Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to stop ds going shopping with his Nan as a punishment?

43 replies

whoops · 07/09/2007 18:32

MIL wanted to take ds out tomorrow to buy his birthday present but I feel that his behaviour has got too bad and needs to be dealt with.
I made him ring his Nan and tell her he had been too naughty and couldn't go - she was fine and was happy to back me up
Dh has now said I am wrong and that he can't be punished that way. I feel he is now going to make me look so stupid by going against my decisions.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 09/11/2022 19:35

@BetterDays07 obvioulsy has some kind of issues

ExtraOnions · 09/11/2022 19:32

Zombie cunt is back … clearly fuck all to do with their time … probably some bored dickless Incel

BetterDays07 · 09/11/2022 19:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ -PBP

browniedropout · 07/09/2007 22:35

Did this post seem OK or Bad: gut reaction ??

Negotiation whilst looking strong is the key. Give a tiny bit - antyhing at all - If dear son will move that shoe to the top of the stairs - you can go shopping with nanny. DS - six year old knows you have been generous, DH is just so grateful problem is solved, Dear Nanny respects you for being a strong parent.... lol by the way parenting is an up hill struggle but worth it.

whoops · 07/09/2007 22:17

Nan is MIL

OP posts:
browniedropout · 07/09/2007 22:13

is nan MIL or your mum?

whoops · 07/09/2007 22:09

Nan doesn't seem to be that bothered when she gets to see the kids (she missed ds's christening and didn't come to see them the 2 years we lived in Scotland but that's a different story)
Nan would understand and the other thing I could cancel would be his trip to the cinema with his friend but that would be worse for his friend that is looking forward to the trip.
I have cancelled ds going to legoland and taken dd in his place before I like to stick to the punishments that I have set

OP posts:
theslownorris · 07/09/2007 22:05

True, but I think the real issue here is that Whoops isn't being backed up by her dh. He should have discussed it with her first and then together decided on a suitable course of action. Ok, allow ds to go but you can't just back down, it needs to be done in a roundabout way.

2shoes · 07/09/2007 21:58

yabu why punish his nan??

theslownorris · 07/09/2007 21:53

Whoops' ds is my nephew and this isn't one off behaviour.
Maybe with hindsight it wasn't the most suitable punishment, although it was only the trip that was cancelled and not the actual present, but how many times when we're under pressure do we act first and think later? BUT I do think bil should have backed her up, it is definitely giving him mixed messages if Mummy says one thing and then Daddy tells him differently. Perhaps he doesn't see a reason to behave if his punishment isn't followed through.

Of course my children are perfect little angels and behave all the time

browniedropout · 07/09/2007 21:42

Whoops, after much thought (well.. 8 minutes) IMO, and always when reading MN stuff remember its just theirs, mine, your opinion... I think your DS, DD and D nanny are just normal, human, tired, doing-their-best, its not the same world for a 30 year old man- as his 65 year old mum. In my wide experience, which include several you really would not want to visit - professionally and personally.

negotiation whilst looking strong is the key. Give a tiny bit - antyhing at all - If dear son will move that shoe to the top of the stairs - you can go shopping with nanny. DS - six year old knows you have been generous, DH is just so grateful problem is solved, Dear Nanny respects you for being a strong parent.... lol by the way parenting is an up hill struggle but worth it.

whoops · 07/09/2007 21:33

dh doesn't deal with any of the week day getting ready for school, getting home from school etc as he has to leave for work at 7am and doesn't get home til 7pm ds behaves differently with him as to me - he doesn't run off from him etc,
Nan doesn't see him that often even though she is 5 mins round the corner

OP posts:
browniedropout · 07/09/2007 21:32

Soapbox - might b a good idea to change nickname.. but u must be ok cos ....your still thinking.
.I.m still thinking but please agree.... great Nanny!

harpsichordcarrier · 07/09/2007 21:29

yes whoops we all wish that but tbh six year old boys don't
I think the fact that he said he was sad at making you sad and cross is a very very good sign - he clearly wants to please you.
parenting is a long flipping hard slog.
what support do you get? from dh, and from his nan?

whoops · 07/09/2007 21:28

He has been like this for a long time and not just this week with it being 1st week back at school, birthday etc

OP posts:
whoops · 07/09/2007 21:27

I have tried reward charts, naught step, we have even seen a behavioural nurse who said it was us not disciplining him properly
He actually said to me he wasn't sad at not going with his Nan but making me sad and cross
I just wish he would listen to me and do as he was asked

OP posts:
oliveoil · 07/09/2007 21:25

x posts

(we are so wise...)

oliveoil · 07/09/2007 21:25

bit mean imo

he is 6, first week back at school, tired etc etc

harpsichordcarrier · 07/09/2007 21:24

gosh so his birthday was Wednesday and this is the first week back at school - do you not think he is just tired and overwrought?

soapbox · 07/09/2007 21:24

I think you need to read the Tanya thread and take note of her advice. Your behaviour is reinforcing his behaviour which is why nothing is being resolved. I really do recommend that you read what she wrote yesterday, I think it would be enormously helpful to you in revising the way that you parent your child.

harpsichordcarrier · 07/09/2007 21:23

I am sorry you are having a hard time and you are feeling so worn out with it all
BUT
six is very young and it is the first week of school and his birthday is tomorrow.
I think you need to think about your disciplinary strategies. and give yourself a break. and get some support.
not letting him get a birthday present is not fair on him if he didn;t get any warning. to say " you won't get a present for all these things you have already done" will just make him feel resentful and powerless - and is unlikely to change his behaviour imo.
could you try and work on his behviour in the future by some sort of positive reinforcement. ignoring bad behaviour and rewwarding good? having a reward system (daily/weekly) for reaching some (attinable) targets - not just "being good" but "not fighting with dd" etc.
having a tantrum is difficult - learning to control your emotions is not an easy job and can't just be switched off. have you tried any strategies to help him deal with his anger?
have you ever read How to talk so kids will listen and listen so kids will talk? it is a very useful book imo. I have a pretty challenging 4 yo by the way

Aero · 07/09/2007 21:21

x-posts - I'd be livid if my dh didn't back me up. Birthday present shopping could easily wait a week, and ds would probably behave better in anticipation!

Dd's aunt took her out last Sunday for a similar trip (to Hamley's!), whole month after her birthday.

whoops · 07/09/2007 21:19

His Birthday was on the 5th and his Nan did say she would take him next Saturday if he was good all week.
It doesn't matter now as dh has asked his Mum to take them tomorrow

OP posts:
browniedropout · 07/09/2007 21:19

ok so DH isn't backing u up, bless em - they rarely do. will have a think about this but just stay quiet .. whilst us oldies.. been through lots of this... get suggestions summarised e.g. have a think.... lol by the way

Aero · 07/09/2007 21:16

Is it actually his birthday tomorrow? I think is a fair enough consequence for bad behaviour as long as he was aware of it beforehand. I'd give him a chance to 'earn' the trip back with better behaviour, doing what asked etc, not necessarily tomorrow, but perhaps next week if Nan is happy to take him out then instead.