Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think these comments from Peter Tatchell are concerning? *title edited by MNHQ at OP's request

36 replies

CaveMum · 12/02/2020 12:07

Why on earth do people keep giving this odious man air time? And why on earth does he have an opinion on girls and their right to privacy and dignity.

Apparently we should be encouraging girls not to be embarrassed by their bodies so that they’ll happily get changed in mixed sex facilities. Sounds like a massive safeguarding red flag to me!

twitter.com/rtuknews/status/1226901136566870018?s=21

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AlfonsoTheMango · 28/07/2021 14:56

I don't trust Peter Tatchell and know that he has no right to determine issues regarding children's safeguarding.

ChainJane · 28/07/2021 14:42

According to Tatchell the Guardian apologised. I guess he thought there was no need to sue if they had printed an apology.

I can't help thinking that the latest comments about shared changing rooms are just the natural progression of the "equality bandwagon" that has been rumbling on for the past century or so. Decades ago people thought that giving women the vote was radical or nonsensical. But the equality movement persisted and women got the vote. People thought equal pay for women was outrageous, because a woman doing the same job wouldn't actually work as hard as or be as productive as a man. People opposed the decriminalisation of homosexuality, they opposed the laws to prevent discrimination based on sexual orientation because they felt gay people were inferior and/or dangerous. More recently, people have opposed gay marriage because they believe marriage should be between a man and a woman.

All these obstacles were overcome, often despite great opposition. It's the same fight today with gender recognition and the idea that a male-to-female transitioner should be treated as a woman, or that there should not be single-gender spaces because they prevent people gaining access purely based on their gender.

The arguments against them are the same old arguments - it's stupid, it's offensive, it's dangerous. No doubt they will be overcome in time and people who argue that girls shouldn't be obliged to change in front of naked men at the swimming pool will be seen as offensive and outrageous as the argument that homosexuals are likely to be paedophiles is today.

The thing to remember is that those arguing for change don't care about the interests of those who want to keep the status quo. There's not point arguing, all that does is delay things. You can't stop progress, whether you see it as a good thing or not.

Xenia · 28/07/2021 14:27

Most people who are wise don't sue because you just run massive risks of losing every penny you have and might not win anyway. However the bottom line here is that women and young girls should be the ones deciding who can come into our private spaces when we are taking our clothes off, not men like Tatchell.

The cult Children of God used similar arguments to this kind of thing and it went very very badly wrong and vast numbers of very small children were abused.

plodalong12 · 28/07/2021 14:24

*made me out to be defending paedophilia, I should have wrote above.

plodalong12 · 28/07/2021 14:23

He faced a storm of criticism in 1997 for writing a letter to The Guardian in defence of another controversial book. In the letter, he claimed that some of his friends “had sex with adults from the ages of nine to 13. None feel they were abused”.

He later said that the letter, which he pointed out said it was “impossible to condone paedophilia”, was edited before appearing in the newspaper.

If someone edited something I wrote and it made me out to be a paedophile when I wasn’t, I would sue them without a shadow of a doubt. Did PT sue the Guardian over this? I can’t find anything on Google.

OhHolyJesus · 28/07/2021 13:24

Full text from the Telegraph yesterday:

By
Hayley Dixon,
SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT ;
Melanie Newman
and
Julie Bindel
27 July 2021 • 9:30pm
Peter Tatchell
Peter Tatchell has argued that “children have sexual desires at an early age” as he praised the “courage” of those selling what he later described as a “pro-paedophilia” book, The Telegraph can reveal.

In a review of a 1986 collection of essays compiled by Warren Middleton, former vice-chairman of the Paedophile Information Exchange (PIE), Mr Tatchell, a gay rights campaigner, said that children should be “educated” so that they can decide when they want to have sex.

Mr Tatchell had even written a chapter for Middleton’s anthology - Radical perspectives on Childhood Sexuality, Intergenerational Sex, and the Social Oppression of Children and Young People - but has since attempted to distance himself, claiming that he was “conned” into contributing to “that vile book”.

The Telegraph can now reveal that a year after the book’s publication, Mr Tatchell submitted a review praising the way it “speaks coolly, clearly and radically about a subject which has far too long been shrouded in emotional hysteria and adult chauvinism”.

ADVERTISING

Mr Tatchell’s chapter in the book, written when the age of consent for gay men was 21, argued laws criminalising underage sex do more harm than good. Other chapters covered child pornography and prostitution, incest and “how to make paedophilia more acceptable”.

In the review for the newsletter of the Communist Party of Great Britain in 1987, Mr Tatchell wrote: “Society would remove a lot of fear, anxiety and depression if, instead of repressing children’s sexuality, it acknowledged the fact that many children have sexual desires at an early age and accordingly educated children, so they are able to make free, informed and responsible decisions about when and with whom they have sex.”

On Tuesday night, Mr Tatchell said that he had still not read the book when he submitted the review, which a colleague had drafted, adding: “I apologise unreservedly for putting my name to this review, and for failing to make clear my unconditional opposition to adults having sex with children.”

The review emerged just weeks after a documentary celebrating the campaigner’s life was released by Netflix.

Advertisement

In Hating Peter Tatchell, celebrities including Stephen Fry and Elton John line up to praise Mr Tatchell’s work while Chris Smith, the former Labour MP, describes him as a “national treasure” and Dr George Carey, the former Archbishop of Canterbury, says he was “on the right side of history”.

The documentary, in which he is interviewed by Sir Ian McKellen, makes no mention of his comments on children and sexual desires.

But Mr Tatchell has long been dogged by accusations of being a paedophile apologist.

He faced a storm of criticism in 1997 for writing a letter to The Guardian in defence of another controversial book. In the letter, he claimed that some of his friends “had sex with adults from the ages of nine to 13. None feel they were abused”.

He later said that the letter, which he pointed out said it was “impossible to condone paedophilia”, was edited before appearing in the newspaper.

In an interview republished on his own website claiming to set the record straight on his views, Mr Tatchell describes Middleton’s book as “pro-paedophilia”, saying: “I had no idea that it had any connection to PIE and that it would even mention paedophilia, let alone justify it.”

Advertisement
“If I had known, I would not have agreed to write anything for that dreadful, nauseating book.”

But his denials have been called into question by his review of the same book, still available in the archives of the British Library.

Headlined “Radical thoughts on consent”, Mr Tatchell noted in the review that Middleton had “found it impossible to get a publisher”

He continued: “I am only writing this review because it seems that no one else is willing to risk association with this taboo subject.”

He wrote that while the authors “oppose coercive and exploitative child sexual abuse” they “also argue that consenting, victimless sexual relationships between younger and older people should not be penalised by the law”.

The review goes on to argue there should be “greater rights for children” who should be “given opportunities to exercise power and choice in every facet of their lives including their sexual and emotional feelings”.

Mr Tatchell said last night that he had still not read the book and did not know of its connections to PIE when he was asked by “[a] person I trusted” to write a review condemning the censorship of it in 1987.

Advertisement
His colleague drafted the review as he was too busy, the former Labour Party Parliamentary candidate claimed, while Mr Tatchell himself made some stylistic changes.

Mr Tatchell claims that he only learnt of the true contents of the book and Middleton’s connections when it was sent to him years later and he “felt tricked and betrayed”.

“I am very sorry and deeply regret the terrible mistake of submitting this review. I was very wrong,” he said when approached by The Telegraph.

“It does not reflect my opinion that adults should never have sex with children and that children cannot consent to sex with adults. Once more, I apologise unreservedly.”

Mr Tatchell said that he “condemns” sex abuse and has “never knowingly been in contact with anyone involved or associated with PIE”.

He added: “I have always supported victims of child sex abuse in their quest for justice. For the record, my view is that paedophilia is the sexual abuse of children.”

Telegraph Breaking News alerts

Be informed about the latest news stories as soon as they break
Sign up
Related Topics
Netflix, Stephen Fry, Sir Ian McKellen, Sir Elton John
More stories
Simone Biles' disintegration was shocking - but we should have seen it coming
Image of Simone Biles' disintegration was shocking - but we should have seen it coming
Freedom for double jabbed as UK opens to world
Image of Freedom for double jabbed as UK opens to world
Nicola Sturgeon accused of 'Donald Trump-style meltdown' over vaccine figures
Image of Nicola Sturgeon accused of 'Donald Trump-style meltdown' over vaccine figures
Behold the £2m 'hill of rubble': new Marble Arch Mound already giving refunds
Image of Behold the £2m 'hill of rubble': new Marble Arch Mound already giving refunds
‘Why I gained two stone in lockdown – and how I lost it’
Image of ‘Why I gained two stone in lockdown – and how I lost it’
Simone Biles on her Tokyo 2020 Olympics gymnastics final 'freak out': 'I just didn't want to go on'
Image of Simone Biles on her Tokyo 2020 Olympics gymnastics final 'freak out': 'I just didn't want to go on'

More from News
V&A boss says the wealthy have stopped donating to museums because of scrutiny
By
Anita Singh
28 Jul 2021, 6:00am
Tristram Hunt at the V&A on his first day as Director.
Thousands more Afghans who worked with Britain should be allowed to relocate to UK, urge Army chiefs
By
Lucy Fisher
28 Jul 2021, 6:00am
Carrying the Union Jack, the last British troops leave Camp Bastion, Helmand Province, Afghanistan
Juan Carlos: Ex-lover of Spanish king claims he told spies to track her in UK
By
Phoebe Southworth
28 Jul 2021, 6:00am
Corinna zu Sayn-Wittgenstein is seeking damages
Childhood obesity fuels midlife health crisis, study finds
By
Laura Donnelly
28 Jul 2021, 6:00am
Childhood obesity
Criminals to be guaranteed accommodation when they leave prison
By
Charles Hymas
28 Jul 2021, 6:00am
Boris Johnson and Priti Patel visit Surrey Police headquarters to launch the Government's Beating Crime Plan
One in four adults has not been hugged for more than a year
By
Gabriella Swerling
28 Jul 2021, 6:00am
Stay at Home poster, lockdown London
More from The Telegraph
Patients died after operations to remove objects left inside them were cancelled due to Covid
Image of Patients died after operations to remove objects left inside them were cancelled due to Covid
Don’t mention the culture wars – they aren’t big here... yet
Image of Don’t mention the culture wars – they aren’t big here... yet
Charlotte Dujardin makes history with fifth Olympic medal - as Bianca Walkden left 'dead inside' at bronze
Image of Charlotte Dujardin makes history with fifth Olympic medal - as Bianca Walkden left 'dead inside' at bronze
Nicola Sturgeon and SNP criticised for failing to support Team GB at Olympics
Image of Nicola Sturgeon and SNP criticised for failing to support Team GB at Olympics
Explosion at German chemical complex leaves two dead and more than 30 injured
Image of Explosion at German chemical complex leaves two dead and more than 30 injured
Kirstie Allsopp has the right idea – when Covid cases are coming down, doom-peddlers should cheer up
Image of Kirstie Allsopp has the right idea – when Covid cases are coming down, doom-peddlers should cheer up
Back to top
Follow us on:
Contact us
About us
Rewards
Reader Prints
Branded Content
Syndication and Commissioning
Guidelines
Privacy
Terms and Conditions
Advertising Terms
Fantasy Sport
UK Voucher Codes
Betting Offers
Modern Slavery
Manage Cookies
© Telegraph Media Group Limited 2021

OhHolyJesus · 28/07/2021 13:23

I think this is the most recent thread, though there are several, on Tachell, so sharing this here

twitter.com/twisterfilm/status/1420342338552057858?s=21

Thelnebriati · 12/02/2020 22:24

You don''t need to be prosecuted to have a hate incident put on your record. All it takes is for anyone to make a complaint that you have expressed an opinion about women's rights or safeguarding and to have that comment framed as 'transphobia'.
This will show up on a DBS check.

The end result is that women who have concerns about safeguarding children (for example, raising the issue of mixed sex sleeping or changing arrangements) can fail a background check and so be prevented from working with them.

MummyOfBoyAndGirl · 12/02/2020 22:23

Terrifying if he is able to influence young people

CallofDoodee · 12/02/2020 22:17

How does this man have any sort of influence?

Please MNHQ don't delete posters discussing what is happening here.

I am fucking horrified at his comments - talk about in plain sight!

Languishingfemale · 12/02/2020 22:13

People like Tatchell have no business trying to influence children and practice in schools. His comments about adults having sex with children should automatically disbar him. Yet in this 'woke' world of ours schools are abandoning many of their responsibilities for safeguarding and allowing people like this - with no qualifications in child development, child psychology, safeguarding or education - to "advise" on how schools should operate and how girls should undress in front of boys and men.

He evidently believes that he is beyond criticism - so dangerous.

Winesalot · 12/02/2020 22:12

This man is deeply troubling. That he is given access to schools or even a platform to speak is frightening. If this is allowed, surely this is a safeguarding failure.

GCAcademic · 12/02/2020 21:48

I'm also wondering who is reporting and/or moderating this thread.

If it’s anything like the Feminism board, there are people monitoring us constantly when the subject of safeguarding is discussed. Certain activists have lobbied MNHQ to ensure that we are not permitted to use the necessary words to discuss what is happening.

blubellsarebells · 12/02/2020 21:41

I'm also wondering who is reporting and/or moderating this thread.

blubellsarebells · 12/02/2020 21:37

Deeply questionable indeed.
So why are the people who are supposed to be protecting our children, not asking the relevant questions?

CaveMum · 12/02/2020 19:48

The new CPS “guidance” on hate crimes is also concerning - suggesting that a girl who objects to a transgirl in the female changing rooms could be punished under hate crime legislation.

OP posts:
Ikeasucks · 12/02/2020 19:46

Check your schools policy on this, Peter and likes of Stonewall are basically forcing and shaming girls (and boys) to not speak up if they feel uncomfortable with boys (girls) in their loos, changing rooms etc. They have access to dictate policy and “best practice”

AIBU to think these comments from Peter Tatchell are concerning? *title edited by MNHQ at OP's request
AIBU to think these comments from Peter Tatchell are concerning? *title edited by MNHQ at OP's request
AIBU to think these comments from Peter Tatchell are concerning? *title edited by MNHQ at OP's request
hazeyjane · 12/02/2020 19:26

I was appalled by this interview. The idea that girls of 13 need to get over their discomfort....fuck that shit.

HumphreyCobblers · 12/02/2020 19:23

Can't believe I was deleted.

No email.

Can I say that encouraging girls to lack boundaries so that they will tolerate naked men in their spaces without complaint, no matter how uncomfortable it makes them, is A BAD THING?

popehilarious · 12/02/2020 16:51

Ooh, my first deletion that I know of - no email. Thought it was benign and agreeing with others but I see those posts characterising this as certain word have also been deleted.

Anyway, the dog needs his fur brushing by a professional so I'm off to the

BanKittenHeels · 12/02/2020 16:45

PIE
PIE
PIE

Bezalelle · 12/02/2020 16:41

People need to understand that the rainbow flag isn't all happy, accepting freedoms and unicorns.

It's a massive lobby underpinned by a desire to break down safeguards and barriers.

Always ask "Who benefits?" It's almost always powerful men.

Always ask "Where is the money?" and it will lead you to these men.

MrsSnippyPants · 12/02/2020 16:08

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Whatisthisfuckery · 12/02/2020 15:05

It’s beyond me how a man who does not have any relevant experience or qualifications with children,, and who has made on record comments that look dodgy as hell about children having sex with adults and lowering the age of consent should be allowed anywhere near a school, let alone lorded as the patron of an organisation that delivers RSE. The world has gone fucking mad. If he goes anywhere near my DS’s school I’ll be down there like a shot. His interest in children looks deeply questionable in the extreme.

Tellmetruth4 · 12/02/2020 14:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.