Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect Mumsnet NOT TO ALLOW OPENLY RACIST THREADS TO STAND UNDELETED?

235 replies

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 11:23

Hmm? Well AM I?

If someone tells me not to click on the FUCKING thread in question, I think I will explode. Racism should have no place on Mumsnet.

OP posts:
fluffyanimal · 10/09/2007 14:29

Can someone explain the distinction between xenophobia and racism because I've always assumed they were pretty much the same thing.

pagwatch · 10/09/2007 14:27

Ah HB - still a better liberal than me I tend to swear at the screen and vent at poor DH when he gets home. Perhaps a quick vom is more effective ?
Vomit away - a gals got to do what works

cushioncover · 10/09/2007 14:25

I think too often on MN the term racist is used when actually a post is more xenophobic.

Can I just add that statistically, there's almost as many people leaving this country each year as there are coming in.

Blandmum · 10/09/2007 14:25

OK, I would hope, tht if I came accross a post that I considered racist on MN, I would make my feelings known and report the post for deletion.

In other words if someone wrote ''Racial group of your choice', I hate them, they are subhuman and we should deport them all.

Nice and easy. Not only racist, but incitement to racial hatered is illegal in the UK.

But there are a range of comments which stretch from ignorance, through xenophobia through to full blown racism, and where you draw the line, varies , I think, from case to case.

So the comment made earlier,

'"All I see is a poor health system, poor schooling, poor policing, poor housing and lots of people who don't speak english in the town centre during the day." ' Could be seen a racism if it was describing a group of Somali people, but possibly only Xenophobia if they were talking about Bangor in North Wales, and the people involved were welsh (I'm welsh BTW)

If the implication of the first possibility is the, 'And they should not be here' that is probably racism.

If it was 'And they should all be talking English' I'd think that person an arrogant arse, but possibly not racist.

The context does matter.

In school I'm a biology teacher. I have to teach that sickle cell disease is more common in black people than white....but this doesn't make me a racist, it makes me a biologist. In the cause of balence, I should point out that cystic fibrosis is more common in whites.

I hope I wouldn't pass a racist comment by.

I also hope that I learn from reading. Up iuntil a recent thread I seriosly never cosidered calling a chinese meal a chinkie offensive. Since chinese people posted on MN as said they did, I've re thought things.

Out attitudes chance and move on, it isn't static. I'd never crack a jewish joke, but I've heard jews do.

It isn't a balck and white issue (no pun intended)

3andnomore · 10/09/2007 14:24

lol LA...I was just saying that usually teh term Nazi is reserved for Breastfeeders on MN...whihc is true, you must admit...

Tigana · 10/09/2007 14:24

I'm sure this point has already been made, but, people have the right to say what they want about their experiences, thoughts and perceptions as long as it is not inciting violence.
Other people then have the right to confront them tell them they are wrong/misguided/ignorant etc and explain to them why this is the case (as long as they don't incite violence either!).
In some cases, a debate is going to affect peoples opinions and views and beliefs. Particularly if an opinion is based in ignorance or in limited experience.

If posts use offensive words then fine, report them ( argument for ability to selectively censor posts...so the post can remain withthe offensive word removed/replaced?).

I hadn't realised how offensive/upsetting it was for some people when the N word is used out of context, until a previous MN debate enlightened me.

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 14:24

for you Pagwatch. That was dreadful. Thank you for posting.

Generally I am a good liberal and I do believe in freedom of speech. But also I have a right not to feel sick whenever I click on active convos. Or worse still, even click into that horrible thread.

OP posts:
LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 14:23

LOL How does BF-ing get dragged into every conversation on MN? Its like that '6 degrees of Kevin Bacon' game. Start a thread on nuclear fecking war and it will eventually get round to cracked nipples and let-down reflexes.

pagwatch · 10/09/2007 14:21

HurlyBurley
a long way back on this thread you drew a comparison with parents of a special needs child. FWIW I HAVE had converstaion about SN children amongst mainstream kids and how that affects the MS kids and the SN kids. I also had a 'friend' phone my hubby to give him info about my severely ASD son soo that they could use examples to try and BLOCK an application for assisted housing near them .

My view is that however painful these converstaions can be they are nearly always hugely benficial and are rarely initiated because of hatred but tend to be born out of the fear of the unknown and the unfamiliar. People are apprehensive of meeting my son because they have no frame of reference for his behaviuour - not because they have a hatred of people with autism. And once they meet him they usually love him .
The thread in question made me wince and I have not read it because I am feeling a bit battered just now.
But discussion is the cure to these ills. It roots out the bigots, it encourages people to think and it causes their blinkered views to be challenged. I think many people grow and learn. Of course some don't - but I would rather explore and discuss than stiffle discussion or else ignorance is passed around undercover like a sickness.
And for my poor boy - too many strangers avoid us because they are afriad of saying 'the wrong thing'. When you make people guilty of wrong thinking and then remove the means by which they may be enlightened then you perpetuaute the problem.

Blimey - that was long winded. Sorry

3andnomore · 10/09/2007 14:21

becuase Nazi's were a specific organised group many years ago....they were called Nazi's because they were followers of the Nationalsozialistischen Partei....that is why....obviously I realise ther are now Neo Nazi groups...and of course it's o.k., imo, to use the term Nazi on them...

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 14:19

Who? @ lionheart. Who has said this, who that I should give any credit to?

madamez · 10/09/2007 14:19

Stupid people always seem to think that by screaming, hyperventilating and calling for bans, they can erase bigoted attitudes altogether. It doesn't work. It just makes the bigots even more resentful, paranoid and self-pitying.
Everyone is entitled to air their opinions no matter how disagreeable others find those opinions. Counterspeech is always a far better solution than censorship. You may not be able to change every bigot's mind, but by making them look stupid you put other people off them more than if you allow them to feel martyred and suppressed.

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 14:18

Apparently Nazi means breastfeeders on here.

Strange but true.

OP posts:
LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 14:17

...and while I'm at it,. why can't one use the term 'Nazi' if deemed appropriate? 'Nazi' has become a widely accepted way to refer to fascists, e.g. the anti-Nazi League don't spend their time campaigning against dead German war criminals, do they? They challenge racist, fascistic organisations and individuals. And why bloody not?

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 14:16

I agree with LoveAngel.

That's a seriously offensive post. Not of course if you are white.

OP posts:
lionheart · 10/09/2007 14:16

But people of all backgrounds who are concerned with ethnicity and education, history and culture have said similar things, LA.

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 14:15

Dinosaur - if you like - I will try to explain why I objected quite vehemently to those posts - but I'd prefer to do that on the other thread. I don't want to rehash those sort of opinions on this one, which is more about freedom of speech versus freedom not to be offended by racists.

OP posts:
lionheart · 10/09/2007 14:15

That's the example I was thinking of 3, because some people really didn't know that

the word caused offence but they learnt from the discussion.

It's also a good example of racism as a word being overused or misused.

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 14:14

I find DullWitch's comment:

'I fear an emphasis on the evils whites did to blacks feeds notions of victimhood among black children who should instead see they have great opportunitiies if they choose to seize them'

I find this statement extremely offensive. EXTREMELY. It is EXACTLY the sort of thing the BNP say. Call it racist, or don't. It's still a horrible thing to say. Disgusting.

3andnomore · 10/09/2007 14:14

was that to me, Dinosaur...if so, I did not imply that Witch said anything racist...I just meant that I hate that term being used , unless people actually have a discussion of the holocaust and nazi's, when it becomes factual....

lionheart · 10/09/2007 14:12

It also looked much worse when quoted out of context.

3andnomore · 10/09/2007 14:11

Hurly, but tehre is racism, and then ther is sometimes ignorance...and I have found out that things I thought would be acceptable to say, are indeed offensive to some people...like I used to say "people of colour" rahter then saying black or whatever...and until I was told so, I never knew it could cause offense....but I never said it to be nasty or anything...but I jsut didn't know better...and it was, indeed MN that opened my eyes about this.

Also, recently there was a discussion about the term "chinky" , and whilest it isn't something I would consider using...I didn't actually know the history of it and until someone explained to me, I had no idea it could be offensive (and rightly so)....

in the end we don't know what we don't know...until we get enlightened...of course....you got to be openminded for that to happen!

lionheart · 10/09/2007 14:11

You may be right, HB, and it is horrible to engage with this kind of hatred and paranoia

but I think, all things considered, you have to keep trying.

Blandmum · 10/09/2007 14:10

have had the audacity to be in work!

Now at home so will look though this thread, may take some time....

Dinosaur · 10/09/2007 14:08

I don't think what the DullWitch wrote was racist, though. Not even moderately racist.

You may disagree with it (I disagree with part of what she said) but how is it "racist"?

Swipe left for the next trending thread