened. He may have been right to speak sharply. You just don't know.

Winterlife · 26/03/2020 18:06

I'd tell a kid shouting hello at me over my fence to stop as well.

Really? I'd just say "Hello, how are you?" back to the child.

TerrorWig · 26/03/2020 18:05

So you weren’t there, you have no idea what was said or not but admit your son can sometimes shout into the back garden.

Not actually sure what you want? If you don’t know what your son was doing, and you clearly don’t know what he was told off for, and you didn’t hear anything - do you not think maybe your DS was told to be quiet which he has interpreted as ‘told off’?

Confused no I don’t think the man should explain to you why he might have told a loud child to stop shouting at him, which is the most likely thing that happened. I think you should explain to your son that your neighbour wants to be left alone.

(Yes I understand he has autism. But it’s your responsibility to teach him he can’t do everything he wants or to supervise him so you can intervene before he gets told off).

Malvinaa81 · 26/03/2020 17:58

Your neighbour was within his rights, so maybe your child needs more supervision- then this wouldn't happen.

WorraLiberty · 26/03/2020 17:56

What did your other kids say when you asked them about it?

Wineislifex · 26/03/2020 17:55

I would leave it. Just tell your son not to pester the neighbours in future, not everyone wants to talk to children!

BeetrootRocks · 26/03/2020 17:55

Gardens are small in lots of areas and children have needs too.

So far we've had, they should be banned from supermarkets (irrespective of single parents etc) and multiple threads about how if they must go in the garden they must basically make no noise.

This country has a reputation for not being child friendly and I think it is fair.

Children need exercise and play and laughter and all that but they are way down the list in priority order for many in the UK. I think it's pretty bad tbh.

Seen and not heard and preferably not even seen is the way it goes. No wonder we have such issues with pnd and lack of help for kids living in povery etc etc (even before all this).

FrancisCrawford · 26/03/2020 17:55

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

JuanSheetIsPlenty · 26/03/2020 17:54

Well what did the man even say? Confused you’re becoming all outraged but do you even know what he said? He mightn’t have told him off at all!

Crackerofdoom · 26/03/2020 17:52

I would relax OP.

Do you tell your kids off when they are annoying you?

When my kids are annoying me I tell them to stop.

My kids play out and when they are annoying to the neighbour, the neighbour tells them to stop.

I don't see it as any different.

Obviously if he was aggressive or threatening or used bad language I would intervene but you don't know what was said.

If you don't want the neighbour telling your kids off then you need to supervise them more.

And if you want him to take into account your son's ASD then you should talk to him.

I have made a point to introduce myself and my kids to the neighbours who share garden boundaries with us and have made it clear to the kids that the neighbours should also be able to enjoy their gardens without the zoo of my 3 kids screaming all day at them.