Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The school is getting a school dog

565 replies

Worriedaboutthedoggy · 10/01/2020 23:27

The school had sent out a newsletter today that they are getting a school dog. The letter has all the positives mentioned - they are getting it from a reputable breeder and good bloodlines, it is a hypoallergenic breed (labradoodle), it will be staying in a family environment when off duty (presumably with a member of staff), it will teach the children about the importance of caring for someone - but I still am feeling a bit weird about it, can't put my finger on why exactly.

I am not sure about the impact on the dog - won't it be stressed by the usual playground ruckus? What if it turns out to be wrong temperament?

I am also ashamed to admit that one aspect that concerns me is financial. The average lifetime cost of keeping a dog in the UK (according to google) is around £18K, and I can't help feeling that there are better ways to spend these money (the school is currently fundraising for quite basic things).

Please do tell me I am BU and a total killjoy, and please do tell me your positive stories.

OP posts:
pinkstripeycat · 13/01/2020 17:31

I am allergic to curly dogs. The last time I was around a poodle I had an asthma attack end ended up being taken to the hospital by ambulance

GrumpyMiddleAgedWoman · 13/01/2020 17:03

to cap it all...not a rescue
Actually, with children and insurance to think about, you're much better off with a dog whose background is known, and the temperament of whose parents is known.

what's in it for the dog
I know the dog who is due to come into the school where I work. Very jolly, loves people, will only be in for an hour once a week to begin with: I think she'll have a blast and if she hates it, I can't imagine her owner will persist.

BBOA · 13/01/2020 16:42

Sure it great to have therapy dogs visit but let's face it, who wants to be surrounded by kids all day. It won't have a choice poor thing . 😂

BovaryX · 13/01/2020 15:57

Coming at it from a slightly different pov, what's in it for the dog? Seems like it's to be seen as a "resource" .How much it will help the kids etc etc. What will its life be like?
Precisely. It's bloody bonkers

BovaryX · 13/01/2020 15:55

Why on earth does a school need a dog? And to cap it all, a pedigree dog not a rescue. Utterly bloody ludicrous

thecatsabsentcojones · 13/01/2020 15:48

I think it's a lovely idea, it would really help some kids.

Neither of my dogs would be stressed out by a situation like that and it's a good learning opportunity for the kids. As for those saying their kids would be terrified, give them a day and they'd be as in love with the dog as all the others. My dogs have a 100% fear conversion rate!

CauliflowerBalti · 13/01/2020 15:24

Oh. Yeah. He doesn't roam the corridors - he's always on a lead, and he's a trained therapy dog so when he's working, it's one on one with kids in a session, or a group 'stress relief' session. The only time you ever really see him is on some parents evenings or at selected school events, when he is wheeled out and on show. Mostly he's in an office, doing his thing.

CauliflowerBalti · 13/01/2020 15:21

My son's school has a dog and he is amazing. He helps children that are struggling with big emotions, he is always there for an ear rub during exam stress... He seems very happy and relaxed so I don't think it's stressful for him, at all - he lives with one of the pastoral team, and hangs around with her all day. I think it's a nice life for a dog - and the kids love him.

JosieJasper · 13/01/2020 14:06

I really do judge parents who say their children are ‘scared’ of dogs, it ALWAYS comes from the parents, is is frankly ridiculous

Sorry but you’re WRONG there! My daughter loves dogs from a distance and as much as she wants to like them close up she is just scared due to several situations with dogs in the park that we walk through to get to school. One was a Jack Russell running over and stealing food from her hand when we were at a picnic in the park with friends. Another where luckily she was holding my hand but two big dogs playing ran into her from behind as we were walking and literally swept her off her feet so she was horizontal in the air. The other was a very cute but bouncy puppy (cockerpoo) jumping up at her so it’s face was in hers and nipping at her. (It’s OK, he’s friendly, shouts the owner from 100 meters away) Whilst none of these dogs were out to hurt her...and I have explained this to her many times, she is still scared. I love dogs, I had a lovely one as a kid and I have always spoken to owners of friendly dogs to ask if we can stroke them and have told her that you always let the dog sniff the back of your hand first etc but no matter how cute and adorable the dog, she just can’t do it. This has absolutely not come from me! Also, I find it bizarre that PPs think it’s crazy to be scared of dogs yet they can’t even cope with a bloody spider/mouse 🙄.

Beastieboys · 13/01/2020 13:46

Good grief I hope your post is a joke.... Never heard such tripe (and I've heard shed loads of it),.......

BlaueLagune · 13/01/2020 13:19

You wouldn't take a tub of peanut butter into a classroom and wave around spoonfuls of the stuff. So why would you deliberately expose students with animal allergies to a potentially deadly allergen

Not just students, staff could be allergic too. I only developed a (mild) cat allergy in my late 20s.

I suppose they'd argue peanut allergies are often life-threatening, whereas animal allergies usually aren't (although BIL has asthma made worse by certain animals, so it could be life-threatening more often than I think). But it doesn't matter because the dog lobby is so powerful at the moment.

Mendingfences · 13/01/2020 13:16

Do we keep our allergic child out of parks? No, outdoor spaces are much less problematic. However, experience has unfortunatly taught us that said child really should not visit houses with pets, should preferably avoid crowded indoor situations (lots of pet hair on clothes causing problems) and as far as sports go, swimming is by far the least problematic as everyone showers before entering the pool and swimming costumes are not usually worn when cuddling pets.

Obviously these restrictions are not fun but do make a huge differences healthwise, and no i'm not a fan of anything that increases the amount of pet hair in her school environment or on other pupils clothes.

As far as service dogs go - i would very much hope that pupils would not be cuddling such dogs. A teacher using a service dog in the classroom would unfortunatly make that an unsafe place for my kid.

peachescariad · 13/01/2020 13:11

I think it's brilliant idea. What a fab school your DC go to.
I work in a secondary and the SEN and Well Being would love this

Mistigri · 13/01/2020 13:02

using regulated exposure to specific allergens

And the whole point of this is that exposure if regulated ie at controlled doses.

I've had several courses of desensitisation to dogs and it either works poorly or not at all. Still can't go into an enclosed space with a dog.

Schools can not eliminate all allergens from the environment, but what they should not do is deliberately introduce large quantities of allergen into the school environment without proper medical supervision of allergic pupils!

You wouldn't take a tub of peanut butter into a classroom and wave around spoonfuls of the stuff. So why would you deliberately expose students with animal allergies to a potentially deadly allergen?

Mistigri · 13/01/2020 12:57

I and my kids are severely allergic to dogs, and the idea of a hypoallergenic dog is a marketing one not a scientific one. I would be fuming at the very idea tbh ...

jwpetal · 13/01/2020 12:56

We just received the same letter! We love dogs, but have similar concerns. 3 years ago our school had chickens that were left at the school. Due to poor care they had to be rehomed. Our school is also constantly asking for funds and so am concerned about , who owns the dog and how it will be paid for. We love dogs and have no concern about the dog in school. Just about its longterm care and financial support. My ds has ASD and she loves being with a dog. it calms her down so on that end it is good, hence why we are planning on getting a dog.

10brokengreenbottles · 13/01/2020 11:57

Allergen specific immunotherapy isn't suitable for all. DS1's immunology and allergy consultant ruled it out for him because of how unstable his asthma is and other medical conditions he has. Even if it was suitable it is initiated in a controlled environment, not a school.

Passing a dog in the park is very different to being in an enclosed building with one. But, where possible we avoid parks where dogs are allowed off the lead because DS1 has previously reacted when a dog ran up to him. We also mitigate exposure to other allergens such as dust mite by e.g. having hard flooring not carpet, blinds not curtains, damp dusting daily, limiting soft toys and freezing the ones we do have weekly etc. And food allergens by e.g. being careful what restaurants he eats out at and not having him near anyone cooking fish/shellfish. All on the advice of the CIA consultant. DS1 is not in school at the moment but when he was they made adjustments too.

Yes, there will always be allergens in the environment but that is why DS1 doesn't go anywhere without epipens, inhaler, antihistamines and prednisolone and why he has Xolair injections.

olivehater · 13/01/2020 11:47

Well I grew up with cats and am still allergic to cats. I stopped getting ill all the time when I moved away to university. Go figure. It’s a trial. A school is not a place to trial things on children.

Sandbox · 13/01/2020 11:24

There are allergens in every environment and will always be so

Yes and that’s why people have inhalers but there’s a big difference between unavoidable triggers such as the weather and dust and adding a potentially huge trigger like a dog which isn’t needed. Not to mention the possible phobia and distractions that would come with a dog.

Juliehooligan · 13/01/2020 11:20

I don’t like the idea of having a school dog, sen teachers train all the time on what to do if a child has a melt down, it shouldn’t take a living being to be used for that purpose.

Baaaahhhhh · 13/01/2020 11:07

Allergy specialists are finding more and more via clinical trials that using regulated exposure to specific allergens including dander from domestic animals

I had my own trial. DH was very allergic to cats, I came with cats, and we have always had cats. 30 years on, he is no longer allergic to cats (not that he had any choice poor DH, he did suffer for a few years).

Also DD has many phobias, including dogs. We have been investing in private "exposure" therapy. It works! I would recommend it.

Lincolnfield · 13/01/2020 11:00

‘I expect school to be a safe space without allergen triggers.’

My middle son is severely asthmatic and has been all his life. Could his school eliminate dust mites and dust in the atmosphere? (In those days) chalk dust in the classroom - guaranteed to irritate his lungs. Of course not! Changes in temperatures such as from outside to inside or catching a cold from another child frequently triggered an asthma attack in him. Could his school do anything about that? Obviously not.

There are allergens in every environment and will always be so. Hence my comment about wrapping kids I’m cotton wool. From my, admittedly limited, knowledge of ‘school dogs’ mainly gleaned from comments here, I doubt the intention is to have a dog roaming the corridors or wandering in and out of classrooms but to keep the animal in a safe environment where anxious children can go to benefit from the calming effect (well evidenced) of cuddling a dog.As others have commented, the positives far outweigh the negatives.

Allergy specialists are finding more and more via clinical trials that using regulated exposure to specific allergens including dander from domestic animals in small but increasing amounts is proving extremely effective in eliminating or reducing allergic responses but some of the work is being stymied by parents who won’t permit their kids to be included in the trial. Go figure.....

ralfeesmum · 13/01/2020 10:22

Ideally, I hope the school in question gets a Sausage Dog - but I think in order to stand up to the rough and tumble of a kiddie environment it might have to be something a little sturdier. An English Bulldog is more like it.

Sandbox · 13/01/2020 10:13

The problem for a lot of these ‘allergic’ kids, is that their ‘wrap ‘em up in cotton wool’ parents are allergic to life.

Big difference from passing a dog at the park and coming into contact with one. Why should kids be left out when others are allowed to pet and play with the dog? I take my sons inhaler when we go out, I expect school to be a safe space without allergen triggers. Apologises if wanting my child to be able to breathe during the school day is ‘wrapping him up in cotton wool’

Damntheman · 13/01/2020 09:40

Sounds lovely! My kids' school has chickens that the classes take turns to take care of. They clean out the hen house, let the chickens in and out, collect the eggs. They love it!

Swipe left for the next trending thread