Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The school is getting a school dog

565 replies

Worriedaboutthedoggy · 10/01/2020 23:27

The school had sent out a newsletter today that they are getting a school dog. The letter has all the positives mentioned - they are getting it from a reputable breeder and good bloodlines, it is a hypoallergenic breed (labradoodle), it will be staying in a family environment when off duty (presumably with a member of staff), it will teach the children about the importance of caring for someone - but I still am feeling a bit weird about it, can't put my finger on why exactly.

I am not sure about the impact on the dog - won't it be stressed by the usual playground ruckus? What if it turns out to be wrong temperament?

I am also ashamed to admit that one aspect that concerns me is financial. The average lifetime cost of keeping a dog in the UK (according to google) is around £18K, and I can't help feeling that there are better ways to spend these money (the school is currently fundraising for quite basic things).

Please do tell me I am BU and a total killjoy, and please do tell me your positive stories.

OP posts:
WendyMoiraAngelaDarling · 11/01/2020 15:14

But insects are wild, that is not the same as choosing to bring a dog into the school

Yes so there's no control over them as there would be with a dog, multiple insects come in uninvited and are regularly learned about as part of the NC. Should I try to prevent this because my child doesn't like it, ignoring the benefits it will bring to the majority of other students?

Geschwister4 · 11/01/2020 15:06

Avoidance is a really bad way to deal with anxiety though. I’m not trying to dismiss your DDs anxiety, I’m not a great fan of dogs and my DD was also very scared of dogs a few years back, but the way to overcome phobias is to be exposed to them in a controlled safe environment. Having a dog in the school has really helped with my DDs dog phobia. She still doesn’t like them as such but she doesn’t go hysterical so we have to cross the road when we see one now.

But that is something that should be worked on away from school, where the child and the parent can exercise some control over how much exposure and when to call time when it becomes too much. You can't do that if the school dog is always there. It is also difficult enough to get my DD into school in the first place, as her anxiety is crippling. It would just seems really unfair to make her have to face yet another source of fear and anxiety just to do the thing that she is obliged to do everyday and has no choice over. Children have to be in school- dogs don't.

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2020 15:03

@lynsey91 - my son became scared of dogs because someone let their dog come running up to him aggressively barking. I was a bit afraid of dogs running up to me for a while as a child as a dog ran up to me and bit me.

Geschwister4 · 11/01/2020 14:59

My dd has autism and is terrified of insects. Even photos or models of them. She won't go into a room if one has been spotted there. She didn't go to my sisters house for two years because she'd spotted spiders webs and a daddy long legs up in a corner of the hall ceiling. Should the entire school not learn about mini beasts, not draw or model them or learn about their life cycles and should trips to the zoo or natural history museum be cancelled because of her phobia?

But insects are wild, that is not the same as choosing to bring a dog into the school.

UndertheCedartree · 11/01/2020 14:58

Is it a therapy dog - so specially trained? We have one at my hospital. He is owned by the head Occupational Therapist and comes in to work with her (not every day - I think she works from home some of the time). Once a week he does a visit to all the wards and on other days patients take him for walks or he might visit a particular patient.

gamerwidow · 11/01/2020 14:56

Avoidance is a really bad way to deal with anxiety though. I’m not trying to dismiss your DDs anxiety, I’m not a great fan of dogs and my DD was also very scared of dogs a few years back, but the way to overcome phobias is to be exposed to them in a controlled safe environment. Having a dog in the school has really helped with my DDs dog phobia. She still doesn’t like them as such but she doesn’t go hysterical so we have to cross the road when we see one now.

80skid · 11/01/2020 14:53

Wow, massive respect for the staff member putting their new pet through on expenses GrinWink

lynsey91 · 11/01/2020 14:53

Obviously some people are scared of dogs but I do find it odd that so many children are. Are they scared because one of the parents is and so think there is a reason to be scared?

When I walk my dog I quite often see someone with a child cross the road even when the pavement is wide and my dog is by (say) my right hand side and the person would be walking on my left hand side. I also fairly often get people grabbing their young child and holding them up as though I have a tiger on a lead. My dog is just over labrador size so not some massive beast. He also totally ignores anyone we see unless they actually speak to him or ask to stroke him.

If seeing a dog around the school would help some of the scared children it surely would only be good? Dogs are everywhere so being scared of them must be a nightmare. I am terrified of spiders but luckily don't come across them that often.

DH often does work for a muslim customer. He always said he didn't like dogs and was a bit scared of them. The few times he has been to our house we have put our dogs in another room so he doesn't have to see them. He also said his children were scared of them. His eldest daughter has now left home and has a dog. He and his wife have fallen in love with it and are saying they regret never having one as they feel they have missed out.

WendyMoiraAngelaDarling · 11/01/2020 14:48

My DD too. I would not matter that the school would keep the dog away, in a separate room/annex whatever, if my DD knew there was a dog on the school premises she would not be able to control her anxiety. No matter how much the school would try to reassure her, there would always be the 'what if someone accidentally left the door open and it got out?'

My dd has autism and is terrified of insects. Even photos or models of them. She won't go into a room if one has been spotted there. She didn't go to my sisters house for two years because she'd spotted spiders webs and a daddy long legs up in a corner of the hall ceiling. Should the entire school not learn about mini beasts, not draw or model them or learn about their life cycles and should trips to the zoo or natural history museum be cancelled because of her phobia?

MontStMichel · 11/01/2020 14:46

DD went to two special schools, which had a dog. The idea of walking the dog really motivated her!

Still, one had the dog on its farm, which was a 10 minute walk from the school on a 60 acre campus, so allergies and phobias would not have been a problem!

Yamihere · 11/01/2020 14:44

Not RTFT but have lots of experience and qualifications in dog behaviour/welfare. I would make sure that if the school are doing this they have a qualified behaviourist to advise on how to manage the pup. Too many people know not enough on dog body language and behaviour.
Also, I would be very sceptical of someone claiming to be a good breeder who breeds doodles. Even the guy who invented labradoodles regrets it because of the negative impact it has had on their welfare.
School dogs can have a huge positive impact on kids learning and emotional development but only if it is carefully planned out and the temperament of the pup/dog is suitable for the environment.

FullOfJellyBeans · 11/01/2020 14:43

Literally five posts before yours is an account of a dog roaming the corridors.

Fine but it's still very unlikely (I even somewhat doubt whether that's story is true) by far the majority of school dogs don't work like that.

toomanyleggings · 11/01/2020 14:40

Humph, I know a headteacher who's made their dog the 'school dog'. Real reason is their partner worked nights so was home in the day when they first got it. They split, dog was destroying the house and barking so suddenly the dog was a 'school dog'.
It sounds like a ridiculous distraction to me and I wouldn't be happy if it was at my dc school

Geschwister4 · 11/01/2020 14:32

my dd has sn, she is petrified of dogs, actually any animal really. She cannot relax if there's an animal in the room. If she thought a dog might appear at some point during the school day, she'd be so anxious and worried.

My DD too. I would not matter that the school would keep the dog away, in a separate room/annex whatever, if my DD knew there was a dog on the school premises she would not be able to control her anxiety. No matter how much the school would try to reassure her, there would always be the 'what if someone accidentally left the door open and it got out?' at the back of her mind. And that could very easily happen, so she is not being outrageously irrational. There are too many ways that a scared child could have their school time, which lets face it is compulsory, turned into a time of constant fear of the dog- and that is really not fair.

Leighhalfpennysthigh · 11/01/2020 13:58

I am not sure how me asking questions qualifies as "mouth frothing" and "pearls clutching". I am really sorry if my post had triggered a bad emotional reaction in anyone

Nah it's just a MN dog thread. They always go the same way. To read one you'd think that keeping dogs was akin to keeping a dragon and that they are all just straining at the leash to attack a toddler. It's ridiculous levels of froth and anger that just isn't seen in real life.

Blueuggboots · 11/01/2020 13:54

My friend who used to be a head teacher had a school dog. He's the most adorable thing, taught from small not to lick people or jump up. He's enormous but the most gentle, loving lump of love. She had a lot of very troubled kids in her school and found it really beneficial.
They've both now retired. He knows he's not allowed to lick still but does occasionally slip!!

goldenorbspider · 11/01/2020 13:48

School with a dog would be a huge selling point for me

namechange1041 · 11/01/2020 13:43

I suppose I am 50/50.
My sons school has a dog and it is lovely, no problem at all.
But I can't help but feel sorry for the kids or staff who may be allergic to it. I don't know how they're meant to cope, must they take antihistamines everyday? If so it just seems unfair when it could be avoided.

myself2020 · 11/01/2020 13:40

@Doyoumind depends on the school building - ours consists of several small 1-2 floor buildings that are connected by outside walkways. the dog room is currently in the main building, but a bit that is not used for classes (but office space and storage). if necessary, it can be moved to a side building that is only used for art in the moment (and the art classes would move in the current storagr/dog rooms). in a compact 1 building multi storey school, its more difficult

Doyoumind · 11/01/2020 13:34

My personal view, based on my own experience, is that a severe asthma attack is unlikely if the asthma is controlled with medication and steps are taken to ensure sufferers don't come into contact with the dog or in spaces where it's been. However, they are likely to experience some kind of symptoms within the building even if the dog is kept at a distance.

WendyMoiraAngelaDarling · 11/01/2020 13:34

I agree myself2020.

myself2020 · 11/01/2020 13:32

@WendyMoiraAngelaDarling i would be surprised if there would be any - a school dog is not like a family dog that is allowed to roam free everywhere. many encounters are outside, the inside ones are in rooms that are not used by children who are allergic. and always supervised. its quite easy really!

WendyMoiraAngelaDarling · 11/01/2020 13:29

I am asthmatic by the way and painfully allergic to guinea pigs, horses and various other types of animal hair, dander etc.

WendyMoiraAngelaDarling · 11/01/2020 13:27

I'd love to see some stats on medical emergencies in schools and how many of those were/are allergic reactions due to the school dog.

No one on here seems to have had or know of such an incident so far but maybe someone will the longer the thread goes on.

Mendingfences · 11/01/2020 13:27

Adding my voice to the chorus of "there's no such thing as a non allergy inducing dog" lets face it hypoallergenic just means less likely to cause an allergic reaction. Im baffled by how many schools ban nuts because of allergies but bring dogs in....