Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why living together has become the benchmark for others to recognise you’re in a serious relationship?

214 replies

AllHeart1 · 23/01/2020 10:26

I’ve read on here on numerous occasions that “if you’re not living together then he’s not your partner, he’s your boyfriend.” “If you don’t live together then it’s not a serious relationship,” and most recently “we didn’t invite anyone who wasn’t living together to our wedding.” And no this is not a TAAT, it’s a lot more common on here than that example.

Thing is, it wasn’t that long ago that people didn’t live together until they were married. yet they were engaged, planning a wedding, finding a house, wedding gifts were generally things they’d need in their new home.

And yet some people would think now that because they’re not living together, the relationship can’t possibly be serious? When actually couples move in together after five minutes of starting a relationship and their relationship is seemingly more real than that of the couple planning to move in together after the wedding.

There are all sorts of reasons why couples can’t live together such as geographical location/not wanting to blend families while children are small/both being used to their own space now., But that surely doesn’t mean that that relationship can’t be a serious one and that that person is just a boyfriend?

OP posts:
00deed1988 · 24/01/2020 06:34

My husband was a full time single dad when we got together.

For that reason we didnt want to uproot my DSS too soon ect. But we were engaged and planning wedding ect.

We married on the Saturday and got the keys to our new place on the Monday and moved in officially the following Sunday.

I have lived with 2 previous partners. Much less serious than my husband prior to moving in together/married. But no kids involved in those relationships.

For me it doesn't mean it's not serious....however this comes from someone who was brought up by my mum who wouldn't allow my 'stepdad' move in even though they had 3 kids.....so maybe my view is a bit biased! 1

BrokenWing · 24/01/2020 06:31

Oh dear, so my 26 year marriage isn't a proper committed relationship because we were engaged (and living in different countries) for 6 years before that.

Obviously is now, back then no, I wouldn't have considered it serious.

thepeopleversuswork · 24/01/2020 06:30

dodgeballchamp

That attitude of the partner having to live with you before being invited as a +1 is so prurient and judgemental isn’t it?

Sometimes I think the world has moved quite a long way in the past few years. And then I realise a lot of people are still replaying the 1950s.

Scarsthelot · 24/01/2020 06:29

If you arent sharing your day in day out life, finances, household its not really a partnership. But that doesnt mean it's not committed. Its the whole people dont like the word boyfriend, that's the issue.

FWIW, the only time I see 'he is you boyfriend not a partner' on mn when people have been together a couple of months (sometimes living together or not) and when the man is clearly not working in a partnership with the OP.

Or when op is committed and he lives elsewhere and isnt that fussed. Its clear he isnt committed. if both people arent serious, it's not a serious relationship

thelongdarkteatimeofthesoul · 24/01/2020 06:22

Why does a commited relationship have to be marked or crowned or validated by the use of the word "partner" though?

If you aren't actually partners in any sense (not going through life sharing responsibility on all sorts of levels for one another equally, being one another's go to support person, yes sharing some finances and being an alliance on practical as well as emotional fronts) then why is the word "partner" the one you want to use?

A relationship can be committed without being a partnership.

Most humans are commited to other humans through blood ties (their own children and parents for some people siblings and even wider family) and to lifelong friendships. There are all sorts of commited relationship.

To me a partnership means lives are entwined and the two people are one another's main support. Other romantic relationships can be committed relationships, but why explicitly define them as all things partnerships are not (no mutual reliance) but be so insistent on the word partner?

It's just an odd choice of word in that context and words do carry meaning.

In the end obviously everyone can call use whatever words they want about themselves and their relationship, but expecting other people to automatically know that you use the word "partner" for something which from the outside doesn't look like a partnership is a leap.

dodgeballchamp · 24/01/2020 00:59

thepeopleversuswork agree with everything you’ve said 🙌

dodgeballchamp · 24/01/2020 00:57

So reading some of these posts, ‘commitment’ is all about how difficult it is to break up - shared house/finances/children etc. I’ve never been married or had kids. I don’t want kids. I have made an active choice not to enmesh my home or finances with any potential future partners - I want to self sufficient and financially secure on my own terms and I like my own space. So according to some this means I can never have a committed relationship because I don’t want to have kids, join finances or live together? My arse. There is no one right way to do commitment. Some people wouldn’t be happy with the set up I want and that’s fine - but I know what I want and want to meet like minded people. I fail to see how that would lack commitment if all parties are happy.

I’ve never encountered this ‘you don’t live together therefore you can’t be serious so we won’t include you a +1 on invites’ attitude outside of mumsnet. It’s very bizarre and prescriptive.

emilybrontescorsett · 23/01/2020 22:36

It's no one elses business really.

I think a lot of people have children far too quickly. It's unnecessary in this day and age and completely avoidable.
Then they jump from one relationship to the next, dragging the poor children with them.

People don't have to get married now as was the norm not that long ago. Of course some people do not want to live together for various reasons.

Qwerty543 · 23/01/2020 22:36

YANBU. DP and I are serious but we don't live together yet because I'm giving DCs more time. If I didn't have them to consider we would be living together about now but it has to wait. I also refer to him as partner, not boyfriend. Totally against the MN Rules. I'm also miffed that he isn't invited to a family wedding, which according to MN Rules I'm not allowed to be, but I still am!

Redwinestillfine · 23/01/2020 22:32

See I would say marriage was. Living together doesn't necessarily mean commitment (although obviously it can), but I wouldn't think 'oh they're living together they're serious' automatically whereas If they were married I would assume they were serious.

MintyMabel · 23/01/2020 22:25

30 years ago really does not seem long ago to me

It's more than a generation.

SerenDippitty · 23/01/2020 22:24

If a couple bought a house together I would assume they were serious. If not, not so sure. A lot of people move in together for practical reasons, e.g to be able to afford to rent a better place, or because they want privacy/don’t want to live with parents any more. It doesn’t necessarily mean they are thinking of a long term future together.

karencantobe · 23/01/2020 22:19

What do you mean by an emotional commitment?

thepeopleversuswork · 23/01/2020 22:02

I get that there's a step change between boyfriend/girlfriend and life partner. I just don't understand why this has to include cohabitation.

Yes you do have to be able to rely on someone absolutely, to share life with them and for them to be the person you trust above all else. Quite often that means living together. But the idea that the reluctance to pool finances and have a shared bedroom denotes a lack of commitment seems to me to be based on an outdated notion of what commitment really is. That's financial commitment, not emotional commitment.

Sure there are lots of logical reasons why its easier to support someone in a practical sense if you live together and share bills. But its not a necessity. I think if you're really honest with yourselves, you people saying you can't be a partner without living together are basically just subconsciously trying to replicate the marriage template. You've all seen your mums and dads do it, you realise the world has moved on a bit but you can't square the idea that commitment doesn't involve a shared mortgage and bickering about who is going to take out the bins.

It depends a lot on what you think commitment is about. If you think of it as basically leaning on someone to help you out with finances and household tasks that's one kind of commitment. But its not the only kind. Personally I find the idea of commitment with so many strings attached less attractive precisely because its so hard to walk away. If you know you're going to have a bastard of a job untangling all your bills it makes it harder to leave. If you can end the relationship with a text message you know you're genuinely choosing that commitment rather than just doing it out of habit. So you know the person you're with is with you because they genuinely want to be rather than because they're middle aged and a bit past it and can't face having to do their own laundry again.

grandmasterstitch · 23/01/2020 21:44

DH and i didn't live together before we got married. We're Christians and personally do the whole no sex before marriage thing. Having said that we were engaged after 4 months and married 9 months after that so it's not that we were in a long term relationship before we got married. Each to their own I guess but I don't like the assumption of "if you don't live together then you aren't that serious" there's a whole host of reasons why people choose not to live together

RuthW · 23/01/2020 21:36

I'm 52 and my partner of 6 years is 59. We don't live together, we both own our own homes and have no plans to move in together. We live 5 mins apart and are in a committed relationship. He's my partner, not my boyfriend.

toomanyleggings · 23/01/2020 21:20

I don't even recognise living together as a benchmark for a serious relationship tbh but everyone has to row their own boat I guess and think what they like

To wonder why living together has become the benchmark for others to recognise you’re in a serious relationship?
karencantobe · 23/01/2020 21:06

Of course it is possible to love someone and be committed to them and to not want to have sex.

corythatwas · 23/01/2020 21:03

Why might it not be possible to love someone, to be in love with someone, totally different relationship from sharing a house with a friend, yet for whatever reason (asexual, history of abuse) not to want to have sex? What is it to other people? Why should they get to decide?

karencantobe · 23/01/2020 20:58

Leigh why threaten me with violence? I am a stranger on the internet. What does it matter to you what I think?

Leighhalfpennysthigh · 23/01/2020 20:54

@karencantobe I'm going to be deleted for this, but I don't care. You've no idea so DFOD

Leighhalfpennysthigh · 23/01/2020 20:52

Close friendships are definitely important, but there's a difference between a close friendship and a relationship. I love my friends, but it is my partner who I choose to expose myself to, who I love and, guess what fancy and he fancies me. Sex isn't important. Living together isn't important. Love and commitment to sharing each other's lives - that's important.

Maybe it's something that we only appreciate as we get older, second/third relationships. I don't know. I do know that 25 years ago when I met my first husband I thought that commitment was living together, marriage, babies and anything else was weird. I have to admit that if I hadn't lost said husband I probably would have continued in that thinking.

karencantobe · 23/01/2020 20:50

So you are incredibly close committed friends. That is great.

Leighhalfpennysthigh · 23/01/2020 20:45

But I do think a couple have to have had a sex life

Why? I know a couple that have been together for years, married, live together so tick all the MN boxes for a proper relationship- but they have not had sex with each other. They aren't asexual. They just have no desire to do it.

My partner was sexually abused. Sex is something he will always find difficult, so we haven't yet. We may, we may not. It's not the core of our relationship which is based on utter love and respect for each other.

corythatwas · 23/01/2020 20:17

*Not living together defines your relationship as not committed or serious enough to overcome those obstacles.

Engaged for 5 years, then loudly screams a lack of any serious intent, you get engaged to be married and soon after set a date (usually within a year or so), not engaged to be engaged.*

Oh dear, so my 26 year marriage isn't a proper committed relationship because we were engaged (and living in different countries) for 6 years before that. And there I was thinking the longterm planning- making sure I got the training that would enable me to live in his country, him making sure he saved the money that would enable us to get a house together- was a sign of commitment. Oh well, never mind, might as well stay uncommittedly married now, seeing as it's got to be a bit of a habit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread