Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you think there will be a second coming?

891 replies

LuluBellaBlue · 03/01/2020 18:29

This is inspired by the new Netflix show Messiah, about a second coming.

I really hope this doesn’t upset or offend anyone and people can share their beliefs and thoughts openly and without prejudice or judgement as I know this can be very sensitive for some people.

Following on from —binge— watching this series I did a bit of googling and it seems both Christian and Muslim regions predict this. (Not researched if any others do yet)

I’m not very well informed about different regions but the concept of this programme has really interested me, I find it fascinating that this could, maybe? actually happen!

Do you think there could be a second coming?!

(And what would it actually mean for the world? A rise in consciousness? Mass healing???)

YABU - no don't be so daft!
YANBU - yes, this could happen, why not?!

OP posts:
Sametimenextyear · 12/01/2020 10:40

@Igotthisjustabout
Yep ...I'm with you .

roisinagusniamh · 12/01/2020 09:08

CreekIsRising 😀😂

malificent7 · 12/01/2020 08:51

Typos sorry

malificent7 · 12/01/2020 08:47

I detest most organised religions apart from Bhuddism.
The soul ( and as a scientist i di believd in rhe soul) is not meant to be tortured and bound by thess toxic cults.
The second coming is a fear tactic.

CreekIsRising · 12/01/2020 08:46

There already has been a second coming. She's currently in a secure unit on olanzapine. The doctors say her delusions are fixed and long term and she got referred to the local police force after radicalising members of a community youth group.

Lweji · 12/01/2020 08:39

Even if Christians admit that the bible is fictional (and where does that leave them?)

While there is a substantial section that would believe the Bible word for word (e.g. creationists), anyone with some knowledge takes it as "inspired by" rather than directly "dictated by" God.
Even the Old Testament is a collection of books, as is the New Testament. People are encouraged to get together, because God is among them. I think this reflects that nobody has the sole truth, but that people can get to God in a community. The various books are similar. They should be taken together, because none represents the entire message, or God.
That's why there are Bible reflection groups and why they are written as stories and letters. It's not supposed to be an instruction manual.

If you believe in God, you can say the books were inspired by God. If you don't, then you can take them as inspired by a community getting together.

If we get past the idea of God to explain phenomena we don't understand or as a means of trying to make sense of reality and to control it, perhaps we could view God as what arises from communities coming together. A sort of consciousness that doesn't arise from one but many brains, not in a supernatural sense.

I grew up as a Catholic but with an enlightened if conservative mother.
I find the main messages from the New Testament very appealing still today. Not so much because of any after death salvation, but because it's a message that should lead to communities at peace.
Not so keen on the official religions, though. Many, and notably Catholicism, have become like the Pharisees that are heavily criticised in the NT.

So I'm left with being a fan of Christ's message (whoever he or they were) but not so keen on the supernatural aspects that form a religion.

In fact, if we think of a second coming, then we have had it several times. Every time a community comes together and changes rules.

parkrunhun · 12/01/2020 08:35

And what I am saying is that historically religion has been the basis of evil doings since its first existence!

Sacrifice to gods, forced conversion of local indigenous populations to save them for gods, vilification of those who don't follow a certain religions pathways, denial of rights based on biblical teachings, taking babies from unmarried mothers and killing them to protect their salvation for god, abusing children to make sure they behave in a way god would want, the list goes on !

SirChing · 11/01/2020 23:08

because they create guilt and hatred and tear communities apart with their narrow minded agendas and I'm better than you postulating

Same sex marriage was only just legalised in NI, and no doubt would never had been legalised if the fundamentalist at the DUP had had their way

All those examples are examples of humans betraying their religion. Nowhere in the Bible does it say that gay people shouldn't adopt. It does say that we should come together and love our neighbours as ourselves.

So anyone who is causing strife in an area, or trying to say Gay people shouldn't adopt or whatever, they are simply bigots who are not doing what Jesus said they should do. This sometimes happens at an organisational level, which was part of the issue that Jesus had with organised religion being corrupted by men. It doesn't mean Jesus's teachings were wrong. It means that the so called religious person isnt following them.

If Christianity is so anti gay, then why do we have so many gay clergy and congregation? Rev Richard Cole's husband died the other week. Who was also a Rev.

I am not saying that division in communities and anti-gay rhetoric doesn't and hasn't existed in religions. But in terms of Christianity, that is humans warping the messages for their own purpose. Even the Pope has said "love is love" when asked about it.

SirChing · 11/01/2020 22:59

Even if Christians admit that the bible is fictional (and where does that leave them?) that's still the role model that their religion rests on

Actually, it isn't. The think that differentiates Christianity from the Torah, is the New Testament. That's what Christianity is based on. And Christians believe that the arrival of Jesus created a new covanent. Whereby the 10 commandments still existed, but the most important thing is love, not judging, helping those less fortunate etc.

The Old Testament describes the Jewish faith until the birth of Christ. Which is why when Gideons give out bibles in schools, it's just the New Testament they give out. The Old Testament is the back story. The New Testament is the basis for Christian faith.

So our role model is Jesus and his teachings. Not the Old Testament.

Ocarinan · 11/01/2020 22:57

Same sex marriage was only just legalised in NI, and no doubt would never had been legalised if the fundamentalist at the DUP had had their way.

SirChing · 11/01/2020 22:51

@LastTrainEast No, of course I am not saying that men weren't Christian and that's why they killed people.

I AM saying that people of all religions and none can be real bastards and kill for fucked up ideological reasons. But that reason doesn't have to be religion, as those examples show.

Religion is an excuse. If ISIS really were bothered about being good Muslims, then they wouldn't kill a greater proportion of Muslims than any other religion. The Christians in the crusades weren't following Christianity. That was their excuse. It was a land grab in the Middle East.

People will blame their nasty, murderous, land grabbing ways on many religions and many ideologies. It's all a load of crap, designed to make them feel like they are not nasty, murderous, land grabbing bastards. That isn't the fault of religion. Its the fault of the bastard with the weapon in his hand.

LastTrainEast · 11/01/2020 22:38

@RoseWines A law was passed in Scotland allowing Catholic adoption agencies to refuse gay parents because god hates them.

That was 2006 I believe and I hadn't heard that it had been changed, but you could check.

LastTrainEast · 11/01/2020 22:34

@RoseWines perhaps people should be more tactful, but there is no evidence at all for any of the 1000s of gods. To pretend to know that one of them is real is one isn't terribly sensible is it.

When you are asked for directions by a stranger and you don't the place they are looking for I assume that you don't pretend to know and make something up? That would be a ridiculous thing to do wouldn't it and unfair to the person asking.

RoseWines · 11/01/2020 22:32

Christians don't get to kill gay people these days, but they get to fire them from jobs and block them adopting children
Guessing that not a reference to the uk? Because that'd be illegal and doesnt happen here

RoseWines · 11/01/2020 22:28

@ZenNudist
@73kittycat73

Pretty sure there's scriptures in the bible that talk about the fires of Hedes. But the idea of a pitch-folk devil and fire is a middle ages cultural and arts invention.
Jews don't believe in hell, as a place that souls go to either.
Hell, is the absence of all good, the absence of being, the absence of God's love. Things in this world happen and I often think it provides a tiny glimpse of what the absence of good and the absence of God's love would look like, really dark. But I don't think anyone is burning in hell for eternity. Death is described as sleep, souls resting in peace until judgement day. Those who wont live in paradise, will be returned to nothingness (absence of God's love), which is what many atheists believe - that we die and return to the same unconscious state of being that we were before we existed.
I'd have to look up the verses tho to explain in a less waffle-filled way

parkrunhun · 11/01/2020 22:28

There's always a point in these arguments were someone talks about killings and war caused by religion and then someone else comes on and talks about all the non-religions wars and killing etc..

Both are awful but I would say religion and religious people have caused more misery and unhappiness for people (in particular women)the world over because they create guilt and hatred and tear communities apart with their narrow minded agendas and I'm better than you postulating ! And I mean all religions not just Christianity !

Coming from a particular area of the uk which has suffered more than most because of religious division I feel really strongly that while there should be freedom of religion it is even more important that there is freedom from religion!

There won't be a second coming because their never was a first one !

LastTrainEast · 11/01/2020 22:25

@SirChing are you suggesting that Stalin, Mao and Hitler killed simply because they were not Christian? That is a standard response when believers are reminded of their religion's record of atrocities, but it doesn't hold up.
Especially not in HItler's case. A Catholic upbringing gave him his start in life.

Some non-religious people kill and some religious people kill, but in addition to that some religious people kill because they were taught that their god required it.

We might also consider god's list of victims as recorded in the bible. The god who drowned every man, woman, child and baby and unborn child in the Great Flood.

Who slaughtered the firstborn in Eqypt, Even the children of slaves who had no say in what was going on.

Who picked Abraham as father of his religion because Abraham was willing to tie up his own son and cut his throat just for a promised reward.

Who taught that gay people should be murdered.

Even if Christians admit that the bible is fictional (and where does that leave them?) that's still the role model that their religion rests on. Of course it was going to lead to atrocities and still does. Just not on a large scale these days.

Christians don't get to kill gay people these days, but they get to fire them from jobs and block them adopting children etc God told them it was the right thing to do.

RoseWines · 11/01/2020 22:17

@Moonmelodies he's human, he's the Pope, not a superhero or magic wizard

RoseWines · 11/01/2020 22:15

Honestly, that's the only thing I find offensive - accusing religious groups of being weak minded. As if an absence of faith equates to intelligence (it really doesnt)

Moonmelodies · 11/01/2020 22:10

One might wonder why the Pope's invisible friend didn't protect him from the woman.
I've often wondered why his Popemobile has bulletproof glass. Does he not have sufficient faith?

LastTrainEast · 11/01/2020 22:02

I felt sorry for the pope being grabbed like that, but then I thought "hold on. Are we not supposed to believe he's in contact with god and his representative on earth? Shouldn't he be overflowing with god''s love and be unable to be angry and tired"?

I still feel somewhat sorry for an elderly CEO of a failing company.

Admittedly one that only thrived when it had much more power over people than it does now.

SirChing · 11/01/2020 20:45

@contentedsoul Using religion as an excuse to kill, doesn't mean that religion itself causes deaths. Humans have bent and manipulated religious teachings to justify terrible acts, but if it wasn't religion, it would be something else.

Now obviously, as you say, I am only weak minded, but how many millions did Stalin kill again with his bastardised approach to communism? Wiki says estimates over his total time in power are around 20 million.

Chairman Mao's great leap forward - killed about 20 million directly and a further 25 million indirectly over a four year period.

The Khmer Rouge - roughly 2 million out of a population of 8 million

Not to mention obviously Nazism which killed 6 million.

I am intrigued as to which wars in the name of religion have killed more people than this. My weakmindedness must have made me forget......please do refresh my memory.

As for the Pope slapping the woman's hand away - have you seen the footage? She grabs him and pulls him. He is a bloke in his 80s, occupying a role which has attracted assassination attempts in the past. What would you have liked him to do? Let himself be pulled over and break his hip, let himself be a sitting duck for being shot? Get real!

If you don't believe in religion or God, and think that the Second Coming is a load of crap, then fair enough. But the arguments you have used have more holes than a colander.

contentedsoul · 11/01/2020 20:06

How could there possibly be a second coming...Religion in all ita many forms is nothing but a fairy-tale. for weak minded.

Is it not a fact that there is nothing in history that has caused so much death and misery as that as to the kingdom of God...A irony in itself.

I live next to a church, and the sodding Vicar is more akin to a bloody witch. She is awful, so intolerant of others, she has actually forced my neighbour to put their house up for sale by her selfish demands. I along with many on the street truly dislike her.

Remember the pope smacking the womans hand a few weeks ago!!
I thought it summed up religion perfectly. Do as I say, not as I do.

The Middle East, The Irish
All this hatred in the name of a divine spirit. WTF

A second coming ?.... Get Real

73kittycat73 · 11/01/2020 19:54

Hi ZenNudist
Hell and Satan confuse me. It hard enough to get your head round God, Jesus and Mary.

Absolutely! Thanks for your reply.

roisinagusniamh · 11/01/2020 17:53

I think we can happily conclude that there will be no Second coming due to the fact that there never was a First one.😀

Swipe left for the next trending thread