Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The school is getting a school dog

565 replies

Worriedaboutthedoggy · 10/01/2020 23:27

The school had sent out a newsletter today that they are getting a school dog. The letter has all the positives mentioned - they are getting it from a reputable breeder and good bloodlines, it is a hypoallergenic breed (labradoodle), it will be staying in a family environment when off duty (presumably with a member of staff), it will teach the children about the importance of caring for someone - but I still am feeling a bit weird about it, can't put my finger on why exactly.

I am not sure about the impact on the dog - won't it be stressed by the usual playground ruckus? What if it turns out to be wrong temperament?

I am also ashamed to admit that one aspect that concerns me is financial. The average lifetime cost of keeping a dog in the UK (according to google) is around £18K, and I can't help feeling that there are better ways to spend these money (the school is currently fundraising for quite basic things).

Please do tell me I am BU and a total killjoy, and please do tell me your positive stories.

OP posts:
WeshMaGueule · 11/01/2020 10:23

It's quite a lot easier to cage a gerbil than a dog though.

Scarsthelot · 11/01/2020 10:22

There's a very good reason why most reputable rescues will not rehome to families with young children..

That's a rule that many rescues have in place to protect themseleves. The very same rescues also complain they cabt rehome dogs.

No rescue should have blanket ban on dogs where there are children. Some rescue dogs can happily be rehomed with children. The rules should apply to the dog. Not as a blanket ban.

Lots of dogs do very well and are very happy as therapy dogs.

mummaaw · 11/01/2020 10:21

If you don't like dogs as house pets where exactly do you expect dogs to live ?

Fleetheart · 11/01/2020 10:21

There are some people who are allergic to guinea pigs and hamsters and indeed hens, but that doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be in schools! Just that those affected need to avoid them.

Barbie222 · 11/01/2020 10:21

@Treacletoots that's exactly the issue, you are "prepared to be flamed" but happy to state that your way of thinking is the only way, and you can't possibly imagine any reason why there could be a problem with a dog in school! But apparently contact with dogs gives you tolerance and perspective....?

Fleetheart · 11/01/2020 10:19

Crikey, what a miserable load of responses! Trying to pick holes with what the school is doing. I have a feeling that they will probably have thought through all these contingencies and have a way through them. It sounds like a fantastic idea.

Sooverthemill · 11/01/2020 10:19

I think it's a great idea if they fundraiser separately for the cost. No dog is actually hypoallergenic though ( we have ( had) 3 labradoodles and allergic DD wasn't allergic to the first who was scruffy type, is to the second also scruffy type and is allergic to the crap no 3 brings in on his poodle type coat, like leaves, dirt general crap from the outside). We got labradoodle on advice of paediatrician btw as DD was desperate for a dog as were we but she really needs to live in a bubble really. We drug her With antihistamines and don't tell DH she's allergic but I can't see how you could drug an entire school!

Splodgetastic · 11/01/2020 10:19

@Doyoumind, I agree that there is no such thing as a dog that doesn’t cause an allergic reaction. My DM always used to discourage me from stroking dogs for this reason and staying round my grandma’s in the summer holidays was always a bit traumatic as I would inevitably wake up in the night with coughing and wheezing, and wake everyone up. I love dogs and would love to have one, but I have had some really bad reactions (cats are also bad, especially indoor cats, and rabbits are the worst). The worst thing is that I can be okayish with the same dog one day and the next day it will not be okay. Fortunately I have reasonably good control over my asthma (and allergic reactions) now with steroid inhalers (that seem to help with the skin reaction too), so it won’t tend to cause me major problems, but I’m not sure these are prescribed to young children. I’ve experienced a dog in the workplace (guide dog) as an adult and that was okay because I just didn’t touch it and it was quite far away from my desk, but that’s with medication. I don’t think it’s ideal for a school where there will inevitably be a few children in each class with asthma who may react to dogs. Dogs often get annoyed with children poking and prodding them, and even the most placid dog can turn in those circumstances. It is also not an ideal environment for a dog, unless you already know the dog’s temperament.

Scarsthelot · 11/01/2020 10:19

Whilst I am all for a dog in schools, done in the right way. I do think OP should speak to the school about her concerns.

Though it will be an odd converstation as her children wont be negatively impact and the issue is more cultural. As she said herself.

But if she broaches it from the angle of concern for the dog, how it's been trained, the fact that it's not hypoallergenic, stress risk assessments etc she will get the answers.

Either that will relieve her fears about the dog or it will make the school think twice (if they arent doing thos the right way).

I would email a list of questions to the school.

Treacletoots · 11/01/2020 10:17

I think it's a wonderful idea. Dogs are better than humans and (fully expect to get flamed for this but I don't care) anyone who doesn't like dogs is very strange in my opinion.

Teaching children to care about another being, cuddling the dog when they're upset, are all wonderful benefits of this. I know of a dog who lives at the local hospice and gives so much joy to the residents as she visits them.

My DC has grown up with a dog since birth, they adore each other and she loves and respects all animals she comes into contact with as a result. Something more humans could do with learning.

puppup25 · 11/01/2020 10:16

I work in a boarding school where there are 8 dogs belong to Housemasters etc. The children adore them and they add a homely feel to the school. No negative aspects whatsoever!

gamerwidow · 11/01/2020 10:13

OP there is nothing wrong with you asking questions or being unsure when confronted with a situation you are not familiar with. No one should be taking offence here and I’m sure the school would be happy to answer any questions you have about how they will manage the dog as well.

ScrimshawTheSecond · 11/01/2020 10:11

I expect someone bringing in a dog every so often would be great - and kids who are allergic/scared/don't like dogs can be easily kept out of its path.

Not quite sure why it needs to be a permanent fixture?

I agree that the carbon footprint of dogs is horrendous. And the costs are not inconsiderable, either.

Barbie222 · 11/01/2020 10:10

Yes too to the people who've mentioned about cultural differences, it's just another instance where these are ignored and your own way is automatically best.

Grumbley · 11/01/2020 10:08

@Worriedaboutthedoggy you are being sensible and your concerns are rational in my opinion!

Barbie222 · 11/01/2020 10:07

As a teacher with an allergy I would be looking for somewhere else to work. Wouldn't be happy about it being inside at all.

Worriedaboutthedoggy · 11/01/2020 10:06

Guys, please. I am not a dog lover, but not a dog hater either. Some PPs seem to think I am gathering evidence to "throw a spanner" into this idea. Many posts have reassured me now that it is not uncommon at all and it actually works for their schools.
I am not British and have literally never heard of anything like this before.

I mentioned the financial side as there seem to be conflicting messages from the school about the dire lack of financing, and then I researched the costs of keeping a dog and just quoted it as it probably puts it into the "luxury" bucket from my perspective. I don't know how the dog will be funded or legally owned, the newsletter simply says that "we", as in school, will be getting a dog from a reputable breeder. I don't brainwash my child about dogs being dangerous and don't intend to report the school to any authorities. It was mainly for my reassurance and to understand how it normally works. I apologise for all dog owners taking offense, it genuinely was not meant.

OP posts:
Frariedeamin · 11/01/2020 10:03

The Dogs trust and RSPCA strongly advise dogs are not introduced to the school environment. I can’t believe so many dog owners/teachers/other school staff think they know better?

Lougle · 11/01/2020 10:02

DD2's school has a dog. It belongs to the SENCO, has been to training classes and one of the TAs is responsible for her through the day. She stays in the SEN block with a stair gate preventing children from harassing her and she is visited by invitation only (particular children have a 'dog permit', essentially). In break time she is on a particular piece of grass and the children can visit her.

She's sometimes the only reason my DD goes to school.

SummerSazz · 11/01/2020 09:55

My daughters school has a therapy dog (golden retriever) and seems to be a massively positive thing with helping children open up about problems, 'listening' to children reading who struggle etc

I would be very surprised these days if any dogs were allowed to wander around and bump into children who are scared. As far as I know, from 2 local schools with dogs that they are with one person - senco/pastoral team and their day very structured. If kids are scared of dogs they can opt out from having contact. They may see him at a distance on a lead but that would be it.

I do hear the allergy arguments but I presume our school is managing these ok? The benefits seem to be fantastic so I think it would be such a shame to have a blanket 'no' and see if the concerns raised can all be addressed and dealt with sensibly and rationally.

bluebluezoo · 11/01/2020 09:54

it is a hypoallergenic breed (labradoodle)

Oh for fucks sake.

If ”hypoallergenic” is so fucking important they should just get a poodle.

Basic fucking genetics if you cross a hypoallergenic breed (poodle), with an allergy triggering, highly shedding labrador you aren’t going to see an increase in hypoallergenic properties of the offspring.

Why don’t people get this?

VerbenaGirl · 11/01/2020 09:54

There are many positives to having a dog in school, particularly for SEN and vulnerable students. Not to mention staff wellbeing.
In terms of cost, it may well be that the dig actually belongs to a staff member and they pay for everything, or it may be funded from additional ringfenced funding specifically for the support of SEN pupils.
In the cases I know of, the dog has it’s own space (e.g. one of the offices) and isn’t just thrown in with a whole class of rowdy children. This also keeps it away from children who might be frightened, and may even give them an opportunity to get to know the dog in a safe space.
Why not email the Chair of Governors if you want more information or have a concern - as I’m sure Governors will have already had a detailed discussion about the pros and cons.

ittooshallpass · 11/01/2020 09:48

YANBU.

The thing is, all the people who like dogs will think it's a great idea. All those who don't like dogs won't.

frostedviolets · 11/01/2020 09:44

God forbid the school is trying to do something lovely for the kids....
But you have to be mindful that a great deal of children are allergic to and/or frightened of said lovely thing.

Also have to be mindful that the lovely thing is responsible for thousands of injuries every year, mostly to children and one of the top breeds most frequently implicated?

Oh yes, that would be the Labrador.

One half of the labradoodle..

School pets used to be normal and loved to bits
Indeed.

A well trained dog will be well managed -and you child is never going to be forced to have contact if you don’t want them to

The benefits are huge - did you know reading to dogs is a thing that works for poor readers for instance ? Telling your troubles to a dog , just stroking them when you feel sad or angry etc
What about the benefits to the dog?

Or do the dog's feelings just not matter?

There's a very good reason why most reputable rescues will not rehome to families with young children.

Many dogs find children stressful.

Not all dogs want to be constantly stroked, sat with, read to etc.

Many owners are incapable of recognising when their dogs are unhappy, just look at how people perceive tail wags.

Tail wagging = always happy.

That couldn't be further from the truth.

So many people have been bitten by a dog wagging its tail.

I honestly think that so many people are just lucky that overall dogs are such an unbelievably peaceable species who will tolerate a huge amount of shit before reaching breaking point.

The amount of misinterpretation of body language I see on an almost daily basis, it's a miracle the number of bites isn't way way higher.

The school dog idea is just so wrong on so many levels.

And I do say all of this as a big dog lover.

Hoppinggreen · 11/01/2020 09:41

I love dogs, I have a dog and volunteer for a couple of dog charities.
I have even taken our dog into DD’s (secondary school) to offer support to her year group when one of them was killed in an accident
BUT I’m not sure this is a good idea, a lot of dc don’t like dogs, in certain cultures dogs are feared or thought to be unclean (we have had to work really hard with some of ds friends to get them to cope with our dog). Some people have allergies as well. Rescues won’t home in general where there are young children for very good reason and although I think that regular contact with animals is a positive for children there is no need for an official school dog, visits are enough