Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect Mumsnet NOT TO ALLOW OPENLY RACIST THREADS TO STAND UNDELETED?

235 replies

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 11:23

Hmm? Well AM I?

If someone tells me not to click on the FUCKING thread in question, I think I will explode. Racism should have no place on Mumsnet.

OP posts:
3andnomore · 10/09/2007 22:45

Racism and xenophobia most definately exist in all races, cultures, etc...!

The term foreigner always makes me cringe....because, you see there are different levels of foreignerhood...apparently....people around here often talk about them foreigners...and when they do that to me, I tend to say, well, I am a foreigner...what with being german...but I am different, because my hubbie is brittish and anyway we (my family now)don't "scrounge" of the system (the very people who are saying that are actually int eh category of the scrounger of the system themselfs...have never held a Job down or anything....only know life on benefits....and before anyone jumps on me...I do believe there is a need for a benefit system, and I genuinely think that it's often the very people who this was invented for are usually left high and dry because others are more benefit pros and therefore know how to get things out of the system...so, I am, by no means saying that someone living on benefits is a scrounger....just that some are....)!
I mena, these people are generally not greatly educated (not that I am brilliantly educated or anything) and a lot is just ignorance , however, there is also a lot of hate...

lionheart · 10/09/2007 22:19

No, not at all, it's not just white people.

Desiderata · 10/09/2007 22:16

Well, I guess that's it then

Desiderata · 10/09/2007 20:21

I wholeheartedly agree with harpsi's posts on this thread.

I would also like to add that I don't think some of you realize quite how vitriolic you sound. It certainly doesn't seem that you like the 'white man' very much, and that you hold us largely in contempt.

If you were wishing to convert (your notion) of a racist, I doubt whether you will have won over any hearts and minds on this thread.

And may I ask a question? Do you think that it is only white people who are guilty of racism?

wildwoman · 10/09/2007 19:14

Icingonthecake...that guy talks the same crap that my sister's south african inlaws (who haven't quite got their heads round the end of apartheid) would say

harpsichordcarrier · 10/09/2007 19:11

sorry I also wanted to say that if you want to preach tolerance then you must also practice it.
imo.
and that means sometimes permitting people to express their opinions notwithstanding you might find them sepcious and/or offensive.
obviously it is reasonable to draw the line at extremist opinions, expressions of hatred or stirring up violence.

harpsichordcarrier · 10/09/2007 19:09

it isn't necessarily about winning people over with debate.
but to go to the extreme of wanting to entirely supress debate and the opposite view - surely you can see that its massively counterproductive?
e.g. if I wanted to express an opinion like (for the sake of argument) that the majority of gun crime is currently committed by young black men, and to ask why this was the case?
then if I attempted to express this opinion, and I was called a racist (or even a vile Nazi or whatever) and that I wasn't permitted to express this in public.
then how would that have progressed matters?
the issue of "victimhood" for example, is a strong one in many people's minds. if this has stemmed from personal experience then dismissing personal experience is really the road to nowhere.
of course you maynot care about other people's opinions and experiences if they don't equate with your own.
but suppressing them will only serve to breed further resentment and feelings of powerlessness.

lionheart · 10/09/2007 18:57

Are you saying the white man is being treated badly because he doesn't like living among non-whites?

I feel for him, I really do, and for the poor people on the Isle of Wight who are now graced with his presence.

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 18:55

Thank God your friend from London left. One less ignoramous for me to have to deal with.

And the acceptable vernacular is black not coloured.

IcingOnTheCake · 10/09/2007 18:48

I have known plenty of English white people who have moved to another town/city because they were taken over and felt like the minority by coloured/foriegn people. Is this ok Hurly? Or would that be only unacceptable if it were coloured people being taken over and made to feel like the minority?

When me and dp went over to the Isle of Wight the man who we were buying the car off of said he used to live in London but moved because it has turned into spot the white man. He said the city is a dangerous place for a white man to live nowadays. That to me is awful.

Why is it that rasism only applys if it is coloured/foriegn people who are being treated badly?

ladymuck · 10/09/2007 18:22

No, but there are some remarks which are offence which are being unwittingly made - MB's example of referring to a takeaway as a chinkie, or the recent "paddy" thread (though I'm not sure how that was resolved in the end).

And even if we take the thread that you're referring to, I'm not sure that I do view all your quotes as being explicitly racist. But I'm taking time to think about my opinions on the subject, and I haven't yet reread all of the other thread (I did contribute early on, but I guess it has moved on by now). Yes, report "posts", but keep the debate. There are other moderated sites which will limit the topics of conversation.

lionheart · 10/09/2007 18:17

Bloody hard work, though, and infuriating and frustrating and all of that ...

lionheart · 10/09/2007 18:16

Naa, it's not gonna happen like that but did you see the thread where someone used the word chinky and genuinely didn't realise there was a

problem with it. She was called racist and lots of huffing and mudslinging ensued.

Another thread was started by, I think, RedTartanLass that was very much like the one you started, very pissed off.

At the end some people did begin to understand (not all by any means).

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 18:12

Yes I recognise that too. But it's not susceptible to being cunningly argued around though, is it?

OP posts:
lionheart · 10/09/2007 18:08

I don't think it is always ignorance at all. Often it's just a pig-headed single minded desire to hate and despise someone. Not at all rational.

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 18:00

Yes but perhaps neither LoveAngel (nor I for that matter) hadn't appreciated that the racism "debate" needed to be held on Mumsnet. This is not a reasoned argument situation. If you believe that racism is born out of ignorance, then a debate isn't going to fix that ignorance.

As to the audience point, I'm sorry but I just don't buy it. So the hearts and minds of the Mumsnetters are susceptible to being won over or alienated on this issue?

What so if my arguments fail, Mumsnetters all run off and join the Ku Klux Klan?

OP posts:
lionheart · 10/09/2007 17:54

I think that's right too, ladymuck, and even more so because people can read so many different things into silence,

including consent, which is where the other thread on MM comes into it.

ladymuck · 10/09/2007 17:47

LoveAngel, back to your 14:37 post (school run, homework and tea now over): you will not win over everyone with a debate - there will alwasy be a small vocal persistant minority. Yet they enable a debate to occur and for other people to read it and be challenged. Which is important.

After all the skill of a true debate (think Oxford Union, or Question Time say) is winning over the minds of the audience not the opponent.

lionheart · 10/09/2007 15:19

Just got back to this, LA, these things have been debated by many academics, educationalists, people involved with Black History Month,

Affirmative action, those who are developing theories of victimology. They aren't in a any sense agreeing with DW's idea that there is normal

history and then there is history which has a less neutral agenda but they do have concerns about how to teach this history and move

beyond it in various ways. (Black Athena, Mary Seacole, etc).

HTH.

EricL · 10/09/2007 15:07

I wouldn't call it an 'openly racist' thread.

Insensitive and ill-concieved - yes.

I refrained from posting in it cos i knew where it would end up eventually...........

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 15:07

I hadn't read the whole thread - and had missed the mistake that the OP said she had made.

OP posts:
3andnomore · 10/09/2007 15:05
Smile
Desiderata · 10/09/2007 15:04

Quite so, 3andnomore. But never let the truth get in the way of a good racism thread

3andnomore · 10/09/2007 15:03

erm, seeing that teh op was talking about Pre school class...I think it could have been an honest mistake in that case...

LoveAngel · 10/09/2007 14:58

lol@cushioncover. The DoE. What an absolute arse.