Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

WTF happened to Russell Brand?

261 replies

username108 · 18/03/2020 21:16

I'm just watching his videos on Youtube and he seems (sorry) WOKE as fuck all of a sudden. WTF happened to him?!

OP posts:
BeetrootRocks · 19/03/2020 19:02

I don't report people ever, not my style.

Everyone can read what you wrote and form their own opinions.

Making a prostitute cry is something I have got stuck on. I didn't know that.

Past abuse might be a reason. But should never be an excuse for abusing others.

angell84 · 19/03/2020 19:01

@todayisnottuesday the difference between me and Russell Brand is that he has hurt many women, he has talked about sexually assaulting them - pushing many women into doing things that they do not want to do sexually.

Are you always this aggressive? You said you are a nurse right, that is meant to be a caring profession, wow! Just wow.

todayisnottuesday · 19/03/2020 18:55

I think the way he talks about his abusive childhood is- to get sympathy from women

Wow. Sorry, but that is a fucking disgusting thing for anyone to say let alone a fellow sufferer of csa.

todayisnottuesday · 19/03/2020 18:53

Wow, today, your posts to a poster who has just disclosed CSA are totally out of line

Report them then. They were not intended to be that way.

For the record - Russel Brand has previously disclosed csa. Where is the compassion for him on here in that respect?

todayisnottuesday · 19/03/2020 18:51

sometimes I think women get too attached to the notion of the man who used to be abusive but "turned it all around" - fulfils fantasies

Certainly not mine. Most men who are abusive do not accept it, they do not address it or seek to change it as they don't think they are doing anything wrong. He has at least recognised and tried to address that side of him. Most don't.

He has managed to beat addictions to heroin, cocaine, alcohol and many other things. Most don't. Credit to him for what he has achieved in that respect. Does this mean that he never acts like an arsehole anymore? I doubt it. Does that mean we should all hate him and write him off as a bad person? No - I don't think it does. But if doing so makes you feel happier, or superior, then by all means carry on.

amprev · 19/03/2020 18:44

Love RB, think he's very attractive and intelligent. Saw him do stand up once and he was really genuine on and off stage. I think he could have so easily gone down a different and destructive path and has shown great strength of character to have remained sober and chaste for all these years.

BeetrootRocks · 19/03/2020 18:44

Today her post is 100% clear.

You need to drop this please.

BeetrootRocks · 19/03/2020 18:43

Wow, today, your posts to a poster who has just disclosed CSA are totally out of line.

angell84 · 19/03/2020 18:43

@treeshemovie! I agree!

I think the way he talks about his abusive childhood is- to get sympathy from women.

I think him being a spiritual guru - is to get attention from women.

They all fall into the pattern of being a serial abuser

Treesthemovie · 19/03/2020 18:40

Sometimes I think women get too attached to the notion of the man who used to be abusive but "turned it all around" - fulfils fantasies.

angell84 · 19/03/2020 18:39

@todayisnottuesday no I left that part out about MYSELF because it is difficult to talk about.

But when you said it happened to him, I said it happened to me too.

The Earth - the way that it is at the moment - many of us have terribly abusive childhoods.

I am really trying not to repeat the cycle.
I generally take out my pain on myself.

Treesthemovie · 19/03/2020 18:38

He seems dodgy as hell and a bit of a spiritual narcissist. I don't see how he's made up for all his past abuse of women at all, he still seems like a total misogynist. But so are loads of men in the public eye.

Doubtless, he has helped some people but I think a lot of it is about his self image.

KittyJune · 19/03/2020 18:29

he literally always was???

todayisnottuesday · 19/03/2020 18:28

I hate men thst abuse women

Actually, so do I. But perhaps the vanishingly few men like this who DO actually try and address this side of them should not be demonised for it.

todayisnottuesday · 19/03/2020 18:26

y the sounds of some of the things that he has done- he should be in jail

And your evidence for that is?.....

todayisnottuesday · 19/03/2020 18:25

He did it using the 12Step program, which is a process of taking responsibility for your actions, and changing them so you are no longer self ( and other) destructive.
It takes you away from the worm’s eye view of yourself and the world.
It’s an incredibly challenging thing to do, so you gather some wisdom along the way

Exactly - it is also a very courageous and admirable thing to do IMHO.

I meant that I left that part out (being sexually abused) about MYSELF , not him

No, you left that part out about HIM and posted to imply his 'abusive childhood' consisted solely of having an 'absent father' which is not the case at all. Please stop backtracking, its getting a bit ridiculous now.

angell84 · 19/03/2020 18:23

@todayisnottuesday yes we will have to agree to disagree.

I am in judgement of him. I hate men thst abuse women. By the sounds of some of the things that he has done- he should be in jail.

But here he is, out preaching to us.

todayisnottuesday · 19/03/2020 18:21

I really do not buy the bullshit that because anyone was abused as a child, it is okay to excuse them to go on and abuse other people

If that is what you think I am saying it is pointless trying to debate anything with you.

Many times I have agreed - he has acted badly at times, yes. He admits that too. As a result, he appears to have taken a good look at himself and addressed that side of him. So what gives you, me or anyone the right to completely write him off as a bad person and hold his past behaviour against him for the rest of his life?

angell84 · 19/03/2020 18:18

@todayisnottuesday I meant that I left that part out (being sexually abused) about MYSELF , not him.

But yes I have been through all that stuff too.

I have no time for him at all. I especially hate peoplr who abuse people, like he does, and then goes on to be a "spiritual guru". It is another form of manipulation.

Ohyesiam · 19/03/2020 18:17

Well he got himself over his heroin, alcohol and sex addictions.
He did it using the 12Step program, which is a process of taking responsibility for your actions, and changing them so you are no longer self ( and other) destructive.
It takes you away from the worm’s eye view of yourself and the world.
It’s an incredibly challenging thing to do, so you gather some wisdom along the way.
He’s an extrovert so he feels the need to communicate it all.

angell84 · 19/03/2020 18:16

I really do not buy the bullshit that because anyone was abused as a child, it is okay to excuse them to go on and abuse other people.

As a child,

I had one abusive parent
I had the other parent commit suicide.
I was sexually abused by more than one person.

I had a TERRIBLE childhood, and I still did not go on to hurt people the way that Russell beand chose to do. Some of his stories are absolutely horrendous. Have you read everything that he has done?

todayisnottuesday · 19/03/2020 18:15

I looked up what his abusive childhood actually was. He had an absent father. I also had an absent father

You left that part out...... OK. Not like it's relevant or anything in relation to his BPD/ EUPD....

I decided to help others. I volunteer with rape victims

Which IS extremely admirable. But you sound like you actually want a medal or something.

I too had a difficult childhood and now work in a caring role (nurse). And part of my job is treating and understanding people with addictions, relationship and MH issues - people who may well have behaved badly and made poor decisions - with understanding and compassion. Not writing people off as 'bad people'.

chatterbugmegastar · 19/03/2020 18:11

He's been spiritual for AGES

angell84 · 19/03/2020 18:08

@todayisnottuesday I left that part out. I was also sexually abused as a child, as were many of us!

I decided to help others. I volunteer with rape victims.

Him being a cruel, nasty asshole is HIS CHOICE!!!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.