Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why living together has become the benchmark for others to recognise you’re in a serious relationship?

214 replies

AllHeart1 · 23/01/2020 10:26

I’ve read on here on numerous occasions that “if you’re not living together then he’s not your partner, he’s your boyfriend.” “If you don’t live together then it’s not a serious relationship,” and most recently “we didn’t invite anyone who wasn’t living together to our wedding.” And no this is not a TAAT, it’s a lot more common on here than that example.

Thing is, it wasn’t that long ago that people didn’t live together until they were married. yet they were engaged, planning a wedding, finding a house, wedding gifts were generally things they’d need in their new home.

And yet some people would think now that because they’re not living together, the relationship can’t possibly be serious? When actually couples move in together after five minutes of starting a relationship and their relationship is seemingly more real than that of the couple planning to move in together after the wedding.

There are all sorts of reasons why couples can’t live together such as geographical location/not wanting to blend families while children are small/both being used to their own space now., But that surely doesn’t mean that that relationship can’t be a serious one and that that person is just a boyfriend?

OP posts:
MintyMabel · 23/01/2020 18:41

Thing is, it wasn’t that long ago that people didn’t live together until they were married

It was that long ago. It was absolutely the norm in the 80s and 90s. I wouldn't call over 30 years "not that long ago"

thepeopleversuswork · 23/01/2020 18:40

I find this attitude incredibly depressing.

I actually think for mature people, particularly when there are children involved, having a committed relationship but living separately is a far better solution than living together.

People who have cohabited and then lived under their own steam appreciate how much joy there is living on their own without having to kowtow to someone else's needs and having to reset their expectations. Financial freedom -- and responsibility - is a glorious thing.

I think we've been conditioned to think cohabiting is the goal, partly because of the legacy of marriage and thinking its an arbitrary "milestone" they have to hit but also because its cheaper for most people. But if you strip back what society thinks, in a lot of cases people do far better living on their own. Cohabitation brings a lot of compromises and hell can be living with other people.

I am in a settled relationship with someone but no way on earth would I want to give up my space, my freedom to live with him. Why is that so hard for people to understand.

Bluntness100 · 23/01/2020 18:39

Thr partner question is a good one, if you're not managing a home together, raising your children together, but instead go back to seperate homes, and deal with the big things in life separately, bills, kids, housing, cleaning" cooking, shopping,maintenance, general day to day life, then how much of a partner are you?

Of course nothing is black and white, of course there are reasons people may choose not to live together, of course there are people living together who bloody shouldn't be, but really can you call someone your partner if you do all the big things alone?

Is it still a committed relationship, yes, is it as committed as a couple who leave their respective homes to set up one together and deal with everything together, from thr money to the kids, to the day to day, arguably not.

That doesn't invalidate a relationship though. That's extreme.. it's simply there is levels of commitment.

Forcryingoutloudwtf · 23/01/2020 18:31

You are boyfriend and girlfriend if you don't live with each other and have no plans to marry. It isn't an insult. I have had quite a few boyfriends. I even lived with one for a number of years but I never referred to him as anything other than a boyfriend. A partner to me is someone you are committed to living your life with, like a spouse but without the legal commitment.

AllHeart1 · 23/01/2020 18:29

There are complicating issues. He doesn’t drive and for medical reasons is unable to learn, added to which from a financial point of view I have equity in my house here which will buy me a house outright in my home town without having to take out a mortgage, something which is a necessity for me as I am unable to work currently. Whereas where he lives is totally unaffordable on his salary.

These situations simply aren’t black and white. Hopefully he will be able to move but equally if he can’t does that mean that the relationship is invalid?

As for the PP who asked what my own sensitivity is, actually it had nothing to do with me, but having seen a post on a thread where a OP was told that she was unreasonable for wanting her family to include her partner because they didn’t live together even though they have children together it just strikes me as such a narrow minded view.

And as I said upthread, what of couples who live in the same house on a technical level but where one is e.g. deployed in the army for six/nine months at a time? They’re married/engaged/living together/sometimes have children but surely their not being together makes them boyfriend and girlfriend? Except it doesn’t.

Given the varied amount of relationship dynamics it just isn’t realistic to take such a black and white view.

OP posts:
thelongdarkteatimeofthesoul · 23/01/2020 18:16

AllHeart1 is he your partner though, if he's not your main support? That's exactly what a partner is, isn't it? Your life partner, your 1:1 partner through life's ups and downs, the person with whom you share your life with. If your parents and siblings are more of a support than the man in your life, is he genuinely the adult who partners you through your life?

Bluntness100 · 23/01/2020 18:10

*Living together doesn't signify anything in some cases. Many people in abusive relationships are living together, married. They're desperately looking for ways out. It can be healthy to live apart and it doesn't signify anything negative about the relationship

Well of course there are people in relationships where it has went wrong. And of course not living together might be healthier for some, but it can also be a negative.

There are always exceptions, but as a pp said, as a general yard stick couples who have made the extra leap and set up home together, are generally in much more committed relationships because of whay setting up home and then living together entails.

Bluntness100 · 23/01/2020 18:03

Op what's your sensitivity here? This has clearly touched a nerve.

Yes of course it takes a lot more commitment for people to live together and all that entails, from the property to the finances, to even the relationship itself, shopping, cooking, cleaning etc and everything it entails.

Does it mean two people who move in together who have just met are in a committed relationship, well no. Because that's not a sensible thing to do really is it, they hardly know each other. Does it mean people who haven't made that step to share a home together aren't committed, no, of course not, but there is no way round the fact that for most couples the act of setting up home together is a step further in the commitment stakes. It's not just words, it's actions.

Leighhalfpennysthigh · 23/01/2020 17:53

Im engaged and we don't live together

Me too GrinGrinGrin

Leighhalfpennysthigh · 23/01/2020 17:52

I think, in most cases, you don’t really know someone until you live together

In my case it's precisely because I know him that I know we shouldn't live together!

bridgetreilly · 23/01/2020 17:49

I definitely don't think that every couple living together are in a serious committed relationship. And I think it's possible to be in a serious committed relationship where there are temporary, practical reasons not to have married or moved in together and begun to make those kinds of decisions together - finances, family, future. But mostly, I think there is a pretty good correlation between living together and being in a serious relationship.

Leighhalfpennysthigh · 23/01/2020 17:49

*Living together doesn't signify anything in some cases. Many people in abusive relationships are living together, married. They're desperately looking for ways out. It can be healthy to live apart and it doesn't signify anything negative about the relationship.

And you can most certainly be partners even if you're not living together. It's how you choose to define yourself and your relationship. It's just society that says living together is the way to be a 'proper' couple*

Yes this. My partner is my partner. He shares my life. Just not my home.

Louisianna16 · 23/01/2020 17:48

I've been with my (2nd) husband for over 20 years, married for 13, and we've only lived together for the last 5 of those years.

Logistics dictated the situation, but we were + are 100% committed from day one.

Lived with first husband in the usual way before + after wedding but living together actually contributed to a swift exit from that short marriage, on my part.

Horses for courses. What works for one might be anathema for others. Sharing the same space proves nothing, and sometimes is even a trap.

AllHeart1 · 23/01/2020 17:46

And what about marriages/relationships where one partner works away for long periods. Are they not committed either, given they technically don’t live together for the majority of the time?

It’s a lazy assumption.

OP posts:
karencantobe · 23/01/2020 17:46

Allheart Obviously you need to do what is right for you. But if I had a serious life limiting illness it would be my DP who would take care of me. I would not move back near my parents for them to do this.

PatellarTendonitis · 23/01/2020 17:45

A married relationship can be all kinds of things. I know married couples who don't have sex with each other, are they 'not having a married relationship'? What an odd thing to say. The Queen has her own room. Are they not living a married relationship?

AllHeart1 · 23/01/2020 17:42

For those who ask why it would bother someone what other people thought, the answer is that if people base your inclusion in their family on whether you are living together then it’s naive to think that wouldn’t be hurtful and cause resentment towards family.

If you’ve been with someone for a number of years then it’s not unreasonable to want to be included in family events and to not be treated as the new woman/bloke on the scene.

My own situation is that I’ve been with my partner for seven years. We got engaged five years ago and the plan was for him to move to be with me. However he works in.a niche industry and has been in the same job for over twenty years so moving wasn’t that simple. I wasn’t able to move because my DC’s dad lives here so I needed to be here to facilitate their relationship.

We decided that if something didn’t come up then I would move once my youngest left school. However four years ago I was diagnosed with a serious, life limiting condition which worsened around six months ago and my future prognosis is as yet unknown. My primary support currently comes from my family as they are retired but who live in a different place to DP. As such it now makes more sense for me to move back to my home town rather than to be with DP. He has said he will look for work there and has in fact started his own business here on weekends but which doesn’t earn enough yet for him to move here full-time. But there are no guarantees in life so we neither of us know how the chips will fall.

For anyone to suggest that he is purely a casual boyfriend is frankly insulting.

And of course people will say that there are exceptions to every situation, but the truth is that given few people know what those exceptions are, it is not possible to make snap judgements.

OP posts:
GeneticTest · 23/01/2020 17:41

@OlaEliza so if people don’t ‘fully share their lives together’ then they’re not properly committed?
My DH lives somewhere else for more than half the week and he has friends I have never met. Does that mean we’re not properly committed?
What an odd thing to say.

OlaEliza · 23/01/2020 17:41

But they don't have a married relationship if they don't live together.

They live as bf&gf.

NameChangeNugget · 23/01/2020 17:40

Great point @storm11111

NameChangeNugget · 23/01/2020 17:39

But they’re married @OlaEliza

They’re more than boyfriend and girlfriend in the eyes of the law

karencantobe · 23/01/2020 17:25

But surely if someone is actually committed long term and not living together, then others know about this.

storm11111 · 23/01/2020 17:16

I agree with you.

I think living together is a tangible, easy indicator of how serious a relationship may or may not be (notice i said tangible, not accurate)

It is an easy way for people to make a snap judgement without getting the full story.

I would consider it lazy to place the 'living together' couples in the 'serious relationship' category and the 'not living together in the 'non-serious relationship' category without knowing the full story.

but such is human nature, we often make assumptions around us based on the information available to us rather than based on all the facts, we often have to.

PatellarTendonitis · 23/01/2020 17:14

Being middle-aged too, I know none too few who also cannot move their jobs easily due to pension considerations and being unable to find a similar-paying job in another location so cannot shack up with someone, or they have custody arrangements which preclude them from shifted locations easily, if at all; can't get another mortgage due to financial issues, all sorts.

thelongdarkteatimeofthesoul · 23/01/2020 17:13

For me it's just that partner means life partner.

I completely understand never moving in with a boyfriend/ girlfriend as adults with separate lives and separate children. I think it's often the vastly more responsible, sensible, adult decision not to blend families and to keep your love life broadly separate from your family life.

It's just semantics, up to a point, that your partner is literally a partner in your domestic life, and if your domestic lives and finances and residential arrangements are separate from yours, for excellent reasons, you're an independent adult which is arguably the best way to be, and your live interest isn't a partner in a life sense, and it's a bit weird for anyone else to be refering to their status as your sexual partner...

There needs to be another word I think - people refer to someone they've been seeing six weeks as their partner sometimes and regardless of whether you're 19 or 59 they're the man/ woman you're dating/ seeing, or your boy/ girlfriend, or just your (ambigious) friend in that context!

I agree that some people live with a sexual partner who's barely more than a housemate too in some cases - living under the same roof and sharing a bed but not feeling responsibility towards the other person and keeping all finances separate, not doing mutually beneficial tasks for one another, holidaying separately and generally living separate lives outside the bedroom means living together without being partners in any meaningful sense beyond sexual.

Swipe left for the next trending thread