Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect Mumsnet NOT TO ALLOW OPENLY RACIST THREADS TO STAND UNDELETED?

235 replies

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 11:23

Hmm? Well AM I?

If someone tells me not to click on the FUCKING thread in question, I think I will explode. Racism should have no place on Mumsnet.

OP posts:
Scootergrrrl · 10/09/2007 14:50

Perhaps the openly-racist POSTS, of which there were a few on that first thread and which must break some kind of MN rule, could be deleted, leaving the majority of the thread to stand as a debate like any other?

cushioncover · 10/09/2007 14:49

Has anyone ever heard the anecdote about the time that Bernie Grant MP met the Duke of Edinburgh?

DoE: (loudly) And which African country do you come from? Bloody hot out there isn't it?

BG: Tottenham; and no, it mostly rains!

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 14:49

yeh, common mistake to make that

3andnomore · 10/09/2007 14:46

the op of that post, did come back and said it was a mistake to say country, it was meant to say class

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 14:46

'Own country'. Grrrrr. I want to scream every time I read that.

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 14:45

The OP was using the language of racism though. The "own country" reference?

But I do agree with your point that the OP wasn't malign. Some of the others were though.

OP posts:
cushioncover · 10/09/2007 14:44

Unless of course you mean the 'culture of Conservatism'.

Blandmum · 10/09/2007 14:43

I also feel that xenophobia tends to stem from people being simply ignorent.

Racism comes more of hatered.

So not knowing about ethnic differences, could lead to people being xenophobic about Muslims in general.

Islamist Radicals (note, not Islamic peoples), may be racists because they hate Kaffus (unbelievers). BNF memebers are racist because they hate people who are not white(whatever white means)

fluffyanimal · 10/09/2007 14:43

"Racism is frequently more malign than that."

yes that's true, but I don't think the OP in the thread you are talking about was a case of that.

3andnomore · 10/09/2007 14:43

miljee, please expand....

cushioncover · 10/09/2007 14:42

Miljee, please clarify your last sentence before you get jumped on.

miljee · 10/09/2007 14:40

I agree with stillsleeping's post of 13.23. The OP we're talking about wasn't well put but I believe the issue the OP was concerned about wasn't racist, it was culturalist. We so, so often get the 2 confused but they're very different. The first appertains to one's genetic background that may be a strong influencer of one's appearance. The second relates to one's CHOICES of lifestyle. I believe that all races are equal BUT not all cultures are equal.

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 14:39

What if your point is 'You are offending me?'

I haven't seen a single person acknowledge that they have been offensive, whether deliberately or not. Ladymuck's vision of MN doesn't seem to ring true here, I'm afraid.

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 14:38

No Bouncing, there are some things that really should not be said.

You all work from the kind of nice-minded standpoint that the offence being caused is accidental and the result of inadequate education or exposure.

Racism is frequently more malign than that.

OP posts:
cushioncover · 10/09/2007 14:38

Of course you should argue your point. That's the beauty of the beast.

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 14:37

I'm glad its worked for you@ladymuck

Unfortunately, my experience of these sort of threads is that they descend into lots of people swapping anecdotes that amount to not much more than 'they're taking our jobs and our women!' (or perhaps in modern times it is 'our husbands', judging by the recent influx of gorgeous 6 foot Eastern European girls?). In short - it's very hard to reason with someone who holds unreasonable views.

By the way, you're not seriously voting for Cameron, are you? :-)

Desiderata · 10/09/2007 14:36

And obviously, hurly, you suffer from neither affliction?

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 14:36

Quality posts from Ladymuck and Martianbishop.

So you think I should argue my corner? Well maybe I should.

OP posts:
cushioncover · 10/09/2007 14:35

I think xenophobia often stems more from ignorance. People are often frightened of things they have little knowledge about.

Sadly, but IMO true, seeing your race as superior to others is a viewpoint often held by intelligent, well educated people.

ladymuck · 10/09/2007 14:35

[sigh] You also learn that MB always puts things more succinctly. She really should be a politician except that she is probably too nice.

bouncingball · 10/09/2007 14:34

Hurly - you do NOT "have a right not to feel sick whenever I click onto active convos". Your feelings are entirely your responsibility and no one elses.

ladymuck · 10/09/2007 14:32

I've been a member of Mumsnet for 7 years (not always as this name).

One of the things that I have loved about the place is that I have read and debated topics with people who have a totally different view on life to myself (as a Conservative voter on Mumsnet I suspect that I am in one of the smallest minorities in existance on here!). I have had many of my pre-judgements (aka prejudices) on a range of topics (breastfeeding, education, housing policy, health policy, racism, sexism etc)challenged, emerging either changed or confirmed.

Reasoned debate may not make an impact on every MNer, but it does to some. There are whole sections of society that I don't have conversations with, because they don't cross my path every day, but usually they are present on here. I can hear first hand what it was like to be married to someone who died on 9/11, or whose husband is dying or waiting for a heart transplant, or whose rural lives has been changed through foot and mouth disease. Equally I can hear what life is like from a refugee, or someone in a multicultural family.

Yes, MN should delete offensive posts where reported, but deleting whole threads just kills debate and stops the chance of people realising that their views are inappropriate and learning about the perspectives of others. The fact is that quite often most adults aren't challenged on some of their views. And if they have inherited their vieews from their families they may genuinely not even realise that they hold them. So I would see the site as a force for change rather than a place where only people who agree with me can be (it would just be a rather small site).

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 14:31

I think they are arguing that one can be xenophobic without being racist but not racist without being xenophobic.

But I think more like you do, fluffy. Racism is a spectrum, I suppose. It's just that xenophobia is a milder form of it.

OP posts:
Desiderata · 10/09/2007 14:31

Xenophobia is a distrust or dislike of foreigners in general.

Racism is the belief that your race is superior to another.

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 14:29

lol@3andnomore

Look, this thread has actually changed my mind and brought me round to thinking that the thread probably shouldn't be deleted. However, I still defend HB. Its upsetting to hear that so many people have such dodgy views and to be honest, I'd rather not hear them, but hey...let the Alf Garnetts rant away...