Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect Mumsnet NOT TO ALLOW OPENLY RACIST THREADS TO STAND UNDELETED?

235 replies

Hurlyburly · 10/09/2007 11:23

Hmm? Well AM I?

If someone tells me not to click on the FUCKING thread in question, I think I will explode. Racism should have no place on Mumsnet.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SimplerTimes00s · 09/11/2022 19:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ as it's a PBP

MadamePlatypus · 12/09/2007 15:02

Having read the thread, I think the problem was the wording of the OP (which the OP apologised for) and the racist views of subsequent posters. There were some interesting posts (e.g. by chocolatedot) about trying to make friends with other mums who don't speak the same language/share same expectations of school gate culture.

I suppose you can complain about individual posts but its difficult to know the difference between an ignorant/unfortunate post by somebody willing to change their mind/express themselves differently (and I would put the OP in this category) and those people who are ignorant and proud of it.

law3 · 12/09/2007 12:37

hurly - dont worry about it, come and have a chat on other stuff thread

law3 · 12/09/2007 12:05

i also dont have a problem with anyone living in this country, who wasnt born here refering to this country as their country either

law3 · 12/09/2007 12:03

potroo - i agree anyone born in this Country should be allowed to use the term 'my Country'.

Nothing at all racist, about being proud of your heritage.

I think we are creating a nation who are hyper sensitive, easy to offend, who nit pick and shout racist, rather than actually dealing with peoples concerns.

IcingOnTheCake · 12/09/2007 11:56

That's what i didn't understand at the beginning. I know you were very angry but i could see that you starting this thread would mean that we didn't just have one racism thread but we ended up with two! I know you started this thread with best of intentions but i knew it would end up pretty much the same as the other thread- everyone debating over racism. These things always happen when threads with the same topic occurs!

Hurlyburly · 12/09/2007 11:51

You know I invented this thread title when I was corkingly mad and I wish I hadn't now. It seems strident and horrible. Would anyone mind if I asked Mumsnet to delete the thread?

OP posts:
law3 · 12/09/2007 11:47

Difers - well said, everyone is entitled to have an opinion and some might be more articulate than others, the minute we start name calling and labelling, shooting them down in flames, it turns into an arguement, tit for tat etc.

I think people should start to practise what they preach tolerance and understanding, then we all might learn something and perhaps have a better understanding!!!!

law3 · 12/09/2007 08:34

icing - everyone is entitled to an opinion, your not talking b**ks. Thats the whole point listening to other peoples points of views, helps to ease racial tension and is productive, you never know we all might learn something!!!!!!!!!

potoroo · 11/09/2007 21:24

Difers - I don't have a problem with people saying 'in our own country' except when it implies that other non-white Brits are not in their own country.

Being able to trace one's roots is not enough of an indication of one's country surely?

I mean I can also trace my family roots in the UK and Ireland back for several centuries... except for the last couple of generations which were born/raised in Australia. I will shortly be sitting my UK test to become British.

OTOH DH was born in Australia, but his parents are China born Chinese. DH himself does not speak Chinese and doesn't have a huge amount to do with culture (apart from a penchant for stir fries!). China would certainly never recognise him as a Chinese national.

Then we come to DS - he was born here and is British by birth. This is without a doubt 'his country' - despite his mixed race background.

So... its a complicated issue...

IcingOnTheCake · 11/09/2007 21:08

I don't really know how we can solve racism. I think immigration plays a big part in it and i think the reason people in this Country see more and more immigrants arriving each day who are taking jobs, getting benefits etc which probably makes people feel hostile and resentful against the immigrants. I could be talking bollocks but thats the only reason i could think of that would be why people in this Country are becoming racist?

miljee · 11/09/2007 20:39

I was asked to clarify this statement I made yesterday so I will:

"I believe that all races are equal BUT not all cultures are equal."

OK. Culture relates to the way in which one leads one's life- one's choices to a greater or lesser extent, dependent on the degree of power and autonomy one holds. It encompasses religion and the choices made in its name.

Race is purely the gene pool from which you are created. You as an individual have absolutely no choice over this.

To this end, I believe that one can only view all races as being equal. However, many choices people make as a result of unthinking or unchallenged adherence to a received cultural norm can be judged- perhaps judged according to one's OWN cultural norms but I believe that amongst the shifting sands of what's 'right' and what's 'wrong' ie relative to one's own belief or cultural system, certain acts and behaviours stand out as being absolutes, as is absolutely wrong.
Examples include the cultures that not only allow but encourage for fear of ostracism, female genital mutilation; arranged marriages within societies where young women are raped and stoned, with the collusion of whole villages, for making the mistake of falling in love with an unapproved man; cultures that do not recognise the murder of female children as being unacceptable; cultures that actively teach their young that people of other racial groups are inferior human beings thus can be reviled with impunity.

These are just a few examples of what I mean when I say I believe that all races are equal BUT not all cultures are equal.

Difers · 11/09/2007 20:00

Sorry Law3 I agree with you we should look to the causes of racism and be able to speak about issues sensibly.

I don't really think that people are considering other peoples point of veiws and also thinking about the difference in education and communication skills that people on mumsnet might have.

For example,

A) I feel we should have a very robust immigration system, one reason being that I am concerned about the lax system allowing trafficking and sexual explotation of women by criminals into this country, I read in the Guardian that 80% of sex workers in London are immigrants and also separately the STD's are on the increase.

B) All the Polish are over here, on the game, spreading the clap, send em back.

Now, please consider whether A) is racist or B) is racist or both are racist. My point is that some people may not have the words to decribe their concerns in a manner that is acceptable but that their concerns may be the same and just as valid as anyone elses.

law3 · 11/09/2007 15:35

difers oh right!!! got yer the last bit, i was thinking bloody hell i must be going mad, dont remember saying all that.

law3 · 11/09/2007 15:33

difers - did i say that!!!!!!!!!!!

3andnomore · 11/09/2007 15:21

and speedy...that would be an awful shame....wouldn't it...what would we do...

speedymama · 11/09/2007 15:16

3anm, if Hitler had won, there would be no Taebo!

Difers · 11/09/2007 15:16

Agree with law 3 - I think racism was on the decrease in this country prior to 1997 but with the increase in immigration and the scarcity of resources and the pace of social change occuring at the rate it is then I feel that some people are becoming more racist because they feel disenfranchised and marginalised within their own country.

Some people on this site seem to think it is racist to say even something like "in our own country", Well I don't and it isn't, I can trace my family being in my area back to the 1700's so this is my country.

Censoring discussion and branding people as racists rather than trying to see their point of view in my opinion has the adverse affect to what the person trying to supress the discussion wants and therefore actually may increase racism.

3andnomore · 11/09/2007 15:12

just wnated to say that Policywonk has hit the nail on teh head...at that time there weren't many black people in germany, etc....!
Even growing up there were not many Black people in Germany, now there is far more and well, germany become quite multicultural, too...which is a good thing.
OH, and I am also glad Hitller didn't win the war....I think the world would be a very different place now, and probably not good different...shudder...

law3 · 11/09/2007 14:49

icing - nooooooooooooo please dont, we could all be here, all day, swapping discrimination stories, whats the point?????

white - black
black - white
etc, etc.

And at the end of it, do we then decide which colour is the more racist, by how many stories!!!!!!!!!!!

wildwoman · 11/09/2007 14:32

Icing the thing is you keep banging on about this one guy who was the victim of racism...that doesn't really stack up against the racism that we know happens all over the world in all races. Perhaps you could povide a few more anecdotes?

xyzabc · 11/09/2007 14:26

i am aware of that policywonk, a " master race" was trying to be formed and any one that didnt fit the mould was in trouble. so, perhaps we should all be glad that hitler didnt win the war, and go make ourselves a nice cup of tea!

law3 · 11/09/2007 14:25

Icing - spending so much time thinking about who did what to who and what colour, race they were is very unproductive.

We should be looking at what causes racism and what this country could do to ease it.

policywonk · 11/09/2007 14:16

xycabc - black people, Romany Gypsies, homosexuals and political dissenters were all thrown into concentration camps. There just weren't very many black people in the relevant countries in the 1930s-40s, whereas there were millions of Jewish people.

IcingOnTheCake · 11/09/2007 14:15

To be honest i don't think there is alot that can be done about it. It would be nice to have more people be aware of the fact that racism doesn't just happen in black people communities, it happens in white communities too.

Everyone is so geared up to defend victims of racism who are black, which is a good thing, but no one is geared up to defend white people because not many people (which has been proved on this thread) believe racism exists towards white people to the extent that someone had to move from his estate in London to another part of the country.