Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that some Mumsnetters hate men?

508 replies

Ruby8719 · 05/03/2020 14:53

Am I being unreasonable to think that some (not all) mumsnetters hate men and can’t wait to jump in and tell women to leave their husbands?

Obviously there are a lot of stories on here about husbands/boyfriends/dads that sound like arseholes but the amount of comments I see from strangers telling women to leave their men for making a mistake is crazy!!

OP posts:
Johnsonsfiat · 06/03/2020 11:03

Been here years and years and never seen a LTB suggestion that's not linked to emotional, financial, physical abuse.
I think the OP is wrong

FrogsFrogs · 06/03/2020 10:59

I've seen loads of threads where men have been told to ltb

AngelsSins · 06/03/2020 10:59

It takes a special kind of arsehole to fret about female “rapists” and the poor male victims when women commit less than 1% of sex crimes, whilst thousands of women are raped every year and are often treated appallingly.

It takes a special kind of arsehole to brush over the 2 women every week killed by their partner or ex, to instead focus on male victims of female violence (a minority) on a female centric forum where many women have spoken about their experiences.

It takes a special kind of spectacularly thick arsehole to compare racism to women not being kind enough to men or centring them in conversation. To whine over perceived double standards against men, whilst ignoring the many more that favours them and disadvantage women.

No point arguing with someone this dense.

FrogsFrogs · 06/03/2020 10:58

Sorry pumper not read your post.

I do think that people who, in conversations about male violence, say, oh what about the male victims of women, have a skewed view.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/03/2020 10:58

I Think a part of the problem is some men who would probably consider themselves a good guy is they have a remarkable ability to compartmentalise the women in their life away from Things That Happen to Other Women.

For example, a close male relative of mine was raised by kind, compassionate and respectful parents who expected their sons to extend this courtesy to all they meet. However, even though he's married with three very young girls he will visit strip cubs and pay for a private dance. You know, performed by someone's else's daughter/sister.

So many men see women who are treated badly, harassed, assaulted, disrespected and hurt by other men, as different some how to the women they're close to. It's as if their responsibility is to keep these women safe (maybe for some it harks back to days of us being the property of our father then husband? Who knows) and then lock t6e door and hope for the best. Until the bad thing happens to their daughter/sister/wife.

SonEtLumiere · 06/03/2020 10:57

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

FrogsFrogs · 06/03/2020 10:57

'You’re asking why a man might get a different response from women, and I’ve explained why. A better question might be - why seek out women for that advice? Why not seek out other men?

Because this is a site where issues like that are raised'

An interesting question might be, why aren't men talking about these things.

'Also no acknowledgement of the point I’ve made about the difference between men and women. That just doesn’t suit your argument does it?'

Which differences? Like that 97% ish of people in prison for sex offences are men?

(Waits for someone to say women are just as bad but they never get/ police ignore it/ etc... But the recent news around male victims, yet again the perpetrators were guess what, men).

Pumperthepumper · 06/03/2020 10:55

I talked about the dangers of these things in my post that Hooves was replying to. I find it very, very unlikely that Hooves gave exactly the same advice to Hooves’ son as Hooves gave to Hooves’ daughter about MeToo or porn or strip clubs.

Unless Hooves is just flat out stating that they think women are completely equal to men in all aspects of society, and there’s no point in making any distinctions whatsoever.

Cheeserton · 06/03/2020 10:49

And strip clubs? Porn?
Why on earth would you assume she wouldn't educate on matters like that?? Yet again, take a point then extrapolate to the extreme...

Pumperthepumper · 06/03/2020 10:46

I certainly haven't raised my son as a would be rapist, or told him that society wouldn't hold him responsible for his behaviour. He hasn't been raised responsible for every crime ever committed by a man either in the past, present or future.

And strip clubs? Porn? MeToo? Any of that come up?

Hearhoovesthinkzebras · 06/03/2020 10:28

Pumperthepumper

You can accuse me or predict anything. I'm not making up wild scenarios - I am citing actual threads and posts that were made. You trying to put up smoke and mirrors won't change that - it cannot be appropriate on an individual's thread to start excusing what is happening to them on the basis that men have done X,y and z to women for years.

How have I raised my son? In the same way I raised my daughter - to know right from wrong, to have a conscience, both personal and social, to stand up for what they believe is right, to always do their best to do the right thing and to treat others as they would want to be treated.

I certainly haven't raised my son as a would be rapist, or told him that society wouldn't hold him responsible for his behaviour. He hasn't been raised responsible for every crime ever committed by a man either in the past, present or future.

Eckhart · 06/03/2020 10:26

Yes, we all continue to hold our views, Sagrada. That's not news.

Sagradafamiliar · 06/03/2020 10:21

So predictable.

Pumperthepumper · 06/03/2020 10:19

Also no acknowledgement of the point I’ve made about the difference between men and women. That just doesn’t suit your argument does it?

Eckhart · 06/03/2020 10:19

it's often not possible to argue for any middle way without being lumped in with one polar view or any another, even though they don't represent my views. It's shit for everyone

Quite. I've had really objectionable words/opinions put into my mouth on this thread, and then told I'm stupid for holding such beliefs. It makes healthy debate impossible.

Pumperthepumper · 06/03/2020 10:18

Hooves, it’s actually textbook - if you read a few posts up you’ll see I actually predicted you’d do exactly this! Loads of mythical questions and a solid determination to think that everyone just hates men and that’s it.

How have you raised your children? You didn’t answer.

Hearhoovesthinkzebras · 06/03/2020 10:14

You’re asking why a man might get a different response from women, and I’ve explained why. A better question might be - why seek out women for that advice? Why not seek out other men?

Because this is a site where issues like that are raised. If someone was to Google for resources around such issues no doubt MN would show up. A better question might be why shouldn't he ask on here?

Do you question non parents as to why they post anything on a parenting website? I bet you don't because it doesn't matter. It's a public forum where anyone can post. Just because you don't like that it doesn't mean that someone looking for help is deserving of abuse.

They’ve been raised to understand that women are not fair game. They’ve been raised to understand that society will absolutely absolve them of that responsibility and that’s not good enough. How have you raised your children?

That's how you've raised your sons? That society absolves them of responsibility?

How have you expected them to change other men, or to be responsible for how men as a class behave?

Cheeserton · 06/03/2020 10:11

explain why you think NAMALT stops your son from being a rapist?
I haven't said that. I have said that including all men in the debate is necessary,, just not in the unhelpful and hypocritical terms that some posters immediately resort to. Regarding NAMALT, I pointed out that such extreme postings inevitably lead to that predictable opposite response. Both are actually unhelpful. As usual though, and as demonstrated by your uber defensiveness, it's often not possible to argue for any middle way without being lumped in with one polar view or any another, even though they don't represent my views. It's shit for everyone.

Hearhoovesthinkzebras · 06/03/2020 10:08

Thing is you're only getting on side of it and I've often wondered , after wading through War and Peace of some woman royally going into one , what the other side of the story is ?.

Absolutely. On a thread recently the op complained that her husband had called her a dick because they'd had a row in the supermarket. Immediately she was told that he was abusive, she should leave etc etc. Apparently this is not normal in a non abusive relationship and absolutely nothing could justify him calling her that.

Strangely, on doing an advanced search it seemed much clearer that the op was actually a big part of the problem including one thread where she asked if she was being unreasonable for banning her mil from visiting because she was Chinese and therefore a potential Cartier of covid 19 - not that she had visited China (or Italy) or had been in contact with anyone who had it but simply that she originated from China. Suddenly, her husband calling her a dick seemed quite understandable.

Pumperthepumper · 06/03/2020 10:03

You’re asking why a man might get a different response from women, and I’ve explained why. A better question might be - why seek out women for that advice? Why not seek out other men?

I asked if you had a son because I'm wondering about how you've raised them. Have they been raised being told that they belong to a class that you despise? Do you hold them responsible for rape?

And here we go with your usual line of enquiry! They’ve been raised to understand that women are not fair game. They’ve been raised to understand that society will absolutely absolve them of that responsibility and that’s not good enough. How have you raised your children?

PrimeroseHillAnnie · 06/03/2020 10:00

Thing is you're only getting on side of it and I've often wondered , after wading through War and Peace of some woman royally going into one , what the other side of the story is ?.

Hearhoovesthinkzebras · 06/03/2020 09:59

It’s relevant because it leads society to see what happens to women’s bodies as different to what happens to men’s bodies.

It's relevant on a thread where a man is the victim of domestic abuse is it? How?

I asked if you had a son because I'm wondering about how you've raised them. Have they been raised being told that they belong to a class that you despise? Do you hold them responsible for rape?

Pumperthepumper · 06/03/2020 09:56

I have more than one son! And more than one daughter. Why do you ask?

Pumperthepumper · 06/03/2020 09:54

It’s relevant because it leads society to see what happens to women’s bodies as different to what happens to men’s bodies.

So if you want ‘equality’ (everyone treated exactly the same) you’ve got a long way to go before men and women get or give EXACTLY the same advice to each other.

Hearhoovesthinkzebras · 06/03/2020 09:54

Pumperthepumper

Do you have a son?