Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you think there will be a second coming?

891 replies

LuluBellaBlue · 03/01/2020 18:29

This is inspired by the new Netflix show Messiah, about a second coming.

I really hope this doesn’t upset or offend anyone and people can share their beliefs and thoughts openly and without prejudice or judgement as I know this can be very sensitive for some people.

Following on from —binge— watching this series I did a bit of googling and it seems both Christian and Muslim regions predict this. (Not researched if any others do yet)

I’m not very well informed about different regions but the concept of this programme has really interested me, I find it fascinating that this could, maybe? actually happen!

Do you think there could be a second coming?!

(And what would it actually mean for the world? A rise in consciousness? Mass healing???)

YABU - no don't be so daft!
YANBU - yes, this could happen, why not?!

OP posts:
LaurieMarlow · 08/01/2020 09:55

Whether the historical Jesus existed or not is fairly academic.

There is not and never can be evidence that this Jesus was the son of god, born of a virgin, who died and was resurrected to deliver eternal life to his followers.

Even the Christian church is clear on that. It's a matter of faith not evidence.

WaitrosesCheapestVodka · 08/01/2020 09:50

And if there is a god, this shoddy evidence is really his chosen word?

WaitrosesCheapestVodka · 08/01/2020 09:49

I don't think two brief mentions by Roman historians is airtight evidence for the exist of Jesus, but it's probably good enough. My issue is that there is no credible evidence for the resurrection or miracles.

You cannot discount the gospels and epistles due to bias. Most ancient historical records show bias of one sort or another, whether to empires or kings or to matters of faith. It does not make them historically unviable, it makes them useful as historical documents that hold a bias and therefore must be examined in terms of that bias. And when we do that we find all sorts of authentic historical details that cannot be explained by made-up stories weaved decades or centuries later, especially not in terms of writing in antiquity.

Including historical details is exactly what you would do if you wanted to make a document appear credible. This does not make the gospels credible. There are a number of factors which make the gospels wholly unreliable.

For the accounts of our only eye witnesses, they were written very late. The closest was Mark, around 33 years after the death of Jesus. John is at least 60 years after the fact. Memories are fallible, and an account 33 years after an event is not totally unreliable. 60 years is laughable.

The gospels repeatedly contradict eachother, and get more fantastical with age. Mark does not write about the virgin birth or resurrection. Matthew and Luke both include the virgin birth but name a different man as Joseph.

Then you need to remember that these are the gospels that the early church went with. There are many more that did not fit the church's views and so were discarded.

Are the gospels valuable as historical texts? Yes. Are they credible enough to prove that Jesus is the son of god? Of course not. A fantastic claim needs fantastic evidence. The truth is that Christians work backwards, looking for evidence to support their claim.

SirChing · 08/01/2020 09:47

The name Jesus occurs only seven times in the entire New Testament, Christ only four times, and Jesus Christ only twice!

Sorry but that really isnt the case.

Hope you are feeling better @MadHairDay

Walkingdeadfangirl · 08/01/2020 09:47

Ummm.... What?

Sorry posted in a rush. I was making a point about the book of Revelations. Will have to come back to it.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 09:35

Your Santa Claus analogy is a straw man. This is not at the moment a discussion about whether Jesus exists in the now (though I believe with all I am he does), but on whether he actually existed at all. 'Scholars' do not debate the existence of Santa; and in fact there are no historical attestations to St Nick, it is a tradition, unlike the historical attestations to Jesus.

HoneysuckleSpeck · 08/01/2020 09:32

Surely it’s totally irrelevant whether Jesus existed? The important thing is whether he was a magic man who did magical things which clearly only children should believe?

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 09:31

Nobody has kept anything hidden. It is in plain sight for anyone to see. Try reading Bart Ehrman's 'Did Jesus Exist' for an interesting start on it from an unbelieving scholar.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 09:30

Where are you getting these figures? A quick search of any Bible translation will tell you Jesus is mentioned around 1,000-1,300 times, the word translated Christ around 500. Try reading Romans...

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 09:24

The name Jesus occurs only seven times in the entire New Testament, Christ only four times, and Jesus Christ only twice!

Ummm.... What?

Walkingdeadfangirl · 08/01/2020 09:17

the vast majority of NT scholars - of faith and not - agree that the evidence shows Jesus existed

The vast majority of scholars also agree that the evidence shows Santa Claus is based on a real person. Therefore Santa Claus exists. Confused

The name Jesus occurs only seven times in the entire New Testament, Christ only four times, and Jesus Christ only twice! Where is all this evidence that so called NT scholars have of the existence of a barely mentioned character from an ancient book? If it is so overwhelming then why do they keep it hidden?

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 09:10

What is 'the awkward business of Jesus' surviving family', out of interest? We know his brothers were most likely actively involved in the ministry of the early church.

QuizzlyBear · 08/01/2020 09:09

I am the second coming of Christ. Prove me wrong...

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 09:07

The Muslims' Jesus stories are far removed though, by six centuries. Far, far more time to be cloaked in legend and hearsay. The gospels are within 2-3 decades. Incomparable.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 09:06

That's why we must apply hermeneutical tools to the text, though. There are some difficulties with it scholars wrestle with and translators are always working on it to dig deeper into it (for instance, the Herod thing is resolved by a translation of 'before' in terms of the census, when in the original Greek the word meant that as often as 'during', so we must look at both and attempt to apply form criticism etc and common sense. The gospel writers got far too much right in terms of historicity, and therefore what seems to us to be contradictory may be something lost in translation, may be an error on their part, may be something else. But errors and contradictions don't take away from the authenticity of ancient texts - they only would if the whole thing could be proven to be so far from anything historically viable.

Mockers2020Vision · 08/01/2020 08:53

The fact that there may have been a bloke called Yeshua Bar Yusuf is not the same thing at all as there being a real Jesus as written in the gospel fiction.

So many bits of the story we know to be false. The census never happened, and makes no sense in any case. Crucifiction was a Roman penalty. The blood libel on the jews here is filthy. They can't even get the date right. Mixing up their Herods. The awkward business of Big J's surviving family, his undoutbted nieces and nephews and cousins, etc.

The muslims have their own Jesus stories, equally valid or invalid and equally fictional.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 08:45

there is literally not a single scrap of evidence that he existed (apart from the bible, which isn't exactly an unbiased historical source)

You do keep repeating this, Cardinal, as if the repetition of it makes it so. But I'm afraid the fact is that the vast majority of NT scholars - of faith and not - agree that the evidence shows Jesus existed and was killed under Pilate. It is plain enough. You discount Tacitus and Josephus, yet 'contemporary' reports - especially about unknowns, not kings or rulers, would be very rare in the ancient world. The fact that we have near contemporary reports is something far more substantial than 'something Christians desperately cling to' - we are looking at historical documents. We are looking at a Roman historian who was known to be anal about sources. We are looking at a Jewish historian who referred to Jesus twice (the James reference is of the brother of Jesus called Christ, and this is fairly much undisputed except among some fringe scholars, and you simply cannot discount the TF because of the interpolation when Josephan scholars have proven that the core of the text is Josephan and are able to show very clearly the lines of the interpolation - what remains still talks of Jesus life, ministry and death.)

I know well the claims of Jesus-mythers and know well the majority opinion, and any google will show anyone here what that is - and I'm afraid it's simply not the position you assert, however much you repeat it. The fact is that we have good robust historical evidence for the life, ministry and death of Jesus.

You cannot discount the gospels and epistles due to bias. Most ancient historical records show bias of one sort or another, whether to empires or kings or to matters of faith. It does not make them historically unviable, it makes them useful as historical documents that hold a bias and therefore must be examined in terms of that bias. And when we do that we find all sorts of authentic historical details that cannot be explained by made-up stories weaved decades or centuries later, especially not in terms of writing in antiquity.

Somanysocks · 08/01/2020 08:38

As an atheist, people's belief in the second coming terrifies me. It absolves us of our responsibility to look after ourselves and our planet.

No it doesn't

speakball · 08/01/2020 08:23

My sister sees the earth's problems as part of god's end game, so doesn't think we should fight it

You read any Sam Harris? He covers this issue in one of his books.

hairyxmasturkey · 08/01/2020 08:15

No definitely not. I literally cannot get my head around how anyone could believe this stuff.

SirChing · 08/01/2020 07:33

Subduing/taming the Earth so that we can make the Earth a good place for all of us to live is very different from willing on its destruction!

SirChing · 08/01/2020 07:30

how can you say it is "unchristian"?

Easily. It is unChristian because the End Times happens when God decided, and we have a duty to look after the Earth in the interim.

We May be in End Times right now, we may not. The earth might seem like the Magic Kingdom now in comparison to how bad it may get in the future. We don't know. As only God knows and hasn't let us know, surely we have a responsibility to act with as much love and compassion for the planet as we can in the interim?

Trying to hurry the process along is actually acting like God in a way, because it's trying to bring something about that only he has control over. And that is a big no no.

Skyejuly · 08/01/2020 06:55

So 'God' would let disbelievers suffer? That does not sound like something I would support.

speakout · 08/01/2020 06:50

Loopyloopy

I know of this too.

My sister sees the earth's problems as part of god's end game, so doesn't think we should fight it. ( She is in Australia).
My mother's church - in the UK- ( completely different flavour of christianity) encourages this line of thought too.

SirChing how can you say it is "unchristian"? these events are fortold in the bible. Man has been given dominion over the earth, and god told men to "subdue" the earth.

cabbageking · 08/01/2020 01:36

Contemporary would be the writers of the Gospels and Pauls letters which you don't accept. Matthew being completed 41c.

The Aramaic inscription on one side of the ossuary. Scholars acknowledged its reading: “James, son of Joseph, brother of Jesus?
It was rare to name a brother as usually just the father was needed. used by the Jews 00 to 70ce.

Swipe left for the next trending thread