Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why living together has become the benchmark for others to recognise you’re in a serious relationship?

214 replies

AllHeart1 · 23/01/2020 10:26

I’ve read on here on numerous occasions that “if you’re not living together then he’s not your partner, he’s your boyfriend.” “If you don’t live together then it’s not a serious relationship,” and most recently “we didn’t invite anyone who wasn’t living together to our wedding.” And no this is not a TAAT, it’s a lot more common on here than that example.

Thing is, it wasn’t that long ago that people didn’t live together until they were married. yet they were engaged, planning a wedding, finding a house, wedding gifts were generally things they’d need in their new home.

And yet some people would think now that because they’re not living together, the relationship can’t possibly be serious? When actually couples move in together after five minutes of starting a relationship and their relationship is seemingly more real than that of the couple planning to move in together after the wedding.

There are all sorts of reasons why couples can’t live together such as geographical location/not wanting to blend families while children are small/both being used to their own space now., But that surely doesn’t mean that that relationship can’t be a serious one and that that person is just a boyfriend?

OP posts:
LiveFatsDieYoGnu · 23/01/2020 14:39

Why would you care what other people think?

Mainly it just got really, really tedious constantly being asked to explain/justify our situation. Especially to those who were implying not so subtly that, as a wife, I should instantly compromise my career to solve the situation.

AFistfulofDolores1 · 23/01/2020 14:28

I don't live with my partner, and I probably won't. We are in a serious, committed relationship.

The thing is, I'm also in a serious committed relationship with myself, and I operate better when I have my own space.

It is probably different for me because I am financially independent; we don't have children together; and we've both done the cohabiting thing in previous relationships - and it is not an indicator of depth or success, imo.

HugeAckmansWife · 23/01/2020 14:27

Hmm. I sort of get what you mean. My 3 year relationship is somewhat at arms length due to both of us having been burnt by exs leaving for other people, children who don't need the extra issues of blending families and wanting to maintain our independence (or non dependence) on someone else. We are serious about each other and in about a decade we plan to live together but it may well be by then that we prefer the set up as it is. I'm not sure what's so bad about not sharing all the crappy bits of togetherness. Usually, it doesn't matter what other people think but it can affect things like wedding invites etc which can create problems.

URPS · 23/01/2020 14:25

I'm almost 50 and my partner is in his 50's. We are in a committed relationship.

We both never want to live with someone else again and certainly never want to get married again.

There are no blended families to consider and moving in with each other for financial reasons isn't necessary.

I'd possibly agree with the sentiment for the younger generation but I don't think it matters so much to the older generation.

MistyCloud · 23/01/2020 13:41

@AllHeart1

Agree. It's very odd. DH's cousin was with her partner for 20 years (from when she was 45 and he was 55,) and they never lived together.(They met in the mid 1990s...)

She lived in Wrexham and he lived in Chester..... So like 12-13 miles apart. And for the duration of their relationship, they lived apart. He was widowed, and she had never been married before. They both had no children, and both had their home already paid for a few years before they met, and both homes were small and cheap to run.

So they each kept their own home. Some weeks they spent 2-3 days a week at each others home, other weeks they just met once or twice for dinner or for lunch. They also went on day trips and weeks abroad together, and to the cinema and theatre, and they went on rambling trips and picnics, and to the zoo, the pub, the safari park and all sorts, like any other couple... , but still had their own space/own home.

Sounds fecking perfect actually! When my DH hogs the TV remote all day, and puts random shit on the TV, from the 1970s that he (and I) have seen 100 times, hogs the bathroom for an hour at a time, and leaves shit lying around, forgets where it is, and keeps blaming for moving it, I think the 'live apart' brigade have got it made!!!

I never thought DH's cousin and her partner were not a real couple, and the rest of my family didn't either, although we did all think it was quirky and unusual to live apart in a long-term relationship. (Not in a bad way though.)

I would never think badly of any couple who lived apart long-term, OR that they were not serious. And to not invite one person in a couple to a wedding and suchlike, 'because they are 'not living together' is bizarre. And rude.

Many people DO take peoples relationships more seriously though, if they are married/living together, and the law definitely do. You have much less rights than a couple who are married/living together. (Married couples will virtually all be living together ...)

My DH's cousin's partner died when she was 65 and he was 75, and he left everything to her in his will. (Including his house.) As he never had children, and had no living relatives, it was not contested, but if he had had an ex wife, or kids, DH's cousin may have had a battle on her hands.

stellabelle · 23/01/2020 13:40

So if your child moves in with someone after a week you think it’s serious then?

But you'd have to concede that most people don't do that after a week. They date for a while, get serious, decide to live together and then make plans to do so.

My DD was seeing her DH for a couple of years before they moved in together. Until they did that, I considered him as her boyfriend. When they moved in together he became her partner and was automatically her +1 for any invitations.

My DS is a full time single father. He has had a girlfriend for a couple of years - no plans to move in as they both have kids and have to stay where they are due to school locations. They don't call each other " partners" and I wouldn't automatically put her on an invitation.

You might not like it, but I think that it's pretty normal to see couples who live apart as being uncommitted.

FourTeaFallOut · 23/01/2020 13:39

One of the worst aspects was the judgement from other people

Why would you care what other people think?

Urkiddingright · 23/01/2020 13:38

I know this is rare but I do know a married couple who don’t live together. They’re very happy and in love but for practical reasons don’t live together, it works for them.

I didn’t live with DH for a few years and during that time we went through some real hardships together. We spent half of the week together so I wouldn’t say we weren’t serious at all. All that has changed since we moved in together and got married is me nagging at him more Grin.

LiveFatsDieYoGnu · 23/01/2020 13:32

DH and I didn't fully live together for a while even after we got married - mind blowing for some. It was sometimes tough but there were good logistical reasons at the time and our relationship is no less strong because of it. One of the worst aspects was the judgement from other people Hmm

HepzibahGreen · 23/01/2020 13:27

Yep. I agree with everything you say BraveGoldie. Its silly to think that just because you are not under the same roof 365 days a year you dont really know each other! And ditto to "all the modes" Grin DP knows me better that ex husband ever did and we share our lives.
Also this:
It was the norm for us to wait until marriage to live together, as it is in much of our circles. Mumsnet always thinks, ‘well I do this, my friends also do this so that must mean the rest of the world lives like this too’ but there are many reasons and values why a couple may not live together, yet still be in a committed and serious relationship.
I don't particularly want to live together, but I actually won't before marriage. And maybe not even then, unless there's a very big shed!

BraveGoldie · 23/01/2020 13:21

@KurriKurri I think you are right - it is a feminist issue. Self determination should not have to be sacrificed in order to be committed and that tends to be a sacrifice women make more than men.

sunshinesupermum · 23/01/2020 13:20

My DP and I spend lots of time together but don't share a home. His is in France and mine in the UK. We've been together for 12 years in a committed relationship.

HillAreas · 23/01/2020 13:19

Not living together means you aren’t sharing the daily stresses and strains of life together.

I don’t agree that this necessarily means the relationship isn’t serious - as PPs have said there can be many different reasons for it which don’t include “casual bf/gf”.
But I can see why many people look at the obvious and assume it’s not that serious. I’d like to think that people would know their own friends and family well enough as individuals to know what the score was, but apparently that’s not always the case and understandably causes some upset.

KurriKurri · 23/01/2020 13:16

I can think of loads of reasons why people would choose not to live together yet still be committed to each other. In fact there might be far fewer relationship problems if people didn't live together - some people are good people but very hard to live with.
personally if i ever had another relationship I wouldn't live with the person - been there, done that. I like my own space, I like owning my own house and I would never put myself in a position where if we split up assets such as shared housing had to be split and I had to move.
That doesn't mean I can't love and care for someone just as much as someone who chooses to live with their partner.
Several of my friends in my age bracket (55+)have chosen to have their own separate living accomodation after divorce etc and starting a new relationship.
Being married and living together is generally more healthy for men - married men live longer - for women it is more stressful.

BraveGoldie · 23/01/2020 13:11

But you effectively live together in each property part time.

He has seen me get stressed on Sunday evenings. He knows it helps me to get my dd's bags packed and uniform washed and ironed and he does that for me. He sees me through the Monday morning rush. He sees and accompanies me through 'veg in front of tv' mode, period and not feeling sexy mode, parents visiting mode, too busy working from home to spend time with him mode.... all the modes.
He takes the bins out and repairs stuff in my house. He knows when my car's MOT is due and gets it done. What exactly are we not experiencing from a committed relationship?

The only difference is that maybe 1-2 days a week we base ourselves in separate spaces for practical or emotional reasons. We
All know some personal space and self determination is good in a relationship... so having two spaces to enable that is great... that doesn't make us less committed. Just makes us less imprisoned and with more space available! 🙂

Sparklyring · 23/01/2020 13:01

How can you know someone well enough to marry them if you haven't lived together? I think people who haven't lived with their partner have no idea how different it is living with someone to spending a lot of time with them. Very naive.

malificent7 · 23/01/2020 13:00

Also i dont think its weird not to live together...i love space.

malificent7 · 23/01/2020 12:59

Im engaged and we don't live together. Imagine the cognative acrobatics you lot will need to get your heads round that!

EntropyRising · 23/01/2020 12:56

I just think it's weird when people who consider one another 'partners' don't live together, barring an engagement/not living together before marriage (which I think is very sweet and I secretly hope my children do this).

I don't get it. I would be miserable living away from my husband. I understand different strokes and all that, but it's just weird.

PurpleFlower1983 · 23/01/2020 12:54

I think, in most cases, you don’t really know someone until you live together.

Letsallscreamatthesistene · 23/01/2020 12:53

*actually, a lot got married quickly because the woman was pregnant, and it was seen as wrong for her not to be. The term “had to get married” was very real back then.

And then they generally lived in an unhappy marriage for the next 50 years or so, by which time people celebrated how happy they must be together given they’d been together all that time.*

So, with that in mind, its a good thing that people move in together. Its 'testing' each other out before making the bigger commitment of marriage.

Moving together is means having to sort finances out together (generally). Theres just a lot more added strain to relationship. So yeah, it is a bit more serious.

BraveGoldie · 23/01/2020 12:52

"Constant togetherness is central to a committed relationship"

  • really? Why? There are tons of couples who technically live together and are absolutely not constantly together.... and why would being constantly together be a good or healthy thing anyway?

I think we are a little narrow minded at seeing living together as the inevitable goal and progression in a relationship. It's a bit like assuming that the point of marriage is to have children, and if you don't then you haven't gotten there yet' or you can't for some reason.

Different set ups are right for different people - long term.

My partner and I don't live together and are very very committed. We live life as partners, not a dating couple, living in one another's homes, day to day, depending on convenience. My daughter, a couple of days ago, referred to my DP as her "daddy number 2". We probably spend about 70% of our non working hours together.

If we moved in together, we would either have inadequate space for the blended family, or would have to go through the huge disruption and financial cost of selling both and moving. Perhaps we will at some point, but I can't think of many advantages, other than the social recognition of a seriousness we already know we have.

Userwhatevernumber · 23/01/2020 12:49

Mumsnet very often only sees a situation, or values, through the western secular lense.

I did not move in with my DH until after we married. Prior to marriage we were engaged, and often referred to each other as ‘partners’ although technically we were fiancé/fiancee but we were very much committed and serious. We would have been surprised if anyone had judged our relationship as otherwise. We would often spend the entire day together, shop together, cook together, do al sorts of things together and often stay overnights, but we lived separately.

It was the norm for us to wait until marriage to live together, as it is in much of our circles. Mumsnet always thinks, ‘well I do this, my friends also do this so that must mean the rest of the world lives like this too’ but there are many reasons and values why a couple may not live together, yet still be in a committed and serious relationship.

AnneLovesGilbert · 23/01/2020 12:35

Imagine if people started saying that if you’re not married then it’s clearly not a serious relationship even if you have children, and given the fact that not being married is fairly commonplace these days.

People do say this. All the time.

Couples with children who are married are more likely to stay together than those who aren’t. And you can feel your unmarried relationship is as serious as being in a marriage but a lot of people realise it’s not the same at all when the relationship ends. Especially the women. Especially if they’re not financially independent. Having a child commits you to that child. It doesn’t necessarily commit you to the other parent or there wouldn’t be so many single parent families where the other adult fucked off during/after the split and doesn’t even see their child or pay anything towards then.

MrEzraGoldberg · 23/01/2020 12:33

Living together doesn't signify anything in some cases. Many people in abusive relationships are living together, married. They're desperately looking for ways out. It can be healthy to live apart and it doesn't signify anything negative about the relationship.

And you can most certainly be partners even if you're not living together. It's how you choose to define yourself and your relationship. It's just society that says living together is the way to be a 'proper' couple.

Swipe left for the next trending thread