Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you think there will be a second coming?

891 replies

LuluBellaBlue · 03/01/2020 18:29

This is inspired by the new Netflix show Messiah, about a second coming.

I really hope this doesn’t upset or offend anyone and people can share their beliefs and thoughts openly and without prejudice or judgement as I know this can be very sensitive for some people.

Following on from —binge— watching this series I did a bit of googling and it seems both Christian and Muslim regions predict this. (Not researched if any others do yet)

I’m not very well informed about different regions but the concept of this programme has really interested me, I find it fascinating that this could, maybe? actually happen!

Do you think there could be a second coming?!

(And what would it actually mean for the world? A rise in consciousness? Mass healing???)

YABU - no don't be so daft!
YANBU - yes, this could happen, why not?!

OP posts:
EvilPea · 04/01/2020 10:01

I don’t. But the Jehovah witnesses that knock on my door keep telling me there will be, and he’ll sort alllllll this climate change, war and corruption out.

I asked if climate change was a way of getting rid of the evil in the world, by killing off man kind.
That didn’t go down well.

Frogsandsheep · 04/01/2020 10:00

I’m a priest with pretty much an entirely atheist family and friendship group so I won’t be offended if you think my post is bulls*! Grin

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 09:58

Thanks for your response, Saskia.

Because you never mention or reference them - as a theologian I would have thought this would be an obvious thing to do.

Do you mean you want me to copy out portions from Josephus, from the gospels, the Pauline epistles, Clement of Rome etc? I can do that, I just know on these types of threads that could get incredibly tedious very quickly! I have made reference to the sources - what do you mean by saying I only use secondary sources? Is it because I provided links to writings about the sources? If so I apologise - I have to say I really struggle when people simply post a series of links, it's annoying! - but I felt that link did give a good overview of the sources in question without bias. I can see that as a historian that's not what you were after, but some might find it interesting. What would you like me to quote? I don't want to bog us down too much :)

For it to be considered real evidence it would have to be first-hand, or at least contemporary accounts, not later works.

But I've reiterated that the gospels are from eyewitness accounts - that two of them are most likely written by eyewitnesses, and the other two by companions of eyewitnesses. These stand the criterion of historical authenticity in that they can be tested robustly against the culture, customs, geography, climate of the exact time and area - even the names used have been proven to be consistent with names in that time and place, quite difficult to insert later on from authors detached by time and place. The evidence for Christ stands tall because of the sheer amount of writings, in Christian and non Christian sources, within a short time. As a historian, you will know how these things work in terms of antiquity, and I stand with my assertion that for an unknown messianic pretender there are a surprising amount of sources.

Again, what primary sources are you thinking I have not included or not read? I'd really like to establish what you mean by this so I can comment further. I'm sorry if I have not been clear enough.

Frogsandsheep · 04/01/2020 09:57

I preached about the second coming throughout advent and although I do believe in Christ’s return, what the Bible actually tells us about it makes it hard to know how or when it might happen. I don’t live my life looking for signs of the end times (!) but I do believe that he will return - whatever that may look like. I’m quite liberal in my interpretation of the Bible (having studied it to a very high level) and so am open minded (I probably wouldn’t say that it in a sermon!)

Auridon4life · 04/01/2020 09:56

Abed!

Auridon4life · 04/01/2020 09:56
PhilCornwall1 · 04/01/2020 09:56

Well, you can guarantee if there is, he/she/them (got to be fluid these days) will want your money. Religion to me seems like an extension of HMRC!

MopsRUs · 04/01/2020 09:55

No reason why it couldn't be a woman, blank. Even in Genesis it says both men and women are made in God's image.

Auridon4life · 04/01/2020 09:54

I have many followers including Abed and Gwyneth paltrow!!

LuluBellaBlue · 04/01/2020 09:54

@babba2014 thank you so much for the detailed description, this is the most easy to read / digest / understand I’ve seen. Much better than what I’ve found via google so thank you :)

OP posts:
Auridon4life · 04/01/2020 09:53

Do you want my PayPal??

SaskiaRembrandt · 04/01/2020 09:51

Kong Arthur I saw that film - he went bonkers and climbed the Empire State building with Lancelot under his arm Grin

Auridon4life · 04/01/2020 09:51

Yes I am the second coming pls follow me and subscribe to my youtube channel about how to give me all of your worldly possessions and start a juice cleanse.

SaskiaRembrandt · 04/01/2020 09:50

Kong Arthur and Robin Hood are stories woven and steeped in legend, though. The Jesus story is substantiated by eyewitness accounts and near contemporary historical accounts. There is simply no comparison.

This true, but there is a compelling argument that the legends were based on real people, especially in the case of Robin Hood. There is a theory that he was actually based on 3-4 similar people. This is why the claims of his origins are all possibly true, because all these places had a Robin Hood figure.

MopsRUs · 04/01/2020 09:50

Yes, I think there will be. There won't be any doubt, so if your neighbour from number 62 says it's them, it isn't Wink

scarecrowhead · 04/01/2020 09:47

There are no eyewitness accounts if Jesus. The earliest (disputed) texts are Josephus writing 70 years later and Tacitus over a century later.

SaskiaRembrandt · 04/01/2020 09:45

MadHairDay

Yes, of course - I find them fascinating! I have a ton of books of early Christian writings as well as Josephus' works etx. Why do you ask?

Because you never mention or reference them - as a theologian I would have thought this would be an obvious thing to do. Every theologian I know is only too keen to provide primary evidence. You only ever give links to secondary sources.

I apologise for saying you made the claim about Caesar. However, you do say that the evidence for Christ (OTTOMH) 'stands tall'. So please point me towards it.

You seem to discount Tacitus. He wasn't contemporary but he lived in the same century, which in terms of writings of antiquity was close to the time of the events. He was also a careful historian, known to be incredibly picky about his sources, so would have checked them with care. He was close enough to the events to have traced back the line of evidence to the actual person. He said this earlier in his work, about hearsay:

I’m not discounting Tacitus – I’m a historian, I would never be so arrogant. But, as you admit, he was contemporaneous, and he would be the first to admit his account was only secondary. I’d also add there are suggestions some of his work has been edited, probably by later Roman administrators, but I’m on the fence about that.

Josephus is the other historian operating at a similar time - near contemporary, and makes explicit mention of Jesus as a man who preached, performed signs and died by crucifixion - even taking out the later interpolation (the lines are obvious.)

Josephus was also not contemporary.

To ask for contemporary writings is problematic because Jesus was not a well known figure like Caesar who would afford any such writings. He was one of any numbers of preachers in the area claiming to be the Messiah, and the evidence we have about him tends to exceed what we'd expect for such. Yet the gospel writings are within just 3 decades and much Pauline material and the book of James for example far earlier than this (the fifties in some cases), which takes it back even closer to the events.

It's true there will be little evidence about an ordinary person, but you say there is a huge amount of evidence for the existence of Christ. For it to be considered real evidence it would have to be first-hand, or at least contemporary accounts, not later works.

I include the early Christian writings simply as more examples of historical evidence of there being this person who started this remarkable movement - again,.them being close to the time in terms of writings of antiquity. I know I keep banging on about that, sorry about that! - but it's so important to establish the general rules of what we are looking at here, rather than apply the lens of 21st century historicity.

The early Christian accounts are very interesting evidence of the emergence of a religion, they do not give us any primary evidence about the founder of that religion. It’s a shame, because it would be fascinating is it could be found but unfortunately all we have to go is the later testimony.

*I included the link because it is quite a comprehensive review of the evidence you ask for from a skeptical scholar, as is Ehrman's book.&

I didn’t ask for a review – I’m a historian, I’m aware of the arguments around the subject. I’m asking for the evidence of Christ’s life and existence.

I’ll repeat, I’m not actually doubting he did exist. I just think you do your cause no favours by making claims for evidence which has never been found. Using secondary sources and modern analysis does not constitute compelling evidence.

Also, faith is supposed to be just that, faith. Not something you need evidence to justify or reinforce. If a person needs evidence, then that suggests that their faith will disappear the moment someone produces evidence to the contrary

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 09:44

cult + time = religion

I agree with you, which is why I think Christianity stands out as different - the time between the events and the writings is so incredibly short, compared to other such accounts in the period. To have just 20-30 years between the events and the first written accounts, in a society which already practices rigorous oral tradition and history, is quite outstanding. This story cannot come under the heading of legend, because there simply isn't enough time involved.

Happymum12345 · 04/01/2020 09:42

I was pretty skeptical before I became a Christian & could have written a lot of the posts where people are mocking believers. I believe in Jesus and his second coming. Faith is just that-belief, trust & hope. I am infinitely more peaceful than I was before.

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 09:41

King, not Kong. Grin

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 09:40

Kong Arthur and Robin Hood are stories woven and steeped in legend, though. The Jesus story is substantiated by eyewitness accounts and near contemporary historical accounts. There is simply no comparison.

CaptSkippy · 04/01/2020 09:40

I think this sums it up best:

cult + time = religion

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 09:38

Heck, longwayoff, that would've fed the five million, at the very least. With leftovers for soup.

longwayoff · 04/01/2020 09:36

Sardines? Imagine what he could have done with a Mumsnet 🐔 chicken.

Madhairday · 04/01/2020 09:33

You should type in Zietgiest religion clip into YouTube, it will explain how christianity came about in the first place

Only if you like to get your facts from utterly unsubstantiated and debunked narratives which were circulated by a number of unscholarly sources, largely self published, in the 19th/20th centuries. Each 'fact' in that film can be completely laid bare as bunkum, I'm afraid, and the vast majority of scholars will assert this - including Richard Dawkins!