Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Renting a 2 bed house to a family with 3 kids

462 replies

Beetle76 · 31/01/2020 02:51

I’ve got my hard hat on! I am renting out my two bed house while I have been seconded to a job in a different area for a year.
While it’s a small house, it’s in a good area so I received a number of offers for the full asking rent after the first viewing day. I decided to go with the person who stated they had two cats (I know what it’s like to rent with pets so I thought I’d help them out.)
The provisional paperwork listed a single tenant with their cats and I agreed to proceed on that basis. The full lease has arrived for me to sign and now it’s the tenant, plus cats, plus 3 kids.
My view is it’s a two bed house, one living room, small eat in kitchen and is thus not really suitable for a large family.
I didn’t base my decision on no kids, I just wanted to help out another cat person, and they happened to be the only applicant without kids.
I was expecting to have a kid or two in the house, it’s a great area for kids, but I think 3 is too many for the space. I don’t see where they would go - 3 kids beds would not fit in either bedroom, they are just not big enough. Maybe a sleeper couch in the living room? I suppose a kid could live under the stairs Harry Potter style 😂
But I fiercely dislike dishonesty and I feel they have been dishonest by not saying who would be living in the house from the outset. AIBU if I decide to pull the plug on this based that it’s not what I agreed to in the first place?
YANBU = it’s ok to pull the plug
YABU = it’s none of your business how many people are shoehorned into a rental property

OP posts:
BlueJava · 31/01/2020 14:07

I wouldn't take her as a tenant, she told you about the cats, not about the kids. Unless you think you won't get anyone else I'd say no.

Beetle76 · 31/01/2020 13:55

Wow. Lots of responses to consider. Sorry, I’ve been busy so haven’t been able to check back in.

It’s unlikely to be a school zone thing. I believe the 3 bedroom down the road is differently zoned for a much better for school anyway. It’s more likely to be it doesn’t allow cats.

I’m amazed at the number of people who have assumed mum. It’s a dad FWIW. (2 of my lone parent friends are dads so that aspect doesn’t matter to me).

Perhaps “dishonest” is the wrong descriptive. I’m concerned why they asked about cats but didn’t think to mention 3 kids. To me this indicates a lack of full disclosure.

It feels like I’m being given info a scrap at a time so that is part of what isn’t sitting well with me. Again, why not full disclosure from the outset if there was nothing untoward going on.

I have not been able to find this person on social media, not even LinkedIn, with the scant information I have. I’m still waiting for the credit report and references to come through.

I’ve asked the agent directly for more information and thus far I’ve gathered that it is a divorce/separation but no indication of their intended living arrangements.

I’m not going to assume that because he is a dad, the kids won’t be living with him. They have put the childrens’ names on the lease as occupiers so on that basis, I’d expect that they will all be occupying the property. (See previous comment about my single dad friends.)

From a wear & tear perspective, in my book 1 adult with cats, is preferable to 2 adults with 1 child, which is preferable to 1 adult with 3 kids and 2 cats. Which is what my decision would have been if I’d had all the information from the outset.

I’m fully expecting to repaint before I move back in because I’d like a change from what was there so that doesn’t bother me. Damage to fixtures is a worry, irrespective of the cause, as the deposit doesn’t really cover major work. However, I would expect that my landlord insurance would cover me if they did something extreme like pull the ceiling down as one PP has mentioned. (As I go off to read the small print again!)

If they don’t move out after the year when I need to move back in, I’ll be homeless 😳 I don’t see the homeless brigade worrying so much about me having a roof over my head 😂

OP posts:
Lazypuppy · 31/01/2020 13:54

For me it would be the dishonesty! It would worry me

If they had openly said it at the beginning not a problem, how people chose to live is up to them.

I would refuse to let it to then

stayathomegardener · 31/01/2020 13:53

No look for someone with less children, wear and tear will be dreadful.

And I say that as a pet friendly landlord.

TurquoiseDress · 31/01/2020 13:52

It does seem odd that she was not upfront about the children and that is a red flag in my opinion.

However, I don't think 3 kids in a 2 bed house is inappropriate especially if they are all young. also, it may be the only property she can afford in the area that she needs to live in.

We are in a cramped 2 bed terrace with 2 young children and it works ok, yes we would obviously LOVE to have a 3 bed or whatever but as we're saving to buy our own place it's not really a priority to get another bedroom at the moment

HmmIsThisAGoodIdea · 31/01/2020 13:42

Don't do it!!! My brother used to be a LL and rented to someone under very similar circumstances except they didn't have pets. They (not intentionally) trashed the place. The amount of wear and tear was crazy and they left so much damp - a family of that size generates a HUGE amount of washing, where can they dry it?? It was a nightmare. He'd had the house renovated before they moved in and they left about £8000 worth of damage that he had to find out of his own pocket to fix it. After one other crappy tenant he decided enough was enough and he sold the house instead.

The question you need to ask yourself is this: if things don't turn out like you hope are you happy to charitably fund this family's stay and any damage caused while you're away? If so then go ahead and let them live in your house. If you don't have thousands of pounds sitting around and can't afford that gamble then don't.

Honestface78 · 31/01/2020 13:32

At the end of day, if you have specific rental requirements, stipulate them at the point of advertising.

Taddda · 31/01/2020 13:23

@TARSCOUT I don't rent, but I used to. If I was fortunate enough to have two properties I would happily be a LL, understanding and accepting of the risks attached, taking the right legal precautions should they be necessary.

Would I be a landlord to one property and rely on this as my only income? No. Would I let out a property if I still saw it as being my own home? No. It would be the tenants private accomodation along as the contract and terms were adhered to.

But I live in an area where an average 2 bed flat would be upwards of £400,000 - so the possibility of owning multiple homes right now is out of the question. For the people who do, count yourself lucky, but know the risks. If you cant accept them, dont let, Sell! I'd have much preferred to pour all of my hard earned money into my own property much sooner than I was able to, instead of into someone else's pocket.

Dillydallyingthrough · 31/01/2020 13:21

OP I would choose someone else. My parents have a number of rental properties and they have had some nightmare tenants. But they all started with a small lie or something odd, now they are much stricter and have an easier life. Its actually really sad as my DPs have had loads of sad stories (fleeing DV, abuse, etc) over the years, and unfortunately these tenants have always been the ones that trashed the houses (bar one). My DPs have helped all the tenants with furniture and trying to get settled and they have been repaid with a fortune for repairs or court costs. On the other side I was a SP on benefits and it was difficult trying to find somewhere to live, a LL took a chance and I ended up staying there for 6 years and the LL begged me to stay! Sometimes it does work, but my DP must have rented to at least 20-odd times to someone struggling and it's always ended up shit for them except for 1 tenant that they've had for 15 years (she fled a DV situation) so I just think so many people lie and its difficult to work out whos the liar. You need to protect your investment so choose someone else.

ChardonnaysDistantCousin · 31/01/2020 13:16

Sorry, no. I didn’t. Why would I be asking if I did?

iStruggleWithThePast · 31/01/2020 13:11

Maybe she didnt lie

Maybe the children were living with her parents or their dad? But maybe now circumstances have changed You just dont know do you

When we were thinking of living in a 2 bed ( 2 adults 2 children ) we were going to give the kids the bedrooms and us get a sofa bed downstairs

Taddda · 31/01/2020 13:09

@ChardonnaysDistantCousin but I'm guessing you already knew that....Hmm

TARSCOUT · 31/01/2020 13:07

@taddda then feel free to become a LL. Just investing my profit for one of my properties for a whole year to put in a new bathroom and kitchen in a rental property which will be much nicer than the ones in my own house. This is my pension! Why should I have to sell it to a tenant. Work hard, save hard, live within your means and buy your own house if you don't want to rent!

ChardonnaysDistantCousin · 31/01/2020 13:07

Thanks

Taddda · 31/01/2020 13:06

@ChardonnaysDistantCousin
The Department of Social Security (DSS) is a defunct governmental agency in theUnited Kingdom. The old abbreviation is still often used informally. Advertisements for rented accommodation often describe prospective tenants who would be paying their rent by means of Housing Benefit as "DSS" tenants

LoonyLunaLoo · 31/01/2020 12:56

Cats not cars

LoonyLunaLoo · 31/01/2020 12:56

It’s the cars that would put me off. My brother and SIL rented a house from us and we relaxed the no pets rule as it’s family, and they left the house riddled with fleas 😡😡😡 and that’s my own family!

NailsNeedDoing · 31/01/2020 12:47

I can't see how being single makes them any more unwilling to leave than a couple??

Because she will be less likely to be able to afford somewhere big enough for her children and more likely to need of council housing. The council won’t help her until she has been evicted by bailiffs. Her tenancy coming to an end won’t be enough to get their help.

ChardonnaysDistantCousin · 31/01/2020 12:45

Why is this tenant any more likely not to leave at the end of her tenancy than anyone else?

Not all LLs accept cats, so she might find it difficult to find another place, and might not want to leave because of that.

adaline · 31/01/2020 12:45

I see a few here judging this would-be tenant and the possibility of them over staying their welcome.

I wouldn't rent to someone who had lied to me. I don't think many would, surely?

ChardonnaysDistantCousin · 31/01/2020 12:44

Rental adverts generally always start with 'No pets, No Dss, Professionals only' even 'No Children' is popping up more often

What’s Dss?

Taddda · 31/01/2020 12:42

I wonder what it would be like if there wasn't such a housing crisis- landlords actually having to sell their properties to potential tenants instead of putting mass demands on their personal circumstances, charging extortionate fees, insurances, etc...
Rental adverts generally always start with 'No pets, No Dss, Professionals only' even 'No Children' is popping up more often-

The thing is people loose their jobs, Parents separate, people have children- all of which could happen after the tenancy has been agreed, life happens-

Find out about the honesty or whether it was just not relevant on the initial application (could have 50/50 care with the children, possible it wasnt intentionally deceptive...?)

Up to you who you let to, I just wish it was more of a renters market...

jimmyjammy001 · 31/01/2020 12:31

They Should have of been honest like the rest of the applicants who said they had kids, not try and pull a fast one, very dishonest, what happens in a years time when you want the house back and they have no where to move to? Will be costly to get them out with court fees plus if there are kids there the judge may well let them stay

Runnerduck34 · 31/01/2020 12:31

3 DC in a 2 bed house might be a squeeze depending on bedroom size and age of DC. But I have some sympathy with potential tennant, single parent who would probably much rather rent a 3 bed if they could afford it, and then there's the cats . I love cats and as a mum I'd probably rent it to her but then I'm a soft touch!
Ultimately she will be living in the potentially crowded conditions not you. I suppose the more people/pets the more wear and tear there might be but then that would be covered with a deposit ?

ShirleyPhallus · 31/01/2020 12:29

I wouldn’t touch it. Having been in a “charitable” position myself who then when we came to sell the house refused to move out. Because they couldn’t get another rental easily and wanted a council house.

OP isn’t a charity.