Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be pissed off with the NHS over being referred back to GP by hospital......

158 replies

ACautionaryTale · 10/02/2020 15:13

So I've been on the waiting list to have the mirena removed by the hospital as the GP couldn't manage it. I've been waiting over 14 months - which is fine as its not urgent. I don't need it for contraception (DH had the snip) and I'm not planning on getting another one put in.

I got a letter through telling my my appointment was the 19th Feb. Except that I can't do that day. Im self employed and working on a critical project for a major company which goes live beginning of June.

If it goes well, I'm highly likely to get quite a lot of repeat business. We are talking enough to keep my income going for the next few years.

Wednesdays are the one key day of the week that its very visible if you are not around. It was planned that way so that people could have long weekends during the project as it was acknowledged that for anyone involved, taking a whole week would be difficult until end of June.

I phoned up to re-arrange my appointment and they offered me another Wednesday two weeks later. They only do this procedure on a Wednesday. I said this was not possible and could I just go on the list for some time after the end of June as I knew it was not urgent.

This is not possible as you can't delay over three months - if you do you get sent back to the consultant who sends you back to the GP and you have to go through the whole process again.

I feel like banging my head against a wall.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LINDAHOAD · 25/07/2023 17:04

yes the french system works so much better - in fact most systems from abroad have a better system but the mere mention of a change to the nhs system immediately throws up the money issue. the nhs needs drastic change as it cannot cope in its present state. but who will be brave enough to come up with new ideas and ways of financing it.

mummyh2016 · 06/03/2020 07:20

If the contract is worth that much that you can't attend either appointment offered I would go private.

Ginfilledcats · 06/03/2020 06:57

Also @userv the reason they'll be cancelling and rearranging appointments is because of those people who miss or DNA their original appointments but are urgent and need to be seen so get fitted in somewhere which obviously displaced other patients.

Ginfilledcats · 06/03/2020 06:55

They do let the patient choose first appointment - it's called choose and book been around for years.

They can't just let patients choose a day that suits as the consultants are job planned and not in clinic every day! They have ward rounds, teaching med students, procedure clinics. Majority of clinics are split by sub specialty so they can't just have a clinic every day that would be mad, and too much capacity!

In respiratory for example at my hospital, there are 3 consultants who yes between them there is a clinic every day, but depending on what you are referred for determines who you will see. If it's x reason that clinic might only run once a week or every other week because of the demand for that type of clinic and the availability of x machine and nurse to support.

Really short sighted to just say that patient to should be able to choose a day. Of course they can, but only on the day that that clinic runs, which is usually the same day each week.

Also everyone gets the letter about the cost of missed appointments because it's astronomical and patients should be aware of that.

Mistigri · 15/02/2020 16:27

UserV tbh I don't really understand why the NHS still works like this.

I live in France now and if I need a specialist appointment I get a letter from my doctor then use an app on my phone to find a specialist who has a free slot at a time convenient to me. There is no (inefficient and costly) negotiation between patient and medical secretaries to find a time that works. And usually I can get an appointment in less than a month.

UserV · 14/02/2020 21:49

@Mistigri

It's such an inefficient system in many respects, both from the NHS POV (handling appointment rescheduling/cancellation) and for the patient. It would be much easier to give the patient a referral and then allow them to book an appointment themselves, rather than requiring them to attend a specific clinic on a day that isn't convenient.

This. They can't just assume that everyone^ is just free all the time. People have lives, jobs, children, and all manner of commitments. Giving someone access to a booking system on the internet, and letting them choose their appointment time and day would be MUCH better. You can do this for GP appointments, so why not hospital ones? Confused

And another thing, every time my cousin's DH gets an appointment cancelled (AGAIN!) after he has changed the first (inconvenient) appointment, the letter always says 'missed appointments cost the NHS over £200 MILLION pounds a year!'

Yet they keep constantly changing appointments, when many people have probably made arrangements and got work shifts swapped/got childcare/arranged transport.

So they lose the argument really when they moan about patients 'missing appointments' when they keep cancelling and re-arranging them (as I said, often for no reason!)

Snoopdogsbitch · 14/02/2020 19:57

Not rtft, sorry, but YANBU it's ridiculous that you have waited 14 months to get a coil out?!!! I called my GP and it was out within a week. You can also make an appointment with a family planning clinic - my friend was seen within 2 weeks as she was exactly like you- couldn't see the GP due to childcare and work. 14 months is bloody ridiculous. Can you see family planning?

UserV · 14/02/2020 19:50

@ACautionaryTale YANBU, and I hope you get it sorted. As a few posters have said, you can't say ANYthing against the NHS on here; it's like they, and everyone who works for them are flawless Angels without wings who can't put a foot wrong EVER.

The NHS make MANY mistakes, and whilst they are great in many ways, people need to stop putting them on a pedestal.

My cousin's husband is currently having a course of treatment that involves going to the hospital every 5 or 6 weeks, and he does 4-on, 4-off shift work. Without fail, every single appointment he is offered is on one of his work days. He rings and changes it to a non-work day, and then a couple of weeks later, they cancel the appointment and change it to another day, that once again is a WORK day.

So he arranges an inconvenient appointment (fair enough, they never knew what shift he was on when they sent it,) then when the new convenient appointment is made, they cancel it EVERY TIME. And there is rarely a reason.

He doesn't get paid when he is off, his employer keeps getting arsey, (as he has lost 5 or 6 days already this past 7-8 months,) and 90% of the people who go there don't work, so can have appointments ANYtime virtually! But he can't, and they don't get why.

Buuuut he is not allowed to complain, because it's just not allowed. 'Be GRATEFUL you HAVE the NHS!' people crow. Like the OP, my cousin's DH has paid enough into it over the last 30 years! So has a right to moan without being shut down.

YANBU OP!

Chloemol · 14/02/2020 19:49

It’s now or back to the GP as that’s how they work, it maybe to do with targets, it maybe they can’t book that far ahead who knows. Although you say you are self employed, you obviously must be working with a company if you all have to be there on a Wednesday, so either say you can’t be due to a procedure that can only be done on a Wednesday, or go back to the Doctor. No point banging on about it

Mistigri · 14/02/2020 19:24

It's such an inefficient system in many respects, both from the NHS POV (handling appointment rescheduling/cancellation) and for the patient. It would be much easier to give the patient a referral and then allow them to book an appointment themselves, rather than requiring them to attend a specific clinic on a day that isn't convenient.

Ginfilledcats · 14/02/2020 19:10

@ACautionarytale you've been referred back to your GP until you are available. The hospital will have "stopped your clock" when your gp re refers they need to specify to reopen your pathway from this date and should continue from where your "clock" (ie the 18 week pathway) stopped last time. Therefore you shouldn't go to the back of the queue.
They can't let you breach the 18 weeks which they evidently will do, due to patient unavailability, because there will be a fine. The more fines = the less money the trust gets = less funding to put on a range of clinics to expand this one from a Wednesday to a Wednesday and a Monday for example.

Call PALs and ask to speak to the Access team for clarification of your rights on re referral.
The hospital have done everything right. The national access standards say they have to offer you 2 appointments with reasonable notice. If you can't do them you get discharged back to gp until you are available.
Not ideal for you, no, but do you realise how many patients come through the service? It would be impossible to manage any other way.

I hope you get success and get a timely appt following a call to PALs and discussion with your go. Ask to speak to the directorate manager, they will usually bring you in early to avoid a complaint!

makingmammaries · 14/02/2020 18:43

t is a universal rule across most health care organisations. Patients who want their appointments organise themselves to be available. Patients who don't, don’t.

Actually, as an expat, I can state with confidence that most other nations don’t put up with such an inefficient health service that shows such disrespect for people’s need to be able to work.

jadealisha · 14/02/2020 13:40

What they have said is 100%, I worked in women's health for the NHS and that is correct

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 11/02/2020 20:48

Have you contacted PALS?

Bluerussian · 11/02/2020 11:34

Can you not go private for this one off procedure?

CoffeeRunner · 11/02/2020 10:24

I can see both sides here OP.

Unfortunately, the hospital is going on strict protocol which will revolve around targets. The procedure you need is only done in Wednesday’s clinic. But you can’t (understandably) make the next 2 Wednesday appointments offered. So they are unable to book you anything further ahead & protocol is to refer back to the GP. If they offered you an appointment in July for example, while totally logical, that would add 5 months on to their “time on waiting list” for you. That has consequences & that is why protocol doesn’t allow it.

I completely understand your frustration though. Of course you aren’t going to jeopardise such a big project for something fairly routine. But I also understand the reasons the rules are as they are.

I work for one NHS trust & have appointments & treatments in a different one. Arranging appointments drives me crazy too!

TellMeWhoTheVilliansAre · 11/02/2020 10:10

But we could end up in the same scenario again!

In which case your probably better staying out of the public system and going privately at a time that suits.

TellMeWhoTheVilliansAre · 11/02/2020 10:09

I just cannot fathom why they can’t put a delay until July!

Because then what was a 14 month waiting list becomes a 20 month waiting list. And you wouldn't be the only person on just one waiting list looking to delay an appointment. This is reported back to hospital management, to area management, to central statistic figures etc.

You were offered an appointment for 23 days time. Over 3 weeks away. That would be appropriate notice for most people to arrange. If you don't like the free public system that is on offer and can't work it around your schedule then there are other options.

ACautionaryTale · 11/02/2020 09:25

Oh my gp is fine. The problem is when I go back on the list it will be a 12-14 month wait again.

Which I don’t mind. But we could end up in the same scenario again!

OP posts:
NurseButtercup · 11/02/2020 09:12

@ACautionaryTale

I completely understand your frustration, there is a woeful lack of commonsense approach being adopted by referring you back to your GP. Sadly this is common practice in NHS because your request has sadly dragged you into the bureaucracy of the hospital trying to achieve the agreed waiting time targets.

I'm hopeful that you can resolve this with your GP reception. Suggest to the receptionist that your referral is resent towards the end of June. Hopefully they are super efficient and you won't need to chase them or make another appointment to see your GP to kickstart the referral process.

Good luck

MulticolourMophead · 11/02/2020 08:47

There is a hell of a lot of inefficiency in the NHS. 9 years ago, DD had an eye appointment. Afterwards, she needed a follow up, so I went to the desk to arrange one.

Oh no, they said. We send you a letter with an appointment on, and if you can't make it you phone up and rearrange.

Letter arrived with an appointment and it was a date I couldn't do. Phoned up, and they didn't discuss a date with me, just said they'd send an appointment out in another letter.

That letter never arrived, I phoned up to be told we'd missed the appointment and would have to go via GP for new referral. The appointment we'd missed had been the first, cancelled one. 🙄 It was sorted out eventually, but it wasted a lot of time.

The strict targets has led to inflexibility in the system, and I reckon that's costing the NHS more in wasted appointments and admin, than being able to be flexible and actually discuss suitable times with patients.

Berrymuch · 11/02/2020 08:38

I agree it's ridiculous, and far more of a burden on the service to put you back for a referral and on the waiting list rather than just give an appointment after June. I agree that it can't bend to everyone's whim, but it seems reasonable in this case, and you are more than happy to wait which surely gives someone else the chance to have theirs done sooner; you aren't wasting appointments or demanding you are seen on a certain day at a certain time. If you were a teacher or something it would be hard to get a weekday off at a particular time, self employed seems to be thought of as fully flexible though which it's not (if you want to make money anyway!).

SinkGirl · 11/02/2020 08:34

😳

OP’s GP can’t remove it. It’s caught up in a fibroid.

Trying to remove it herself is the worst possible thing she could do. Believe me, in the year I had to wait for mine to be removed while having hours of intense contractions every day, if I could have pulled the fucking thing out myself I would have! But given the three attempts with speculums and tools and the consultant who basically treated me like a cow giving birth, I doubt it would have done much good.

Forgottenagainst · 11/02/2020 08:24

I recently removed a coil myself as I couldn’t get an appointment and I was in a lot of pain for weeks preceding. I read a bit first and felt comfortable doing so and the pain was immediately relieved.

ACautionaryTale · 11/02/2020 07:55

I am Not frustrated they can only do wednesday

I am Not asking for them to do it at a convenient time for me outside normal clinics

I am not asking them to make their service revolve around me

I am frustrated that after being referred to one clinic they refused to do it because the reason for it being there was not on their list

I am frustrated that after waiting 14 months - which I do not mind because I know it’s non urgent and there are other more pressing issues people have - I get given 9 days notice then one more option 14 days after that and if I can’t do either of them I get removed front the system.

I am happy to do any Wednesday after then end of June.

I would be able to do any day other than Wednesday before the end of June but I know that’s not possible because of clinic schedule so I’m not throwing a strop over that.

I just cannot fathom why they can’t put a delay until July!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread