Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be mad at a pupil's Mum who buggered off and left her daughter howling?

22 replies

kindersurprise · 05/09/2007 22:01

I teach English in Germany and some of my pupils are very young. This afternoon I had my 3 year olds. Most of the mothers stay downstairs during class, one or two still want Mum with them. I have no problem with this, completely understandable.

Today one little girl didn't want her mum to go downstairs, she was quite upset but the mum was insistant that she was leaving. I asked whether she wanted to stay but she had her baby with her and was not keen. She said to her daughter that she would just go down and check on the baby then come back up again shortly.

Mum left, winking at me as she went, which I took to mean that she would sit with the other mums and I should call on her if needed.

After a few minutes the little girl started crying, but I was able to jolly her along and she settled again. Only for 5 mins, then she started crying again. After about 10mins, I decided it was not fair on her or the other children and asked one of the other mums to fetch the girls mum.

She was not there! One of the other mums managed to get in touch with her on her mobile, but she took ages to come back.

The poor wee girl was getting more and more upset and I was not able to teach the other children at all. I eventually had to go out with her as she was getting so upset I was worried she might make herself ill.

As I went down the stairs the mum appeared, she had come back about 15mins before. She thought that her daughter had settled again so didn't bother coming up. I can hardly believe that she didn't hear her she had been sobbing for ages.

Sorry for the long rant but I was so annoyed. Must work on my non-verbal communication skills!

OP posts:
mylastrolo · 06/09/2007 00:39

That is so young to start at 3 awwwwww bless the wee pet. Hard on you as teacher hope tomorrow goes better for you all.

islandofsodor · 06/09/2007 13:43

YABU. Either the little girl is not ready for your classes, in which case you should tell the mum so or you should make a rule that parents have to stay on the premises.

I find that leaving my ds (also aged 3 ) is better in the long run than pussyfooting around and staying with him. I would have left.

islandofsodor · 06/09/2007 13:44

Or you need an assistant to deal with upset children etc. We have one in our 4 year old classes and at ds's Tumble Tots they always have enough staff to deal with upset chgildren.

sheepgomeep · 06/09/2007 14:39

YABU for all the reasons that islandofsodor has said.

I've had to leave dd1 and ds crying at the start of term a few times before they settled, I dont believe in pussy footing about.
Thier teachers have been very understanding and have always had assistants on hand to help

sheepgomeep · 06/09/2007 14:41

my dd was just 3 when she started nursery over here (wales)

wildwoman · 06/09/2007 14:44

YABU up until th epoint where she came back and still didn't go upstairs to her child.

totaleclipse · 06/09/2007 14:51

At dts nursery ans ds school, the teachers wont allow you to stay if the children are upset, they just send you on your way and ring you when they have calmed down.

hatwoman · 06/09/2007 14:51

strangely I kind of agree with island - but I don;t think you're being particularly unreasonable. I think you need to talk to her, explain that you understand it might be difficult to settle her at first and that you 're willing to take a bit of disruption in the interests of trying to get her to enjoy the classes. however there does come a point when it's unfair on the other kids and unmanageable, in light of which could she please stay on the premises next time so that she can rescue her if needs be. it doesn;'t need to be a "rule" it's just what makese sense and is fair to the others in this particular case.

totaleclipse · 06/09/2007 14:52

They dont let you sneak away either, you have to tell your child you are going and when you will be back before leaving.

yankey · 06/09/2007 14:54

I left my dd this am crying at nursery she is 19mths old. My dd does not often cry but on the couple times she has I have been asked to go quickly and not hang about as this makes them worse. i don't believe in lying to children though so i think the lady was wrong not to just say good bye, as the girl would probably have settled more quickly then. The problem in pretending is that each time you then leave a room they think you might genuinly be leaving them and then you can;t even go to the loo without tears. Thats my theory anyway.

LIZS · 06/09/2007 14:56

aw bless. I guess the mum decided that as she did actually stop howling it was ok to make a quick exit. Agree it not being fair on you or the class though. Does this little girl normally cry , perhaps she isn't ready to be left like that yet . dd was like that with ballet in Swiss German so I abandoned it after 2 lessons.

kslatts · 06/09/2007 15:04

I agree with island and think YABU.

HorseyWoman · 06/09/2007 15:35

I think YABU. I've been a nanny, worked in schools and am about to start teaching. In all my experience it has been not running back to the child as soon as it cries, that has helped matters. If the mother runs back in and flings her arms round the child every time he or she cries, the child then learns what to do if it wants mummy to stick around. Hey presto, you've got mummy on a guilt trip and the child holding her to account. When children start nursery and school they nearly always cry, which eases as each day passes until in the end, the child realises that at the end of the session/day mummy will come back to get them.

constancereader · 06/09/2007 15:56

I initially thought you were BU from the thread title, but after reading the OP I realised that it wasn't 'school' where getting used to being left is part of the learning process, but a three year old being left at a private language class. This makes a difference imo, so I think YANBU in being annoyed.

3andnomore · 06/09/2007 16:09

mixed emotions on this one....obviously, knowing that in germany children don't start school this early, I assume you give private lessons....so, maybe suggesting trying at a later stage or asking mum to stay with daughter until settled into your class would be best.
Also, maybe calrifying that you want the mums to stay on the premises might be a good idea.
If the mother has a little Baby though....well...maybe she was trying to get some shopping done with just one of the Kids, rather then taking 2...so, I understand...bit odd though she didn't actually came to see her lil one straight away when called back...that is out of order...

HorseyWoman · 06/09/2007 16:21

Oh it's a language class. Hmmmm. Strange then.

hatwoman · 06/09/2007 18:42

can;t believe how many peopl think yabu! I'm not convinced they have appreciated the situation. 3 years old. in private lessons of some sort. entirely reasonable to ask the mother of a child to hang around and step in if that child means you can't get on with your lesson. have been in exactlythe same situation with baby ballet classes

kindersurprise · 06/09/2007 20:53

Sorry that I have not been around to clarify some points.

I teach private lessons, not in a school but at home and the children are accompanied by their parents until they (the children) feel comfortable about staying alone. Normally the Mums just go downstairs and wait (and drink coffee)

I did ask the mum to stay and join in the class but she did not want to. I spoke to her today and she said she just popped to the shops.

This little girl has been attending classes for 12 weeks now, but class was off during the school holidays and afterwards the family were on holiday so she has not been for 8 weeks. Before the holidays she was fine, loved coming, joined in and never looked for mum.

I was annoyed that the mother did not keep her promise to the child to come back in, I think that breaking a promise like that is a breach of trust.

The mum has agreed to stay in class next week or even in the following weeks, but the mum is not keen on staying as she has her DS with her too and is worried about disturbing the class.

I will make sure that the parents do not leave the premises in future, that is a valid point. Thankyou for your posts, it helped me put things into perspective.

OP posts:
3andnomore · 06/09/2007 21:32

kinder...yes, it's not good to break a promise to a young child...I totally agree.

islandofsodor · 09/09/2007 00:17

You are definately not being unreasonable to insist that parents stay on the premises. That is required at my ds's Tumble Tots class for insurance reasons and I have no problems.

What I felt you were being unreasonable for was not making this clear in the first place, and not having enough help to help settle children so you can carry on teaching. At Tumble Tots this week ds was a bit teaful going in as it was the first week back after summer, but he was whisked away by one of the staff and that was much better than me hanging around.

I run classes and although our children are slightly older (from age 4) we have 1 teacher, 1 assistant and one to stay in the waiting area to deal with admin for each class.

I don't think the mum broke a promise. It is a very common technique to say just popping to whatever (I do it every night when I put ds to bed, I tell him I'm just popping in to say goodnight to his sister).

BetterDays07 · 09/11/2022 19:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ -PBP

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 09/11/2022 19:40

How do you find all these threads?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page