Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Renting a 2 bed house to a family with 3 kids

462 replies

Beetle76 · 31/01/2020 02:51

I’ve got my hard hat on! I am renting out my two bed house while I have been seconded to a job in a different area for a year.
While it’s a small house, it’s in a good area so I received a number of offers for the full asking rent after the first viewing day. I decided to go with the person who stated they had two cats (I know what it’s like to rent with pets so I thought I’d help them out.)
The provisional paperwork listed a single tenant with their cats and I agreed to proceed on that basis. The full lease has arrived for me to sign and now it’s the tenant, plus cats, plus 3 kids.
My view is it’s a two bed house, one living room, small eat in kitchen and is thus not really suitable for a large family.
I didn’t base my decision on no kids, I just wanted to help out another cat person, and they happened to be the only applicant without kids.
I was expecting to have a kid or two in the house, it’s a great area for kids, but I think 3 is too many for the space. I don’t see where they would go - 3 kids beds would not fit in either bedroom, they are just not big enough. Maybe a sleeper couch in the living room? I suppose a kid could live under the stairs Harry Potter style 😂
But I fiercely dislike dishonesty and I feel they have been dishonest by not saying who would be living in the house from the outset. AIBU if I decide to pull the plug on this based that it’s not what I agreed to in the first place?
YANBU = it’s ok to pull the plug
YABU = it’s none of your business how many people are shoehorned into a rental property

OP posts:
Circe32 · 31/01/2020 07:42

As others have mentioned, it would depend on the ages of the children, but you need to consider wear and tear on your home, so I would get more information before making your decision.
But YANBU if you were to decide to end the agreement.

Antihop · 31/01/2020 07:39

I would pull out purely because of the dishonesty.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 31/01/2020 07:38

If you feel the house isn't big enough, do not let it to them. Too many people in a small space is not healthy, will mean all your appliances (inc your boiler) will likely be running to higher capacity than they were designed for and causes a higher degree of wear and tear. You have no obligation to house people who are deliberately placing themselves in a situation of overcrowding.

You have mentioned that it is a good area. Does the rent reflect that, eg could she spend the same in a less desirable area to get a bigger property that would be more suitable? If so she cannot afford to live in your area.

Lovemusic33 · 31/01/2020 07:38

They could have a triple bunk? Or one of them may still be a baby and sleeping in parents room?

Either way it is up to you at the end of the day. They should have told you they have 3 kids.

GU24Mum · 31/01/2020 07:37

Somewhere between the agent and the applicant, you haven't been given the full picture. If you only wanted to have X number of people in the house then it's not at all unreasonable to say that as this is now something very different then it's not for you.

It's completely fair that you are able to make a decision on how many people you think the house is suitable for in terms of wear and tear. You've already said that it's a small house (assume only one bathroom etc) so it's quite likely that there is going to be more wear and tear than if you only have a single person or person and 1 child in there.

Marylou2 · 31/01/2020 07:35

Hi OP, wouldn't touch this one at all. Presume it's private rental rather than HB but still the chances of you having to either evict them or end up with significant costs to rectify damage are statistically higher than with a single or couple renting. Also the fact that you weren't given the information about the children upfront is a huge red flag. Good luck.

AnnaMariaDreams · 31/01/2020 07:35

I will probably get flamed but as landlords we have had a very bad experience with a single mum with 2 kids and rent being paid on time. It was every month for over a year and in the end after a lot of chances we gave her notice.
I wouldn’t want 3 children in a small house either. It would put me off if you have had other offers.
We do allow cats (but not dogs) though!

MarthasGinYard · 31/01/2020 07:33

No chance

Deathraystare · 31/01/2020 07:32

They lied full stop. If they had been up front that would of course been different. Normally people don't tell you they have cats but do come clean about the kids!

Go with your gut feeling. My friend let a DHSS woman and child rent but the woman of course said nothing about her drug taking mad as fuck boyfriend. He kicked in the glass oven door and they pulled down the ceiling so they would get a council house. Lovely.

Oh and left dirty nappies in the garden.....

Not quite the same thing but if she lied about something there may be background.

YADNBU

AugieMarch · 31/01/2020 07:29

Has she actually lied/been dishonest? Did the original form ask about children or just over 18s and pets? I rented for a looong time and it varied from one agency/landlord to the next. If the form didn't ask about children then she hasn't actually been dishonest. Perhaps clarify with the agent?

Lionsleepstonight · 31/01/2020 07:29

I can see why you're uncomfortable as a single tenant with 2 cats is a different proposition to 2 cats and 3 kids. Id worry the house would be trashed!
Can you find out more, like why she mentioned the cats and not the kids (weird).
And remember, a good deed rarely goes unpunished!

BettyAll1 · 31/01/2020 07:29

Is the agent handling all this for you? If so then I’d be pretty pissed off with them that you’ve been mislead. If you’ve been managing the viewings and application then it’d be a red flag that this person has been dishonest from the outset. Either way YANBU. Possibly you should have stipulated maximum numbers when you advertised but it’s your house and you need to feel comfortable with whoever is renting it. I’ve rented to a small family with one child who trashed the house and drew all over the walls. I’ve also rented to a larger family who left the house immaculate. It would be the dishonesty element rather than the family size that would worry me.

FlamingoQueen · 31/01/2020 07:29

Could you ask the agent to ask why she didn’t mention the children? You could say you have concerns the house won’t be big enough and that your property may get damaged over the year due to lack of space for them to move around in.
I lived in a 2 bed house with 2 young dc and 2 guinea pigs and there wasn’t really room to swing a cat (luckily then we only had guinea pigs!). By the time my dd was 18 mths we’d moved to a 3 bed house.

TheTruthAboutLove · 31/01/2020 07:29

YABU there is no dishonesty here. It all comes down to what the form asks for, and if she was being dishonest she wouldn’t have declared the children at all on the lease prior to moving in. It’s all speculation and MN thinking the worst of people, that everyone is out to scam everyone else.

It most likely is a divorce situation going from a bigger home to a smaller one, I don’t see the problem myself as long as her checks come back clear and she can pay? All this talk of her not moving out and bailiffs and the like is the usual MN catastrophising, it’s very unlikely to happen if she has good references and credit check. Any tenant could default and whatever, I don’t get why according to MN it’s more likely to happen because it’s a single Mum with children and cats?!

nakedavengeragain · 31/01/2020 07:27

@poetryinaction probably for the same reason the tenant hasn't chosen it. Could be anything. Houses are worth whatever someone will pay and it's seems someone's willing to pay.
The one down the road might be next to a cursed burial ground or opposite the local sewage works. The OPs house might have a view of the Taj Mahal, its own private beach or comes with a cellar full of wine.

Longwhiskers14 · 31/01/2020 07:22

I meant uncomfortable!

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 31/01/2020 07:22

YANBU. The dishonesty alone would put me off and I would have no trouble declining to sign the lease.

I’d wonder why the omission and if there was anything else I didn’t know. I’d also worry about rent payments with so many dependants but appreciate I’m not a LL so may be over thinking it.

Plus that’s a lot of potential wear and tear with a small house and so many occupants.

Poetryinaction · 31/01/2020 07:21

Why are you charging the same as a large 3 bed down the road?

Frouby · 31/01/2020 07:19

Just contact the potential tenant and ask her. It's probably a divorce situation, she's waiting for funds, can't get the cats in anywhere else etc. Or it might be a catchment thing. She may be renting your property just to secure a school place.

NotQuiteUsual · 31/01/2020 07:19

I don't think 4 people in a 2 bed is an issue. We have 5 in a 2 bed and genuinely it's not a squeeze. We do have two reception rooms though, and I'm starting to get fed up of the toddler waking me up farting(we'll be moving in the next few months finally)

SmileCheese · 31/01/2020 07:18

I don't understand all the people defending her and saying she didn't lie. The fact that others discolsed they had children suggests that she deliberately left off the information when filling out the form. If there was no space to disclose the information then surely the OP wouldn't know if any of the other tenants had children.

I would be inclined to find other tenants. Whilst I'm sure they could fit in and be content there for the year I wouldn't like that they were initially dishonest and I would be constantly wondering what else they were not telling you or what they might lie about next.

Poetryinaction · 31/01/2020 07:18

I'd rather help out kids than cats. But the dishonesty would put me off.

Oceanbliss · 31/01/2020 07:17

All these accusations of dishonesty! How was she dishonest when she has included them on the lease? She hasn't lied about having children because she has clearly stated that in the lease. Logically, there had to be some kind of miscommunication. Not dishonesty. Someone who has lied about not having children is not going to include them in the lease agreement. It's bloody well defamatory to be accusing someone of dishonesty without absolute proof. I can't abide by slandering someone, discrediting them, assassination of their character just so you can operate on negative assumptions and not have to make the effort to clarify with the person. No, so much easier to accuse them of some sort of poor character trait like being dishonest.

wesdxc12 · 31/01/2020 07:16

I had this. Man who viewed the house said it was for him and his wife. He turned up with 3 kids. I couldn't turn them away, although I did think they'd struggle as it was a 1 bed and a box room. In the end it wasn't the kids that were the problem, it was that he was inherently dishonest about everything. They also left the place in a disgusting mess. Think baby sick down the side of the arm chairs and front of the TV.

Dishonesty is a huge red flag .

Longwhiskers14 · 31/01/2020 07:16

Ultimately this is your home and you need to be happy with who is living there while you're away. Don't let anyone guilt you into signing a contract that makes you comfortable. Frankly I'd be blasting the lettings agent who clearly knew more than they let on.