Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect Mumsnet NOT TO ALLOW OPENLY RACIST THREADS TO STAND UNDELETED?

235 replies

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 11:23

Hmm? Well AM I?

If someone tells me not to click on the FUCKING thread in question, I think I will explode. Racism should have no place on Mumsnet.

OP posts:
fluffyanimal · 10/09/2007 13:35

Martianbishop was on Aitch's thread talking about how one would react to racist threads. She was using that as an example of what to do about threads you strongly disagree with. She had some good arguments.

Desiderata · 10/09/2007 13:33

Good grief, Hurly ... the expert on what makes a person a racist. They could have done with you during the Spanish Inquisition.

harpsichordcarrier · 10/09/2007 13:32

hurly, are you saying that anyone expressing an opposing view or making a comment e.g. about victim culture is automatically a racist?
I cannot believe such intolerance, name calling and closed mindedness can be the way forward. deleting threads because you don't agree with their contents is pure censorship and I ask you again - what purpose does this serve?

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 13:30

Erm, dunno. Not in here... Should she/he be?

OP posts:
fluffyanimal · 10/09/2007 13:29

Where's martianbishop?

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 13:28

No you haven't still - it's all germane.

Harpsi - a poster on the other thread made a very good point - about racism having certain "calling cards". Like starting a sentiment with "I'm not a racist but.." almost invariably is a preface to a racist comment.

The whole sentiment about victimhood among black people is one of those calling cards. It's about not acknowledging racism, about it being somehow pathetic to complain of it, somehow symptomatic of a victim mentality. Thereby rather neatly putting the problem onto the "whingeing blacks" ...

OP posts:
Desiderata · 10/09/2007 13:26

Whatever day and age it is doesn't make a great deal of difference, hurly. People don't evolve in quantum leaps from one generation to the next. Individuals may evolve, but societies generally don't. The only thing that changes are the toys we get to play with.

Modern day manners deem it unacceptable to say racist things, but it doesn't follow that people aren't thinking them.

If racism is to be understood, then it must be discussed and analyzed without fear of the witch hunt

And I would point out again, that it isn't just the British who are culpable. All nations, all races on earth are equally as guilty as the next.

stillsleeping · 10/09/2007 13:23

ok i agree that everything should be tolerated except intolerance. let's get that clear for starters.

but on the whole white british people are very tolerant and welcoming to incomers. as they should be.

i think part of it is that when that tolerance and acceptance is very publicly rejected ( i'm thinking 7/7) it's only natural for ordinary,people of other cultures to start wondering what the point is.

as a white, middle class, lefty londoner, who worked in barking and dagenham for many years i feel i'm qualified to make this point.

and actually its far more to do with culture/religion than colour in most instances. For some, less intelligent people it becomes more about colour because it's an obvious thing to focus on. and actually i think the person who wrote the o/p on the other thread was more concerned about cultural differences than colour. she just didn't articulate herself very well.

ive gone way off the point haven't i?

harpsichordcarrier · 10/09/2007 13:21

Hurly, I honestly don't see that the views you have cut and pasted are "nutty" tbh.

this for example:
"I fear an emphasis on the evils whites did to blacks feeds notions of victimhood among black children who should instead see they have great opportunitiies if they choose to seize them."
one might not like the way that is expressed, but there is a legitimate view in there. it isn't "nutty" and I can't see it should be suppressed. what would be the point?
the point about tackling racism (or other prejudice) is not to censor people's view and stamp out debate but to tackle people's views head on with logic.

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 13:14

"Whether you like it or not there are a lot of people in this country who feel forgotton and whose views are becoming more and more extreme because they feel that white people don't count."

Well racism is usually synonymous with some form of deprivation. Financial. Educational. Shortage of brain cells. That sort of things.

So where there are areas that have become more impoverished, and people feel disempowered or "forgotten", then racism is likely to be on the increase.

Doesn't mean that they are right, or that they should be tolerated. It is a point of view that actually should be unacceptable in this day and age.

The practice of tolerance and toleration of other people's view points, should not extend to the point of tolerating nutty viewpoints that others find genuinely offensive.

You don't expect racism and xenophobia on a parenting website. You shouldn't expect it, either.

OP posts:
stillsleeping · 10/09/2007 13:05

hurley, whether you like it or not there are a lot of people in this country who feel forgotton and whose views are becoming more and more extreme because they feel that white people don't count. Now before you start jumping on the fact that i've used the word 'white', can i ask why it's any more offensive to want white interests to be looked after by the powers that be, than muslim, or gay rights or any other.

It's the fact that people would rather shout 'RACIST!' than listen to people's genuine concerns that leads to people in places like Barking voting in the bnp. If you don't believe me, go and see for yourself.

In a truly equal society people from all backgrounds would be treated equally, and left wing white people wouldn't be embarassed about being so.

i'm bloody left wing so i should know.

CatIsSleepy · 10/09/2007 12:51

didn't follow the other thread the whole way through and don't have time to read it all now...

The OP was very poorly worded and lots of people made it clear they found it offensive

when she came back she clarified her concerns which did not seem wholly unreasonable

seemed like a potentially interesting discussion but not one I could make a great contribution to not having a dd at pre-school, so I didn't go back to it

sounds like some unpalatable opinions were expressed-
guess there's a lot out there, unfortunately

Agree with EscapeFrom-
I don't think it's possible to sweep it all under the carpet
perhaps it's healthier to have it out in the open and being discussed and challenged

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 12:47

I am not starting a thread about racism.

I have started a thread about the unacceptability of racism.

There's a difference.

Just as there is a difference between a thread discussing race relations, and a thread expressing openly racist views.

OP posts:
IcingOnTheCake · 10/09/2007 12:44

Sorry that was netmum card not mumsnet!

IcingOnTheCake · 10/09/2007 12:43

I don't understand why you would request for the other thread to be deleted then start your own thread about rasism? Surely if you didn't want rasism to be discusted you wouldn't start a thread

Oh and the mumsnet card is always a lame way of saying nananana to mumsnet!

FluffyMummy123 · 10/09/2007 12:32

Message withdrawn

choccybuttons · 10/09/2007 12:32

If i don't like what?

Or should i say netmums is waaaay better like you did

TigerFeet · 10/09/2007 12:31

I wouldn't say that the thread is openly racist at all. There are a lot of unpleasant, xenophobic views on there but there are also people with genuine, valid concerns.

An openly racist thread would read thus:
Poster: All white people are above any other race. Sling everyone else out of the country.
OtherPoster: Wholeheartedly agree. Let's join the BNP pronto

Apologies if the above seems trite btw, just a very generalised way of getting my point across.

The thread in question has morphed into a debate about immigration with differing views that are being challenged by both sides. Nothing wrong with that if you ask me.

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 12:30

Have to go in a sec, but look, to clarify - I think some people have found comments on the thread really very close to the bone. While some may want to debate the subject and others may choose to ignore the thread, some people may actually be very angry about it and find it unacceptable. Why is that so hard to understand? Another card I will play right back at ya, choccy - if you don't like it, why not leave the thread? cackles and flounces...just for a bit, though!

EscapeFrom · 10/09/2007 12:27

How would deleting it help?

Really?

It would be like draping kitchen towel over dog shit.

The dog shit needs to be cleaned up, not covered up. Same with racism.

choccybuttons · 10/09/2007 12:26

Oh god the netmums card has been played has it.

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 12:22

patronise, even

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 12:22

Don't patromnise, then, FGS.

Wolfgirl · 10/09/2007 12:21

dont scrap LoveAngel. ffs

lionheart · 10/09/2007 12:20

Hurly, the views expressed there (and some are vile) are being challenged.

I know there can be a gut reaction to what is being said and obviously, to the title, but an interesting debate has emerged from the initial OP.