Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect Mumsnet NOT TO ALLOW OPENLY RACIST THREADS TO STAND UNDELETED?

235 replies

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 11:23

Hmm? Well AM I?

If someone tells me not to click on the FUCKING thread in question, I think I will explode. Racism should have no place on Mumsnet.

OP posts:
Dinosaur · 11/09/2007 13:32

I don't believe his story, not because he was white, but because it doesn't stack up, in my 21 years of personal experience of living in inner-city London.

speedymama · 11/09/2007 13:30

My friend who is black like me is married to a Belgian (white). A year ago they bought a house in Surrey but because she was away, he moved in first. The white neighbour welcomed him and told him that it was a very nice area but it was going down the pan because of the increasing numbers of immigrants. He said to my friend's husband that he was alright, it is the black ones that he objected to!

My friend's husband made his excuses and left. A few days later my friend turns up. Neighbour sees friend with husband and to this day, no words have been exchanged with said neighbour. He wants nothing to do with them because my friend is black!

When many of the indigenous population in this country spout on about immigration, they are talking about people of colour. If all the immigrants came from Western Europe or Australia or New Zealand or USA or Canada, immigration would not be the hot potato that it is now.

Unfortunately these same ignoramuses seem oblivious to the fact that their public services would collapse overnight without non-white immigrants!

IcingOnTheCake · 11/09/2007 13:25

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Dinosaur · 11/09/2007 13:23

It is just not true that London is, per se, a dangerous place to live for a white man.

IcingOnTheCake · 11/09/2007 13:21

Because he was a white man and no black person is ever rasist towards a white man

Dinosaur · 11/09/2007 13:19

No IcingOnTheCake, I don't think it's "okay", I think he was talking rubbish! I simply don't believe him!

IcingOnTheCake · 11/09/2007 13:19

That post is to Love by the way!

IcingOnTheCake · 11/09/2007 13:18

So you think it is ok that this man who lived in this certain place in London couldn't walk to the shops without fear for his life because of rasism? Meaning he had to then move because people had issues about him having white skin?

Lets reverse the situation. Say i had told you we bought a car off a black man who lived on the Isle of Wight and the man had told us he used to live in London (was born and bred there) bad he had to leave because the area he lived in was mostly white people and was forced out in fear of his life because of rasist people who hated blacks.

Would you still be saying you were glad he moved eh? No, you would feel for him and slag off all the rasist white people who forced him out of his home.

My point is, people are just as rasist to white people as they are to black people nowadays. 50 years ago it was mostly blacks people were rasist against and i am not defending that because that was awful. I am saying in 2007, the word rasist doesn't always warrant black people, it warrants white people too.

Just to add wbut you clearly bought into his ridiculous Daily Mail 'We aren't safe in our own country!' bullshit.

That wasn't him reading out of the Daily Mail some bullshit story, that was him saying why he doesn't live in the part of London he once did. The fact you are defending the people who made him fear for his life because he had white skin makes you a discusting person and just as rasist as those blacks who forced him out because if it were the other way around and the man we bought the car off of was black you wouldn't be calling it a 'Daily Mail' bullshit story would you.

Dinosaur · 11/09/2007 13:10

And although there is a lot of crime in Hackney, it seems (certainly from reading the Hackney Gazette!) that the majority of the victims are black, not white.

Dinosaur · 11/09/2007 13:08

IcingontheCake, I really think that what this guy said was complete rubbish. Please don't believe that this is what London is like, at all.

I've lived in Hackney for over 20 years, in various different areas, and I've spent lots of time in different part of London, north, south and east, and I've never ever had any problems on account of being white.

What I have had, lots and lots, is other white people making racist remarks to me in the full expectation that I will agree with them because I am white. I don't, I always make a point of telling them where to get off, but it really shocks me that even now in multi-cultural London that this still happens.

LoveAngel · 11/09/2007 10:40

Excuse terrible types and inexcusable use of 'there' when I meant 'their'. I thank you.

LoveAngel · 11/09/2007 10:38

Icingonthecake, I have tried, really tried to take on board posts on this thread that express similar sentiments to yours. Unfortunately, I have failed in my bid to be tolerant. My failing, perhaps? I just find the ignorance, and as HB pointed out, the lack of self awareness, let aloneshame depressing.

The guy you mentioned may not have been your friend, but you clearly bought into his ridiculous Daily Mail 'We aren't safe in our own country!' bullshit. (You said: 'He said the city is a dangerous place for a white man to live nowadays. That to me is awful. ')

I have lived in London all my life, from Camden to Camberwell, Harlesden to Hackney, and I think that that is the most ridiculous, stupid, hateful thing to say. I am not denying that racial tension exists in certain areas of London (obviously it does) but this 'Its spot the white man / we ain't safe among all these coloureds / foreigners!' attitude is despicable. Listen to it! Read it back in black and white. Rewind 60 years and replace the word 'coloured' with 'Jew'. Can you not see????

I would also like to point out, for maybe the 3rd or 4th time on this thread, that being black is NOT the same thing as being foreign (not that that should excuse prejudice against people from other countries, ie. genuine 'foreigners'). My DH was born in London. He was raised in London. He has a British passport. He supports the England football team. He pays a hell of a lot in taxes. hell, he even represents his country abroad in his work for the British Council. Our son will be similar. They are both black and have every right to live in London. If the likes of the bloke you mentioned don't like it, it really is there problem - hence why I am glad he left.

People have genuine fears and concerns about immigration, employment, housing. But stirring up hatred towards other groups of people won't solve those problems.

IcingOnTheCake · 11/09/2007 09:21

'Thank God your friend from London left. One less ignoramous for me to have to deal with.'

Erm in what part of my post did i say this man was my friend?He was just a man we bought a car off of and he didn't leave London because he hated blacks, he was forced out because the parts he lived in became no go areas for white people i.e; you get beaten up, attacked etc if your seen in these parts with a white face.

Yes he could have moved to another part of London but he said he moved to the Isle of Wight to get away from the madness and the violence. I know there are plenty of 'no go areas' for blacks in London too but this was just my example of someone who was treated like the minority and the point was that it's not only blacks that get treated this way but white do too but people seem to forget this.

If your not going to read my post properly Loveangel then don't bother to respond.

lucyellensmum · 11/09/2007 09:02

Hurlyburly, i completely agree with you - totally, there are certain thread titles tht insense me and i dont even have to open them. These threads seem to make it ok for overt racism, in the form of, and this really makes me "i'm not being racist bit"............... Yes there are certain things that should not be discussed on MNET and that is one of them for several reasonas. The first being, it becomes a forum for racists to have thier little digs, and secondly, people can mis read comments and be seriously hurt and upset by such comments. As a society we need to learn acceptance, not tolerance because that reminds me of just grudging acceptance and allowing such racism on this site is flying in the face of that.

lionheart · 11/09/2007 08:40

Have a look at the takeaway thread if you get a chance, HB, and the one started about it by RedTartanLass,

because some people did change their minds.

Glad you are calmer and that you had a place to express your anger.

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 23:49

Well I've calmed down now but I have to say that entire thread was a total shocker.

What surprised me was not the views expressed - although I am regularly surprised by how widely these sort of views are held or condoned - so much as the lack of shame in expressing them.

It felt to me as it might to a discarded wife reading about someone posting that they were serial adulterers.

I still don't believe that it is possible to argue people like that around.

But ultimately, I do agree that simply banning repulsive discussions is not the way forward.

Thanks for all the intelligent and lucid contributions on this thread. Too many to mention but Loveangel, Martianbishop, Lionheart and Ladymuck all seemed to talk sense consistently.

OP posts:
nachomama · 10/09/2007 23:25

Hurly, I really had your back on the aforementioned thread- good contributions, imvho.

And despite having caused a veritable war in my house between me and DH (who kinda went off on one upon reading some of the ignorant crap of which you speak), I think that having threads like this are a good thing. If you read through, you can see that a few people are learning something worthwhile through the debate.

Reading back through this post, I realise how wishy-washy I'm sounding but, will have to do- it's bloody late. Sorry. Short answer: racism- no (thread title was unacceptable); debate- yes, even if some repellant views come to the fore.

McEdam · 10/09/2007 23:11

The ch**ky and the paddy threads were about two very different things. One is a term of abuse - and people who had used it unwittingly were gracious enough to say, oh, I had no idea, I won't do that again.

And one was about whether the colloquial term for a tantrum was racist. There was no evidence that the derivation of the word in that context had anything to do with the other uses of the word as a description of a rice field or a term of abuse. Just as 'fit' meaning seizure and 'fit' meaning position are the same word doing different things.

So after reasoned and largely intelligent debate, I thought we'd reached intelligent conclusions based on the meaning of the words.

potoroo · 10/09/2007 23:06

I guess I'm a sort of foreigner too (white Australian - not British yet, but if you go back a couple of generations then all my ancestors were from the UK anyway). But then the Aussie and UK cultures are pretty similar so integration is not that much of an issue.

The whole ethnic background thing seems to be a pre-occupation in Britain that I find a bit odd. Every bit of paperwork I have had to fill out includes a check box for ethnic group. I can understand this for my surgery (as MB says different conditions are prevelent in different races - my DH is of Chinese descent and is a carrier of thalassaemia which is relatively common in Asian races) - but why does my library care?

My category was easy enough (Other White), DH was a little harder (Chinese but only for ethnic orgin, not for culture - his culture is same as me - Australian) but DS... the midwife and I had to think about the combinations for a while before checking the 'Other mixed' box...

MrsMarvel · 10/09/2007 23:05

When you're talking about people who move out because too many "foreigners" come into the area I think it's more to do with aspiration than race. They don't want to be among people who they see as beneath them in rank. That's one of the reasons why our society is so divided.

3andnomore · 10/09/2007 22:57

nighty it's weird sometimes isn't it....think is, these people can sometimes also still be very friendly with people of whatever race, dispite so obviously dispising that race...if that makes sense...i.e. if they actually get to know a person they will quite happily become friends, but still hold the believes against their race in general...I just don't get it!

3andnomore · 10/09/2007 22:53

never been in Bielefeld, but do know where that is...well, roughly anwyay....

Nightynight · 10/09/2007 22:52

3 - as an english person in germany, I also fall into this delicately sometimes-a-foreigner status as well.

just to complicate things, my name is german because my family came originally from Baden-Wurtemburg.

MrsMarvel · 10/09/2007 22:52

Well there's a treble negative for you!
Threads aren't racist - people are.
I'm sure MN would delete racist people.

Desiderata · 10/09/2007 22:50

I was born in Bielefeld, 3andnomore.