Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why living together has become the benchmark for others to recognise you’re in a serious relationship?

214 replies

AllHeart1 · 23/01/2020 10:26

I’ve read on here on numerous occasions that “if you’re not living together then he’s not your partner, he’s your boyfriend.” “If you don’t live together then it’s not a serious relationship,” and most recently “we didn’t invite anyone who wasn’t living together to our wedding.” And no this is not a TAAT, it’s a lot more common on here than that example.

Thing is, it wasn’t that long ago that people didn’t live together until they were married. yet they were engaged, planning a wedding, finding a house, wedding gifts were generally things they’d need in their new home.

And yet some people would think now that because they’re not living together, the relationship can’t possibly be serious? When actually couples move in together after five minutes of starting a relationship and their relationship is seemingly more real than that of the couple planning to move in together after the wedding.

There are all sorts of reasons why couples can’t live together such as geographical location/not wanting to blend families while children are small/both being used to their own space now., But that surely doesn’t mean that that relationship can’t be a serious one and that that person is just a boyfriend?

OP posts:
BrokenWing · 24/01/2020 13:15

But if you're the kind of person who moves in with one boyfriend after a month and then with the next when that doesn't work out- that makes you more serious?

Nope that obviously doesn't make you serious either. It is a combination of many factors another one of which is time.

corythatwas · 24/01/2020 12:19

They may be equally emotionally committed, but that’s subjective.

But the results- being there for each other, staying together, supporting each other through the hardest of times- are surely just as objective as any other results of any other type of relationship?

I enjoy marriage and being enmeshed and all that lark. After a decade of fighting hard for it, I find it a joy and a privilege.

But I am no more or no less committed than my db who keeps a separate household to enable his partner to retain an amicable relationship with her ex for the benefit of her sons. To me, all that commuting, all that juggling, and having to maintain two houses (both of which need a fair bit of work), seems far more of a commitment than simply having dh pottering around here, which I have to say is hardly an effort at all.

Shinyletsbebadguys · 24/01/2020 12:11

I find some people iddly need some level of validation from a hierarchy.

If they are married they insist noooe else is as valid as they are or committed, they need to see themselves as higher on the totem pole if they are living with someone.

Ultimately it's a somewhat sad reason to need validation. I don't think it can be defined. I've known people living together who of I was in that relationship aren't overly committed because they dont make joint decisions over big things, dont have any level of inclusion in bigger aspects of each others lives. I've also sen non residential partners who are to the extreme and cant do anything without each other.

I've been married (technically still am but only because divorce is expensive), living with someone and single and partnered in separate houses. My marriage was less of a partnership than my live in relationship now. We se the future as together and discuss big issues and resolve them. Emotionally it's more committed.

I usually laugh if someone tells my DP is my boyfriend (I'm 40 and hes 36, we share a house , a life , raising DC....if it really bothers people to define the relationship I generally laugh and let them crack on if it makes them happy).

Honestly why does any of it matter (excluding the legal protection of marriage...although I've always been the higher wage earner and main child care giver in my relationships so not really been an issue for me) , why on earth do people constantly seek outside validation, its genuinely just odd.

Dozer · 24/01/2020 12:02

Joint housing, legally binding contract (marriage or civil partnership, or other eg cohabitation agreement) money, business and / or co-parenting are literally commitment(s).

Couple who are not partners in those ways literally have fewer joint commitments.

They may be equally emotionally committed, but that’s subjective.

thepeopleversuswork · 24/01/2020 11:52

PrimalLass

Because living together is far harder than just seeing each other a few times a week

Yes, but why is difficulty the defining characteristic of commitment?

A lot of posters seem to be equating commitment with the degree of red tape that couples have that connects them to one another as if the harder it is to extricate yourself from one another, the more you love one another.

What I (and other posters) are saying is that this shouldn't be a measurement of how committed you are. Its basically the sunk costs fallacy: the more enmeshed I am with my other half and the harder it is to leave, the more I love them.

In fact I choose to frame it the other way: the less there is that enmeshes me with my partner, the more free I am to walk away. And therefore I know I have chosen to be with them rather than feeling I'm so tied up with them that I'd lose everything if I bailed.

I understand there are a lot of upsides to living together but I don't see that being massively bogged down in someone else's life is a great thing and I think we'd be able to approach relationships in a much healthier way if we didn't have this attitude.

Ponoka7 · 24/01/2020 11:16

If a lot of married people had somewhere to move to, they wouldn't stay in their relationship.

Living together can equal stuck and not much else.

If you live separately, but consider yourself in a commited relationship, then you're fully choosing to be with that person. You make time for each other, you aren't just shagging because you share a bed etc.

I know so many people who live together quickly, then have a shit time, before they move on to the next. I don't consider people who live together as any more committed than long term, but living separately, couples.

I will never live with someone again. I don't want to complicate my children's inheritance. I don't want to have to possibly put someone else's wants (TV/food etc) in front of my grandchildren. In my experience it's women and children who compromise and get the rough deal. Many of us are opting to live alone so that doesn't happen.

sunshinesupermum · 24/01/2020 11:04

CardsforKittens I agree with you - and I also think it will become more common as we get older (and hopefully more financially independent)

CardsforKittens · 24/01/2020 09:44

I’m another person who doesn’t live with my partner. He lives nearby and we spend most of our time together when we’re not at work, either at mine or at his. We’re in a committed relationship. My children live with me half the time and with my ex half the time; I’m committed to them too. I don’t really think of relationship commitment in terms of how difficult it would be to walk away - that seems bizarre to me. And I don’t think terms like boyfriend and girlfriend are suitable in my situation because we’re in our fifties.

If someone invited me to a wedding but didn’t invite my partner on the basis of our domestic arrangements I would simply decline the invitation because of course that’s insulting (and lazy, and unimaginative) when we’ve been a couple for many years. I can’t imagine it happening in my family or his though.

I know several married couples who live in different cities. It seems to be increasingly common among couples where women have serious careers and jobs are harder to find.

SerenDippitty · 24/01/2020 09:40

DH and I never lived together before marriage. We were engaged for a year before getting married. I do think that we became committed on marriage and not before, as we could have called off the engagement at any point. Glad we didn’t though. 🙂

corythatwas · 24/01/2020 09:25

What I am trying to say is- people are all different! What would be unworkable for A might actually be doable for B.

And the whole relationship by correspondence thing only seems weird because of the century we're in. A few hundred years ago, deferring marriage until you could support yourself and maybe living in different places for a few years would have seemed perfectly normal for many people.

corythatwas · 24/01/2020 09:23

We weren't able to see each other a few times a week: after an initial year in the same city, we had summers and Christmas together and for the rest of the time we wrote letters (no internet or skype in those days, and phoning abroad was too expensive).

After maintaining a close relationship under those conditions, I have to say my 26 year long marriage has been an absolute piece of cake.
Everything got so easy once we were in the same house and didn't have to worry about externals like the price of postage or whether you got the tone right in your last letter. I also found that because we had been so committed over the letter writing, we actually knew each other very well: there were no surprises.

PrimalLass · 24/01/2020 09:06

Because living together is far harder than just seeing each other a few times a week.

corythatwas · 24/01/2020 09:03

We were so old-fashioned we even collected household equipment for our future home in a special chest years before we actually got to unpack it and use it in that same home. And MIL, who also seems to have believed in our commitment, had her own little cupboard where she put things aside she had bought for us. Still using it 26 years later, haven't broken much. Still get a warm glow when I remember my pride in being able to afford a set of little tin trays and the pleasure in thinking one day we would get there and I would be using those in my own home.

corythatwas · 24/01/2020 08:56

Oh dear, so my 26 year marriage isn't a proper committed relationship because we were engaged (and living in different countries) for 6 years before that.

Obviously is now, back then no, I wouldn't have considered it serious.

So the fact that during those 6 years (and indeed the 3 years preceding) we planned everything we did around our future marriage: got the qualifications we would need to live our whole lives together without any regrets (one of us in a foreign country far from family and friends), sorted out residency, saved money, paid off student debt, got officially engaged with an announcement in my local rag, got to know our respective relatives, learned a new language (dh), planned our lives together to make sure everything would work as well as possible for both of us to stay together for the rest of our life- that was not serious?

But if you're the kind of person who moves in with one boyfriend after a month and then with the next when that doesn't work out- that makes you more serious?

karencantobe · 24/01/2020 08:20

Serious is not the same as making a commitment. Moving in together, especially if you are older and there is more to sort out, is making a commitment. In the same way getting marries is.

HugeAckmansWife · 24/01/2020 08:17

I think the only time it matters is when things like weddings come up and your 'other half' doesn't get an invite because of this kind of idea that it can't be serious if you're not doing living together and therefore you don't come as a package. Other than that, it really isn't important.

okiedokieme · 24/01/2020 08:08

Just me then ... I'm desperate to move in, geography and being a responsible parent and money is keeping me over a hundred miles away. We are obviously just soppy romanticsBlush

dottiedodah · 24/01/2020 08:05

For younger couples I think that living together means a whole lot more TBH ,For people who are divorced with DC from a previous relationship , I can understand its probably more complicated .There is a big difference between dating, and seeing each other for a few hours/W/E and being together under one roof ,sharing bills everyday life and so on .

thelongdarkteatimeofthesoul · 24/01/2020 08:03

Who on earth moves in with someone solely in order to be seen as part of a couple by their extended family? Only people who are insecure to the point of self sabotage surely!

Do people like that also have children despite not wanting them in order to win the approval of extended family?

clairefrasier · 24/01/2020 07:51

Suggesting that people are only serious if they live together means that people feel under pressure to live together if they want to be accepted as a couple by family and friends. How is that ok?

This yes! My DM has been with partner for 15 years. They do not live together. But not deemed by her/my family as a serious relationship but it’s worked longer than done marriages in our family!

thepeopleversuswork · 24/01/2020 07:34

boredboredboredboredbored

We are both 100% happy with our arrangement no rowing over mundane day to say stuff, we get the best of each other. Does it make our relationship less real? Doesn't feel it to me, I love the bones of him and couldn't care less what others think of that.

Exactly this. I think not having to mither one another about paying the gas bill is a massive liberation -- it frees you up to actually enjoy your relationship as opposed to becoming endemically dependent on one another and terrified to leave.

boredboredboredboredbored · 24/01/2020 07:31

Interesting. I'm getting married a week tomorrow and we are not living together / have no immediate plans to do so. Getting married is a pledge from us both to our relationship. We love each other very much.

I have 2 teenagers at home and we have a lovely life the 3 of us, dp has his own lovely house (3 adult dc inc a grandchild). We see each other around 3-4 nights per week but neither of us wants to be together full time at the moment. I'm 43 him 53.

Honestly? We are both 100% happy with our arrangement no rowing over mundane day to say stuff, we get the best of each other. Does it make our relationship less real? Doesn't feel it to me, I love the bones of him and couldn't care less what others think of that.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 24/01/2020 07:15

I don’t see living together as a sign it’s a serious relationship. That comes with marriage for me. Until then either party can simply walk away as it’s only dating, no commitment has been made.

thepeopleversuswork · 24/01/2020 07:12

thelongdarkteatimeofthesoul isn’t this just fashion though? People get terribly hung up on how they characterise their relationship for public consumption.

This is part of the problem in my view: people are desperate to achieve these relationship “milestones” (moving in/getting engaged etc). Mainly because they want society to judge them as having successfully attracted and held onto a mate (because for many people this is still seen as a life goal in itself). So people are desperately concerned about what “stage” others people can define them as being at in their relationship.

In fact aside from where children are involved and need some stability in how they perceive the relationship, none of this actually amounts to a hill of beans.

If we could free ourself from this attitude of worrying about whether x or y think our partner is committed to us we would be able to see the relationship much more clearly. What matters is whether the relationship fulfils your or your children’s needs. Not whether your mates think your other half needs to step up and pop the question.

thelongdarkteatimeofthesoul · 24/01/2020 06:54

Not moving in together because your first responsibility is to your children from a previous relationship is absolutely a mature and responsible decision, far more so than rushing to blend families. Nobody has said otherwise. It's just the determination to use the word partner when there is no shared mutual responsibility that puzzles people. Nobody's saying that it's better to move in together - it's often completely the opposite.

It is just as Scarsthelot says, people don't like the word boyfriend (or girlfriend). There used to be other words like companion used fifty plus years ago, or people would be content just to say friend knowing full well what they meant but that's fallen out of use and people use partner because they don't like boyfriend/ girlfriend. It does sound young. People used to say gentleman friend but of course that's utterly twee to modern ears. There needs to be a new word coined, perhaps, instead of just loosing words and stretching the ones that are left beyond meaning.