Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why living together has become the benchmark for others to recognise you’re in a serious relationship?

214 replies

AllHeart1 · 23/01/2020 10:26

I’ve read on here on numerous occasions that “if you’re not living together then he’s not your partner, he’s your boyfriend.” “If you don’t live together then it’s not a serious relationship,” and most recently “we didn’t invite anyone who wasn’t living together to our wedding.” And no this is not a TAAT, it’s a lot more common on here than that example.

Thing is, it wasn’t that long ago that people didn’t live together until they were married. yet they were engaged, planning a wedding, finding a house, wedding gifts were generally things they’d need in their new home.

And yet some people would think now that because they’re not living together, the relationship can’t possibly be serious? When actually couples move in together after five minutes of starting a relationship and their relationship is seemingly more real than that of the couple planning to move in together after the wedding.

There are all sorts of reasons why couples can’t live together such as geographical location/not wanting to blend families while children are small/both being used to their own space now., But that surely doesn’t mean that that relationship can’t be a serious one and that that person is just a boyfriend?

OP posts:
goodwinter · 23/01/2020 17:13

I should say, my grandparents have been MARRIED 50-odd years.

PatellarTendonitis · 23/01/2020 17:12

I agree. There are far, far too many needy, clingy, immature people with no imagination out there who simply cannot be without being velcro'd to another person. It's tragic.

I've got many friends who are in very committed relationships and don't live together. For most, it's due to being divorced/widowed and needing to protect assets and/or not wanting to blend families but also they have a desire for their own space.

SO many are so desperate to validate themselves by another person they consider everyone they're with a 'partner'.

It's pitiful and immature.

goodwinter · 23/01/2020 17:11

On the flip side... My grandparents have been together 50-odd years. Around 10 years ago, my gran moved out of the family home and up to Scotland to be close to her one remaining parent who required care, while my grandad stayed behind to sell the house.

Turns out they both enjoyed their own space, so when the family home sold, my grandad bought a little house directly across the street from gran's new house. They see each other every day, they have 5 kids together, they support each other through everything, but after all these years frankly they irritate each other too much to be up in each others' space all the time.

Are they committed?

PurpleFlower1983 · 23/01/2020 17:04

@Userwhatevernumber Yes I agree it depends on individuals but that it my experience and the experience of all my friends.

han2020 · 23/01/2020 17:02

It is a sign of how committed you are to a relationship but it’s not the only sign! I took a punt and moved in with my wife after a year out of financial necessity rather than moving back home after uni (probably too soon with hindsight and nothing to do with commitment) Thankfully it worked out and ten years later we are happily married.

Only you know how serious your relationship is, that’s not for others to decide. You do you - never mind what others think.

OlaEliza · 23/01/2020 17:01

They aren't partners because they don't fully share their lives together.

OlaEliza · 23/01/2020 17:01

@NameChangeNugget I think that because to me, you can't be that serious about each other if you don't want to live together, to change your life around to be able to do so. Two couples of 30yrs that don't live together are still only boyfriend and girlfriend.

2020GoingForward · 23/01/2020 16:37

I met DH at 18 education and careers kept us in different places - was engaged at 24 moved in together one month before the wedding.

I was suprised to encounter this attitude a lot just before and the changes in attitude after the wedding. Interestingly it did seem to correlate with people who got offended if one or both of us couldn't go to a child free invite because of lack of childcare.

There was also a period for few years when DH lived away during week due to work commitments - we had three kids and a mortgage and many people kept insisting we were divorcing Hmm or our marriage was in trouble.

okiedokieme · 23/01/2020 16:31

If you are in love then you want to be together! Geography can hold you back but I for one am rearranging my life so I can move - we knew after just a couple of weeks, you just know

Sparklyring · 23/01/2020 16:30

If you don't live together then where's the commitment?! You're essentially just dating... Spend evening and weekends together, no joint finances, none of the every day stresses of life to share together, not falling asleep together at night, not coming home to each other. That's commitment not spending your time together.

ShinyGiratina · 23/01/2020 16:16

Quite a few of DM's friends age 60+ are in stable, long term relationships but often live seperately. They've usually come out of the other side of widdowhood or divorce following long marriages that saw children into adulthood. They like their own space and have their families to protect financially so I can see a lot of sense in the logistics of being emotional partners but not necessarily financial partners.

In younger people, particularly without children in the equation it is unusual to live indefinitely as partners without any aspiration to live together, marry or have children (a form of commitment that long outlives many a relationship).

Living together is a reasonable, obvious indicator that people are partners in sharing various aspects of life. Obviously that's not infallible as many a mn thread will testify, but without getting intrusive about the particulars of an aquaintance's relationship, it's a boundary that works pretty well for most the patterns of most people's relationships.

Dozer · 23/01/2020 16:10

Or pets Grin

Dozer · 23/01/2020 16:10

A relationship may be emotionally “serious”, but if either party can walk away without having to deal with housing, DC or money it’s essentially dating.

Dozer · 23/01/2020 16:08

“partnership” implies shared parenting, finances and/or housing.

Marellaspirit · 23/01/2020 16:03

I met my partner 14 years ago and we have been in a serious relationship for 8. It upsets me that because we don't live together people would think of us as not being in a serious relationship. We are engaged, committed to each other and certainly not interested in being with anyone else. We spend every other weekend together, have lots of holidays and speak/Skype/text most days. It works for us.

There are lots of reasons why we can't live together at the moment but we do plan to get married and live together eventually. Certainly my family and friends see us as being in a serious relationship and he is always invited to weddings/parties etc.

I have numerous friend who have moved in with multiple partners in the time we've been together and the relationship hasn't lasted. Why should they be considered as more serious than us?

NameChangeNugget · 23/01/2020 15:55

Why do you think that @OlaEliza?

I know of two married couples who’ve been together 30+ years who don’t live together

Userwhatevernumber · 23/01/2020 15:55

@PurpleFlower1983
“ I think, in most cases, you don’t really know someone until you live together.”

That’s your opinion and experience. I completely felt like I knew my fiancé/ husband before we lived together. Like I said before, in many cultures and religions it is very normal to live apart until marriage and they would not agree that they did not really ‘know’ each other (unless it’s an arranged marriage of course, which mine was not).

corythatwas · 23/01/2020 15:50

When people didn't live together before marriage, they generally got married a lot faster. They didn't just "date" for 6 years and then get married

Long engagements were very common in the olden days among classes that might not be able to afford their own household straightaway.

Which is also the reason dh and I were only able to live together 10 years after we first became a couple, 6 years after we formally got engaged. In the meantime, I did a PhD and paid off my student loan, he saved up for the house deposit.

Userwhatevernumber · 23/01/2020 15:48

Or OlaEliza it could be - don’t live together - fiancé as it was with me.

OlaEliza · 23/01/2020 15:39

Don't live together = boyfriend
Live together = partner/fiance/husband

Dylaninthemovies1 · 23/01/2020 15:13

An example being @HugeAckmansWife above who is being very sensible in not just flinging her children into a blended family

Dylaninthemovies1 · 23/01/2020 15:11

I don’t think living together is the sign of a committed relationship. It’s between the couple. No one else has a right to stick their beak in.

I lived together with a boyfriend as a teenager. It was a fucking disaster. I don’t think we were any more committed than a couple who have decided not to live together for any of many reasons

CharitySchmarity · 23/01/2020 15:05

I agree about part of it and don't agree about part of it.

I think of the terminology as being partner=living together, boyfriend=not living together.

However, I don't think a partner outranks a boyfriend, and I would invite both to a wedding (well, not if one person had a partner and a boyfriend Wink !) After all, all relationships start somewhere and, as other people have said, there are people who are firmly committed to each other but have to live in different cities or even countries for their jobs. If it was very new relationship I would probably put "...and guest" rather than the other person's name, just in case it didn't work out, but I would respect that person's right to have their boyfriend/girlfriend with them if everybody else was allowed to bring a loved one.

NameChangeNugget · 23/01/2020 14:46

I totally agree with you OP.

Some people live in bubbles and have a very narrow outlook on life

bathsh3ba · 23/01/2020 14:42

I agree. I'm divorced, not dating at the moment but due to my faith I won't live with a man until I'm married. That won't mean I'm not in a committed relationship until that day.

A relationship is committed if it's exclusive and the couple intend to stay together long term. Whether they live together or marry or not is immaterial to that.