Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Renting a 2 bed house to a family with 3 kids

462 replies

Beetle76 · 31/01/2020 02:51

I’ve got my hard hat on! I am renting out my two bed house while I have been seconded to a job in a different area for a year.
While it’s a small house, it’s in a good area so I received a number of offers for the full asking rent after the first viewing day. I decided to go with the person who stated they had two cats (I know what it’s like to rent with pets so I thought I’d help them out.)
The provisional paperwork listed a single tenant with their cats and I agreed to proceed on that basis. The full lease has arrived for me to sign and now it’s the tenant, plus cats, plus 3 kids.
My view is it’s a two bed house, one living room, small eat in kitchen and is thus not really suitable for a large family.
I didn’t base my decision on no kids, I just wanted to help out another cat person, and they happened to be the only applicant without kids.
I was expecting to have a kid or two in the house, it’s a great area for kids, but I think 3 is too many for the space. I don’t see where they would go - 3 kids beds would not fit in either bedroom, they are just not big enough. Maybe a sleeper couch in the living room? I suppose a kid could live under the stairs Harry Potter style 😂
But I fiercely dislike dishonesty and I feel they have been dishonest by not saying who would be living in the house from the outset. AIBU if I decide to pull the plug on this based that it’s not what I agreed to in the first place?
YANBU = it’s ok to pull the plug
YABU = it’s none of your business how many people are shoehorned into a rental property

OP posts:
myself2020 · 31/01/2020 08:47

The dishonesty is the problem : they apply with 1 adult 2 cats, then its 2 adult 2 cats 3 kids, once they move innit might be 3 adults, 2 cats, 3 kids and a dog. this exact scenario happened to a house across the road from us (2 bedrooms and a boxroom, in the end 6 adults, 3 kids plus cats and dogs lived there). place was trashed

whateverhappenstheremore · 31/01/2020 08:46

Get another tenant

Lifecanonlygetbetter · 31/01/2020 08:46

As a landlord I wouldn’t, largely because she has been dishonest but also because of the potential wear and tear if it’s a small space.

Panicmode1 · 31/01/2020 08:42

What are her references like?

I used to manage property for a very wealthy man - he got references for the cat for one of the tenancies. They had had a terrible experience with a cat who wrecked a flat, so despite usually allowing animals, he always checked with previous landlords, and had stringent terms for any damage in the lease.

Have you met her? Again, we would always insist on meeting tenants first. Perhaps if you meet her and find out why she wasn't 100% honest, you can make a judgement.

I wouldn't be happy with 3 children in a small house, but as others have said, it does rather depend on their ages.....

Taddda · 31/01/2020 08:40

Do you think she intentionally left her children off the application initially? I take it you haven't finalised or handed the keys yet but she has now stated she has her 3 DC's beforehand? I'd find this out first before labelling her as dishonest.

Perhaps she's leaving a relationship with her children and a 2 bed is all she can afford right now, which is why the year tenancy? Do you also know the ages, as bunk beds and co-sleeping with an infant is hardly overcrowding in a two bed, tight squeeze maybe, but manageable, especially for a year.

I'd ask to meet with her before making a decision.

margoletta · 31/01/2020 08:40

My tenancy agreement had a clause about overcrowding- we had to state names and ages of children to verify the property wouldn't be overcrowded (and thus poor environment for children) by us living there. It is a housing association not private LL though.

leckford · 31/01/2020 08:36

Did you go through an agency? They would have done more investigation
Do you have a mortgage on the property? If they don’t pay can you afford to keep up the mortgage?
Do you have sufficient money to pay for a lawyer if it all goes wrong?

Spied · 31/01/2020 08:36

I agree it's the dishonesty.
Who would mention cats but not children?
If they'd been honest then I wouldn't have a problem as really if the property is too small for them it's their issue not yours. (So long as it's still maintained and cared for).
I wouldn't go ahead now though.

dognamedspot · 31/01/2020 08:32

The last dishonest tenant that I gave the benefit of the doubt to left me losing about £3.5k and it turned out that they were more dishonest than I discovered. So I'm biased.
But - without making any "shitty" assumptions - she applied as a sole tenant then added 3 bodies at the last minute. You agreed to a sole tenant. I don't care what the lie was, it's a big one and it would make me mistrust her.

NoIDontWatchLoveIsland · 31/01/2020 08:29

Afriggingoat
you realise you could be leaving her homeless

OP bears zero responsibility to house this adult! While her circumstances could be difficult, that doesn't make it OP's job, as a private landlord, to take on an unacceptable level of risk.

Idontkowmyname · 31/01/2020 08:24

Dishonesty is the problem

TARSCOUT · 31/01/2020 08:24

I am a LL too. Getting property back end Feb and although use agent I view with shortlist of candidates. My property my decision and got instinct is my ruler.

ChardonnaysDistantCousin · 31/01/2020 08:22

Two cats and three children is a lot of wear and tear in a small space. It’s easier in a big house, but the more cramped the worse it is.

Also, I would worry about getting the flat back when you return. Some posters are speculating that this might be a divorce case, and I know I’m speculating as well, even further, but the fact that she’s leaving the house with the children suggests an arrangement that’s not amicable.

TARSCOUT · 31/01/2020 08:20

I would not rent due to the dishonesty and I would tell her that also. What else is she hiding?

MintyMabel · 31/01/2020 08:20

Some really shitty assumptions being made about this proposed tenant.

EntropyRising · 31/01/2020 08:19

No way, she fell at the first hurdle. You'd be mad to go forward.

Afrigginggoat · 31/01/2020 08:19

This poor woman, found somewhere to rent for her cats and kids, kids are perhaps with dad fifty percent of time so she reckons she can manage and you want to take the roof from her head?
I think it's awful to go back on your agreement. You realise you could be leaving her homeless?

vdbfamily · 31/01/2020 08:15

maybe she is divorcing an hd trying to buy somewhere but needs to get out short term. If looking to buy she will want to save as much as she can and not rent somewhere more expensive. Maybe the kids are not there all the time. You do have a choice because the wear and year will be on your property but she ultimately gets to choose how she is prepared to live and as others have said, if youngest is toddler she may be happy with a bunk bed in one room and a cot in with her. It is only short-term after all.

TooleyVanDooley · 31/01/2020 08:14

No way, too much wear and tear and the dishonesty would be a deal breaker for me. If she’s lying now, I would worry about her actually leaving at the end of the tenancy.

BorneoBabe · 31/01/2020 08:13

Another LL here. They've lied to you already. It would be a 'No' from me.

Hadtoask · 31/01/2020 08:12

It’s the dishonesty that would be a red flag to me.
It reminds me of the time that I was interviewing for a post and I gave the job to a particular candidate because she said she had come from the USA on her own and was finding places to rent. It all sounded really difficult so I gave her the job. She was really weird. Lots of weirdness followed. And it transpired she had come to the uk to live with her doctor partner. Lots of lies followed.

Absolutely nothing to do with your story OP except that lies about big things are a red flag. I would pull out of the arrangement if I were you.

Iusedtobeapartygirl · 31/01/2020 08:08

I'm a former landlord.

If you feel unsure about this tenant and feel misled then refuse the tenancy. Always go with your gut feeling.

I agree that if she has lied or misled about 3 children then it is likely that she will not be honest about other things in the future.

You don't want to end up in a nightmare situation of a tenant stopping paying rent and refusing to leave.

It's your house, you make the best decision for you.

Urkiddingright · 31/01/2020 08:07

The dishonesty is an issue but she must have been desperate, maybe you were the only one who allowed her to rent with her pets? Many landlords won’t allow it at all.

If the children are all under ten and the bedrooms are fairly roomy they could either all share one bedroom or one could share with the Mother. All three of mine shared until the eldest was 6, they enjoyed sharing.

GFJoe · 31/01/2020 08:05

I wouldn't. Partly because of the wear and tear, which would be significant, but mainly the dishonesty.

GiveHerHellFromUs · 31/01/2020 08:02

Would you have accepted her if she'd been honest up front? If not then don't accept her now.

DP rented out our house before we moved in (he owned before we met) to a 'single woman with one child and a small dog'.

She moved her husband in plus another two kids and two big flea ridden dogs.

She stopped paying rent and wouldn't leave. It took about 6 months to evict her, and it's even harder to evict tenants now than it was then.

The house was a complete shithole when she finally went.

He'd accepted her as a tenant because she'd spun a story about getting away from her husband (the one she moved in and never mentioned of the tenancy).