Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you think there will be a second coming?

891 replies

LuluBellaBlue · 03/01/2020 18:29

This is inspired by the new Netflix show Messiah, about a second coming.

I really hope this doesn’t upset or offend anyone and people can share their beliefs and thoughts openly and without prejudice or judgement as I know this can be very sensitive for some people.

Following on from —binge— watching this series I did a bit of googling and it seems both Christian and Muslim regions predict this. (Not researched if any others do yet)

I’m not very well informed about different regions but the concept of this programme has really interested me, I find it fascinating that this could, maybe? actually happen!

Do you think there could be a second coming?!

(And what would it actually mean for the world? A rise in consciousness? Mass healing???)

YABU - no don't be so daft!
YANBU - yes, this could happen, why not?!

OP posts:
Mockers2020Vision · 09/01/2020 09:24

If God willing to prevent evil, but not able, then he is not omnipotent.
If he able, but not willing, then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing, then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing? Then why call him God?

Epicurus - around 300BC

speakout · 09/01/2020 08:58

I once asked someone religious why if God exists so many bad things happen in the world. Their reply was because God gave people free will to make their own choices and it’s always stuck with me since.

How does "free choice" account for earthquakes? Ebola virus? Parasitic infections?

Blitzen2 · 09/01/2020 01:19

I like the belief that there is something bigger out there that could save us and give us miracles.

I once asked someone religious why if God exists so many bad things happen in the world. Their reply was because God gave people free will to make their own choices and it’s always stuck with me since.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 17:57

I'd agree with that!

Glad we can find some common ground Grin I find that is a general life experience when it comes to Monty Python.

SirChing - don't worry, I'm already on antibiotics. I have long term lung diseases so have all treatment at hand as I'm not a massive fan of pneumonia or hospital admissions (managed to avoid one for a year, so hoping that continues!) Glad you're feeling better.

lilgreen · 08/01/2020 16:55

Nope.

SirChing · 08/01/2020 16:53

@nowayhose Grin

nowayhose · 08/01/2020 16:48

Only if I change husbands, lol :)

Mockers2020Vision · 08/01/2020 16:21

Look at it this way:

There really was a Colenel TE Lawrence, and he did play a role in the Arab revolt. But he wasn't half as important as Western Orientalists make out, and he looked nothing like Peter O'Toole.

Gertrude Bell was far more important, but for various reasons is not so famous.

SirChing · 08/01/2020 16:15

Also, I propose that a Slipperwig is a noun to describe a gathering of four penguins or more on the Thames! Grin

SirChing · 08/01/2020 16:13

Hi @MadHairDay. Feeling less like a herd of elephants are having a Zumba class in my head thanks. Sorry to hear you are feeling ropey. Please be wary and if no better tomorrow go back to the GP. Its so easy to have it turn into pneumonia which is pretty scary.

@LastTrainEast "might then find yourself grabbing the old pitchfork and torch and yelling "Kill the Blasphemer"

Grin that proper made me laugh. I can't do that, it may involve running which is definitely against my personal religion Grin

CardinalSin · 08/01/2020 14:07

I will admit that I haven't read through the whole of Josephus (there is quite a bit of it!), but I'm not aware of any other paragraphs that so blatantly interrupt between two others that don't make sense because of it. There may be others, but I would have to be made aware of them.

CardinalSin · 08/01/2020 14:04

I'd agree with that!

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 13:46

That's a fair enough, rational position, Cardinal. But I also went on that search, in the midst of a theology degree where all my assumed knowledge seemed to be shattered into pieces, and came to different conclusions on the evidence I delved into. Just because there is evidence of forgery in a passage doesn't mean we should discount that passage - that would surely be historically careless - what we should do, and what scholars have done, is to examine the passage in the light of Josephan writings in general and what we know about him and the contacts he would have had. And the majority of scholars agree on an authentic core in that passage - and having looked into it (in more depth than I'd really have liked Grin ) I agree with them.

As for contemporary writers, there were actually far fewer operating in Jewish circles, more in pagan circles. And as I've said, Jesus was one of a number of Messiah claimants - as we know from the True History of the great Life of Brian (well, from other sources, but that one is the best.)

CardinalSin · 08/01/2020 13:39

Obviously, many people will go into the search desperately wanting to find evidence that he existed, and therefore proclaiming every little thing they find as genuine.

I went in to find out what the incontrovertible evidence that I had been told existed was. When I found out it didn't exist, my tolerance for anything "claimed" which doesn't stand up to what I consider to be reasonable scrutiny became very low. The very fact that it has been claimed for centuries that there is absolute proof of his existence, when this is not true, means I am now less likely to consider anything inconclusive, and more, if there is genuine doubt over it's provenance (such as the TF), I will not count it as evidence, merely as evidence of forgery - and likely further forgery as well.

CardinalSin · 08/01/2020 13:25

The trouble is, is that there were a number of contemporary commentators writing at that time, in that area. But not a single one of them mentions Jesus or any of the events that are supposed to have happened around him...

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 12:59

Not contemporary, nor eyewitness, merely hearsay.

poor old anal Tacitus would be very upset to hear his carefully constructed history as 'hearsay' Grin

Again, it would be awfully strange to find contemporary (extra-biblical) sources about a bloke who thought he was the Messiah in an obscure corner of Judea, and the fact that we have near-contemporary accounts is startling, really.

OK, I'm boring myself now.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 12:42

Ah well, the less said about that annoyance Eusebius... Grin

I think we've had this discussion a few times, Cardinal :) I still robustly disagree, as someone who has also studied Josephus and these passages in depth. The 'bittiness' of the passage is not ignored, but instead equated with the 'patchwork' nature of Josephus' writing in general. I really don't want to go down that whole rabbit hole, because from experience it is endless, but would recommend reading Mason on Josephus for some useful scholarly exploration: amazon.co.uk/Josephus-New-Testament-Steve-Mason/dp/0801047005/ref=sr_1_2?keywords=josephus+mason&qid=1578486748&sr=8-2]]

CardinalSin · 08/01/2020 12:27

And it is also noticeable that the TF was never so much as mentioned until the 3rd century. Particularly by Origen, who searched all his life for any references to Jesus that he could find from anywhere.

Strangely, it was only noticed by that self confessed forger of early Christian history, Bishop Eusebius. Who apparently found it in Origen's copy of Josephus!

What a coincidence!

CardinalSin · 08/01/2020 12:24

"That's not late, in terms of writings of antiquity. At all."

Not in terms of antiquity, but it is still late. Not contemporary, nor eyewitness, merely hearsay.

And, having studied Josephus in depth, I disagree strongly with anybody who claims the TF is authentic. The fact that it's even in the wrong place (between two paragraphs which should obviously be contiguous, and don't make sense with this in between) is something often ignored. The later reference literally makes no sense if it is referring to Jesus Christ. The "who was the Christ" must be an addition by a "helpful" scribe - remove it, and it's obviously about Jesus, son of Damneus.

Madhairday · 08/01/2020 12:18

For me I don't care much except that it's very revealing when many Christians appear to think the Romans had his birth certificate etc. Who told them that I wonder?

That'll be from Justin Martyr, writing in the 2nd century, claiming that Jesus' birth could easily be found on the registers of 'the taxing made under Cyrenius'. I place no particular credence on this and wouldn't claim the Romans had his 'birth certificate'. I do think we have to be careful when claiming Luke 'lied' about the census - history tends to be a whole lot more nuanced, especially ancient history, and there are a few possible explanations to do with translation, error, whether Quirinius was governor twice, the translation of 'governor' etc. Some scholars even said Josephus had the date wrong - he's not immune to error either (FWIW I tend to think he was pretty accurate though - just pointing out that we must dig deeper into historical method to understand this stuff.) On balance it's more likely that Luke was talking about a different census, that either ended in the reign of Quirinius as governor, or was before that (some scholars say the translation is closer to 'before' than 'during'), or when he was 'procurator; a different post than governor. Luke may have made an error in dating, of course, but it's unlikely he'd have made such a big gaffe, being such a careful historian - and he would have been called out on it by eyewitnesses too.

The whole Bethlehem/Nativity kids' panto narrative is a concoction from several centuries later.

That's a difficult position to assert, when all the material is in Luke/Matthew, and the dating for those in the 1st century well attested. The only things in the 'kids nativity' narratives that are dodgy are the stable (not mentioned, more likely a cave/room under a home where animals were kept), and the three kings (an indeterminate number of wise ones) - embellishments not based on the text, but for the effect of story.

speakball · 08/01/2020 11:54

It's like C.S Lewis puts it - was Jesus a liar? Was he deluded? Or was he Lord?

Or a legend? (Not my words. Read it somewhere.)

roisinagusniamh · 08/01/2020 11:51

boymum9
I consider myself lucky to have a strong faith and will never deny that, it's interesting reading through people's comments who oppose it because all it does it strengthen me and I'm sure that's the case for other Christians. I will follow Gods will for my whole life, and feel so lucky I feel his presence working in my life!
How does it strengthen you?
What's God's will for you?
How do you feel his presence?

LastTrainEast · 08/01/2020 11:44

@SirChing thank you, I really prefer to debate in a civilised manner and I don't hate believers, but only what they believe in.

However I'm not gentle when it comes to the belief itself so if someone starts a thread such as "Would we WANT a second coming" or "What do we think of god" you might then find yourself grabbing the old pitchfork and torch and yelling "Kill the Blasphemer"

WaitrosesCheapestVodka · 08/01/2020 11:40

I think the NT makes a good case for Jesus believing he was, so our question should be if he was who he said he was.

It's like C.S Lewis puts it - was Jesus a liar? Was he deluded? Or was he Lord?

This CS Lewis quote always makes me cringe. It is infinitely more plausible that he was deluded or a liar than the son of god. There just isn't the heft of evidence present to back up such an extraordinary claim. Jesus is one in an army of messiahs, and Christianity started from one of many resurrection cults in history.

You believe, and of course that's fair enough. But I doubt that you (or any Christian) bases their faith on the evidence available.

LastTrainEast · 08/01/2020 11:33

boymum9 see my previous post for proof the gospel writers were liars and unreliable sources.

I'm curious though how you meant "factual consistencies written in the bible and the accounts of the gospels"

Sometimes people say that when they mean "he mentions Bethlehem and that's a real place so he must be telling the truth" but perhaps you had something else in mind