Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you think there will be a second coming?

891 replies

LuluBellaBlue · 03/01/2020 18:29

This is inspired by the new Netflix show Messiah, about a second coming.

I really hope this doesn’t upset or offend anyone and people can share their beliefs and thoughts openly and without prejudice or judgement as I know this can be very sensitive for some people.

Following on from —binge— watching this series I did a bit of googling and it seems both Christian and Muslim regions predict this. (Not researched if any others do yet)

I’m not very well informed about different regions but the concept of this programme has really interested me, I find it fascinating that this could, maybe? actually happen!

Do you think there could be a second coming?!

(And what would it actually mean for the world? A rise in consciousness? Mass healing???)

YABU - no don't be so daft!
YANBU - yes, this could happen, why not?!

OP posts:
Skyejuly · 08/01/2020 11:28

What particularly makes you feel happy or glad about having faith? I am generally wondering this? What is so bad about no faith?

LastTrainEast · 08/01/2020 11:28

@Madhairday "That's not late, in terms of writings of antiquity. At all. With many other historical figures we don't find any writings until centuries later."

It's a bit late for supposedly eyewitness accounts., but in any case I think it makes a difference when the people making the claim are in the same club. it's like the only people who have seen the bridge this guy is selling me are his co-workers in his bridge selling company. But he can point to a couple of people who once saw a similar bridge.

For me I don't care much except that it's very revealing when many Christians appear to think the Romans had his birth certificate etc. Who told them that I wonder?

Regardless it's easy enough to dismiss the miracles and those were confirmed by the same people saying that Jesus existed so we know they were liars and can't be used as reliable sources at all.

Maybe it's just a coincidence that such a big deal as a new Messiah didn't get recorded by other historians, but Zombies?

Matthew says in chapter 27

Jesus, when he had cried again with a loud voice, yielded up the ghost.
And, behold, the veil of the temple was rent in twain from the top to the bottom; and the earth did quake, and the rocks rent;
And the graves were opened; and many bodies of the saints which slept arose,
And came out of the graves after his resurrection, and went into the holy city, and appeared unto many.

Earthquake and Zombies and no one thought that worthy of a footnote?

speakball · 08/01/2020 11:26

Alexander the Great is taught as fact and not disputed but was written 400 years after his death.

Do you know anyone who prays to Alexander The Great and believes they can spend eternity worshipping him? Its because the bible makes claims about the supernatural that means it gets spoken about more.

boymum9 · 08/01/2020 11:14

If anyone is interested in the reliability of what is written in the bible, an interesting book to read is "The case for christ" by Lee Strobel.

People can argue semantics forever, but there are actually factual consistencies written in the bible and the accounts of the gospels for the time they're written prove to be as reliable as they can be.

As a reference the biography of Alexander the Great is taught as fact and not disputed but was written 400 years after his death. The accounts of Jesus and his miracles were all written within the lifetime of people who witnessed then, all at different times by Matthew, Mark, Luke and John (there is disputes about who specifically wrote the entirety of these from what I understand) but have many many consistencies. Even the people who persecuted and hated Jesus agreed that what he did was nothing short of miraculous. As for the New Testament being anti Semitic, that is actually not the case and something which people say from what they've heard through generations who haven't read it. Jesus was a Jew, his disciples were Jewish.

I consider myself lucky to have a strong faith and will never deny that, it's interesting reading through people's comments who oppose it because all it does it strengthen me and I'm sure that's the case for other Christians. I will follow Gods will for my whole life, and feel so lucky I feel his presence working in my life!

Skyejuly · 08/01/2020 11:14

I always feel like abrahamic religion is constantly trying to reach higher to 'god/etc' yet we are humans. We are enough as we are. We do not need to constantly try and pray above.

How can praying to Earth Goddesses be the work of satan? So trying to praise nature and the earth is evil?

My friend had an attempted suicide. Many of the church went to visit yet all slagged her off behind her back and then stopped seeing her when she didnt go for ages anyway.

speakball · 08/01/2020 11:11

What is your source for this?

Just google it I guess. This is from a Wikipedia page about their authorship.

During the following centuries, each canonical gospel was attributed to an apostle or to the close associate of an apostle.[58] Most scholars have rejected the traditional attributions.

Mockers2020Vision · 08/01/2020 10:45

The census story is a straightforward lie. The whole Bethlehem/Nativity kids' panto narrative is a concoction from several centuries later.

Jesus, whoever he was, seems to have emerged as a preacher as a fully formed adult. His origins are uncertain. As a potential jewish messiah, his lineage and birthplace etc would have been significant, but the overwhelming majority of jews weren't buying it, which says something to that.

The antisemtism in the Gospels, particularly the crucifiction story, qualifies these particular lies as hate speech.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 10:37

Except Matthew didn't write it. And neither did Mark, Luke or John.

What is your source for this?
The earliest traditions and earliest manuscript fragments we have attach these names to the gospels. They were written in the time frame of eyewitnesses, 60-70 and 90ish. They have many elements pointing to the use of eyewitness testimonies. I don't know for a fact Matthew the apostle wrote Matthew, but have no reason to disbelieve the earliest traditions and certainly his emphasis on Jesus' ministry to the Jews and status as an educated tax collector points to the possibility.
There's really very little doubt among scholars that Mark and Luke were written by Mark and Luke, companions to eyewitnesses.

Really. Should. Go.

Halloweenbabyy · 08/01/2020 10:34

@Ronia. Yes it was! I was trying to remember the actor. Fab.

LaurieMarlow · 08/01/2020 10:31

Historians have shown that is not enough time for legend to creep in.

Come on now, you don’t need any time for agenda pushing, shaping the narrative and selecting the evidence to kick in.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 10:30

Anyway, I really must do some work.

@SirChing thank you. I'm no better today unfortunately, really struggling with breathing. It's hard work. How are you feeling today?

speakball · 08/01/2020 10:29

Matthew wrote for a Jewish audience so emphasised OT prophecy etc.

Except Matthew didn't write it. And neither did Mark, Luke or John. I have to be honest, when I was going to church I automatically assumed the gospels were written by the disciples. I had no idea of the time frame.

LaurieMarlow · 08/01/2020 10:29

But absolutely possible for someone to do good things and be deluded about other things at the same time.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 10:28

Given that we have no access to the oral tradition they were working off, you have absolutely no way of knowing that.

The early gospels were built on oral histories. But it's the shortness of time that gives us the most information and shows us what the stories were and what they believed - early creeds in use in the 30s, epistles written only 20 or less years later. Historians have shown that is not enough time for legend to creep in.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 10:25

It's a pretty extraordinary claim. It would be a huge leap to simply take his word for it, even if came across as genuine in his belief.

Yes, that's true. It is a crazy, wild claim. And I wouldn't just take someone's word for it - I would want to know that person, to know they were trustworthy, to know more about their character. And the character of Jesus is spilled out across the pages of the NT, as someone who was a voice for the oppressed, who cared about justice, who exposed the hypocrites, who didn't have time for false righteousness, who demonstrated the greatest compassion. It's like C.S Lewis puts it - was Jesus a liar? Was he deluded? Or was he Lord?

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 10:21

It'd depend on the sources. BBC or ITV? Times or Guardian? What can we trust? Like anything I'd want to look into it for myself and determine whether it could possibly be true. I would of course discount the possibility unless faced by evidence and by a Penguin Experience in my own life. Which sounds quite fun.

LaurieMarlow · 08/01/2020 10:19

I think the NT makes a good case for Jesus believing he was, so our question should be if he was who he said he was.

It's a pretty extraordinary claim. It would be a huge leap to simply take his word for it, even if came across as genuine in his belief.

LaurieMarlow · 08/01/2020 10:17

But it was not a later channeling of something earlier into something different.

Given that we have no access to the oral tradition they were working off, you have absolutely no way of knowing that.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 10:16

And they were the only ones trying to do that you think?

I'm well aware of the bias in the gospels. The difference is that these writers were not trying to shape a different narrative from another source, like the gnostic gospels later - they were recounting the eyewitness stories they had seen and believed. You might call their emphasis a shaping of their own, of course. But it was not a later channeling of something earlier into something different.

WaitrosesCheapestVodka · 08/01/2020 10:14

And they were the only ones trying to do that you think?

Do you not think the church should be held to a higher standard?

Say I claimed to see penguins in the Thames. I have numerous eye witnesses, but only use four. Would you think me objective and reliable? Would you trust my claim about the penguins? Or does it appear I am ignoring evidence that undermines my claim?

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 10:12

The church picked the accounts that fitted their view and agenda, and discarded other evidence.

No. They simply continued to use what they had used from very early on, what was agreed on from the start in the earliest creeds and writings, and eventually compiled that in canon. Of course the discarded what was not in agreement - they would not allow anything that was not authentic to the faith they held and had held from the start. That wasn't discarding evidence, it was upholding their faith and preserving it for future generations. The gnostic gospels were not destroyed, merely not included.

But the age and numerous inconsistencies in the gospels do enough to make them insufficient to prove that Jesus was the son of god.

The numerous inconsistencies are not as inconsistent as many would have us believe. The great majority of inconsistencies in the manuscripts we have are small grammatical errors or spelling mistakes, and it's been proven that even the larger inconsistencies do not in any way detract from central tenets of faith. If you are referring more to inconsistencies between gospel texts, they make sense in terms of what these writings were; they were by different authors for different audiences with different emphases. Luke wrote as a historian for a Greek/gentile audience and so emphasised things regarding that, Matthew wrote for a Jewish audience so emphasised OT prophecy etc. Even today you'd expect some inconsistencies when two or more people report on an event - they see what they see, from their POV. Genealogies etc were written in antiquity with differing emphases too, so some concentrating more on the royal line and some other branches.

However, proving that Jesus is the son of God is another matter. I think the NT makes a good case for Jesus believing he was, so our question should be if he was who he said he was.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 10:03

For the accounts of our only eye witnesses, they were written very late.

That's not late, in terms of writings of antiquity. At all. With many other historical figures we don't find any writings until centuries later. And added to that is the oral traditions/histories emphasis of teh Jewish community at that time - people were trained from childhood to pass stories down word for word, were robustly challenged if any change happened, so not comparable to Chinese whispers. The epistles were mostly written before the gospels, some of them in the 50s, and the existence of very early creeds is referred to in these as well as in the later wider tradition. In the earliest creeds, most likely in wide use only two-five years after the events, believers were claiming that Jesus was died and resurrected on the third day.

WaitrosesCheapestVodka · 08/01/2020 10:02

The existence of them does not water down the historical value of the gospels; it merely shows there were variations among later sects, notably gnostics, who wanted to shape the narrative to something suiting them instead.

Of course it does. The church picked the accounts that fitted their view and agenda, and discarded other evidence.

But the age and numerous inconsistencies in the gospels do enough to make them insufficient to prove that Jesus was the son of god.

LaurieMarlow · 08/01/2020 10:01

who wanted to shape the narrative to something suiting them instead.

And they were the only ones trying to do that you think?

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 09:58

The other so called gospels were not in general use in the early church and so were not included in canon because they did not meet the criteria of use - eyewitness accounts, in wide use from early on, in agreement with the gospel narrative. In fact, some of them were utterly fantastical and in opposition to the original gospels. The existence of them does not water down the historical value of the gospels; it merely shows there were variations among later sects, notably gnostics, who wanted to shape the narrative to something suiting them instead.

Swipe left for the next trending thread