Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The school is getting a school dog

565 replies

Worriedaboutthedoggy · 10/01/2020 23:27

The school had sent out a newsletter today that they are getting a school dog. The letter has all the positives mentioned - they are getting it from a reputable breeder and good bloodlines, it is a hypoallergenic breed (labradoodle), it will be staying in a family environment when off duty (presumably with a member of staff), it will teach the children about the importance of caring for someone - but I still am feeling a bit weird about it, can't put my finger on why exactly.

I am not sure about the impact on the dog - won't it be stressed by the usual playground ruckus? What if it turns out to be wrong temperament?

I am also ashamed to admit that one aspect that concerns me is financial. The average lifetime cost of keeping a dog in the UK (according to google) is around £18K, and I can't help feeling that there are better ways to spend these money (the school is currently fundraising for quite basic things).

Please do tell me I am BU and a total killjoy, and please do tell me your positive stories.

OP posts:
steff13 · 11/01/2020 00:50

they're all nutcases

No. Ours was lovely and I know quite a few others that are similar. All dogs have their own personalities.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 11/01/2020 00:49

Sorry that post was to @Fozzleyplum

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 11/01/2020 00:47

Agreed.

My DM would have probably been taken to court in this era over my number of absences due to health, but they were legitimate. Additionally she recognised there were days, due to levels of bullying, were my mental health couldn't take much more and I needed time out.

I find this new system were parents are cross examined like criminals for letting their child have as little as 2 days off in a row, really bizarre and actually imposing upon and prohibiting responsible good parenting.

lostsoulsunited · 11/01/2020 00:47

If my daughter goes near any dog she has an asthma flare up, last time it lasted a week so her attendance would drop dramatically. She can't go in any room that has a dog in or has had one in it.

eeyore228 · 11/01/2020 00:47

Why not just ask the school? I don’t understand why people are so quick to jump on the old keyboard to ask if they are unreasonable with no actual facts. Find the facts out, you would not be unreasonable to ask. Eg how will the school fund this? What will happen to the pup after school, weekends and holidays. Once you have these details then ask if you’re unreasonable.

YourWinter · 11/01/2020 00:43

This is awful.
Labradoodles aren't automatically hypoallergenic.
I know a few, they're all nutcases, one has bitten a few adults and they've all forgiven it because the owners are 'lovely'.
It's bad enough when schools have hamsters passed around to a different family each weekend but to do it with a dog is utter lunacy.

lostsoulsunited · 11/01/2020 00:43

The RSPCA don't approve according to one of their education officers

Fozzleyplum · 11/01/2020 00:41

Whilst I would have loved it if there had been a dog at my school, I think it's an impractical idea, for the reasons already listed.

Some practices in schools nowadays seem to ride roughshod over safeguards and rights that have to be observed in the workplace. Posters are saying that having a school dog is now fashionable, notwithstanding genuine safety and health concerns. Similarly, schools' draconian stance towards attendance, with censure for absence without a dr's note, and 100% attendance awards that deny treats to the genuinely ill and disabled, all seem to be straight out of the 1970s.

june2007 · 11/01/2020 00:38

Our primary school didn,t have a school dog as such, but there was the care takers dog Sam. He was a lovely good natured retriever. He sat in doorways a lot and wasn,t allowed in class rooms. He was in good con and well looked after. My chilrrens school had the care takers cat. He wasn,t allowed in the school but like to sit in the entrance getting attention. He left with the last care taker.

Ozgirl75 · 11/01/2020 00:38

We’ve got chickens at school and they’re fab. They live in a large run and children get picked to collect the eggs and generally help out. When my son started school and was tearful at drop off his teacher would take his hand and ask him to come and collect the eggs and say hello to the chickens, and the promise of this every morning helped him through those first few tricky days.

After a few days he would see another upset child and say “I think X needs the chickens more than me today”

They will even sit on a child’s lap (if they want) and this has helped a friend’s boy who was behind with his reading as he loves reading to the chickens.

So a school pet in general can be a lovely idea but I’m not mad keen on dogs as they are so much more work.

And they don’t lay eggs.

SunSeaCocktails · 11/01/2020 00:37

My DC went to boarding school for a few years. The school was full of dogs. Live in staff would bring thier digs into lessons. They'd just sit under the desk quietly.
Kids were involved in walking them on school grounds sometimes.
House staff had dogs too.
My kids loved the dogs. They were just like family pets but in and around school. Even during academic school hours.
Dogs came and went with thier staff member but no trauma caused by it. I recall some sadness when one if the HeadMasters dogs was put to sleep at a grand old age, but that's part of life.
My kids are all grown up now and speak very fondly still of these dogs.

As long as the animal is under the care of a staff member I don't see the problem.

BackforGood · 11/01/2020 00:36

If someone is allergic to dogs, they don't need to be in their presence to experience symptoms, just be in a space the dog has been in. It's unlikely to be life threatening but could cause a lot of discomfort. If someone had severe hayfever, you wouldn't fill a school with flowers year round.

They aren't talking about filling the school with dogs though.
My old HT's dog used to live in his office, or be walked around the field. I didn't have any reason to go into the HT's office. He may well have had a vase of flowers in there. Wouldn't affect the overwhelming majority of dc as they don't go in there.

Worriedaboutthedoggy · 11/01/2020 00:35

So more than anything it’s cultural for you?
I am struggling to answer this for myself, but probably yes (I am not religious or consciously consider dogs impure or anything, must be just some echoes of my childhood). I lived with dogs before, one of my exes had dogs and I was ok with it. DC does not have allergies or phobias, and neither do I, so I can't claim it would affect us in any adverse way.

OP posts:
EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 11/01/2020 00:31

And the way to deal with that is to gently introduce them to one

And a specifically expressed desire NOT to be introduced to one should be overlooked

No respect for personal choice or boundaries in a nutshell.

NO ONE wants to be introduced to a dog because that dogs owner has decided that them not wanting to makes the person and not the owner deficient in manners and personal skills.

isittheholidaysyet · 11/01/2020 00:31

And the way to deal with that is to gently introduce them to one. If they see the other children reacting well it will help calm their fears.

I used to be scared of dogs, then one bit me. I hated them after that.

My aunts all had them, so I was slowly introduced to them. Turns out my fears were entirely rational!

I am no longer scared of dogs, nor hate them.
But I totally have no time for them. I don't want your dog to leap up at me, put it's dirty paws on me, sniff me, breathe near me, nick my food out of my hand, shit on my garden. etc.

If I'm in the dog's house I will tolerate it, but tbh there's a lot of people I don't bother visiting any more because they have a dog now.

School is compulsory. The dog would be being forced on me. And as a pupil, I would have no say or right to complain about it.

Doyoumind · 11/01/2020 00:30

If someone is allergic to dogs, they don't need to be in their presence to experience symptoms, just be in a space the dog has been in. It's unlikely to be life threatening but could cause a lot of discomfort. If someone had severe hayfever, you wouldn't fill a school with flowers year round.

Unhomme · 11/01/2020 00:29

Dog ownership is very bad for the environment. We are in a climate emergency - no one should be buying dogs except for service dogs. Dogs are a nice luxury but one we should do without for the sake of the planet.

Humans are far worse.

Numpty.

aroundtheworldyet · 11/01/2020 00:27

So more than anything it’s cultural for you?

hmmokaythen · 11/01/2020 00:26

Ps I'm not against the idea of a school dog I just hope they have provisions for any kids that have a fear or struggle to be around dogs for any reason.

hmmokaythen · 11/01/2020 00:23

I'd have been terrified if this happened whilst I was at school.

I was attacked by a big dog at a young age and despite the efforts of my family I grew up being very scared of dogs (crossing the street etc if one was coming near)

I got over it when I grew up as they felt smaller by comparison

I've had dogs since and now love them but I'd really feel for any kids that have a fear of dogs like I did. It was awful

BackforGood · 11/01/2020 00:23

My school (in the 70s) must have been SO ahead of it's time.
Both the HT and one other member of staff used to bring their dogs into school. Smile

I presume if someone were so allergic to dog hair, that would be on their medical records and the wouldn't be able to take part in therapy or caring for the dog. No reason why that opportunity should be denied to all the other dc though.

Nanny0gg · 11/01/2020 00:21

Loads of children are very nervous around dogs. I hate the assumption that we are all dog lovers.

And the way to deal with that is to gently introduce them to one. If they see the other children reacting well it will help calm their fears.

It's not ideal to grow up with a fear of dogs

Doyoumind · 11/01/2020 00:19

In my experience as someone who suffers, there is no such thing as a dog that doesn't cause allergies. Also, some people just don't like dogs and I agree that the environment is possibly not the best for a dog.

If my dc's school said they were going to do this I would be the killjoy complaining.

Nanny0gg · 11/01/2020 00:19

@SpruceTree

Well, we'll just have them all put down then.

@BillHadersNewWife

Because the odds of there being behavioural issues with a rescue are pretty high. They're not always recommended for homes with young children,

frostedviolets · 11/01/2020 00:18

When you see a child in a total meltdown calming down at the side of the dog

🤦🏻‍♀️

You know I have a super gentle, child tolerant dog.

She snuggled up with all my kids as babies, loved to lie down with them in her bed, they could give her commands and she'd obey.

You know what she does when one of them (I have three) starts arguing or temper tantruming or crying?

She runs upstairs to bed, settles down to sleep and refuses to come back down until they are quiet.

It takes a very special sort of dog and dedicated training to lie quietly unfazed and unbothered in the midst of a meltdown.

It's not a natural born trait for most dogs!