Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The school is getting a school dog

565 replies

Worriedaboutthedoggy · 10/01/2020 23:27

The school had sent out a newsletter today that they are getting a school dog. The letter has all the positives mentioned - they are getting it from a reputable breeder and good bloodlines, it is a hypoallergenic breed (labradoodle), it will be staying in a family environment when off duty (presumably with a member of staff), it will teach the children about the importance of caring for someone - but I still am feeling a bit weird about it, can't put my finger on why exactly.

I am not sure about the impact on the dog - won't it be stressed by the usual playground ruckus? What if it turns out to be wrong temperament?

I am also ashamed to admit that one aspect that concerns me is financial. The average lifetime cost of keeping a dog in the UK (according to google) is around £18K, and I can't help feeling that there are better ways to spend these money (the school is currently fundraising for quite basic things).

Please do tell me I am BU and a total killjoy, and please do tell me your positive stories.

OP posts:
frostedviolets · 12/01/2020 15:42

I certainly would never scream and shriek because I realise that's going to further alarm a dog which is the last thing I'd want
Unfortunately I have seen this reaction more than a few times.
I know the poor people obviously feel petrified and I genuinely do feel sorry for them but please, God, try and stop!

But I don't understand why when an EDO can see that you are visibly unhappy being pestered by their dog, the default response is often not "Rover, come away" but "Oh he's just being friendly"
I don't understand either.
Unless they think by saying he's friendly your magically not going be scared anymore?
I don't know.
I dislike owners like this as much as you do, they give everyone a bad name.

For me there is an additional issue of my having a balance disorder, lots of dogs jump up in the act of "being friendly" but my balance is such that even a small dog with force could knock me down and then having knocked me down literally be on top of me, so I have a reason to be nervous, and yet my reticence is seen as hostility and being unfriendly, rather than protecting myself. And in the moment in a park, I'm not going to be approaching random EDO's to let them know I have a balance disorder, nor am I going to be wearing a neon sign everywhere
No decent considerate owner with a well trained dog would be allowing it to jump up at people in the first place.

Accidents can happen occasionally though, with young dogs still proofing their training or just occasionally for no apparent reason, they are animals after all but you'd hope the owner would be absolutely mortified and beyond apologetic.

People are expected to be considerate of dogs
Absolutely.
They have considerably faster reflexes than you do, sharp teeth and many of them are sufficiently large to severely injure or even kill you should they decide to.
So yes people absolutely should be considerate of dogs.

Owners don't think that they need to reciprocate that consideration to all of the public not just people who like dogs
Some entitled owners.
Not all.
Many of us are very considerate.
Many of us have dogs that we don't allow to approach strangers at all, let alone jump at them and many of us, if we see a person who looks distressed, we will put the dog on a leash, walk the other way etc.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 12/01/2020 15:36

everyone if frightened people/non dog lovers tried not to behave in that way and opted to 'freeze', stay still, ignore eye contact etc instead because the alternative is potentially dangerous.

Actually, this is EXACTLY what I do, freeze and give a wide berth.

The first 12 words of this comment, I feel contain again of

"Well if these people KNEW HOW TO BEHAVE"

Most of us do, after years of dealing with it.

It is your dog, you are it's owner, the onus is on YOU to make sure it doesn't bother other people, not on other people to make sure they aren't bothered.

The chronic failure of the EDO to recognise/acknowledge this and act accordingly is the crux of the matter.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 12/01/2020 15:25

I certainly would never scream and shriek because I realise that's going to further alarm a dog which is the last thing I'd want.

But I don't understand why when an EDO can see that you are visibly unhappy being pestered by their dog, the default response is often not "Rover, come away" but "Oh he's just being friendly"

For me there is an additional issue of my having a balance disorder, lots of dogs jump up in the act of "being friendly" but my balance is such that even a small dog with force could knock me down and then having knocked me down literally be on top of me, so I have a reason to be nervous, and yet my reticence is seen as hostility and being unfriendly, rather than protecting myself. And in the moment in a park, I'm not going to be approaching random EDO's to let them know I have a balance disorder, nor am I going to be wearing a neon sign everywhere.

People are expected to be considerate of dogs

Owners don't think that they need to reciprocate that consideration to all of the public not just people who like dogs.

frostedviolets · 12/01/2020 14:58

Entitled Dog Owners on the other hand take great personal exception to the idea that someone may not be comfortable in the vicinity of their "lovely" dog and "how dare they"
They obviously need to be more exposed to dogs so that they can learn that they are wrong and they can change and be accepting and accommodating and less selfish

There are definately many of these awful people around.

But some us, myself included, absolutely respect that not everyone likes our dogs and we keep our dogs under control and we don't allow our dogs to run at/jump at/bark at etc people because we accept it's rude and scary.

But it is a bit upsetting when certain said frightened people shriek and scream at the top of their lungs and run (when our dog is nowhere near you!) causing our dogs to get agitated/excited and try and chase, jump on you etc where they ordinarily never would have tried to behave in that way.

I accept people get frightened and I do what I can to keep my dog well away from you, I leash, I change direction etc but it really would be much better and much safer for everyone if frightened people/non dog lovers tried not to behave in that way and opted to 'freeze', stay still, ignore eye contact etc instead because the alternative is potentially dangerous.

I am well aware I probably sound like one of these 'entitled' dog owners and I honestly really am not.
I am wary of strange dogs myself, my DM and aunt and uncle are all dog phobic, I do have a lot of sympathy and I absolutely do not allow my dog to approach others but the exaggerated reactions some people show really grates on me because it's potentially dangerous and can make it extremely difficult to regain control of the dog, especially if it's fairly young.

fascinated · 12/01/2020 13:57

EineReise - exactly right.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 12/01/2020 13:36

Sorry that should say :

The fact that they, the Entitled Dog Owner are being selfish by belligerently refusing to accept that they don't have the right to force people to accept intrusive behaviour escapes them completely

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 12/01/2020 13:34

The implications of that sort of statement are that those who do not like dogs have some sort of "problem" that they need help with, so that they can learn to be "comfortable around dogs" - well bollocks to that!

Exactly fucking this. People who aren't dog lovers are capable of accepting dog lovers exist.

Entitled Dog Owners on the other hand take great personal exception to the idea that someone may not be comfortable in the vicinity of their "lovely" dog and "how dare they"

They obviously need to be more exposed to dogs so that they can learn that they are wrong and they can change and be accepting and accommodating and less selfish.

The fact that they, the Entitled Dog Owner are being selfish and belligerently refusing to accept that they don't have the right to force people to accept intrusive behaviour.

Dogs off leads running mad destroy nice walks on the beach or in country parks for other people to the point where you simply can't go.

Entitled Dog Owners don't give a shit because "doggo is happy"

frostedviolets · 12/01/2020 13:23

this, just this. The implications of that sort of statement are that those who do not like dogs have some sort of "problem" that they need help with, so that they can learn to be "comfortable around dogs" - well bollocks to that!

I mostly agree with what you are saying, however, a large proportion of dog owners don't have the control over their dog that they should have.

I am in no way defending this, just stating a fact.

That, coupled with the fact that the typical reaction of the fearful person is often - shrieking, running, flailing, waving etc tends to come across one of two ways to dogs.

Extreme excitement which the dog misinterprets and tries to play and chase which is even more terrifying for the scared person.

Or weird, frightening behaviour that unsettles the dog and they then react aggressively which is obviously even worse for the scared person.

It is useful in order to keep everyone safe for dog phobic people to get help for their fears, and tbh, I think all people with phobia benefit from help to 'get comfortable' with the scary thing anyway as phobia can be pretty debilitating and learn how to deal with dogs safely.

You can't always avoid them but at least if you know how to behave around them and how to make yourself boring you can usually stop dogs that do approach from trying to interact with you.

Mischance · 12/01/2020 12:22

PetPeter - this, just this. The implications of that sort of statement are that those who do not like dogs have some sort of "problem" that they need help with, so that they can learn to be "comfortable around dogs" - well bollocks to that!

sueelleker · 12/01/2020 11:12

If they're getting it from a breeder, presumably it's a puppy; and won't have had any training. Who's going to take the time to train it properly as a therapy dog?

bluebluezoo · 12/01/2020 10:55

n summary, my conclusion from this discussion is that the average british school is absolutely awful as parents can’t trust them even at the most simple things (like making sure allergies aren’t triggered

Well if the reason to get a labradoodle is because of allergies their knowledge of allergies and triggers is shit, and they haven’t done their research into the best breed for a school with allergic children.

So unless they could justify why a labradoodle is better for allergies than one of the genuine non shedding, low allergenic breeds than yes, the school is going to drop hugely in my estimation.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 12/01/2020 09:10

DS1’s senior school has a therapy dog available during exam periods in the support area.
I think it is a great idea.

beautifulstranger101 · 12/01/2020 08:56

n summary, my conclusion from this discussion is that the average british school is absolutely awful as parents can’t trust them even at the most simple things (like making sure allergies aren’t triggered, kids are not terrified ). Why are people sending their kids to places like that? why is there no protest if things are that bad????
Thankfully i do trust our school

Yup- this has been my conclusion too.
I'm glad I dont send my child to a place where apparently, teachers are forcing kids to do things they are deathly afraid to do, triggering asthma and death, preventing kids learning through fear and intimidation and letting loose dangerous animals in the corridors.
If thats what you think of your school then why on earth would you send your child to such a place?!

myself2020 · 12/01/2020 05:48

In summary, my conclusion from this discussion is that the average british school is absolutely awful as parents can’t trust them even at the most simple things (like making sure allergies aren’t triggered, kids are not terrified ). Why are people sending their kids to places like that? why is there no protest if things are that bad????
Thankfully i do trust our school

JamieVardysHavingAParty · 12/01/2020 03:03

BossAssBitch

You have to have a soul first though. They do say ‘never trust anyone who dislikes dogs’ and I have found that to be spot on advice.

-dogs
+cats

You're welcome.

PetPeter · 12/01/2020 01:27

be comfortable around dogs, an important life skill
Bollocks is it an important life skill! I’ve had no interaction with dogs for many years now, I neither need nor want to be “comfortable “ around them.
Dogs smell and so do the houses they live in

AmelieTaylor · 12/01/2020 00:51

@SanAntonio 🤣🤣🤣 fucking phone 🤣

SanAntonio · 12/01/2020 00:36

Where else, exactly do you propose they get a dig from?!

English heritage?

AmelieTaylor · 12/01/2020 00:28

Why buy from a breeder?

Because they don’t sell them at the school supplies company?

Where else, exactly do you propose they get a dig from?!

Rosspoldarkssaddle · 11/01/2020 23:53

A lot of pet allergies are due to the dander not the fur. A labradoodle is not hyper allergenic any more than a poodle or labrador is!
Why buy from a breeder?
Stupid idea.
Have a visiting one if they must...

GlamGiraffe · 11/01/2020 23:48

DS' current school (secondary) and previous one both had school dogs. I realise that school dogs are typical but we seem to gave had schoolcwhere thry were normal. Thet have always just been there, sometimes you see the dog in the background wandering but usually its sitting on the floor in the room where its human is (of is expected to be). My son was always very wary of dogs but he got used to them being there by virtue of the first school dog which was so chilled out due to bring surrounded by children all the time. I suspect school dogs are becoming more common over time.

maddening · 11/01/2020 23:38

The main issues are allergies and phobias, as someone massively allergic to dogs if my child were the same as me they would effectively be excluded from school because of this - that to me is not acceptable.

Flowerballs · 11/01/2020 23:32

I work in a school we have a dog. It's ludicrous. Not well trained at all, a massive distraction to everyone and horrible for the children and staff who don't like dogs or have allergies. I don't mind dogs, but they don't belong at work, unless you work as shepherd. YANBU.

YouokHun · 11/01/2020 23:20

Dog ownership is very bad for the environment. We are in a climate emergency - no one should be buying dogs except for service dogs. Dogs are a nice luxury but one we should do without for the sake of the planet

Is the Carbon Pawprint a thing? It must be a lot smaller than the impact of having children.

I think a ‘school dog’ could be very unfair on the animal if not managed very carefully. There are also quite a few children and adults who are dog phobic and may find this a real concern. On the other hand, I’ve seen first hand the therapeutic benefits of contact with animals. A tricky one but I think on balance it’s probably better to have a regular visiting dog who is older and well socialised and who can get away from what could be a stressful environment.

frostedviolets · 11/01/2020 22:47

Get over yourself, it's a dog not a bloody lion

Just out of interest, have you actually been threatened or even bitten by a dog?
Particularly a bigger one, like say a Labrador, one of the most frequent breeds to go for me..

Do you have any idea how fucking scary it actually is..?

I have a dog, I like dogs but even I am wary of dogs I don't know.

And I'm an adult. Who likes dogs.
Can't even begin to imagine how terrifying it must be for a child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread