Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect Mumsnet NOT TO ALLOW OPENLY RACIST THREADS TO STAND UNDELETED?

235 replies

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 11:23

Hmm? Well AM I?

If someone tells me not to click on the FUCKING thread in question, I think I will explode. Racism should have no place on Mumsnet.

OP posts:
LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 12:17

I don't think HB is 'overly riled'. I think she appears to feel strongly about a very serious issue. The place for hugs and coffee is Netmums by the way. Even a newbie like HB knows that much.

choccybuttons · 10/09/2007 12:15

'So what do you do when you see a coven of racists getting together and cosily exchanging the same nasty little views?'

You look at them and think what a sad bunch of narrow minded tossers. You don't try and get the thread deleted because that won't erase the issue, it would simply be putting a temporory band aid over the it. Like someone said, we need threads like that now and again, not so people can throw nasty rastist comments about but so people can educate those who have these nasty views and maybe try and change their perspective. It won't change everyone's views but even if it only changed a few, that would be a good thing wouldn't it?

Cashncarry · 10/09/2007 12:15

I really can't see where you saw a "coven of racists" on that thread Hurly. Maybe I'm just being a bit dumb but although some of the posts made uncomfortable reading for me personally, I didn't think they sounded BNP like in the least.

TBH, I think that your problem may be that you have too much of a "them and us" attitude. Ironically that is exactly the problem of the OP and those who agreed with her.

I wish you would reconsider your point of view on having the thread deleted. I think you clearly have very strong views on this subject and those who don't have the same kind of experience would really benefit from your input.

Wolfgirl · 10/09/2007 12:14

Yes Hurly, you seem overly riled at the other thread. Are you OK? take a cyber hug and coffee from us MNs.

Desiderata · 10/09/2007 12:13

Hurly, you really need to lighten up.

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 12:09

Thanks for the advice, Cod.

So what do you do when you see a coven of racists getting together and cosily exchanging the same nasty little views?

Erm, register a polite objection? Flounce? Shrug it off? Is there no code of conduct that racism is not allowed?

OP posts:
Wolfgirl · 10/09/2007 12:07

Hurly - I totally agree. It would be awful, I wouldnt stomach it very well tbh. I get very defensive on my DSs behalf if I think kids wont play with him blah blah blah. (you didnt need to do the blah blah bit btw

But I stand my ground and say that if we dont discuss these things, how will people change? How then can you get alongside someone and encourage them to think differently. Threads like this will keep cropping up periodically, and the same offended will cry out and retaliate.

Its called education and encouraging someone to have a change of heart, and if that dont work, then least ways learn to be more tolerant - dont you think? what gives anyone the right to take acceptance to such things anyway? And someone did point out that years ago, a child with black skin would most definatley have been the minority in a class of white children. It would certainly have been the case in my school days. Was it right then? absolutely not, but it happened, and that poor child would have had to cope with it etc. But times have changed, people have changed. Its just that some people are still not 'used' to it, and need help.

Am I wrong to think this? I dont. This is a huge subject Hurly, and I doubt most us MNs have time to get into such deep profound subjects - especially with LOs round our ankles.

Sorry - I have to go but I do see your angle on things - I just differ with this particular case.

choccybuttons · 10/09/2007 11:57

But is this really a big suprise to everyone? I mean really?

No it's not nice to read threads like that if you get offended by it but most of the stuff written in the posts have all been heard before.

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 11:57

To hear people talk sometimes...@WB ...I often do wonder if people take that on board before posting.

Tortington · 10/09/2007 11:53

maybe they can make it a secret place - a la special needs.

WelshBoris · 10/09/2007 11:53

even

WelshBoris · 10/09/2007 11:52

"NOT EVERYONE HERE IS WHITE"

[SHOCK] [SHOCK]

no-one told me that before I joined

Cashncarry · 10/09/2007 11:52

Hurly - as a "person of colour" I was indeed initially offended by the title but went ahead and contributed to the discussion nevertheless.

There are plenty of questionable views all around me in society - I hear lots of Daily Mail-esque garbage every day at work and it does make me feel very uncomfortable at times. However, if I was to ignore them and shut myself away in my own "PC" world, I would never have the chance to understand where those views spring from and maybe even have a chance to change them.

I hope my DD is similarly understanding and tolerant of other people's views - after all, we can't cocoon them forever...

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 11:49

Exactly @HB. I sometimes wonder if half the people poasting on this forum realise that NOT EVERYONE HERE IS WHITE.

niceglasses · 10/09/2007 11:49

I'd have to agree with CashnCarry - whilst those statements may be distasteful and not true, I wouldn't use the term 'racisit' exactly. They certainly wouldn't come close to my own opinions, but ........

I'm afraid the title of that thread always meant a very full and frank discussion, and thats what you got. Thousands of pple would hold similar views - esp if they read the likes of the DM - where its par for the course. They would claim as you know that just by having a debate about immigration is not racist. Many many many pple hold that pt of view.

Desiderata · 10/09/2007 11:48

To be racist is to believe and to act upon the notion that your race is superior to another race. The term is used too freely on MN.

At worst, some of the posts were mildly xenophobic.

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 11:47

I don't think your post was unreasonable Wolfgirl. It's all very well saying it was misguided and came across as racist (as indeed have many of the posts on that thread) but we should be supportive blah blah ...

What about the effects upon someone who is not white of reading this on a forum they previously used for support and laughs and jollies?

To find that there are posters who worry about sending their children to the same school as children like yours? And that was the least of it, it was really. Some of the views expressed on there just shouldn't be articulated.

How would the parent of a special needs child feel if I said I did not want my children to go to school with a special needs child? For example.

OP posts:
Cashncarry · 10/09/2007 11:42

Whilst I don't agree that your quotes represent facts, I'm struggling to see that they're racist. They are just people's heartfelt views - however misplaced some of them seem to be to me personally.

If we don't have open discussion Hurly, we'll never get to the root of what causes this kind of discontent in society.

< peace, love and harmony and all that >

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 11:41

I whole heartedly agree with HB.
Healthy debate = fine. P{eople ranting ignorantly about immigrants (as well as somehow mixing them up with British born-and-bred non-white people!) - NOT OK.

Wolfgirl · 10/09/2007 11:40

oh grief Im gonna get slated for this, but this is what I think of what the OP experienced on the other thread.

Here goes. I think that she is not racist and asked a genuine question. I equally think that this is not the forum to ask such a question though, as it is a very sensitive issue. I think, that as in all things, when presented with something new or alien or out of ones experience - then one can be 'taken aback'.

I think - that this is what has happened, that the Op was 'taken aback'.

So. Should she have been? In light of her opening a thread and pouring out her concerns so publicly, I think that we should be more supportive and guiding towards her.

My advice to her, would be: the colour of ones skin should not pose a problem to you. We are all human regardless of colour, race or religion. You should have dealt with your concerns in private, as your thread did come across as racist - but no doubt you did not mean it to. Go make a coffee, take a time to sit and think. Each child in that class is a special child - with beautiful coffee colour skin, or dark brown skin, or white skin. Each child starting a journey in this world - looking to be accepted, learning to love, learning to play and make friends....etc
Think about it. Its a beautiful mix of beautiful children - and each one able to offer something different to another. There is no need for concern. Take care

And so, should MN delete such a thread. No I dont. Because we can learn from it. We can learn and see what the response was, we can learn and see that someone has genuine struggles out there and needs help. We can also see that there is still a divide in race, religion and skin tone. And thats a shame, but times change and people change. We need to encourage people to see what is right, not just slam them at the first hurdle.

All this of course, is imho.

choccybuttons · 10/09/2007 11:38

Hurly, those aren't just opinions they are facts!

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 11:36

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/2724/384375

Well here's a selection culled from the first few posts - which were enough to make me physically sick

"I fear an emphasis on the evils whites did to blacks feeds notions of victimhood among black children who should instead see they have great opportunitiies if they choose to seize them."

"I agree and think this is where balance tipped for me as I have been verbally abused at work by migrants from countries with whom the UK has no link with about how awful our housing system is and I just think, if our system is so crap, why are you here?"

"There are alot of people abusing our tolerant society, our fantastic health service, our housing systems."

"The knock on effect of mass imigration is huge and I've never had the opportunity to say I don't want more people coming to this country through the electoral system."

"All I see is a poor health system, poor schooling, poor policing, poor housing and lots of people who don't speak english in the town centre during the day."

OP posts:
choccybuttons · 10/09/2007 11:36

For someone who doesn't want rasism discusted, you aint half drawing attention to the subject!

heifer · 10/09/2007 11:35

agree we don't do it that way - but am pretty sure we don't like the N word either!

FluffyMummy123 · 10/09/2007 11:34

Message withdrawn