Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you think there will be a second coming?

891 replies

LuluBellaBlue · 03/01/2020 18:29

This is inspired by the new Netflix show Messiah, about a second coming.

I really hope this doesn’t upset or offend anyone and people can share their beliefs and thoughts openly and without prejudice or judgement as I know this can be very sensitive for some people.

Following on from —binge— watching this series I did a bit of googling and it seems both Christian and Muslim regions predict this. (Not researched if any others do yet)

I’m not very well informed about different regions but the concept of this programme has really interested me, I find it fascinating that this could, maybe? actually happen!

Do you think there could be a second coming?!

(And what would it actually mean for the world? A rise in consciousness? Mass healing???)

YABU - no don't be so daft!
YANBU - yes, this could happen, why not?!

OP posts:
SteelRiver · 04/01/2020 06:16

It's all a work of fiction. God, Jesus et al never existed. Probably all made up by groups who wanted to control people, I'm afraid.

EerieSilence · 04/01/2020 06:12

I don’t believe in the second coming, let alone the first one. I believe that Jesus lived as a historical figure but that he was just one of the preachers who roamed the Judea at that time. Unlike the others, his ideas struck a major cord with the people and the politically unhappy decision to crucify him by the Judean government (I don’t think the Romans had a problem with him especially as he wasn’t calling for a military conflict but they didn’t care either whether he lives or not) only supported the legend and helped it spread. I don’t think it would have become so popular without Paul who was a very skilled leader and good politician, in my opinion.
So yes to Jesus, no to God’s son (a rehashed theme in mythologies, e.g. Zeus), water to Chardonnay, resurrection.

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 05:56

Thanks for your explanations about the second coming in Islam, @babba2014, that's very interesting to read.

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 05:53

the cult of Christianity is just a reboot of the cult of Isis and Osiris, which predates the period in which Jesus was alleged to have lived in any case.

This has been debunked again and again. There is no historical evidence whatsoever to prove Jesus was a reboot of the Isis/Osiris myth. What we know about the story is cloaked in mystery, based on pictorial evidence, and then on rituals developed later on. There are multiple lists of so called similarities between Jesus and Osiris/Horus/Mithras/Adonis etc etc circulating the internet, but none of them can be substantiated with empirical historical evidence. The actual similarities come to very little indeed. The very definition of fake news, in fact.

You are sticking your fingers in your ears and saying lala

I prefer to use my reason than block my brain off. Because of that I have researched this in depth (my specialism was NT theology and history) and continue to do so. I have a living faith but find again and again it is built on a solid foundation of rationality and robust evidence. Faith as a word doesn't generally mean blindly groping in the dark and simply hoping, crossing fingers etc, but tends to be associated with trust - if we say we have faith in a doctor, for example, we've built that for a reason - because they have shown themselves worthy of trust. So faith is more than hope without foundation - it's trust with reason. And it gives me a sense of hope in the most difficult of circumstances which sustains and assures. I'd actually hate to stick fingers in ears and choose not to listen - questioning and use of mental faculties has always been far too important to me, so I continue to do so.

bulletjournalbilly · 04/01/2020 03:26

"To those that don’t believe there was a first one, do you think Jesus was totally made up?"

Yes I do OP

leapinglucy · 04/01/2020 02:29

Depends if you're a theist or an atheist, doesn't it?

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 04/01/2020 02:25

Questions about the existence or otherwise of Jesus Christ, and any supposed second coming, become totally moot once you realise that the cult of Christianity is just a reboot of the cult of Isis and Osiris, which predates the period in which Jesus was alleged to have lived in any case.

You're as likely to see horned gods and folk with the heads of birds walking around at some indeterminate point in the future as you are to see Christ reappearing as neither existed in the first place.

Karen256 · 04/01/2020 01:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NotTheMrMenAgain · 04/01/2020 01:53

I believe in Jesus as a historical person, who had interesting ideas and the conviction to die for them. I don't believe that he rose again as the Christ of faith. I believe that in early versions of the scriptures Mary was described as a 'young girl' and it was later mis-translated/misconstrued to mean 'virgin' - which makes more sense, to me.

I find religion generally interesting, it's fascinating what people believe.

Wellsomebodydid1 · 04/01/2020 01:33

The full version of the video I posted earlier: Did jesus rise from the dead?

RoseyOldCrow · 04/01/2020 01:12

Yes, I believe it. It's a core part of my faith. Knowing that heaven is real & that we can reach it through our Saviour Jesus Christ is the thing that has ultimately given me peace after a challenging 4 decades.

On the other hand, I often really struggle with being with "Churchy" people & end up praying & praising Him on my own.

Pixxie7 · 04/01/2020 00:57

I find it hard to believe that someone who did so much good to the world is pure fabrication. However many of the things in the bible have been proven scientifically. One op mentioned the book of revelations some of high can be seen happening today. Nobody knows if their is a god or not so we will have to wait and see.

Wellsomebodydid1 · 04/01/2020 00:55
babba2014 · 04/01/2020 00:52

The Anti Christ will travel from city to city. He will go everywhere to spread mischief.
In the hadith there is a description of one of his modes of transport. Of course in those days there were no aeroplanes etc. but the way it is described with wings spanning this much to this much wide, it sounds like aeroplanes of today although only God knows the modes of transport available when the anti christ is around.
He won't be able to enter Makkah and Madinah as the angels will be guarding the two cities but there will be earthquakes there where hypocrites will die in those earthquakes.
The anti christ will camp outside these cities and keep trying to enter. Oddly enough there is a palace constructed around that location.

I just went on twitter to see comments about the TV series and Muslims were saying it seems like they are mixing up things from Imam Mahdi and the Anti Christ and they should have just thrown in bits from Jesus peace be upon him too so but I'd say just go to the hadith and find a wealth of information there about the signs of the last day in Islam then read up the part about the Anti Christ as after he arrives, Jesus peace be upon him will descend.

Inthebleakmidwinterz · 04/01/2020 00:49

Yanbu- Matthew 24 explains it all, King James Version. m.kingjamesbibleonline.org/Matthew_24/
After the tribulation period, Jesus will return to reign on the earth. All that matters is that you are saved, not by any good you can do yourself, it’s nothing to do with going to church, it’s not about being nice and giving money to charity, nobody can get to heaven on their own goodness, no one is perfect, it’s just trusting that Jesus died for your sins and rose again. Take a look at this video if you want to know exactly how to get to heaven when you die.
And Jesus wasn’t a homosexual.

Walkingdeadfangirl · 04/01/2020 00:46

I can find more evidence for Harry Potter than I can for a 'Jesus'. But 'faith' is the belief in something without any evidence, so you always get a few people believing it. Thankfully in the UK we are becoming more educated and old superstitions are dying out.

It will always be said their is a 'second coming', David Koresh, David Icke, possibly even global warming will be the new 'Noah's' flood. But short of Netflix, no, their wont ever be a second coming because their is no rational reason to think their is anything to come twice.

But its good advertising for Netflix to make money.

Ambrose2 · 04/01/2020 00:43

Not sure what I believe, but loved this series it has gave me some food for thought and hoping there's another season!

RoseMartha · 04/01/2020 00:41

As a Christian I live by faith with hope that Jesus will come again as it is promised in the Bible. No one knows when that will be.

But as others have mentioned I also feel we are in the end times.
How long are the end times? We do not know. But there are signs we are in the end times now.

babba2014 · 04/01/2020 00:39

I also missed this out, in the Qur'an there is a chapter called The Chapter of Mary. An entire chapter dedicated to her. If you read it, you will find some of her story there and of Jesus peace be upon him.

CaptSkippy · 04/01/2020 00:38

@Madhairday

You're grasping at straws. You're sitting behind your computer with your hands over your ears, going: "la, la, la. I can't hear you."

If, despite of everything you've heard (including from religious leaders themselves), you are still convinced of the supernatural, there is nothing I can say that would convince you.

That would be like trying to convince a Trump supported that their president is a con-man.

babba2014 · 04/01/2020 00:36

I forgot to add, the guy playing the main character, his real name is Mahdi/Mehdi.
In Islam we have Imam Mahdi at the time of all this happening but he is not the Messiah but a leader for a short while. A good guy.

babba2014 · 04/01/2020 00:35

@LuluBellaBlue I have only read the first post and some comments after that but as a Muslim yes I believe Jesus peace be upon him will return.

For me the information comes from the Qur'an which is an unaltered book (in Arabic). In it there are verses related to Jesus peace be upon him, where God explains Jesus is a messenger like Abraham, Moses and Noah peace be upon them and not God or 3 in 1.
There is also mention of him in the hadith (sayings of the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him) in great detail especially regarding the end of times.

I haven't watched the show, didn't know it was out yet but I have read people stating it feels like it is a way of misguiding and making a mockery. As I haven't seen it I can't say but I can share with you the Islamic perspective.

In brief, and very very brief, we are told of signs of the last day in the hadith. Every messenger was sent with signs to tell their people and warned against the one eyed liar.
In the hadith there is a lot of information about this one eyed liar. In Arabic he is called Dajjaal.
There are two messiahs. One is the true Messiah (Jesus peace be upon him) and one is the false Messiah (Dajjal/the anti-christ).

The series of events we are told is as follows that a time will come where it will be very difficult for a believer to practise their faith in public. It will be like holding onto burning coal. Believers will be seen as strangers so glad tidings for the strangers.

The time will get so bad that it is a time we probably don't want to be around then.

Before the coming of the Anti-Christ, there will be drought/famine for 3 years. Then the Anti Christ will appear. He is going to be the biggest trial on earth. He will spread mischief and he will also gain a lot of followers because you can imagine the dire state people will be in and the Anti Christ will be able to give food etc to people instantly. Apparently there is a seed being manufactured in some way that will allow a tomato to grow in a day or something but this is just something I read online and isn't part of the hadith but when we look at what's happening at farmers and them buying GMO seeds, their first year of harvest is great but then their land is killed off and they are unable to grow crops which is why so many are committing suicide, certainly in India this is the case. When the earth's nature fertile soil is being destroyed, you can imagine how we are inching towards that time of drought and famine and how when the Anti Christ comes with all his new technology or whatever he has, people will follow him as they will think he is the way to success.
He will claim to be a Prophet and then later on God.

As Muslims we are given a description on how he looks. He has one eye but the other eye is there but just looks like a squashed grape or something. He will have the word disbeliever written on his forehead which only a believer will recognise no matter what language they speak or read.

Before his arrival though, when the believers will be holding onto their religion like holding onto burning coal and the time will be so difficult for them, a man will be in Makkah by the Ka'bah praying. His name is Imam (leader) Mahdi. The believers will recognise him and make pledge to him to be their leader. He will refuse at first but eventually accept. He won't even know he is the leader until the time comes. He will be 40. He will lead the believers to some form of safety.
I've read comments about the Messiah series after the trailer was out and someone said it may be that they make Imam Mahdi to be the evil guy. I'm not sure if it played out like that as I haven't seen it as I said earlier.
Soon after is when Jesus peace be upon him will descend in Damascus. There is a description of how and what including him looking like he's just had a bath. At the time, the believers will be in congregational prayer so Imam Mahdi will tell Jesus peace be upon him to lead the prayer but he will decline as imam Mahdi is the leader. After that prayer is done, Jesus peace be upon him will lead the believers. He will eradicate tax etc.

He is the one who will win over the anti Christ who will first flee and then after be killed.

Jesus peace be upon him will not return as a Prophet, with new beliefs etc. He is a prophet and always will be but he will be a follower of the prophet who came after him and he will live a normal life and have children etc. Then the Gog Magog will come and destroy everything so the believes will retreat to the mountains with Jesus peace be upon him.

Now leading up to all of the above and amongst all of that there is mention of an increase in natural disasters, in fires etc. We are seeing that right now. As a Muslim I don't just see climate change but a sign of many signs of the end of times. Tall buildings and competing to make the tallest is also another big sign of the end of times.

As a Muslim I need to focus on my death more than the anti Christ because we are closer to our death than worrying about how to not get convinced by the Anti Christ but we are advised to read verses from the chapter of the Qur'an called Al Kahaf (the Cave) every Friday for protection against the Anti Christ.
We are also told he will have fire in one hand and water in the other but like everything else about him, he is a deceiver and we should choose the fire and not the water as it's a trick and choosing the fire will result in us entering gardens.

If we go back even further, we don't believe Jesus peace be upon him ever died. He is not Ever-Living like God because he will die eventually but when he was on the earth, they wanted to kill him, like people killed prophets before him. God protected him and so when the enemy came to get Jesus peace be upon him, God made that mana face resemble Jesus' face. Jesus was raised to heaven via the Angels.
The other people waiting outside for the man to bring Jesus, wondered why it took so long to bring Jesus out. So they went inside to fetch them both and saw their guy but they thought it was Jesus as now his face looked like Jesus. The guy obviously protested saying it's not me it's not me but they laughed at him and killed him.
Jesus is in the second heaven waiting for his appointed time to return and complete his mission.

There is so much information to share and it all links together but this is just a very brief summary to understand the Muslims view of Jesus peace be upon him returning.

Muslims do not believe he is God or the son of God but that he is a Messenger of God and he was born miraculously with just a mother. However this isn't difficult for God to do as He created Adam without a mother and father and Eve without parents too.
In Islam, Muslims call God Allah. Allah doesn't literally translate to God. It is an amazing word because you can't make it into a plural God's, you can't make it into masculine or feminine Goddess. It's just one diety worthy to be worshipped, with no partner, father or son or wife or anything. Just Allah.
When you translate the Bible to Arabic, the word for God used is Allah, something my Christian neighbours taught me.

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 00:34

We even have copies of copies of extant documents of gospel writings dating from C2, so no one could possibly assert that they were written 'hundreds of years later', from this fact and a hundred others which place the gospels firmly in C1.

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 00:30

Tacitus wasn't even alive during the time period when Jesus supposedly lived and the gospels were also written hundreds of years after that.

I'd been clear that Tacitus was a near contemporary history, especially in terms of writings of antiquity where histories often were written at the least decades after or even hundreds of years after the events, so finding Jesus in Tacitus etc is quite extraordinary (the Romans really wouldn't have been awfully bothered about some itinerant Messiah figure wandering Palestine and getting himself killed for saying he was God)

As for the gospels, no they really were not written hundreds of years after the events. Not even the most liberal scholars would asset that! The first gospel was most likely written around AD60, less than 30 years after the events. In terms of forming of legends, historians say it takes several generations for legends to form in oral traditions, but they couldn't possibly form and be embellished within 30 years - especially in first century Judaism, where oral histories were so integral to how the community operated, with each detail finely checked over and over as it was retold (nothing like Chinese whispers at all, in fact.)

The fact is that the gospels were written in the time of eyewitnesses, most likely by eyewitnesses and companions of eyewitnesses, and are thus incredibly useful in ascertaining the historical events - even accepting the bias.

Rubyupbeat · 04/01/2020 00:26

If there is a second coming, it won't make a difference if you don't believe, Jesus will come to earth with a army of Angel's who will wipe out the unholy and non believers, will resurrect the the Dead and will chain satan for a thousand years, to give every one a chance to live a good life and then judgement will reign down on mankind after the thousand years....
This is just one of the christian interpretations, I love studying religion, and tbh, you read revelations, it describes the times we are living in now.
Other religions have other ideas.
Other Christian Faith's too.