Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you think there will be a second coming?

891 replies

LuluBellaBlue · 03/01/2020 18:29

This is inspired by the new Netflix show Messiah, about a second coming.

I really hope this doesn’t upset or offend anyone and people can share their beliefs and thoughts openly and without prejudice or judgement as I know this can be very sensitive for some people.

Following on from —binge— watching this series I did a bit of googling and it seems both Christian and Muslim regions predict this. (Not researched if any others do yet)

I’m not very well informed about different regions but the concept of this programme has really interested me, I find it fascinating that this could, maybe? actually happen!

Do you think there could be a second coming?!

(And what would it actually mean for the world? A rise in consciousness? Mass healing???)

YABU - no don't be so daft!
YANBU - yes, this could happen, why not?!

OP posts:
BowStreetStunner · 04/01/2020 00:23

I am not convinced there has been a first!

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 00:22

That video is full of misinformation that does not take scholarly research seriously, instead choosing to push half truths and sheer untruths in a lamentably bad way. For example, he simply writes off one of the passages in Josephus as pure interpolation, when most Josephan scholars agree that most of the material is in fact authentic Josephan. No mention of this in the video. Same with the assertions about Jesus/sun of god mythology - there is no historical basis for much of this. The Jesus Seminar, Zeitgeist and Acharya S have a lot to answer for....

CaptSkippy · 04/01/2020 00:21

Tacitus wasn't even alive during the time period when Jesus supposedly lived and the gospels were also written hundreds of years after that.

Furthermore, each time a person recalls a memory it changes. That's just how memory works. That's why a fish that was caught is five times larger by the time the fisherman tells the story for the 10th time.
Unless there are historical documents of the period itself, you'll never have proof. Romans where diligent recordkeepers and we have learned much from their writings, yet not a single record of the Jesus character exists. If he had so much influence surely the romans wouldn't have written about him, even just to vilify him. If we haven't found it by now, we never will,

It is also physically impossible for a human being to walk on water and no fermentation process will ever turn water into wine.

FloraGreysteel · 04/01/2020 00:18

Of course not! There wasn't even a first coming.

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 00:15

Also, a lot of his plotlines are directly copied from other/older mythologies, namely The Epic of Gilgamesh and Egyptian mythology.

No they are not. Please cite sources that are peer-reviewed and not a list of so called similarities planted by one single layperson with an agenda, which have somehow grown in popularity despite being utter bunkum.

CaptSkippy · 04/01/2020 00:13

This video explanes it well:

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 00:12

There are no first hand eye witness accounts. There are no contemporary accounts. The best evidence comes from the gospels, which were written decades after his death by people who hadn’t met him.

The gospels were written within the lifetime of eyewitnesses, with two of them most likely written by apostles and the other two by people who were closely associated with apostles - in one case by a historian. More and more scholarly research points to some very interesting things about the gospel accounts and how they display a first-hand knowledge of the geography, culture and customs of that particular period in first century Judea, which a more legendary make up of stories would never have been able to hold. As for extra biblical writings, there are quite a few near contemporary mentions - very rare, in fact, for a little known figure to be mentioned at all yet accounted for by the likes of the Roman historian Tacitus - a very thorough historian - and the Jewish historian Josephus (yes, I know about the interpolation, it doesn't detract from the main passages about the life and death of Jesus). Other near contemporary writings also mention him and the early church.

The gospels have the mark of historicity as much as any writings of antiquity. You could say they were biased accounts - you could say that about most writings in history, it does not make them useless in terms of historical significance. Far from it. I stand with my original contention, along with the vast majority of biblical scholars.

Defenbaker · 04/01/2020 00:06

I'm a lifelong agnostic so it's no good asking me. I wish I knew, but having spent decades pondering on religion, and having read the bible and some other religious texts, I'm still not sure about any of it.

I think JC existed and was a charismatic man with many gifts, who genuinely tried to lead by example. Son of God? I don't know.

I think that the earth was probably created by a divine power, and there may be some sort of universal consciousness, but I'm not sure about anything else.

Wellsomebodydid1 · 04/01/2020 00:01

The resurrection of christ

mbosnz · 03/01/2020 23:56

My advice, if you want to believe would be to do some research online, start reading the bible (even if just a verse or two) attend a church or if you don't want to attend a church, there are plenty of more relaxed, casual christian meetings now. Then make up your own mind on whether to believe.

Done all that, including theological study at third year in university. And going to church (politely) with misogynistic prats who made it so much easier not to believe.

And made up my own mind.

I do believe Mr C.S. Lewis provides some arguments to both sides.

FarTooSkinny · 03/01/2020 23:52

@Madhairday

But the fact stands that the evidence for Jesus stands tall among evidence for other figures of antiquity

There is no physical evidence of Jesus. There are no first hand eye witness accounts. There are no contemporary accounts. The best evidence comes from the gospels, which were written decades after his death by people who hadn’t met him. That doesn’t mean he didn’t exist but claiming the evidence is strong and ‘stands tall’ is just hokum.

Dip1 · 03/01/2020 23:48

Not a believer. The bible belongs on the fiction shelf

Littlemeadow123 · 03/01/2020 23:43

Don't make the decision whether or not to believe in God and Jesus based on others opinions.

My advice, if you want to believe would be to do some research online, start reading the bible (even if just a verse or two) attend a church or if you don't want to attend a church, there are plenty of more relaxed, casual christian meetings now. Then make up your own mind on whether to believe.

Yes, I believe in God and I'm a practising Christian. This is because I have witnessed and experienced things that cannot be explained any other way. I won't go into them on here just because they'll get ripped apart and ridiculed by non-believers, but if anyone wants to DM me feel free.

CaptSkippy · 03/01/2020 23:37

I think the Jesus character from the bible is a compilation of historical figures and myths from that period. Also, a lot of his plotlines are directly copied from other/older mythologies, namely The Epic of Gilgamesh and Egyptian mythology.

There was no first coming and there won't be a second, but we will get more awesome stories and hopefully they'll be better written than the bible.

LeSquigh · 03/01/2020 23:34

A second coming? There was not a first coming! Mary clearly did the dirty on Joseph and made up a completely unbelievable story that for some reason he believed and people still continue to believe to this day. What a load of nonsense!

Cornettoninja · 03/01/2020 23:22

But that’s faith isn’t it @Miljea? I don’t think it’s fair to describe it as arrogant, I think it’s more of a surrender that in the absence of your own knowledge you accept a teaching.

As it goes I don’t have any scientific knowledge past secondary eduction (and the infinite monkey cage and bill bryson!) but I have faith in what people I consider more knowledgable than myself tell me.

I’m not superior compared to someone whose faith is put into religious teachings; neither of us would have been able to reach our conclusions for ourselves.

Madhairday · 03/01/2020 23:20

I wouldn't say there was more evidence for Jesus than Caesar, skinny. That's poor use of historical method. But the fact stands that the evidence for Jesus stands tall among evidence for other figures of antiquity, and the amount of evidence we have far, far surpasses the amount we have for most others, in terms of documentary evidence close to the events.

Madhairday · 03/01/2020 23:15

He was charismatic and didn’t say he was the sin of god.

  • He made messianic claims and claims to his oneness with God/sonship both explicitly and implicitly, through the synoptics and the gospel of John. The reason he was handed over to the Romans for crucifixion was the Jewish blasphemy laws - because he made these claims in what he said and his actions - healing and his authority to forgive sins, which only God has.

He was close to death but hadn’t actually died when he went into the cave. Back then there would be many mistakes made. He came round and this was what people believed was his resurrection.

  • One of the most interesting factors about the crucifixion accounts is how the guards checked the death of those crucified - they would usually break the legs in order to insure or quicken death. When they came to Jesus, however, they speared his side and the biblical account says blood and water flowed, which we now know means that he was already dead, although obviously they weren't as scientifically literate then. As well as this, of course, Jesus was brutally flogged before his crucifixion, and if you look into how this was done it would leave you in no doubt he'd have little life left even before the cross. With that, with being forced to carry the cross then the actual crucifixion, there was no chance of survival, certainly not one where it was possible to come round after 3 days and swan around the place in full health. :)

Jesus was hyped up by his followers.

They had little reason or motivation to do so if the resurrection did not happen. They were a band of poor fishermen and hangers on, in the main, they had no resurrection narrative to hang on to - it wasn't something expressed in Judaism and not something that would have been on their horizon at all. They'd have had no reason to start preaching a Messiah resurrected, especially when the story could have been so easily squashed by those at the time who knew they were making it up. The only explanation for their sudden turnaround from a chaotic, depressed group to a dynamic, purposeful band of people who went on to spread the gospel was the resurrection. The very fact that most of the disciples were murdered for their faith tells us that they hadn't simply made it up - people don't go to death for a made up thing. I know the argument is that many people go to their death for religious reasons, but we are talking about people who were there, at the time, who knew what happened, who knew the truth - not people who have been brainwashed into a cult system which isn't anything to do with lived experience and facts.

Cornettoninja · 03/01/2020 23:15

@Legoandloldolls I really like that: “you cannot dismiss that you cannot disprove”

It always baffles me how recent lots of scientific knowledge actually is. Galaxies weren’t discovered till something bonkers like the 1940’s, not even 100 years, yet everyone (including my self) without even a remedial knowledge of astrophysics can state with absolute superiority and certainty that they are a fact. I’m pretty sure gravity is still only a theory.. Grin

The universe is an astounding place and I’m hoping to see explanations for lots of traditionally unexplained phenomenon in my lifetime; I’m just sad my brain isn’t wired in a way to explore it for myself.

It’s the one thing that stops me enjoying Brian Cox, he explains things so well and in a captivating way and then becomes a full on dismissive skeptic when questioned with any spiritual angle. I get he’s a scientist but he’s so receptive in other ways to knowing we don’t know everything it’s smug and off putting.

Wagsandclaws · 03/01/2020 23:13

Yes I do. I also believe we are in end times, maybe it will take a couple of hundred more years but this is our dying throes.

As the bible said no one will know the time or the day but there will be signs.

FarTooSkinny · 03/01/2020 23:10

Whenever these threads appear someone always claims there is more evidence for the existence of Jesus than for Julius Caesar. In the terminology used by historical scholars, this is total bollocks.

cheesenpickles · 03/01/2020 23:07

Nooooo. And even if there was nobody would believe them.

Miljea · 03/01/2020 23:07

Second coming?

How arrogant do you need to be to believe you are an adherent to the one true religion? Out of all the billions of sentient life forms that predated you? All the belief systems dating back tens of thousands of years? Why yours?

That's what I cannot grasp.

Personally I am not so much an atheist as an evidence based scientist. Earth to earth. Ashes to ashes. We are formed of the elements of the universe; we will, atom by atom, return to them.

Species after species, culture after culture has risen up, has formed its mythologies, its gods, it's End Times story; and either been destroyed, or destroyed itself. We are just another in that line.

roisinagusniamh · 03/01/2020 22:58

Spot on Likethebattle

Wellsomebodydid1 · 03/01/2020 22:54

The guy in the video Sam Shamoun is a christian and has a deep knowledge of the bible and Islam.

Swipe left for the next trending thread