Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to stop ds going shopping with his Nan as a punishment?

43 replies

whoops · 07/09/2007 18:32

MIL wanted to take ds out tomorrow to buy his birthday present but I feel that his behaviour has got too bad and needs to be dealt with.
I made him ring his Nan and tell her he had been too naughty and couldn't go - she was fine and was happy to back me up
Dh has now said I am wrong and that he can't be punished that way. I feel he is now going to make me look so stupid by going against my decisions.

OP posts:
kentgirl73 · 07/09/2007 21:14

I fell like that too sometimes, its so hard to know what to do next, but i do feel the only way with my ds is to take things away that mean something, friend round for tea, dancing, no computer...it seems to be working a bit - shes on at the moment, no high school musical 2 cd, wonder when she will get that..............

whoops · 07/09/2007 21:10

He is 6 and had a tatrum before, on the way and at school while dropping him off. When I picked him up he ran off and tried climbing over a fence then wouldn't come back to me. We got home and he was told to get into his pj's while I cooked dinner, he went upstairs and was kicking a football around, he kept fighting with dd and taking her toys off her, he just doesn't listen to me and doesn't do as he is asked, I am at the end of my tether with him and am at the point of wanting to walk out on them

OP posts:
harpsichordcarrier · 07/09/2007 21:03

how old is he?
what has he done, specifically, to make him lose a birthday present?
was he warned?
I think your dh is right. sorry.

whoops · 07/09/2007 21:02

Dh has decided that it isn't fair on ds to lose out on a birthday present as his birthday was on Wednesday and if MIL was a bit more with it ds would have had the present then so they are now going
I am very at the fact dh has gone over a punishement that I have set which will make ds think that anything I set won't be stuck to.

OP posts:
browniedropout · 07/09/2007 20:52

and, of course, adding "nanny may not take be willing to take you shopping now, we will have to check with her". With my older two - I got this one right, just because my Mum had. Negotiation in all but dangerous matters makes our children respect our judgements.

kentgirl73 · 07/09/2007 20:49

i think you just need to make the point that the punishment is for this bad behaviour and if he is good then set him a goal...

LittleBella · 07/09/2007 20:48

Can they do it on Sunday instead?

Then you won't be backing down, but he still gets his present

Alambil · 07/09/2007 20:47

but is the present confiscated??? I am under the impression it is just the trip TO GET the present - not the present itself

harpsichordcarrier · 07/09/2007 20:45

how old is he?
what "bad behviour" ar eyou talking about?
it seems very mean indeed to spoil his birthday like this unless you were very clear that if he did X he wouldn't get his birthday present.
I think you have probably been rather harsh. a more positive thing might have been to get his nan to have a word with him. this way just breeds resentment and probably leaves him feeling hurt, hard done by and pissed off. and not any morelikely to behave.
imo.

browniedropout · 07/09/2007 20:40

Quick, quick don't change YOUR decision. The key to this is consistency. Lucky you - Nanny has backed you up and is supporting your boundary. If you now change your mind and fold (without negotiation) next time will be a disaster. If you say tonight or tomorrow morning that he can sway your decision by doing something (washing up - cleaning out the rabbit, whatever) then he can go shopping with nanny. .... lucky lucky u to have a nanny who stands by you.

kentgirl73 · 07/09/2007 20:37

defo - they always need to know what they will lose before they are on the last warning

wheresthehamster · 07/09/2007 20:36

Only effective if the consequence was known prior to the bad behaviour.
E.g. "If you continue misbehaving then you will not be allowed to go out with grandma tomorrow"
Then it's up to him.

pinkdolly · 07/09/2007 20:30

i think you've done the right thing. i would do the same thing to my children if they badly misbehaved.

kentgirl73 · 07/09/2007 20:28

you did the right thing, i have found taking something away like a treat or an activity really makes my daughter realise...its the one thing that upsets her and every time I have done it she hasnt repeated the episode

Alambil · 07/09/2007 20:24

so, it was the trip out to get the present and not the actual present (which can be given still I'm guessing) - good on you!!

It will teach him a good lesson - actions (however small) have consequences... this seems a very good "punishment" I think. YANBU in my opinion

yomellamoHelly · 07/09/2007 18:38

Depends in a way how much MIL was looking forward to it too. It is almost like punishing her too. It's all hypothetical but I may have confiscated the pressie after it had been bought to punish him (returned once his behaviour had improved).
Good on your MIL to back you up though.

cocolepew · 07/09/2007 18:38

I think you did the right thing, especially getting your DS to phone up and explain. You're lucky you have a MIL who respects your decision. How old is DS? Will he remember this and learn from it? My own DD is 8 and it goes in 1 ear and out the other!

SenoraPostrophe · 07/09/2007 18:35

yes you are being unreasonable, unless by bad behaviour you mean stealing cars or something. It's his birthday, and if he's under about 10 then it won't be very effective anyway because the gap between bad behaviour and punishment is too great.