Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Variations in Height Weight & Dress Size

34 replies

Bunnylady54 · 11/03/2020 12:20

I just read an article about a woman who lost 3st 12llb with Slimming World. She’s 5ft 2” , now weighs 11 stone 2 but reckons she wore a size 10 dress for her 40th. I’m about half an inch taller & maybe just a couple of pounds heavier but there’s no way on earth I’d fit into a size 10! I got down to 9 stone a while back but was still in a 14! I do have broad shoulders & hips but even so, can there really be such a variation in people’s dress sizes?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YerAWizardHarry · 16/07/2022 18:48

I’m 13at 10, 5ft 6 and wear a 16 comfortably or sometimes a 14 depending on item etc. People are generally shocked when I tell them how much I weigh because I apparently “carry my weight well”

LottieDingle83 · 16/07/2022 18:44

I’m just over 5’1 and nine and a half stone. Just gained nearly three stone in two months on Mirtazapine! Definitely more comfy at about eight stone as I’m skinny of leg, flat of chest and large of tummy 🥳🤣I’m a dress size 12!

mencken · 11/03/2020 15:25

it saddens me that women are still so obsessed with the label in their knickers. And still believe that dress size labels mean anything.

you are female. The fashion industry assumes you are a fool and labels accordingly.

mistermagpie · 11/03/2020 15:01

On another note, I don't know why people who are clearly not interested in discussing this topic are even bothering to post, other than to be rude. Just go and read something else!

mistermagpie · 11/03/2020 14:59

I'm 5'8 and just under 10 stone. I'm a size 12 but on another thread people of the same height as me were saying they looked 'gaunt' and like they had an eating disorder at my weight. I didn't even look gaunt when I was 9 stone!

People just carry their weight differently.

h3av3n · 11/03/2020 14:40

@JasonBrun it's literally relevant to the topic of the thread... Never heard the idea that it's navel gazing to mention weight, clothes size etc... Very odd.

mnthrowaway202020 · 11/03/2020 14:11

I’m also short but can wear size 4/6 - because of my height, not because I’m super slim. Smaller sizes tend to look more tailored if that makes sense, as because I’m short clothes generally fit quite oversized on me eg leg/arm length

Lou670 · 11/03/2020 13:43

My weight fluctuates from between 8 stone to 8 stone 11, but generally settles at 8.8. I am 5'7. I am 32.30.32 so totally out of proportion! Very thick waisted with skinny arms and legs.

Most tops are 6/8, bottoms are usually a 10, sometimes an 8. Depends where you shop. For example Tesco's and Marks I buy a size down as they come up big on me. Topshop, I go up a size.

I used to be a 14/16 but lost a lot of weight due to illness and have not managed to regain.

LuckyLickitung · 11/03/2020 13:43

As a 5ft2 pear shape, I'm size 8 on top and size 10 on my lower half. That's pretty constant whether I'm 9.5 st or below 9st. I store a lot of my bulk around a musuclar bum and thighs (long distance runner), and people tend to underestimate my weight due to a small bust and shoulders.

I would be surprised at someone of the same height, towards a couple of stones more than me being a genuine size 10 rather than the dress being from a shop that cuts very generously (no M&S, I really am not a size 6!) or the dress was very stretchy. 11st at 5ft 2 remains an overweight but no longer obese BMI, which tends to be hard to hide at 5ft 2. (Obviously she's made a very positive change to improve likelihood of better health, and it's an achievement to have made that kind of change)

JasonBrun · 11/03/2020 13:32

Oh gawd. Shall we all list our heights weights and dress sizes now Wink

Seriously who fuckin cares. Get a better hobby than literal navel gazing.

Reginabambina · 11/03/2020 13:30

I’m sane weight as sliming world lady but eight inches taller. I can just about fit in a ten in most shops but I’d opt for a twelve if wearing trousers. She may have a very narrow frame or she might be a fairly extreme pair shape. A lot of people are twin completely different sizes top and bottom.

Dixiechickonhols · 11/03/2020 13:22

Gone from an 18/20 to a 10/12 on SlimmingWorld in 8 months. I wear mainly joules, Boden, next. Even in same make sizes vary. I have size 10 next jeans that hang off me but need a 12 in another next pair. Some clothes are huge, just had to send a size 8 dress back to hush that looked like a sack on me.

h3av3n · 11/03/2020 13:16

I'm 9 stone 4, size 6 sometimes even 4 and 5 foot 5, I've been the same weight at a size 10!

h3av3n · 11/03/2020 13:15

Muscle mass makes a huge difference, people are always surprised by my weight compared to my small size but it's because I have a decent amount of muscle

Daddypigsglasses · 11/03/2020 13:07

If she’s pear shaped then she will be able to fit into a smaller dress, the magazine will have written it in the most flattering way possible as they’re selling a product.

She probably wouldn’t fit into a size 10 pair of jeans and vice versa for someone apple shaped who may but would need a bigger dress.

Not to mention that sizes bar hugely by shop.
Also fitting into a stretchy size 10 doesn’t necessarily mean you are a size 10 IYKWIM.

araiwa · 11/03/2020 13:00

Ive never understood dress sizes

If theyre not standardised then theyre a waste of time. Theyre literally just meaningless numbers. Nothing to stop me making a dress for a 7ft 300lb woman and calling it size 0

CookPassBabtridge · 11/03/2020 12:59

Of course body shapes are all different. I have a wide frame, so even when very skknny, size 10 was the lowest I could get due to the width of my pelvis and shoulders. Some people are petite or carry weight well etc..

KatharinaRosalie · 11/03/2020 12:53

Of course there is, muscle mass makes a big difference as well. Me and my friend are the same height and same size, we swap clothes, including jeans and not just the stretchy one-size-fits-nobody stuff. I lift weights, she does not work out - she's almost 20 pounds lighter.

KnitFastDieWarm · 11/03/2020 12:50

At 9st 8lb (my lowest adult weight) I was a size 8 (yes, in topshop Hmm. In 2007). Even now that I’m several stone heavier, people never guess my weight correctly and I wear a size 16, sometimes a 14. It’s all about frame and fat distribution and muscle etc etc. We’re all different!

Darlingsleepthief · 11/03/2020 12:49

That’s crazy @mumof1andacat I am 5ft6 and weight 9.7 stone and am a size 12!

Bunnylady54 · 11/03/2020 12:47

She was 15st & dropped to 11st 2

OP posts:
Mumof1andacat · 11/03/2020 12:46

My friend is 5ft 6. Her ideal weight is 10st 4 which makes her a size 8 - 10. I'm 5ft. At 10st 4 I have to wear a size 14! We all carry weight differently. A while ago my DH lost 4st and didnt budge on clothing size.

Didntwanttochangemyname · 11/03/2020 12:41

I'm 11st 8, 5ft 8 tall and I vary in size from an 8 to a 14. It's all bollocks and means nothing. If it fits you and you feel good in it, wear it.

KittenVsBox · 11/03/2020 12:38

Any chance 11s2 was her starting weight? And now she is 7s4?

randomsabreuse · 11/03/2020 12:35

I carry most of my weight on my arse and thighs - which means I can be a 16 in jeans and need a 10 for a skater dress to fit the rest of me.

Tailored things I'm likely to be a 12 unless generous across the shoulders - I then need some darts for it not to hang like a sack below my bust.

Size depends on shop and style.